You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Brighton Match Thread
November 16 2026 6.12am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Brighton Match Thread


Page 12 of 13 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 Dec 19 9.06pm

Originally posted by Willo

Trossard scored 17 goals for Genk last season and Brighton signed him for £18 Mill.
He has scored over 60 goals in his career, Meyer has scored nowhere near that amount.

True but he played mainly as defensive midfielder who topped the Bundesligua for interceptions . I doubt Trossard did this in Belgium

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 Dec 19 9.07pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

True but he played mainly as defensive midfielder who topped the Bundesligua for interceptions . I doubt Trossard did this in Belgium

And Meyer didn’t cost £17 million

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 18 Dec 19 2.32pm

The way he uses Meyer is quite clever in some respects.

Aim to muscle a 1-0 win through a tough defensive set up. Should keep it tight and may be successful. High chance of a draw, possibility of leading, low risk of being 2 down on 70 minutes.

If we're chasing a draw from a defeat (like bha) teams will sit back and defend what they have. Meyer can turn it in our favour and will play in the 'right areas' both for him and for Roy. If we're on top in aa draw against a peer team, he's also worth consideration.

As a means of getting points, it's smart.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Uphill Flag Bedford 18 Dec 19 3.42pm

Any neutral watching on Sky expecting a decent game of football would have:
1. Been sorely disappointed
2. Admired Brighton for playing decent stuff
3. Noted that Palace had no idea and were ugly to watch.
4. We were outplayed yet our defence got lucky.
5. A point for us was daylight robbery

People will jump in and say that the result is what counts and staying up by playing ugly if necessary is all that matters. Yes, up to a point, but our sole objective is to survive and consequently our more skilful players don't get much of a look in.

Football is often called 'the Beautiful Game' - watching Palace will soon disabuse you of that feeling ....

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 18 Dec 19 4.02pm

Originally posted by Casual

I said exactly the same about Meyer.
Can’t knock the points Hodgson has achieved since he has been here, we should stay up by some distance , but there cannot be a team in the league that plays worse football to watch than us.
Was laughing as we walked out how we had ‘nicked a point’, absolutely dominated for 70 odd minutes, we never got a corner until an hour into the game.
Don’t think we have ever played aswell /outplayed a team , as they did, in 7 years in the top league.
The irony being that once they scored , our players seem to grow a foot each, have 2 yards more pace and could easily have won.
Well happy now, but an awful , shocking 70 minutes.

Watford??

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 18 Dec 19 4.24pm

Does anyone think the Liverpool fans are crying about how bad they played against Watford , but nicked all 3 points thanks to their keeper and their star player ?

 

pssguy Flag 18 Dec 19 4.32pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

And Meyer didn’t cost £17 million


But Trossard is probably on a much lower salary, has a higher resale value and actually plays for his team

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 18 Dec 19 4.38pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Does anyone think the Liverpool fans are crying about how bad they played against Watford , but nicked all 3 points thanks to their keeper and their star player ?

Of course not, every team has an off day.

But with Palace our last four games were 'off days' yet we got 8 points and conceded one - very good as far as it went. We had to rely on our keeper and makeshift defence to keep it that way but 4 goals in 3 games shows why we play so defensively and daren't risk using some of our more talented players who can actually pass the ball.

It's ugly but some of us purists hope forlornly for better ....

 

pssguy Flag 18 Dec 19 4.38pm

Let's face it, Brighton have everything we could wish for. Several young skillful players, a progressive manager more than a quarter century younger than ours and a stadium to die for

Don't get me wrong, Hodgson is a good fit for this squad and in Zaha, Tomkins and Guaita we probably have enough quality to keep us up given the points we already have. But I'd be very surprised to see us ahead of them come the end of the season - or over the next few

 

AERO Flag 18 Dec 19 4.46pm

s

 

AERO Flag 18 Dec 19 4.47pm

Spot on we need to rebuild in more ways than one.

 

Aray Flag South London 18 Dec 19 5.05pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

True but he played mainly as defensive midfielder who topped the Bundesligua for interceptions . I doubt Trossard did this in Belgium

Although he played at the back - I dont think he was a defensive midfielder, rather a deep lying playmaker.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 18 Dec 19 8.51pm

Originally posted by samprior

Sakho will still be out with suspension. Newcastle have their own problems with ASM, Shelvey and Almiron all potentially out. Could be quite an ugly game with both teams desperately trying to give each other possession

Still we could get something if we play like we did in the last 20mins yesterday. Hopefully Gayle won't come back to haunt us and we have the entire first team squad wrapped in cotton wool until Saturday.

My money is on last game on MOTD again. In terms of Monday night sounds like another poor start where we were lucky still to be in the game after 70 mins. With an unlikely start of Tekkers and Ayew the lack of attacking mid options was again noticeable. Really hoping that we can be proactive in Jan and attempt to remedy this situation. The way this season is going the whole back line should be player of the year. COYP !!

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 18 Dec 19 11.20pm

Originally posted by pssguy

Let's face it, Brighton have everything we could wish for. Several young skillful players, a progressive manager more than a quarter century younger than ours and a stadium to die for

Don't get me wrong, Hodgson is a good fit for this squad and in Zaha, Tomkins and Guaita we probably have enough quality to keep us up given the points we already have. But I'd be very surprised to see us ahead of them come the end of the season - or over the next few

Luckily our team have some fighting spirit, unlike it seems many on this site.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 18 Dec 19 11.30pm

Originally posted by Uphill

Of course not, every team has an off day.

But with Palace our last four games were 'off days' yet we got 8 points and conceded one - very good as far as it went. We had to rely on our keeper and makeshift defence to keep it that way but 4 goals in 3 games shows why we play so defensively and daren't risk using some of our more talented players who can actually pass the ball.

It's ugly but some of us purists hope forlornly for better ....

How long have you supported Palace?
You hope for purity?
7 seasons in the Premier, 9th in the table, took a point off our allegedly biggest rivals who played at their peak of ability against our makeshift team, where's your passion ? If you are supporting Palace for purity, sorry wrong team .
This is tribal, partisanship and pride, that's what Palace is about

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 19 Dec 19 8.46am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

How long have you supported Palace?
You hope for purity?
7 seasons in the Premier, 9th in the table, took a point off our allegedly biggest rivals who played at their peak of ability against our makeshift team, where's your passion ? If you are supporting Palace for purity, sorry wrong team .
This is tribal, partisanship and pride, that's what Palace is about

Since 1948 actually when I sat on my dad's shoulders. I take your point that this is Palace but in the days of Johnny Byrne we (and he especially) played football worth watching, although not in the Top Division, obviously.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 19 Dec 19 9.04am

Originally posted by pssguy

Let's face it, Brighton have everything we could wish for. Several young skillful players, a progressive manager more than a quarter century younger than ours and a stadium to die for

Don't get me wrong, Hodgson is a good fit for this squad and in Zaha, Tomkins and Guaita we probably have enough quality to keep us up given the points we already have. But I'd be very surprised to see us ahead of them come the end of the season - or over the next few

Can’t disagree with some of your points about Brighton but don’t forget they have 2nd highest debt in PL, albeit a loan from Bloom that is nearly £300 million. This years accounts show they turned profit into a loss and their wage bill is increasing so perhaps all not as rosy as they will have you believe

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Dec 19 9.12am

Last night when I was out with my wife I had a contretemps with a Brighton braggart much to the chagrin of the dear lady.

The temulent cur was in conversation with chaps who were also in an advanced state of refreshment and was being highly critical of our team,ground,supporters using a word, the alternative to which is "Excreta". The diatribe continued and I intervened only to be accused of listening in to his conversation when he had a voice like a foghorn and I told the oaf that if he didn't wish to be heard by all and sundry he should "Pipe down" and not inflict his thoughts on those who perhaps ventured out for a quiet and civilised night.

Rest assured, I defended our team with vim and vigour and dismissed his piffle with high-decibel fulmination.I am certainly not a reed bending to the storm wind and I suspect he formed this view in a short timescale.The chap was a varmint and no threat to Mensa.

I will have to buy my dear wife a bunch of flowers as she had to endure me rearing up akin to a dray horse and getting involved in a heated spat when we were out enjoying a tipple.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 19 Dec 19 9.44am

Originally posted by Willo

Last night when I was out with my wife I had a contretemps with a Brighton braggart much to the chagrin of the dear lady.

The temulent cur was in conversation with chaps who were also in an advanced state of refreshment and was being highly critical of our team,ground,supporters using a word, the alternative to which is "Excreta". The diatribe continued and I intervened only to be accused of listening in to his conversation when he had a voice like a foghorn and I told the oaf that if he didn't wish to be heard by all and sundry he should "Pipe down" and not inflict his thoughts on those who perhaps ventured out for a quiet and civilised night.

Rest assured, I defended our team with vim and vigour and dismissed his piffle with high-decibel fulmination.I am certainly not a reed bending to the storm wind and I suspect he formed this view in a short timescale.The chap was a varmint and no threat to Mensa.

I will have to buy my dear wife a bunch of flowers as she had to endure me rearing up akin to a dray horse and getting involved in a heated spat when we were out enjoying a tipple.

I hope you didn't threaten him with your zimmer frame?

I spoke to a Brighton mate yesterday, a more civilised conversation, he acknowledged our defensive qualities and admitted that whilst they had the lion's share of the game Brighton could have lost it in the last 20 minutes.

 


One more point

si_1967 Flag Surrey 19 Dec 19 9.44am

Sounds like you should've challenged him to a duel...

Pistols at dawn etc

 


... what

Page 12 of 13 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Brighton Match Thread