You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Arsenal Match Thread
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Arsenal Match Thread


Page 12 of 12 << First< 8 9 10 11 12
taylors lovechild Flag 12 Jan 20 12.55pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'MoTD' by Midlands Eagle

It is only slight, but Aubemayang does actually appear to slightly raise his tackle, not lower it, which suggests he might not be as innocent as everyone is trying to make out. Most Palace fans didn't complain when Sakho was sent off and he barely caught the player, whereas this instance is practically the modern day definition of a red card tackle i.e. out of control, studs up and potential to cause injury.

I do think however if that had been Luiz or one of Arsenal's other defensive players no one would have questioned the decision, and it seems perhaps it is just Aubamayang's reputation as being a 'nice guy' that is leading to people talking out of their ars*s.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 12 Jan 20 1.09pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

[Link]

If you want a laugh and a taste of a totally delusional gooner then this is the link to follow. Tends to ignore the fact Xakha committed 6 fouls in the first half alone with Kolasnic not far behind him.

No mention of Pepe stamping on our player I notice?!! Maybe they were swayed by some of their player's acting abilities, such as when Tomkins' arm brushed Socrates face and he went down clutching his face and screaming of injustice. We were physical, and I did think Ayew was lucky not to get booked for repeated fouls, but you could hardly call us dirty. Also, every time we went to break they used tactical fouls around the half way line. The referee was pretty lenient on both teams with regard to bookings but his decisions had no impact on the result. With regard to VAR it was as clear a red as you're going to see: studs up, out of control and potential to cause injury.

This Arsenal fan is clearly fed up that aside from 20 minutes they weren't much better than they have been since Arsene left. Given they only had one injury in their squad this probably is a poor result from then given our decimated squad. I hope for his sake we finish above Arsenal

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 12 Jan 20 1.31pm

Re MoTD they were very quick to say Sakho's red card against BMouth was justified. Very biased against Palace. However sod em I now tend to just watch the games and ignore their drivel, except when we're featured.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

trapperjohn Flag Horsham 12 Jan 20 2.10pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

The first thing I said after their goal is that they wouldn’t have carved through us if Luca had been playing. He is hard as nails and most opposition are scared of him. Plus he keeps on Zahas back. Keeps him going. Sorely missed in my view. But he needs help with keeping his head.

That is interesting as I have come to the conclusion that he really isn’t hard at all. He can be niggly, hence all the bookings, but when he gets clattered like Weed at home last season, he doesn’t in my view, want to know. He postures a lot, but compared to say Jedi, he isn’t hard.

And as for not having the opposition carve through when he is there, he was AWOL many times in the first half against Weed this season and left Jairo hanging out to dry repeatedly. On form he doesn’t deserve to be picked ahead of anybody else at the moment

 


I got vision, and the rest of the world wears bifocals.

The Dolphin Flag 12 Jan 20 6.47pm

Originally posted by the.universal

Or even two!

Good point well argued!


Edited by The Dolphin (12 Jan 2020 6.47pm)

 

PatrickA Flag London 12 Jan 20 7.42pm

I was unhappy how we set up for the game.
This is the third game where Meyer has played on the right and it doesn’t work from an attacking or defensive standpoint.
He hasn’t got the pace/strength to play the role and can’t tackle.
It’s almost as if Hodgson is setting him up to fail.
I also see it as pointless for Wilf to continue to play in a narrow channel on the left about 60 yards by 20 yards.
He is so easy to contain when he plays in a confined space.
If he’s tightly marked and can’t get a kick he needs to be able to move around the field. We have 3 defensive midfielders and a solid back 4 which should provide enough defensive cover to allow more movement across the field from him.
It’s almost as if he’s playing in a straitjacket.
Set Wilf free - and I don’t mean by transferring him!

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 12 Jan 20 7.56pm

Originally posted by trapperjohn

That is interesting as I have come to the conclusion that he really isn’t hard at all. He can be niggly, hence all the bookings, but when he gets clattered like Weed at home last season, he doesn’t in my view, want to know. He postures a lot, but compared to say Jedi, he isn’t hard.

And as for not having the opposition carve through when he is there, he was AWOL many times in the first half against Weed this season and left Jairo hanging out to dry repeatedly. On form he doesn’t deserve to be picked ahead of anybody else at the moment


Completely agree. Jedi was hard. Luca, fine player that he is, is like you say just niggly.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 12 Jan 20 8.09pm

Originally posted by JRW2

What about Danny Murphy? I had admittedly had a few drinks when I watched MOTD, but my memory says that he uttered a load of drivel about the tackle looking worse in slow motion, and looking worse than it was because Meyer's ankle was turned over. I'm lost for words.

What they're referring to is malice and that the tackle wasn't meant to take Meyer out but an genuine attempt to get the ball and I agree with them, Murphy even suggested an orange card! lol, it was the same as Sakho's red (actually more or less in the same place) and that looked a lot worse in the same way, but he was genuinely clearing the ball away with no intention of taking the player out, both were dangerous but only because of timing issues.
The game is going to become non contact quite soon I believe because of all the pulling and pushing that is going on as well.

 

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 13 Jan 20 2.52am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

[Link]

If you want a laugh and a taste of a totally delusional gooner then this is the link to follow. Tends to ignore the fact Xakha committed 6 fouls in the first half alone with Kolasnic not far behind him.

Nary a mention of the Thompkins header that was almost all the way in?

 

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 13 Jan 20 5.07am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I was unhappy how we set up for the game.
This is the third game where Meyer has played on the right and it doesn’t work from an attacking or defensive standpoint.
He hasn’t got the pace/strength to play the role and can’t tackle.
It’s almost as if Hodgson is setting him up to fail.
I also see it as pointless for Wilf to continue to play in a narrow channel on the left about 60 yards by 20 yards.
He is so easy to contain when he plays in a confined space.
If he’s tightly marked and can’t get a kick he needs to be able to move around the field. We have 3 defensive midfielders and a solid back 4 which should provide enough defensive cover to allow more movement across the field from him.
It’s almost as if he’s playing in a straitjacket.
Set Wilf free - and I don’t mean by transferring him!

Play Wilf on the right. It still enrages me that our most gifted player plays on the wrong side of the pitch.

 


Spirit of 1974

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 13 Jan 20 6.39am

Looking back, it was good Arsenal scored when they did. Roy holds us back so much against the bigger clubs, and at least we had to chase the game. I must admit I was frustrated with Wilf, and didn't credit enough the fact that the might be injured. I can't understand why we'd play a player like him injured. Or why he'd accept selection.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

southnorwoodhill Flag 13 Jan 20 8.06am

Extremely poor management to let any player play who is carrying in an injury if this is the case.
There is every chance of the injury being aggravated and thus the player being out for longer, and the player's fear of aggravating the injury thus the failure to apply 100% to the game.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 13 Jan 20 8.54am

Originally posted by Willo

This post has been merged from a topic called 'MoTD' by Midlands Eagle

"Intent" is totally irrelevant.
The fact of the matter is that the challenge was worthy of a red card.

Danny Murphy, who I quite like, said it was not a red! A lot of pundits seem to be going down the "he is not nice bloke" route. Never met him so can't comment but that was a red all day long.
I agree with Willo how did it take VAR so long?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 13 Jan 20 10.06am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Danny Murphy, who I quite like, said it was not a red! A lot of pundits seem to be going down the "he is not nice bloke" route. Never met him so can't comment but that was a red all day long.
I agree with Willo how did it take VAR so long?

Sorry meant he is a nice bloke

 

taylors lovechild Flag 13 Jan 20 10.49am

I've been wondering whether the MOTD pundits were more influenced by their anti-VAR agenda, than any real belief that it wasn't a red card. Remember, Linekar tweeted that our goal should have stood the other week when Wilf's elbow was supposedly offside.

I still think there was slight malice in the tackle, perhaps borne out of Aubameyang's frustration that he wasn't getting the ball much in the second half. I don't think he meant to injure Meyer, but anyone who has played football at any level knows that going in with your studs up at that height is dangerous.

 

cpj Flag Kent 13 Jan 20 10.57am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I was unhappy how we set up for the game.
This is the third game where Meyer has played on the right and it doesn’t work from an attacking or defensive standpoint.
He hasn’t got the pace/strength to play the role and can’t tackle.
It’s almost as if Hodgson is setting him up to fail.

I also see it as pointless for Wilf to continue to play in a narrow channel on the left about 60 yards by 20 yards.
He is so easy to contain when he plays in a confined space.
If he’s tightly marked and can’t get a kick he needs to be able to move around the field. We have 3 defensive midfielders and a solid back 4 which should provide enough defensive cover to allow more movement across the field from him.
It’s almost as if he’s playing in a straitjacket.
Set Wilf free - and I don’t mean by transferring him!

Totally agree with this. Meyer should be in the number 10 role but Roy will not give up his 3 defensive CMs.

 

rawpalace05 Flag Saltdean 14 Jan 20 12.02am

Big critic of Meyer but thought he was overall pretty good saturday. That said,his weaknesses still showed. The cross for our goal was a lucky mis-hit ball and then he had that volley laid on a plate which he squewed pathetically wide without any power whosoever. As it stands with injuries im happy with his inclusion as there are signs he is improving/getting fitter. Personally think that if he needs the space he did in Germany then he needs to play DM, pulling strings in a cabeye esque role. Of course further forward is more Max but it seems too congested and physically demanding up the pitch for him to be effective.

Next whinge up despite the impressive fight and effort shown by the team was Wilfried. Was he injured? Was he playing for a move to Arsenal, wanting to keep them as a big club within touching distance of us? Whatever it was he should have been subbed for Wickham / Pierrick. Really under par from him.

Two biggest pluses. Firstly Jairo. What a great game. Ok so he still cant defend seamlessly and can get done with a yard of pace, but the rest of his game is superb. Great engine, great footballer and gets us up the pitch. Much needed energy in the absences of JS, PVA and Andros. So much improved and really enjoyable to watch.

Second plus and biggest of all. Vicente! What a keeper.He just oozes class, calm, crazy, respect..and never say die and at all costs with everything he does. Proper palace player and really doing the business...that save!! Motd chose to ignore...quietly becoming a cult hero and one of the best in the league imo. Give a f*** he occasionally kicks it out by mistake, if he didnt he'd be signing for a CL club tomorrow.

Really encouraging and pleasing performance given the current injury crisis. Well done the boys! UTP!


Edited by rawpalace05 (14 Jan 2020 12.08am)

 


1/6/2010.a new era.we made it everyone!!!lets get the ball rolling for another 105 years of proud history.thank you cpfc2010.

palace forever.eeaaaaaaaaaaaaaggglless!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Page 12 of 12 << First< 8 9 10 11 12

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Arsenal Match Thread