You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Southampton match thread
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Southampton match thread


Page 12 of 17 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >
EddieMac Flag 22 Jan 20 9.06am

Originally posted by Willo

Once again we started so poorly.We go into our shell, allow the opposition to have the ball and they are able to make passes, get into their stride and dictate the tempo.
They get onto the front foot striaght away.
It is almost as though we are so petrified of conceding an early goal that we drop back in numbers, pay the opposition far too much respect and if by chance we gain possession we just don't have the movement to create anything as unlike us the opponents engage our players and don't allow us the space we afford them.

It really is a dreadful watch and I fear more of the same next season if we remain in the PL under the same ownership and management.


Edited by Willo (22 Jan 2020 8.55am)

Our biggest problem all season has been our complete fear of holding onto the ball. I think Riedewald must have gave it away about 20 times last night and then nobody else was much better.Sakho makes a differnce when he starts because he tries to pass the ball but then he is always liable to make a big mistake so id rather stick with Tomkins and Cahill.

I think we are a better team with Ayew up front and he deserves to play up there ahead of the rest of the strikers.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Jan 20 9.12am

We were at home, yet registered no shots on target and didn't win a single corner.
The lowest of the low.

 

Den1923 Flag 22 Jan 20 9.12am

Originally posted by Gribbo

Playing dire football, lowest goals scored in the premier, 7 points off relegation and knocked out the cups by Colchester and Derby. And people keep saying we are having a good year. Squad is paper thin, we have the 20th largest wage bill in the world, that’s the world, not UK, the the ground is an absolute toilet. Good year, perhaps not.

I agree, yet some still dream of top six finish, bottom six more likely, the teams average age is of great concern, no succession planning all Parish likes to do is the odd loan deal which means if do survive, then next season will be no different, I do not blame Roy he has done rather well with limited resources so far, as he has said himself in a roundabout way, survival is the ethos of Parish not investment in the team!

 

EddieMac Flag 22 Jan 20 9.14am

Originally posted by Willo

Some supporters might deem that we will be safe etc etc, but we are only 7 points clear of the relegation zone,and have only won 3 of our last 11 PL games.The likelihood is that we will survive but alas I have a worried brow.

Edited by Willo (22 Jan 2020 9.02am)

I don't believe we are safe in the slighest. I can see this year being the highest points total to stay up in recent history.

At this point last year we had

Cardiff 19 points
Fulham 17 points
Hudderfield 11 points.

so already there is 4 point difference on the team in 3rd last and the bottom teams this year are stronger. we are far from safe.

 

EddieMac Flag 22 Jan 20 9.18am

Originally posted by Willo

We were at home, yet registered no shots on target and didn't win a single corner.
The lowest of the low.

Desperate stuff and yet all could have been different if Tosun hadn't of s*** himself and wellied the ball to Devon.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 22 Jan 20 9.22am

I think Roy is a very decent “recovery manager”

His strength is organisation. When he got the England job he organised the team - but it looked sod all like scoring at times. Then the rot set.

Same here. He isn’t going to play youngsters, or have an eye on the future too much as he won’t be here in 5 years.

I think the main frustration is the board does acquire players - Meyer, Camarasa and he simply won’t use them - whether out of stubbornness or simply not knowing how. Hodgson for all his nice guy (which I’m sure he is) has an arrogant streak too.

Look at Liverpool now - Alexander Arnold, Robertson, Gomez - the fullbacks they use and all young, vibrant players brought through. Roy went there and signed Paul Konchesky. Those players wouldn’t get a look in from our youth team. The one that did was through an injury.

If you gave the man £100 million to spend we would end up with an aging squad of functional journeyman pros.. Great for the next few years but then the D-Day comes. A bit like Stoke.

No young player would want to join us and if they did they wouldn’t get used. The recruitment policy and manager don’t seem to be aligned, and if that’s the case it is which one goes. With an eye to the future, and sustainability it might have to be the manager.

As the old Blackadder Goes Forth approach of the secret plan of going over the top for the 18th time (as that’s what we’ve done the last 17 times and it’s the last thing they will expect” isn’t working.

 

Den1923 Flag 22 Jan 20 9.22am

Originally posted by EddieMac

I don't believe we are safe in the slighest. I can see this year being the highest points total to stay up in recent history.

At this point last year we had

Cardiff 19 points
Fulham 17 points
Hudderfield 11 points.

so already there is 4 point difference on the team in 3rd last and the bottom teams this year are stronger. we are far from safe.

Could not agree more, would not take much for the team in third to come to our level with us going the other way!

 

Painter Flag Croydon 22 Jan 20 9.27am

Originally posted by Badger11

Soton exposed how slow our back four are and just passed their way through our midfield. The only good thing to come out of last night is that our next game is 10 days away.

Very disappointing performance maybe Roy is right that the games have finally caught up with them.

Anyway here's hoping that we are feeling fresh for Sheffield united and maybe have a few more players back.

COYP

It just goes to show, if your not on top of your game in the Premier, you will lose, there are no easy games. There is no doubt the injuries have limited his selections and we looked tired last night, whilst they could rest their top scorer.
Not having Luca in front of the back 4 cost us, both there goals came from outside the box, where Luca plays.
10 days rest and maybe some players coming back will help.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 22 Jan 20 9.30am

Originally posted by EddieMac

Our biggest problem all season has been our complete fear of holding onto the ball. I think Riedewald must have gave it away about 20 times last night and then nobody else was much better.Sakho makes a differnce when he starts because he tries to pass the ball but then he is always liable to make a big mistake so id rather stick with Tomkins and Cahill.

I think we are a better team with Ayew up front and he deserves to play up there ahead of the rest of the strikers.

I would agree, but we are currently short of a quality right winger. The pressure would lift off Zaha in an instant if we had a similar outlet on the right. It would as you rightly say, then allow Ayew to move back to his preferred central position and we would revert to a balanced attack. At the moment we are restricted to left side assaults which every team we play has worked out how to deal with.

This is why I have been banging on about spending decent money on a winger but it seems to fall on deaf ears.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Jan 20 9.34am

Originally posted by EddieMac

I don't believe we are safe in the slighest. I can see this year being the highest points total to stay up in recent history.

At this point last year we had

Cardiff 19 points
Fulham 17 points
Hudderfield 11 points.

so already there is 4 point difference on the team in 3rd last and the bottom teams this year are stronger. we are far from safe.

I had a conversation with an A.Villa supporter the other night who was incredulous that I was showing concerns over our prospects.

We gain draws, pick up wins here and there on the back of abject performances and at the end of the day this might not be enough.

At the weekend Burnley beat Leicester, I would have no faith that we could emulate this result.Last night Bournemouth scored 3 to beat Brighton - don't think too many supporters would bet on us to actually score 3 goals in a game and of course we failed to beat Brighton at home.A.Villa came from behind to beat Watford and Newcastle came from 2 goals behind to gain a very commendable draw at Everton. I accept we came from behind to beat W.Ham but at a time when they were in the doldrums under Pellegrini.In general terms I and many others I suspect have precious little faith that we have the ability to turn a game on it's head as others have done.

Edited by Willo (22 Jan 2020 9.35am)

 

Rainforest Flag London England 22 Jan 20 9.40am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I do think Wilf is being asked to play in a very rigid fashion and is not being given freedom to roam - otherwise he would so.
Hodgson’s rigid tactics do not get the best out of Zaha or Townsend.
Those who think Hodgson is the greatest manager in our history are entitled to their opinion.
For me I beg to differ and would like us to occasionally venture into the opposition half and not have the worst goalscoring record in the division.
I will always support the club, but in my opinion I can’t stand the way we are set up and despair at the football served up.
Being a fan for me doesn’t mean blind loyalty and inability to see faults staring one in the face.

At least Roy should tinker with the formation/tactics slightly when Max came on. Just move Max (although he is not a winger) to the wing and Zaha to play centrally.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 22 Jan 20 10.02am

Lets just move on. Saints were better than us in every department. I went to the reverse fixture a few weeks ago and we matched them for the vast majority of the game.
Last night just felt we were running on empty with no energy.
The odd observation from the home season so far is the only team we have outplayed at home this season has been Liverpool.

 

fromtherope Flag In the woods of deepest Surrey 22 Jan 20 10.04am

Good morning, I have to admit that i have not read through the 20 pages of comments on this thread but I have scanned through the last few pages. So here is my take on last night

Us, lethargic, overly defensive minded and outrun in midfield. Ayew not a wide player so failed to protect kelly who is not a right back. Tuson rush of blood was a killer blow.

Them, fresh, all over us, creative, worked on our weak right side. To be fair two good goals but both should have been closed down. Their sh*t house players wound up Wilf who acted the whole night like a petulant schoolboy.

Ten days rest much needed, recovery from injury of our wounded, sign Walker-Peters from Spurs try and get a creative midfielder and a right winger.

Relegation? Highly unlikely but we need a few more results to be sure. they will come with a revitalised squad.

And finally... Roy must step down (or go upstairs) at the end of the season and we have to find a manager who can bring a breath of fresh air, new ideas and an attack minded approach to help us move on and up.

As for the board and investors, Who knows what is and will happen?

 


I am enjoying being back at Selhurst and having a beer with my mates just like we have done for the past 40 years. Through Thick and thin we stick with our club. Not chairman, players or managers, OUR CLUB!

drbiscuit Flag croydon 22 Jan 20 10.12am

Here here.... great post

Originally posted by fromtherope

Good morning, I have to admit that i have not read through the 20 pages of comments on this thread but I have scanned through the last few pages. So here is my take on last night

Us, lethargic, overly defensive minded and outrun in midfield. Ayew not a wide player so failed to protect kelly who is not a right back. Tuson rush of blood was a killer blow.

Them, fresh, all over us, creative, worked on our weak right side. To be fair two good goals but both should have been closed down. Their sh*t house players wound up Wilf who acted the whole night like a petulant schoolboy.

Ten days rest much needed, recovery from injury of our wounded, sign Walker-Peters from Spurs try and get a creative midfielder and a right winger.

Relegation? Highly unlikely but we need a few more results to be sure. they will come with a revitalised squad.

And finally... Roy must step down (or go upstairs) at the end of the season and we have to find a manager who can bring a breath of fresh air, new ideas and an attack minded approach to help us move on and up.

As for the board and investors, Who knows what is and will happen?

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 22 Jan 20 10.14am

Originally posted by HKOwen

We lost a game and all the haters start to hate etc.

We are still having a good season overall.

The moaning gets very boring

I think Wilf, as our best player, still needs to be more mature. He's not a kid but still reacts like one sometimes.

Nothing to do with hate.

We are discussing last nights game. Perhaps you didn't see it but it was an abject performance and people are venting their frustration at how hapless we were. If we had just been unlucky then your comments would perhaps be valid, but there were no positives whatsoever in last night' performance.

We were slow, outwitted, couldn't pass and toothless up front. In fact they are features that have been prominent in our play generally this season but somehow we have muddled through by raising our game for periods in matches. What it does show is that we are walking a fine line between success and failure.

 

EddieMac Flag 22 Jan 20 10.19am

Originally posted by fromtherope

Good morning, I have to admit that i have not read through the 20 pages of comments on this thread but I have scanned through the last few pages. So here is my take on last night

Us, lethargic, overly defensive minded and outrun in midfield. Ayew not a wide player so failed to protect kelly who is not a right back. Tuson rush of blood was a killer blow.

Them, fresh, all over us, creative, worked on our weak right side. To be fair two good goals but both should have been closed down. Their sh*t house players wound up Wilf who acted the whole night like a petulant schoolboy.

Ten days rest much needed, recovery from injury of our wounded, sign Walker-Peters from Spurs try and get a creative midfielder and a right winger.

Relegation? Highly unlikely but we need a few more results to be sure. they will come with a revitalised squad.

And finally... Roy must step down (or go upstairs) at the end of the season and we have to find a manager who can bring a breath of fresh air, new ideas and an attack minded approach to help us move on and up.

As for the board and investors, Who knows what is and will happen?

This was probably our biggest problem all night but we have to remember that we have be playing the last month without a recognised full back so our draws against Arse and City were only papering over the massive cracks. EWe have played more than a month without a fullback and 1 winger. We have lost most of the pace in our side and most of our width. We are blessed to not be sitting in the relagation zone. There are not many teams in this division that would cope with so many injuries in the wide positions.

The board need to take full responsibilty for this and fans need to fealise the situation we are in.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Jan 20 10.19am

Originally posted by fromtherope

Good morning, I have to admit that i have not read through the 20 pages of comments on this thread but I have scanned through the last few pages. So here is my take on last night

Us, lethargic, overly defensive minded and outrun in midfield. Ayew not a wide player so failed to protect kelly who is not a right back. Tuson rush of blood was a killer blow.

Them, fresh, all over us, creative, worked on our weak right side. To be fair two good goals but both should have been closed down. Their sh*t house players wound up Wilf who acted the whole night like a petulant schoolboy.

Ten days rest much needed, recovery from injury of our wounded, sign Walker-Peters from Spurs try and get a creative midfielder and a right winger.

Relegation? Highly unlikely but we need a few more results to be sure. they will come with a revitalised squad.

And finally... Roy must step down (or go upstairs) at the end of the season and we have to find a manager who can bring a breath of fresh air, new ideas and an attack minded approach to help us move on and up.

As for the board and investors, Who knows what is and will happen?

I believe what was labelled against Chris Hughton at Brighton was the fact that they never played a brand of attractive football.
At present after 24 games, Brighton sit in 15th place on 25 pts.
Under Hughton after 24 games last season, Brighton were 13th on 26 pts.
The style of football coupled with the fact they finished 17th last season probably cost him his job.

 

eaglesdare Flag 22 Jan 20 10.22am

Win some you loose some. Move on...

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 22 Jan 20 10.26am

Saints looked a class above. Outplayed in every dept. Our one potential threat was wound-up and fouled out of the game.

Palace are an enigma. Battled to a draw at ManCity yet could not get remotely close against Saints.

Where is the next win coming from?

After last night's effort I'm wondering if the board and manager have shares in Prozac.
Safe? Not f***ing yet.

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

The_Aviator Flag Rochester 22 Jan 20 2.50pm

Originally posted by Eaglehamster
Palace are an enigma. Battled to a draw at ManCity yet could not get remotely close against Saints.

The expression 'Typical Palace' was coined many years ago when I were a lad. Nothing has changed much in 50 years except that we are now an established top flight team instead of playing in the old third division.

Cup half full here.

 

Page 12 of 17 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Southampton match thread