You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > One word answer..... Should Roy go now...
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

One word answer..... Should Roy go now...


Page 12 of 14 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Feb 20 4.38pm

Originally posted by Bangell

I think our transfer policy won't change regardless of who the manager is.

There might be more cohesion or input or less stubbornness or whatever it is he’s possibly doing. I don’t completely blame Parish and Freedman. Roy takes some blame for Sørloth the shambles of Meyer, possibly camerasa, maybe hiding behind excuses that aren’t the full story. Something isn’t right with all three of them and there’s only one that’s going to go and it ain’t Parish or his favourite greasy Scottish &rse rimming licker.

 


COYP

Dancer Cat Flag Farnborough 11 Feb 20 4.38pm

I don't post much these days, but I have to say I'm a little bemused / ashamed of this thread.

I think it's possible we'll get relegated, & our football "style" is attritional to put it mildly. but 2 points people:-

1. (minor) - I don't think l anyone else (given our squad) would be able to garner any more points from our remaining fixtures than Roy could.

2. (F-Major) - I think we owe a debt of loyalty to Roy (& Ray) for punching above our weight for 2.5 seasons now - given the shocking squad management - bad transfer window following bad transfer window ad infinitum.

This thread (unfortunately) shows me that we're just the same as every other of the "91" - we should aim higher morally in. my opinion.

& yes, he should go in the summer

No doubt Parish will f-up (again) but offering out of date goods a further shelf extension (Pards, Benteke).

 

SurbsEagle Flag 11 Feb 20 4.41pm

Originally posted by Dancer Cat

I don't post much these days, but I have to say I'm a little bemused / ashamed of this thread.

I think it's possible we'll get relegated, & our football "style" is attritional to put it mildly. but 2 points people:-

1. (minor) - I don't think l anyone else (given our squad) would be able to garner any more points from our remaining fixtures than Roy could.

2. (F-Major) - I think we owe a debt of loyalty to Roy (& Ray) for punching above our weight for 2.5 seasons now - given the shocking squad management - bad transfer window following bad transfer window ad infinitum.

This thread (unfortunately) shows me that we're just the same as every other of the "91" - we should aim higher morally in. my opinion.

& yes, he should go in the summer

No doubt Parish will f-up (again) but offering out of date goods a further shelf extension (Pards, Benteke).

Fantastic post.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Feb 20 4.41pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I know PL status isn't everything but I fancy he's our best shot at preserving ours. If Pochettino wants a 3 year contract with us, okay, thanks for all the hard work, Roy.

But he doesn't. People calling for change so casually must offer a realistic alternative. Because I don't see one.

And don't say Allardyce. He got us out by spending about 36m in one window.

With the same players Roy has.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Feb 20 4.51pm

Originally posted by SurbsEagle

And I would say that is a fairly reasonable assessment of this season and last season. We haven't won any games by playing pretty football but when have we ever won any games playing decent football in this league? We gave 'pretty' football a chance and sacked it off after 4 games. You go from Pulis to Pards to Allardyce to Roy - all play fairly similar conservative style football (some more than others). Roy has just out-performed all the others in my opinion. In terms of saying teams have worked us out, it's easy - don't let Wilfried Zaha into the penalty area and they won't score.

Believe me, I am as bored of watching this football as the next guy but until someone can name a decent replacement to Roy, that is available to this club, then why would we sack the manager?

Finding the new manager is for the football oracle Freedman to find and decide along with the football and strategy nous of Parish seeing as he’s so good at football strategy cost effectively. (In the summer. Put up with the decline of Roy for this last ordeal)

 


COYP

PatrickA Flag London 11 Feb 20 4.51pm

There’s a poll on the other forum as to whether Roy should stay or go.
It’s currently running at 210 in favour of him going and 100 in favour of him staying.
Not sure how representative this is of the entire fanbase as I thought more would be in his favour.
I suppose football fans (including me ) are a fickle bunch and if we win the next couple of games the results of the poll will reverse.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 11 Feb 20 4.59pm

2 very inactive transfer windows suggest there is some restriction in our spending ability presently. Roy may not be happy but hasn't run off like some other managers. If this is going to be a similar situation next season then Roy's quotes about talks concerning contract extension are credible. I'm not sure any new manager will come in under those circumstances but Roy might well stay, suiting the owners.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Feb 20 4.59pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

There’s a poll on the other forum as to whether Roy should stay or go.
It’s currently running at 210 in favour of him going and 100 in favour of him staying.
Not sure how representative this is of the entire fanbase as I thought more would be in his favour.
I suppose football fans (including me ) are a fickle bunch and if we win the next couple of games the results of the poll will reverse.

I am surprised at that because ‘sacking’ roy now for me would and should depend on the replacement. But I’d 100% not extend his employment this summer.

His shelf life here is well and truly done. He’s now a turkey unsold on 27th December with a use bu date of Boxing Day.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Feb 20 5.05pm

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

2 very inactive transfer windows suggest there is some restriction in our spending ability presently. Roy may not be happy but hasn't run off like some other managers. If this is going to be a similar situation next season then Roy's quotes about talks concerning contract extension are credible. I'm not sure any new manager will come in under those circumstances but Roy might well stay, suiting the owners.

Then Parish’s amazing stewardship of all Palace football matters has truly come home to roost. I know it’s for the other thread but Parish was found out years ago on this website. Has dug himself out of sh1t with money from the future several times and after managerial errors from having very little clue, and a lot of that stems from not having or not listening to non yes-men. Someone who knows feck all about the game ignores those who do. All is okay now because we have Freedman who stitched him and us over who also had and has zero experience of the role he was employed for.

 


COYP

PatrickA Flag London 11 Feb 20 5.07pm

For the purposes of clarification 151 think Hodgson should go in the summer with 59 thinking he should go now.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Feb 20 5.24pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

For the purposes of clarification 151 think Hodgson should go in the summer with 59 thinking he should go now.

That’s what I expected. Only bad or owners unwilling to spend again and really risk ourselves would keep him next season.

Same again then, until we’re fecked earlier on and worse, with the wrong players and player mix after another window flushed down the toilet.

Shambolic owners we have now. Truly w@nk.

 


COYP

Putitout Flag Oxford 11 Feb 20 5.31pm

Originally posted by Dancer Cat

I don't post much these days, but I have to say I'm a little bemused / ashamed of this thread.

I think it's possible we'll get relegated, & our football "style" is attritional to put it mildly. but 2 points people:-

1. (minor) - I don't think l anyone else (given our squad) would be able to garner any more points from our remaining fixtures than Roy could.

2. (F-Major) - I think we owe a debt of loyalty to Roy (& Ray) for punching above our weight for 2.5 seasons now - given the shocking squad management - bad transfer window following bad transfer window ad infinitum.

This thread (unfortunately) shows me that we're just the same as every other of the "91" - we should aim higher morally in. my opinion.

& yes, he should go in the summer

No doubt Parish will f-up (again) but offering out of date goods a further shelf extension (Pards, Benteke).

These are good points, but this thread only reflects what has , and does happen at most clubs that have probably reached their realistic potential. In most cases the clubs involved have spent big trying to go forward . That hasn’t happened here.
Calling for Hodgsons, head might hold water if he had any real backing in the transfer market. He hasn’t , And because of that we are where we are. People think Palace could,should, play differently when needed . That could only happen if he had real game changers in the squad.He hasn’t ,because apparently the club can’t afford more than space fillers and potential.
There aren’t many that would want his job.And none to do a better job under the same conditions.
The board are trying to get success on a shoe string, the result is we in effect stand still, in football that usually means it will end in tears.
Getting rid of a manager that handles the situation as well as Hodgson has is invariably part of the last act before relegation.

 

beak Flag croydon 11 Feb 20 5.49pm

.... and I think he should stay as long as he likes,great man, a very experienced manager who is safety minded,are we going round and round with Allardyce, Pulis and the other mercenaries? Please be serious!

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 11 Feb 20 5.50pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Then Parish’s amazing stewardship of all Palace football matters has truly come home to roost. I know it’s for the other thread but Parish was found out years ago on this website. Has dug himself out of sh1t with money from the future several times and after managerial errors from having very little clue, and a lot of that stems from not having or not listening to non yes-men. Someone who knows feck all about the game ignores those who do. All is okay now because we have Freedman who stitched him and us over who also had and has zero experience of the role he was employed for.

I think a snake oil charlatan can spot Parish a mile away - a fool and his money...

 

deleted 25 Flag 11 Feb 20 6.19pm

No

 

jhillman Flag USA 11 Feb 20 7.06pm

No

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 Feb 20 7.19pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill


I think a snake oil charlatan can spot Parish a mile away

Eight years ago Parish was revered like a god on this forum. Three of us had reservations about him and were roundly derided at every given opportunity with one particular R Sole being banned several times for his tirade of personal insults.

I read many of the comments about our chairman nowadays with a wry smile

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Feb 20 7.35pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Eight years ago Parish was revered like a god on this forum. Three of us had reservations about him and were roundly derided at every given opportunity with one particular R Sole being banned several times for his tirade of personal insults.

I read many of the comments about our chairman nowadays with a wry smile

I’ve replied in the ‘moaning’ thread.

[Link]

 


COYP

Dannyh.V2 Flag Stone lickers 11 Feb 20 7.38pm

Originally posted by SurbsEagle

My Fulham mate would argue Roy was the best thing that's ever happened to them as he took them to their only European final. And Liverpool were to blame for their failings, Roy was made a scapegoat - even Liverpool fans will tell you that.

First off, even Pardew got us to the FA Cup Final and he was gloriously Sh1t. As for the Dippers one of their defenders a certain international Glen Johnson who knows more than any liverpool " fan " has been on interview and slated Hodgson for being way to negative. So sorry mate that means nothing.

Roy's a busted flush and teams beat us with relative ease.

 

PatrickA Flag London 11 Feb 20 7.52pm

As a minimum , if the club is thinking of offering Hodgson a contract, it should certainly hold off until the club are safe.
For him to sign a new contract and end up taking the club down would seem very strange !

 

Page 12 of 14 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > One word answer..... Should Roy go now...