This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Hi Neillo,
The best footie management game: [Link] |
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
I don’t disagree with anything you said but Roy was not brought in to develop younger players he was brought in to keep us safe for a few years while the club sorted itself out in the background. It is up to Parish and Dougie to get those younger players in and be ready for the next manager to develop. Roy has no interest in signing 19/20 year olds as he knows he will be gone in a year or so and more than likely this will be his last year in football management. The same goes with developing or moving with the times, he was not brought in to develop or move with the times and why would he change everything he knows. He is 74 not 34. This is just something we are going to have to put up with for another year so a lot of may as well get used to it. Roy will be gone in 12 months and so will most of that squad, the next few transfer windows are critical and it will not be Roy making the signings. Agree. Roy has done the job he was hired to do which was to keep us in the EPL. Whilst he may not be one for blooding young players, he is clearly not averse to young players coming in for future development (think Banks) and but for a medical issue we would have had Fergusson as well. As for playing our own youngsters, as I've said on other threads, when your U23 team are joint bottom of their league (comprising mainly Championship and League 1 clubs) it's unlikely there will be talent there that is ready to be exposed to the Prem. We've had glimpses of two possibilities in Pierrick and Mitchell. Obviously, last night wasn't a game in which to give them an outing. With the contracts of most of the first team due to end next year, the next 12 months will, to say teh elast be interesting.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Just watched the highlights on Palace TV. Commentator suggesting that Chelsea should have stopped play for the first goal when Cahill went down. Clutching at straws for that it wasn't a life threatening injury they were entitled to play on. There was no obligation for Chelsea to stop the play.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I broadly agree with this viewpoint. I would add that Schlupp provides physicality and being left-footed provides a balance down the left. He has also chipped in with some goals. You mentioned our ageing squad.I believe that in this post-lockdown period with a succession of games in a short period of time, we have to recognise the demands of those in the twilight of their careers. Have to say that we are definitely missing Schlupp and Tomkins and will be likewise missing Cahill for the way that they can operate Defence and support Midfield and beyond.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ian-VI
Hi Neillo, Totally right about the system. Unfortunately for us we have never really seen this happen, particularly in the Championship, which shows the problem with the academy. Hopefully this will start to be addressed with it's upgrade. Somebody mentioned that Richard Shaw wasn't happy about the lack of loans. As none of our youngsters are in that league and playing regularly it gives a good indication of where we are at the moment.
“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ” |
|
|
Mr Ward had a really bad game which was a shame considering how consistent he normally is.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Tickled pink
Mr Ward had a really bad game which was a shame considering how consistent he normally is. His poor performance also coincided with Mr Zaha playing in front of him. Ward needs constant help back there or he is in trouble against pace.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
Well the good news is that the club IS focusing on the future with the big investment in the Academy and gaining Cat 1 status. Scouting is something that never stops but success depends on how effective your network is and how it is managed. The constant criticism of Hodgson not giving youth a chance is something of a red herring in my opinion. The fact is, AWB aside, we haven't had a glut of young players pressing for a first team place. Hodgson will be looking at addressing the overall age of the squad this summer I am sure. It's an accepted fact that needs to be done. I don't think it will be too radical more of a gradual rebuild. My concern is that when you are only effectively contracting a manager for a season at a time, it surely hinders medium term planning. That being the issue though. As you say there is no medium term plan. The youth may be a red herring, but until RH considers trying something different or not just like for like we will never know. When he took over he had to play Zaha and Townsend up front and was forced into it. We signed Sorloth who is banging them in, Benteke was scoring under Allardyce. RH seems to want to sacrifice players strengths for the sake of the system - fine, but the system is easy for an opposition to plan for. Pulis, Allardyce, Hodgson - all seasoned “keep you up managers”. But if they overhauled your squad they are not going to go for prospects - they will go for aging senior players which is not what we need. Older pros clearly respond to Roy, I’m not sure a team of younger players will or indeed would want to come - hence the vicious circle continues. It is an overly romantic idea to think we can play fast flowing football straight away. I’d just rather we attack with a bit more pace and accepted we can take the game to some teams on the front foot. Zaha, Townsend and Benteke is a front three that should score goals at this level.
|
|
|
Originally posted by robdave2k
That being the issue though. As you say there is no medium term plan. The youth may be a red herring, but until RH considers trying something different or not just like for like we will never know. When he took over he had to play Zaha and Townsend up front and was forced into it. We signed Sorloth who is banging them in, Benteke was scoring under Allardyce. RH seems to want to sacrifice players strengths for the sake of the system - fine, but the system is easy for an opposition to plan for. Pulis, Allardyce, Hodgson - all seasoned “keep you up managers”. But if they overhauled your squad they are not going to go for prospects - they will go for aging senior players which is not what we need. Older pros clearly respond to Roy, I’m not sure a team of younger players will or indeed would want to come - hence the vicious circle continues. It is an overly romantic idea to think we can play fast flowing football straight away. I’d just rather we attack with a bit more pace and accepted we can take the game to some teams on the front foot. Zaha, Townsend and Benteke is a front three that should score goals at this level. Zaha and Townsend have never been known for their goals.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Zaha and Townsend have never been known for their goals. Also all 3 of them have been in poor form all season.Townsend and Benteke have had a lot of injuries which may be a factor but it is not Roy’s fault that Townsend and Zaha can’t cross a decent ball or Townsend has lost the ability to beat a full back or Benteke can’t even kick a football. These issues are not tactic related they are down to ability and form. When the players are on the pitch they are in control. Our general passing is abysmal which again Roy has no control over.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Zaha and Townsend have never been known for their goals. Thanks Wikipedia. Kind of the point I was making: two wingers crossing, a forward who thrives on crosses.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
Also all 3 of them have been in poor form all season.Townsend and Benteke have had a lot of injuries which may be a factor but it is not Roy’s fault that Townsend and Zaha can’t cross a decent ball or Townsend has lost the ability to beat a full back or Benteke can’t even kick a football. These issues are not tactic related they are down to ability and form. When the players are on the pitch they are in control. Our general passing is abysmal which again Roy has no control over. He's the coach; he decides who plays and to an extent who we sign (such as he wanted McCarthy who has been next to useless). How is it not down to him?
|
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
I don’t disagree with anything you said but Roy was not brought in to develop younger players he was brought in to keep us safe for a few years while the club sorted itself out in the background. It is up to Parish and Dougie to get those younger players in and be ready for the next manager to develop. Roy has no interest in signing 19/20 year olds as he knows he will be gone in a year or so and more than likely this will be his last year in football management. The same goes with developing or moving with the times, I fully agree with you, Roy was bought in as a safe pair of hands after the destruction of FdV.With little resources Roy has done a tremendous job in keeping us in this division with little support on the recruiting front and despite the latter has remained loyal to the club, unlike others in the past who threw their toys out of the pram when they could not get support from the top. Roy is with us until the end of next season at least and it's time we showed our appreciation for what he has achieved.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cpj
He's the coach; he decides who plays and to an extent who we sign (such as he wanted McCarthy who has been next to useless). How is it not down to him? So your telling me that when the ball is at PVA’s foot or any players foot for that matter and that player can not pass the ball 12 yards that it’s the managers fault? And I think your wrong about McCarthy, he should be starting in midfield.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
I fully agree with you, Roy was bought in as a safe pair of hands after the destruction of FdV.With little resources Roy has done a tremendous job in keeping us in this division with little support on the recruiting front and despite the latter has remained loyal to the club, unlike others in the past who threw their toys out of the pram when they could not get support from the top. Roy is with us until the end of next season at least and it's time we showed our appreciation for what he has achieved. I fully appreciate his efforts at our club and I have expressed these sentiments both in HOL and in conversations with those who are not contributors to this site.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
So your telling me that when the ball is at PVA’s foot or any players foot for that matter and that player can not pass the ball 12 yards that it’s the managers fault? And I think your wrong about McCarthy, he should be starting in midfield.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
I find it strange that Meyer gets slagged off after every cameo performance but a long serving player like Ward, who has been dire since the return doesn’t get as much criticism. Wardy has been really bad, I hate to say it but AWB would have nailed Pulisic before he got that shot in for the second last night..
|
|
|
Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews
Wardy has been really bad, I hate to say it but AWB would have nailed Pulisic before he got that shot in for the second last night.. AWB is an excellent one-on-one defender and Pulisic would not have been able to get that shot away. What I will add about Pulisic is that he has a quick change of direction and has the ability to score with both right and left feet and his head. Edited by Willo (08 Jul 2020 3.17pm)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.