This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Palace v Newcastle Match thread
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
BM 27 Nov 20 11.20pm |
|
Originally posted by SwordFish
Spot on Willo, I thought the same about Dann and it’s a real shame but he’s had his day now I think, and totally agree Newcastle were lucky to come away with win, only 3 mins before their second goal we had 2 chances to win the game!
Our attacks mostly coming down the left is nothing new. There is no rule that says you have to attack evenly from both flanks. Townsend unbalances us when he plays because it means we have a good player on the left and a poor one on the right.
|
Numbers Man Tulse Hill 27 Nov 20 11.21pm |
|
|
It was obvious what was wrong against Burnley.. We allowed Newcastle to dominate for the first 20,minutes the same as against Burnley. RH should realise that this is a mistake especially at home but he never seems to learn. We never replaced Cabaye who had time on the ball and made himself available for a pass in a tight spot. Koyate played well in mid field but him and James McArthur are too similar to create opportunities for the front men. But at the end of the day we are dependent on Wilf to win games.
|
palace chick South Croydon 27 Nov 20 11.25pm |
|
Originally posted by SwordFish
Spot on Willo, I thought the same about Dann and it’s a real shame but he’s had his day now I think, and totally agree Newcastle were lucky to come away with win, only 3 mins before their second goal we had 2 chances to win the game!
Yes, Dann was awful - It also didn’t help us that his mistake(s) in the 1st half didn’t put us behind. We just may have made earlier changes, including bringing on one of the two central defenders on the bench? To me, Newcastle were always the team that was going to score. I’m not at all confident that we will pick up points in matches to come - perhaps I will feel differently tomorrow but at this moment I feel we need a change to our managerial team of Hodgson and Lewington and quickly.
Perhaps the only chance with sticking with Hodgson now is to go back to the 3 defensive midfielders by bringing Luka back in alongside either Kouyate and McCarthur or McCarthy? Boring to watch but will give us more points hopefully? Would also mean the bench for Reidewald and Eze?
Edited by palace chick (27 Nov 2020 11.32pm)
|
Kentbaldeagle64 Swanscombe 27 Nov 20 11.29pm |
|
|
I just give up. Older players past their best or can last 60 mins before fatigue set in. Why not play a younger central defender alongside Cahill or Dann to develop. Missing Tompkins for sure.
Depressed.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Nov 20 11.30pm |
|
Originally posted by Mathers
Tonight showed yet again that Roy is tactically clueless both pre-match and during the game. 3
Dann - was having a stinker all night. Almost gave away two goals in the 1st half with slack passing. He was left on and unsurprisingly was the guilty party for Wilson’s goal by getting dragged out of position and no pace to recover. Should have been subbed at HT.
Benteke- clearly we need a target man when we don’t have Wilf to run at defenders. Ayew is useless when he’s isolated up front. It’s unlikely Benteke will score but at least he’ll bring people into play and give defenders a hard time in the air. Should have come on HT.
Townsend- should only be on the pitch in tandem with Benteke. If he isn’t crossing it to somebody with half a chance of winning it, then he’s absolutely garbage. No pace, no trickery and he seems to have completely given up shooting from range. When Benteke did come on, Andros was subbed a minute later. Sums up Roy.
It’s a complete joke we let him stay after the disastrous end to last season. Hope Parish grows a pair and gets rid instead of letting him piss away the rest of the season waiting for him to retire
I would like to see us sign Giroud in January on a deal until the end of the season.
In midfield, I believe John Lundstram would be a decent acquisition.
On the right we really miss an attacking full-back to provide a different dimension down that flank.
In central defence,Cahill has been sound but is in his mid 30s, Tomkins is in his 30s and hasn't played for a while.I don't have a great deal of confidence Sakho, Kelly or Dann. Another area to strengthen.
Edited by Willo (27 Nov 2020 11.39pm)
|
Eaglecoops CR3 27 Nov 20 11.35pm |
|
Originally posted by Gribbo
I am just so bored with it all now. A bewildered 73 year old man lacking passion and motivation, stumbling around with a team of 30 year old players, not knowing what to do to score a goal. It’s pitiful really.
Think I will give the rest of the season a miss. I cannot bear to watch it any more. Will come back next season, when Hodgson has finally given up the ghost. Not really fussed what division we are in, I just want to watch a decent game of football, with flair, attacking players and the expectation and excitement of a goal from open play.
I get more pleasure watching the U23s on a one-camera internet stream. I have enjoyed watching Southampton this year, a bunch of no-name players giving 100% to try and score goals, with a great manager who has them organised and exciting to watch - happy days for their fans.
Thanks for all your efforts Roy, but you have had your day, it’s time to pack it in. Try not to drive the club too far into the mire in the next 6 months.
Bang on mate, don’t let the idiots put you off posting this. Most have had enough of the garbage we are playing. Some obviously think it’s ok however
|
SwordFish Peasmarsh,East Sussex 27 Nov 20 11.39pm |
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Bang on mate, don’t let the idiots put you off posting this. Most have had enough of the garbage we are playing. Some obviously think it’s ok however
Nah, if he gets more pleasure out of watching Southampton??? Then I suggest he goes and watches them and not post on a palace message board , good night
“This is a crisis, a large crisis.... in fact if you have a moment, it’s a 12 storey crisis, magnificent entrance hall, carpeting throughout, 24 hour portage , and an enormous sign on the roof saying “This , is a large crisis” - Edmund Blackadder
|
BlueJay UK 28 Nov 20 12.03am |
|
Originally posted by Kentbaldeagle64
I just give up. Older players past their best or can last 60 mins before fatigue set in. Why not play a younger central defender alongside Cahill or Dann to develop. Missing Tompkins for sure.
Depressed.
We are rather stuck in our ways it has to be said.
|
Henry of Peckham Eton Mess 28 Nov 20 12.36am |
|
|
What could anyone say about the game that hasn't already been said so many times before?
Yet another dreadfully disappointing outcome. We really couldn’t hit a barn door!
Denial is not just a river in Egypt
|
Palacesince64 Edinburgh 28 Nov 20 12.49am |
|
|
I agree it doesn’t make sense to put Benteke on and take Townsend off even though it has to be said Townsend is awful currently. Last decent corner we had was taken by Eze against Leeds and scored by Dann yet Townsend gets to take the corners on both wings. Benteke did ok for the 30 minutes he played but isn’t the answer to our goal drought. If we do anything in January it has to be buying a decent striker.
Only plus for me was that Clyne did pretty well at right back and looks a smart signing until Ferguson gets over his injury.... if he ever does!
Oh and if Ajax come offering decent cash for PVA we should probably grab it. He silent look like the player of the last 2 seasons.
|
Hannes Vienna 28 Nov 20 7.17am |
|
|
Banner translated: With you it's like with women: We are looking for a nice weekend and after three minutes we are pi$$ed off!
Attachment: QDUG1603.JPG (42.44Kb)
|
The Dolphin 28 Nov 20 7.35am |
|
|
When Ian Dowie took over as Manager all those years ago we were beaten 1-0 at home by Millwall but it was the best defeat I can remember seeing and I left the ground that day full of hope for the future and and what followed proved that. Right now these stupid defeats and the blind assertions that this is our "best start ever" completely obscure the facts. If you are going to succeed and not tread water you need to improve and regardless of statistics we are not doing that really. I don't expect us to win the League but I do expect the team that I have supported for near 60 years to play with a plan and when players are earning tens of thousands of pounds every week that they are able to do the basics. Last night we could have won - their keeper made some good saves - yes. That is what keeps do though isn't it and Newcastle could have scored well before they did as well. Look at the stats on attempts and on target - we were second best again! Are we better than the likes of Newcastle and Burnley - just, yes, but we lose to them without scoring and with tactics that would shame a game played on the local park. Losing is fine but at least do it in style with the semblance of a plan! Our Manager's tactics are dull and negative and worse than that, they waste the talent that we do have available. Our players know how to play football but they are simply not allowed to because they are not given the framework to do so. Add to that, utilising players out of position and playing players who shouldn't even start! Schlupp played well last night but he is a left back/midfielder - he played up front whilst a £30m center forward who we are thinking of offering a new contract to sat in the stand and his sidekick on loan worth over £20m who we might buy sat beside him - who does that - the same Manager who had Harry Kane taking corners for England - that's who! Scott Dann started his second game in 5 days - he isn't fit enough to do that and it showed. He also started on the centre right whereas last week he was centre left - why? He is a great guy and a wonderful player but he has had his day as a starter! McArthur - industrious and hardworking but now past his sell by date whilst Reidewald sits in the stands and where Schlupp could fit in if we played a centre forward in his place. Ayew - I just don't get it - top scorer last season - not saying much though is it - he is either not used properly or he is just plain not good enough - I don't know which. The list goes on but the bottom line is that Roy Hodgson no longer has what it takes. We start games like strangers, we are unable to string passes together, we are unable to hold the ball, there is no Plan A even. I totally understand the Curbishley theory and like I say I am not expecting Palace to be world beaters but at least hold our own against the likes of Burnley and Newcastle but above all give me hope that despite theses losses that there is more on the way - trouble is there is no hope - just the knowledge of more drudgery to come. I will not set foot inside Selhurst Park again until the Manager is changed (yes - pandemic - I know!) - this negative risk averse football has to stop. I didn't agree with Pardew's ideas and the way he treated some of his players but there is a happy medium. Something has got to give - we are a joke!
|
HesHereHesThere Beckenham 28 Nov 20 8.25am |
|
|
Our two Belgium strikers on the bench (FIFA world ranking no1 team btw) and played three wingers instead, Eze played out of position, Townsend not dropped after Monday, in pre match interview Roy was a bumbling mess...turned it off at half time as it was making my teeth itch. There's only one answer and Parish needs to end this agony for us and for the Roy's...thanks Roy but TTFN.
|
Badger11 Beckenham 28 Nov 20 8.31am |
|
|
Early on my Amazon Prime picture froze unfortunately they got it going again.
I think others have probably covered what I was going to say.
One more point
|
Henry of Peckham Eton Mess 28 Nov 20 8.35am |
|
|
For those who may still be interested ... I see the 20/21 team shirts are 35% off this week. A few more games like last night and I suspect they'll drop to 75% off.
Denial is not just a river in Egypt
|
palace chick South Croydon 28 Nov 20 8.36am |
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
When Ian Dowie took over as Manager all those years ago we were beaten 1-0 at home by Millwall but it was the best defeat I can remember seeing and I left the ground that day full of hope for the future and and what followed proved that. Right now these stupid defeats and the blind assertions that this is our "best start ever" completely obscure the facts. If you are going to succeed and not tread water you need to improve and regardless of statistics we are not doing that really. I don't expect us to win the League but I do expect the team that I have supported for near 60 years to play with a plan and when players are earning tens of thousands of pounds every week that they are able to do the basics. Last night we could have won - their keeper made some good saves - yes. That is what keeps do though isn't it and Newcastle could have scored well before they did as well. Look at the stats on attempts and on target - we were second best again! Are we better than the likes of Newcastle and Burnley - just, yes, but we lose to them without scoring and with tactics that would shame a game played on the local park. Losing is fine but at least do it in style with the semblance of a plan! Our Manager's tactics are dull and negative and worse than that, they waste the talent that we do have available. Our players know how to play football but they are simply not allowed to because they are not given the framework to do so. Add to that, utilising players out of position and playing players who shouldn't even start! Schlupp played well last night but he is a left back/midfielder - he played up front whilst a £30m center forward who we are thinking of offering a new contract to sat in the stand and his sidekick on loan worth over £20m who we might buy sat beside him - who does that - the same Manager who had Harry Kane taking corners for England - that's who! Scott Dann started his second game in 5 days - he isn't fit enough to do that and it showed. He also started on the centre right whereas last week he was centre left - why? He is a great guy and a wonderful player but he has had his day as a starter! McArthur - industrious and hardworking but now past his sell by date whilst Reidewald sits in the stands and where Schlupp could fit in if we played a centre forward in his place. Ayew - I just don't get it - top scorer last season - not saying much though is it - he is either not used properly or he is just plain not good enough - I don't know which. The list goes on but the bottom line is that Roy Hodgson no longer has what it takes. We start games like strangers, we are unable to string passes together, we are unable to hold the ball, there is no Plan A even. I totally understand the Curbishley theory and like I say I am not expecting Palace to be world beaters but at least hold our own against the likes of Burnley and Newcastle but above all give me hope that despite theses losses that there is more on the way - trouble is there is no hope - just the knowledge of more drudgery to come. I will not set foot inside Selhurst Park again until the Manager is changed (yes - pandemic - I know!) - this negative risk averse football has to stop. I didn't agree with Pardew's ideas and the way he treated some of his players but there is a happy medium. Something has got to give - we are a joke!
Agree mostly if not all with that, but if I’m lucky enough to get a ticket I will be attending Selhurst whatever manager is in charge :-)
|
Petereagle Brockley 28 Nov 20 8.55am |
|
Originally posted by palace chick
Agree mostly if not all with that, but if I’m lucky enough to get a ticket I will be attending Selhurst whatever manager is in charge :-)
Me too.
|
Petereagle Brockley 28 Nov 20 9.04am |
|
Originally posted by SwordFish
Spot on Willo, I thought the same about Dann and it’s a real shame but he’s had his day now I think, and totally agree Newcastle were lucky to come away with win, only 3 mins before their second goal we had 2 chances to win the game!
Dann did look dreadful and clearly was exhausted. But our squad has been dreadfully depleted by injuries and Covid. Sakho and Tomkins are not quite matchfit and I am sure Dann will be rested when these key defenders are ready to go. McCarthy is greatly underrated even by Palace fans. Luka is a solid DM even if not the player he once was. And our talisman Zaha has been out for 2 games so far. I think results will improve. I am doing my best to stay positive!
|
dreamwaverider London 28 Nov 20 9.22am |
|
|
If we are allowed 4000 wonder if we will get capacity??
|
dreamwaverider London 28 Nov 20 9.25am |
|
|
Prime Amazon are shocking. We are shocking. Empty stadiums are shocking. Newcastle are crap. I’m worried. Lock down matches of last season we went on a massive losing run with no goals. Are we there again? Big games ahead. Very worrying
|