You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Sheff Utd Match Thread
November 16 2026 5.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace v Sheff Utd Match Thread


Page 12 of 14 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 02 Jan 21 7.35pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

He was absolutely flawless today. He is a better defender than PVA and his passing is better. The position is his to lose now.

It certainly is in my book!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Spiderman Flag Horsham 02 Jan 21 7.36pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

He was absolutely flawless today. He is a better defender than PVA and his passing is better. The position is his to lose now.

Think his passing needs to improve but thought he was very good today

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 02 Jan 21 7.54pm

Originally posted by Palacesince64

Well played today and a great result. If it hadn’t been for Eze’s wonder goal McArthur would have been MOTM. He worked his socks off today. I agree With the posts re captain. Neither Luca nor Wilf are skipper material but I thin Mac is the lease on the field and I’d make him captain for the rest of the season.

I thought Roy was spot on with his post match interview re Eze and his defensive responsibilities. You need to track back in the PL Ian’s can’t get away with not doing it like you can in the championship. Roy and Ray will make the lad a better all round player. Remember how lazy Wilf was defensively and how much he has improved. Mind you his temperament is still an issue and Roy should have considered subbing him today.

As for that goal. Reminded me of John Hughes runner up for goal of the season in 1971. And guess who that was against? I’d add a link if I wasn’t such a techy Luddite! Help anyone? It’s on the redandbluearmy site.

Might be here......

[Link]

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Jan 21 8.04pm

3 vital points. The best thing about Eze's goal was the precise finish - no wild blast, just caressed accurately into the corner; highly impressive!

 

Casual Flag Orpington 02 Jan 21 8.12pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

3 vital points. The best thing about Eze's goal was the precise finish - no wild blast, just caressed accurately into the corner; highly impressive!

Agree. Great finish. At his age after running from where he started and beating a few players, most would have put there laces through it.
Quality , quality goal.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 02 Jan 21 8.14pm

Decent performance, brilliant second goal.
Jimmy Mac was brilliant, still needed the keeper to play well to keep them out.
Professional performance, well happy.

 

Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 02 Jan 21 9.42pm

Very welcome and necessary three points against very limited opposition. Did we lose twice to that lot last year? Even our journeymen players looked good today. While accepting that you can only play against what you're up against on the day, let's not get ahead of ourselves. Reaching for my hard helmet, I'll venture that the game that followed us on Sky looked as if it came from a division higher. We can still struggle with the notion that it is about winning the ball, bringing it under control, and then passing it, preferably quickly, to someone on your side.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 02 Jan 21 9.52pm

A comfortable win.

For those who moan about Sheff U having more possession than us (55-45), Spurs had just 37% today, but still beat Leeds 3-0). It's about what you do with the possession you have. Sheffield Utd didn't do a great deal with theirs and the main reason for that was that we were well organized and limited their shots on goal.

Sheffield Utd have now lost 15 games this season. HOWEVER, we are just the FOURTH team to have beaten them by more than one goal. So for those who are underwhelmed by our achievement today what about those 11 teams who only beat them by one goal (they include, Leeds, Villa, Man C, Liverpool, Arsenal, West Ham, Everton, Leicester and Man U)?

We are now more than half way to safety and still 2 more (albeit difficult) away games before we reach the half-way mark in games.

We weren't at our best today, but then we didn't need to be.

Savour the victory and be thankful that we didn't (as many had thought we would) slip up on the |Sheff U banana skin and give them their first win.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 02 Jan 21 10.13pm

Well said Doombear

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 02 Jan 21 10.27pm

Originally posted by doombear

A comfortable win.

For those who moan about Sheff U having more possession than us (55-45), Spurs had just 37% today, but still beat Leeds 3-0). It's about what you do with the possession you have. Sheffield Utd didn't do a great deal with theirs and the main reason for that was that we were well organized and limited their shots on goal.

Sheffield Utd have now lost 15 games this season. HOWEVER, we are just the FOURTH team to have beaten them by more than one goal. So for those who are underwhelmed by our achievement today what about those 11 teams who only beat them by one goal (they include, Leeds, Villa, Man C, Liverpool, Arsenal, West Ham, Everton, Leicester and Man U)?

We are now more than half way to safety and still 2 more (albeit difficult) away games before we reach the half-way mark in games.

We weren't at our best today, but then we didn't need to be.

Savour the victory and be thankful that we didn't (as many had thought we would) slip up on the |Sheff U banana skin and give them their first win.

There was only ever one winner of that game today. You get a gut feel whilst you are watching a game and today I was never concerned. The blades are a poor side this season and will be relegated.

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 02 Jan 21 10.56pm

I can remember getting roasted at home by a very poor bottom of the table Sunderland a couple of seasons ago, so job well done today. Let’s not waste too much time with the Jan window, we need to be focusing on a proper replacement for Roy, in place before the seasons end with a proper transfer budget to boot. Contracts in place for senior retained players, I.e. not Hennessy, Meyer, Van Aanholt, Wickham, Sakho,.

Pack off Bats back to Chelsea, his understanding of the offside rule and how to lead the line is comparable to my son’s U-11s Sunday side who are just playing offside for the first time this season. You explain the same thing to them every week in training, and on match day they just run head first at the goal as soon as the side gets possession. Acceptable in a 10 year old kid perhaps, but would expect an international striker to have figured it out by now. He plays too far up as he has no pace and no presence. Bullet dodged thank god.

 

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 02 Jan 21 11.06pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink
It’s here 4th December 1971 at Selhurst Park. John Hughes scored 2 goals in the 5-1 against Sheffield United. Our second goal was runner up for goal of the season.

[Link]


Might be here......

[Link]

 

ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 02 Jan 21 11.38pm

I think today if we had more adventurous we could have scored more goals but could easily have conceded as well.I think it was important that we not only won the game at a canter today but also the clean sheet was also very important too.After conceding those ten goals in two games and with difficult games to come this was great to win and give our defence a confidence boost.Tomkins and Kouate look our most assured CB pairing.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 03 Jan 21 8.56am

Originally posted by Gribbo

I can remember getting roasted at home by a very poor bottom of the table Sunderland a couple of seasons ago, so job well done today. Let’s not waste too much time with the Jan window, we need to be focusing on a proper replacement for Roy, in place before the seasons end with a proper transfer budget to boot. Contracts in place for senior retained players, I.e. not Hennessy, Meyer, Van Aanholt, Wickham, Sakho,.

Pack off Bats back to Chelsea, his understanding of the offside rule and how to lead the line is comparable to my son’s U-11s Sunday side who are just playing offside for the first time this season. You explain the same thing to them every week in training, and on match day they just run head first at the goal as soon as the side gets possession. Acceptable in a 10 year old kid perhaps, but would expect an international striker to have figured it out by now. He plays too far up as he has no pace and no presence. Bullet dodged thank god.

Why do you feel the urge to say that?

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 03 Jan 21 9.02am

Originally posted by ripleyeagle

I think today if we had more adventurous we could have scored more goals but could easily have conceded as well.I think it was important that we not only won the game at a canter today but also the clean sheet was also very important too.After conceding those ten goals in two games and with difficult games to come this was great to win and give our defence a confidence boost.Tomkins and Kouate look our most assured CB pairing.

You have to be having a laugh, apparently on MOTD they had one shot cleared off the line but how on earth does a player who's standing in front of our keeper who uses his legs to block the shot with our keeper in perfect line to stop it anyway constitute off the line? stupidly nuts, once again I'll remind you that we were fouled eighteen times and that doesn't include the ones we didn't get, how many of those were to stop us attacking? ...also one of their players actually said that we should've hacked Eze down to stop him scoring!

Football needs to introduce a form of the sinbin to stop teams cheating every single time they are outpaced or just purely beaten during build up play, it is destroying our game, in he old days teams would be allowed to carry on and if that happened yesterday we may have been able to utilise about four occasions where we managed to pick the ball up after the foul, but you and everyone understands how every team is then afforded to get into position to defend as a whole unit once the foul has been given and everyone knows that is a lot easier to defend then when running back towards your goal!

Edited by Tickled pink (03 Jan 2021 9.15am)

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 03 Jan 21 9.28am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

You have to be having a laugh, apparently on MOTD they had one shot cleared off the line but how on earth does a player who's standing in front of our keeper who uses his legs to block the shot with our keeper in perfect line to stop it anyway constitute off the line? stupidly nuts, once again I'll remind you that we were fouled eighteen times and that doesn't include the ones we didn't get, how many of those were to stop us attacking? ...also one of their players actually said that we should've hacked Eze down to stop him scoring!

Football needs to introduce a form of the sinbin to stop teams cheating every single time they are outpaced or just purely beaten during build up play, it is destroying our game, in he old days teams would be allowed to carry on and if that happened yesterday we may have been able to utilise about four occasions where we managed to pick the ball up after the foul, but you and everyone understands how every team is then afforded to get into position to defend as a whole unit once the foul has been given and everyone knows that is a lot easier to defend then when running back towards your goal!

Edited by Tickled pink (03 Jan 2021 9.15am)

Oliver Norwood - one of the most atrocious things I've heard in regard to a how to play football.
Yes we know-it-all goes on, but it really shouldn't. For someone to openly say this - and for it to get absolutely no coverage or comment is disgraceful.
Imho, intentional fouling is one of the worst things about the game, alongside diving. The FA should at the very least condemn these comments. And even take some form of action against them.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 03 Jan 21 9.37am

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

Oliver Norwood - one of the most atrocious things I've heard in regard to a how to play football.
Yes we know-it-all goes on, but it really shouldn't. For someone to openly say this - and for it to get absolutely no coverage or comment is disgraceful.
Imho, intentional fouling is one of the worst things about the game, alongside diving. The FA should at the very least condemn these comments. And even take some form of action against them.

Would a sinbin or something similar work then?

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 03 Jan 21 9.53am

Originally posted by ripleyeagle

I think today if we had more adventurous we could have scored more goals but could easily have conceded as well.I think it was important that we not only won the game at a canter today but also the clean sheet was also very important too.After conceding those ten goals in two games and with difficult games to come this was great to win and give our defence a confidence boost.Tomkins and Kouate look our most assured CB pairing.

Can’t say I agree about the CB pairing - For me it’s Tomkins and Cahill. And then Dann before Kouyate. I would go back to having Luka, McArthur and Kouyate in midfield and have Eze alongside them. Think we need a stronger midfield to accommodate Eze and that may work? Or even play him in his preferred no 10 role and don’t play Zaha? Anyway, back to yesterday which was a win needed after recent thrashings and the Leicester match where they made 7 changes. Still worry that we are so open and make lots of mistakes defending which against prem teams means goals conceded. Luckily Sheffield are a very poor prem team. We shall see in coming matches just how good we are. I’m hoping that even if we get beaten it’s not a thrashing but I’m not hopeful unless we change the formation which I doubt RH will do?

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 03 Jan 21 10.08am

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

Oliver Norwood - one of the most atrocious things I've heard in regard to a how to play football.
Yes we know-it-all goes on, but it really shouldn't. For someone to openly say this - and for it to get absolutely no coverage or comment is disgraceful.
Imho, intentional fouling is one of the worst things about the game, alongside diving. The FA should at the very least condemn these comments. And even take some form of action against them.

I clocked that as well but they’re deluding themselves. None of them got close enough.

 

Melbourne Eagle Flag Melbourne 03 Jan 21 10.11am

Originally posted by Spiderman

55% possession which mostly consisted of playing it backwards. One of the easiest wins for Palace I have seen in PL.

Agree, very happy to see the opposition play it backwards, sideways and sometimes no ways when we are 1 or 2 up.

They can do that all day if they want.

 

Page 12 of 14 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Sheff Utd Match Thread