This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by thai-eagle
What happened yesterday - why did we play against Holmesdale in the first half? Yes, we lost the coin toss. Surely this should happen more often as the obvious thing to do when winning the toss away is to change ends and knock the home team out of their routine. The home team will always shoot at their main end second half - Liverpool at the Kop, Villa at the Holte End etc.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
Yes, we lost the coin toss. Surely this should happen more often as the obvious thing to do when winning the toss away is to change ends and knock the home team out of their routine. The home team will always shoot at their main end second half - Liverpool at the Kop, Villa at the Holte End etc. I'm surprised it doesn't happen more often. Although it didn't stop us getting a couple in the Whitehorse end.
Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled. |
|
|
Originally posted by thai-eagle
What happened yesterday - why did we play against Holmesdale in the first half?
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
Wilf has been having a good season. Just because he had an average game you don't drop him. Schlupp is an ideal impact sub really as he's fast and direct. When he starts he seems to lack focus and his passing isn't the best, but when he has a simple instruction (i.e. get in the box) he seems to thrive. Olise on the other hand will surely be edging Ayew out soon for a starting place based on that cameo. Ayew has been a model pro but if we are to progress we need more than just hard work and endeavour from our front players. Edouard will prove to be a great signing. A little bit more sharpness and he'll start banging them in. Compared to Bentenke he seems to be in the right place at the right time with the ability to create space for a shot and actually get one away. So we keep quietly improving, largely ignored by the media. Ok so it's only 7 points, but we've already played 5 out of the top 7 from last season, plus two of the most in form teams this season. Keep progressing like this and a top 10 finish might not be out of the question.
Edited by doombear (04 Oct 2021 10.37am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer
I'm surprised it doesn't happen more often. Although it didn't stop us getting a couple in the Whitehorse end. I think the toss should only be for who kicks off. The home team should always be given the choice which way they want to kick 1st half
|
|
|
Originally posted by CT Charlie
Seven games in, Viera looks to be a fine manager. However, in Gallagher, Guehi, Olise, Edouard, Andersen (except for the past 100 minutes) and perhaps Hughes, he is blessed with talent far livelier and more skilled than Roy ever managed at Palace. And Mitchell's minutes at the end of last season helped him to make a huge leap forward. So I think it's possible to say Vieira is a wonderful manager, and Hodgson was, too. There is simply no way Hodgson could have set up his players to press high and control the ball as Viera wants HIS players to do. the truth probably lies somewhere in the middle. I can't imagine that Vieira would have played exactly like Roy had he had the same squad because they weren't capable of anything better. You only have to look at Ward and Luka to see that they are capable of more than what Roy got out of them (or didn't get out of them). Which players did Roy actually improve? Yes he worked on shape and solidity and working hard without the ball, but that's not necessarily improving the individual. I get the impression that Vieira is looking at the individuals and challenging them to do things that haven't been asked of them before. Their whole football philosophy is different. As some have said - it's comparing apples with pears or oranges or whatever, which is valid to a point. But my main question is whether Roy's philosophy is fit for purpose, and I don't think it is any more. Anyway, what a great comeback yesterday!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Daddyorc
I'm sure almost no one watched PV coach NYCFC; I did and he always played high intensity. He was a very good coach, although he couldn't put the pieces together to win the league. What he did with Harrison was amazing, it's why Leeds values him so much. A great coach makes every player better. Look how he's made Wardy and Luka into new players. I was just amazed today seeing Wardy in the middle of the pitch, under previous managers he basically hugged the right sideline. I actually voted for Ward as my player of the month in September. I also LOVE watching us play. We've only been completely outplayed in one game - Chelsea at Stamford Bridge. Had to say I was worried after that game. Now I'm super excited. I really think we can challenge any team. Super excited against Arsenal, I think they'll crumble under us. Onwards and Upwards! Or Townsend if he had stayed ?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Frickin Saweet
the truth probably lies somewhere in the middle. I can't imagine that Vieira would have played exactly like Roy had he had the same squad because they weren't capable of anything better. You only have to look at Ward and Luka to see that they are capable of more than what Roy got out of them (or didn't get out of them). Which players did Roy actually improve? Yes he worked on shape and solidity and working hard without the ball, but that's not necessarily improving the individual. I get the impression that Vieira is looking at the individuals and challenging them to do things that haven't been asked of them before. Their whole football philosophy is different. As some have said - it's comparing apples with pears or oranges or whatever, which is valid to a point. But my main question is whether Roy's philosophy is fit for purpose, and I don't think it is any more. Anyway, what a great comeback yesterday! I couldn't resist responding to this, especially in light of the way Andros has started at Everton. Here's a quote from Andros from the end of last season '' He’s made me into a better player, and he’s made me into a better man. So I owe a lot to Roy Hodgson. '' As for Roy's philosophy still being fit for purpose, I suspect we will never know as it's unlikely that he will work again at this level. But it certainly achieved stability even though being an increasingly hard watch.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
The Manager, team, squad I see as still very much Work In Progress. But certainly heading in the right direction. It was good to see the crowd yesterday sticking with the team at 0-2 down and giving encouragement to the players as it was hard to take given the way that the play had gone. Good to see Olise have the impact that he did. PV is managing his minutes prudently I think. His time will definitely come so it would be good to see the usual bores on here laying off of Ayew. I'm sure there will be some more bumps in the road in the coming months, but so far this is an enjoyable journey. I think everyone can finally see the team moving in a positive direction. Individual errors are frustrating, with a young team and manager it's going to happen. With time they get the game experience to cut them out. I'm sure they all know what they should be doing, but executing those decisions is another thing entirely. 7 points from 7 considering the option is a decent start all things considered. New manager, new players, and having played 5 teams you'd expect top half finished plus 2 lower half teams (Brighton and Brentford) in blistering form. Olise now returned and Eze waiting in the wings. Good Times are ahead.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
I would, or at least in the no 9 role. Almost like the role that Shluppy was asked to play when he came on. I'd rather bring Ayew on centrally in place of a midfielder, then swap Edouard for Benteke.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
I think everyone can finally see the team moving in a positive direction. Individual errors are frustrating, with a young team and manager it's going to happen. With time they get the game experience to cut them out. I'm sure they all know what they should be doing, but executing those decisions is another thing entirely. 7 points from 7 considering the option is a decent start all things considered. New manager, new players, and having played 5 teams you'd expect top half finished plus 2 lower half teams (Brighton and Brentford) in blistering form. Olise now returned and Eze waiting in the wings. Good Times are ahead. When it’s considered that in most cases the performances in the last two home games would have have produced six points, there is every reason to be really optimistic about the way things are going.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
I couldn't resist responding to this, especially in light of the way Andros has started at Everton. Here's a quote from Andros from the end of last season '' He’s made me into a better player, and he’s made me into a better man. So I owe a lot to Roy Hodgson. '' As for Roy's philosophy still being fit for purpose, I suspect we will never know as it's unlikely that he will work again at this level. But it certainly achieved stability even though being an increasingly hard watch. So what are you saying, that Townsend is performing so well at Everton because of Roy, despite him hinting at the opposite of that since joining? Don't you notice how everyone has only positive, lovely things to say about Roy when he's their boss (funny that), yet now he's gone, both Townsend and Zaha have shared their frustration with Roy's regime, and how they're much they're now enjoying their football? And the on-pitch evidence points towards them being far better attacking players than we've watched over the previous years. I'll agree that in the public domain, footballers and pundits shower Roy with niceties, seemingly all down to him being a very old and generally nice chap. Yes the irony is that the likes of Lineker and Shearer couldn't find a good word to say about what he was paid a handsome sum to do (his job) - the football he had his team playing last season. Of course, I know we won't agree. But I can see those comments from the likes of Townsend for what they are.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
I agree
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
I gave Eduoard my man of match. His little runs around the box, deft flicks and the way he beat defenders with apparent ease was great to watch. I agree he should have scored, probably hit it too well but the way he made the initial space deserves credit. I honestly believe he will become a cult hero at Palace. I thought just the same spider. The TV never sees the whole scene and certainly doesn’t capture all the atmosphere. But much better than nothing.
|
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
You are. On a serious note, what did Wilf do today to keep his spot? But he does occupy their defence. Always doubled up sometimes more which creates space elsewhere.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Frickin Saweet
So what are you saying, that Townsend is performing so well at Everton because of Roy, despite him hinting at the opposite of that since joining? Don't you notice how everyone has only positive, lovely things to say about Roy when he's their boss (funny that), yet now he's gone, both Townsend and Zaha have shared their frustration with Roy's regime, and how they're much they're now enjoying their football? And the on-pitch evidence points towards them being far better attacking players than we've watched over the previous years. I'll agree that in the public domain, footballers and pundits shower Roy with niceties, seemingly all down to him being a very old and generally nice chap. Yes the irony is that the likes of Lineker and Shearer couldn't find a good word to say about what he was paid a handsome sum to do (his job) - the football he had his team playing last season. Of course, I know we won't agree. But I can see those comments from the likes of Townsend for what they are. No, I'm not saying that at all - merely responding ( light heartedly ) to your comment as it reminded me of the Andros quote - that's it. All credit to Andros and Benetez for what's happening at Everton. Good for you that you have an insight into what these comments '' for what they are ''. That doesn't stack up to my own experience when talking to a couple of his former players that I know and that have no reason to say anything other than exactly what they think of him - Including that they found the training incredibly dull ! While I supported Roy over the seasons he was with us, I don't think anyone could make a case for the football being attractive. Edited by NEILLO (04 Oct 2021 2.55pm) Edited by NEILLO (04 Oct 2021 2.57pm)
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
No, I'm not saying that at all - merely responding ( light heartedly ) to your comment as it reminded me of the Andros quote - that's it. All credit to Andros and Benetez for what's happening at Everton. Good for you that you have an insight into what these comments '' for what they are ''. That doesn't stack up to my own experience when talking to a couple of his former players that I know and that have no reason to say anything other than exactly what they think of him - Including that they found the training incredibly dull ! While I supported Roy over the seasons he was with us, I don't think anyone could make a case for the football being attractive. Edited by NEILLO (04 Oct 2021 2.55pm) Edited by NEILLO (04 Oct 2021 2.57pm) without going too far down the rabbit hole on this, as I know the pros and cons of Roy have been debated to death, but that's the bit I find really weird. On one hand it's all "he's a wonderful man, a legend of our time", whereas the day-to-day reality is that the training for players and experience for fans is incredibly dull an uninspiring - the opposite of what it's supposed to be, yet he still takes the plaudits. I need to get my head out of this senseless mental loop and do some work.
|
|
| michaelpearce |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by thai-eagle
What happened yesterday - why did we play against Holmesdale in the first half? think you find it was more todo with conditions. wind was a big factor some teams like to attack with the wind 1st half some would sooner defend, team i played for wanted wind behind second half as we held the ball better than most teams
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.