You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Man City v Palace Match thread
November 16 2026 4.26am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Man City v Palace Match thread


Page 12 of 13 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
Teddy Eagle Flag 31 Oct 21 3.09pm

PV also deserves credit for his choice of coaches - Wilson & Roberts have changed things significantly.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 31 Oct 21 3.16pm

Before the game, days earlier, there were agonised moans about the choice of referee.

I thought Andre Marriner had a great game, keeping calm, ignoring the histrionics on both sides and very tolerant of our time wasting.

Showed he had no bias against Wilf where other refs might have taken a less tolerant attitude to Wilf's histrionics.

Even Lee Mason (never our favourite) correctly called the VAR decision which was tight.

It all came together: a great team performance and deserved luck (for a change)

 


Man and boy Palace since my first game in 1948 sitting on my dad's shoulders

dreamwaverider Flag London 31 Oct 21 3.19pm

Originally posted by Den1923

I just hope SP will get a move on with making Gallagher move permanent during the next T/F window, he clearly has no future at Chelsea and he is well down the pecking order and if we do not move for him quickly then I fear us losing him at the end of the season which would be a shame and a great loss!

Wishful thinking. The way CG is playing is being noticed everywhere now. He is easily good enough for Chelsea now. Can you imagine him drafted into their team. Doesn’t bear thinking about. I reckon he will just get better and better this season for us. Problem is, he is pretty much irreplaceable. Oh well enjoy him while we got him. He’ll be an England player very soon. The guy is dynamite.

 

ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 31 Oct 21 3.43pm

Originally posted by Den1923

I just hope SP will get a move on with making Gallagher move permanent during the next T/F window, he clearly has no future at Chelsea and he is well down the pecking order and if we do not move for him quickly then I fear us losing him at the end of the season which would be a shame and a great loss!

Just a slight worry in signing him in January, is we have him on a season loan and if he was unfortunte to get a serious injury between January and the end of the season I assume he would go back to Chelsea and could we replace him with another loan?

 

eaglesdare Flag 31 Oct 21 4.07pm

Originally posted by ripleyeagle

Just a slight worry in signing him in January, is we have him on a season loan and if he was unfortunte to get a serious injury between January and the end of the season I assume he would go back to Chelsea and could we replace him with another loan?

Ah tbh! That could happen to any player! Sure we loaned and signed permenantly zaha and puncheon in January didint we?

 

eaglesdare Flag 31 Oct 21 4.12pm

Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker

No id say thats about right , his time wasting did have an impact on the game and fustrated absolutly everyone ( except palace of course ) I would have given it to Ward personally , he managed that bad hair t*** Grealish perfectly , who was throwing himself to the ground at every oppertunity and writhing in agony. I was just doing the math there and if brighton didnt equalize with the last kick of the game and the same with arse , and we beat Newcastle and we should have . We would now be in the champions league qualifying place . Just saying


Ifs and buts! Never know we might never have beat city if we had won at arsenal and Brighton! Seems Vieira learnt alot in those games with the late goals!

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 31 Oct 21 4.33pm

Olise play for the second goal was world class. And he’s 19!!!

 

charliehub Flag newforest 31 Oct 21 4.39pm

If we had lost yesterday as the world predicted, and was a possible outcome...we'd have been fourth from bottom right now.
You make your own luck!

 

YT Flag Oxford 31 Oct 21 4.45pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare


Ifs and buts! Never know we might never have beat city if we had won at arsenal and Brighton! Seems Vieira learnt alot in those games with the late goals!

Winning at Brighton would have been unbelievable!

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Den1923 Flag 31 Oct 21 5.36pm

Originally posted by ripleyeagle

Just a slight worry in signing him in January, is we have him on a season loan and if he was unfortunate to get a serious injury between January and the end of the season I assume he would go back to Chelsea and could we replace him with another loan?



Yes, that is a risk with any player, hopefully this is where injury insurance plays its part. It would be silly not to try and secure him permanently in the next T/F window before the vultures get circulating.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 31 Oct 21 6.11pm

Shearer uncharacteristically nice about us last night. Pretty much reflected my view that we should be higher up.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 31 Oct 21 7.38pm

Originally posted by gerry theagle

I was there, Guiata was MOM for time wasting, how he didn't get booked until near the end only Andre Marriner knows.

Yes it seemed like the City fans were booing him literally from the first kick! A City fan launched a pie at us when the second goal went in. Fortunately his aim was about as good as the City strikers and actually clipped the top of the stewards head &#128515;

 

YT Flag Oxford 31 Oct 21 10.11pm

Three Palace players in Garth Crooks' team of the week (BBC). Why only three??!!!

(Guehi, Gallagher, Zaha)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 01 Nov 21 1.28am

Originally posted by ripleyeagle

Fantastic performance from the boys yesterday,and I thought Jimmy and Conar should have jointly won MOTM.So many players have improved under PV especially Joel Ward and Tyrick Mitchell who have benefitted from having two Good centre backs beside them.Where have all the JW knockers gone who called him a Championship full back, I bet PV doesn’t.Jimmy MAC has also gone up another level as has Benteke who’s work rate has gone up considerably.Wilf has stopped sulking after being left out and realised he is not indispensable.Isn’t it great to look forward to the next game whoever we are playing, as we are a match for anyone now.COYP

He said something in the post match interview about having players (specifically Gallagher) willing and able to link up with. I think he's just revitalised and re-motivated. The standard of our attacking ability has finally raised to meet his standard, and it's challenging him to be better.

Watching Newcastle, with their deep defence (and still conceding three) reminded me of us last season. A midfield and defence pass it sideways, and slowly backwards, eventually reaching the keeper who can only hoof it, as there's nowhere else to go. And Allan Saint-Maximin does his best to reach a ball he'll never get, chasing heroically, but with utter futility. Instead the opposition casually win it back, with 19 outfield players in the opposition half, and their cycle of dominance starts again. The defensive team have to work so hard, to get so little, and any success is reliant on genius.

For Saint-Maximin, read Zaha, who did this for years. He's not had this much fun since Bolasie was here.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 01 Nov 21 6.23am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Olise play for the second goal was world class. And he’s 19!!!

Second that! Just watch our 2nd goal vs City. Olise and CG start it all, his way of carrying the ball and finding Wilf would never happen with Ayew in same position. And his awareness and sublime lay-off serving the ball on the platter for Gallagher - world-class deluxe!

 

slubglurge Flag welling 01 Nov 21 6.45am

Olise is a class act. He ran 50 yds at full pelt with the ball almost glued to his feet. We are lucky to have him

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 Nov 21 7.10am

Originally posted by ripleyeagle

Fantastic performance from the boys yesterday,and I thought Jimmy and Conar should have jointly won MOTM.So many players have improved under PV especially Joel Ward and Tyrick Mitchell who have benefitted from having two Good centre backs beside them.Where have all the JW knockers gone who called him a Championship full back, I bet PV doesn’t.Jimmy MAC has also gone up another level as has Benteke who’s work rate has gone up considerably.Wilf has stopped sulking after being left out and realised he is not indispensable.Isn’t it great to look forward to the next game whoever we are playing, as we are a match for anyone now.COYP

When was Wilf left out? Presumably you mean when he was ill having returned from International duty

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 Nov 21 7.11am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

PV also deserves credit for his choice of coaches - Wilson & Roberts have changed things significantly.

100% this

Edited by Spiderman (01 Nov 2021 7.11am)

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 01 Nov 21 9.00am

Watched the whole game last night, that was the best defensive display so far from back to front. I couldn’t tell who the City fans were booing, definitely Guita though as he took his time with distributing the ball from goal kicks. Although he did bowl it out pretty quickly on each occasion to our defenders.

I used to think City fans were pretty decent bunch especially when they were struggling in Division 1, but since the money men came in they have turned into an entitled bunch who don’t back their team when they are losing.

What’s more they pretty much all f***ed off with 15 minutes to go, what s*** house support they have turned into!

 

YT Flag Oxford 01 Nov 21 9.21am

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

Watched the whole game last night, that was the best defensive display so far from back to front. I couldn’t tell who the City fans were booing, definitely Guita though as he took his time with distributing the ball from goal kicks. Although he did bowl it out pretty quickly on each occasion to our defenders.

I used to think City fans were pretty decent bunch especially when they were struggling in Division 1, but since the money men came in they have turned into an entitled bunch who don’t back their team when they are losing.

What’s more they pretty much all f***ed off with 15 minutes to go, what s*** house support they have turned into!

I take it you didn't go to the 1995 League Cup tie v City at Selhurst then? The City fans were so poorly behaved during their team's 4-0 defeat that Palace fans sang to them "You're the sh!t of Manchester!" (to the tune of 'Bread of Heaven'. Given who the other major Manchester team is, that was quite an indictment!!

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Page 12 of 13 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Man City v Palace Match thread