You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Aston Villa vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread
November 16 2026 3.02am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Aston Villa vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread


Page 12 of 13 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
CrazyBadger Flag Ware 18 Sep 23 1.54pm

Originally posted by Goalpost1

Taking off my Palace hat for a moment. When I saw the penalty incident in real time you can see why it was given but looking at it on replays CR gets a lot of the ball. I think it is a very harsh call.

This is what I thought.
Looks a harsh pen, but could be argued that CR fouled the player before taking the ball. VAR said he should see it again, and he did, seeing nothing clear enough to change his opinion.
We've all been asking for the ref to not blindly follow The VAR office, and this is the result.
It wasn't a blatent attempt by the attacker to dupe the ref into a pen, so It's a footballing incident. move on.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

palace chick Flag South Croydon 18 Sep 23 3.48pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

This is what I thought.
Looks a harsh pen, but could be argued that CR fouled the player before taking the ball. VAR said he should see it again, and he did, seeing nothing clear enough to change his opinion.
We've all been asking for the ref to not blindly follow The VAR office, and this is the result.
It wasn't a blatent attempt by the attacker to dupe the ref into a pen, so It's a footballing incident. move on.

What we have been asking for, is that the ref and VAR make the correct decision. No doubt it looks a pen in real time. Certainly doesn’t when you look at it slowed down on a screen. Ref made the wrong decision after having time to re examine it. Villa being at home, crowd in his ear probably swayed it. Don’t believe we would have got that penalty if it was down Villa’s end after the ref had viewed it in my opinion. I think these decisions should be decided by the VAR but even then we have seen them making incorrect decisions :-(

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 18 Sep 23 4.02pm

Originally posted by Gribbo

Don't worry about the penalty decision. The problem is that Palace don't match the ambition of Villa. They had strength in depth on the bench, we have very little.

Wilf left, Olise injured, and Ayew went off. Our response is to bring on Mateta, put Schlupp wide right and leave Rak-Sakhi on the bench. The Brazilian wonder kid has not even appeared yet.

Joel got rinsed again at right back. We have needed a replacement since AWB left, but we spent £20m on a reserve keeper instead.

Yes we will stay up - Luton and Sheff U are very poor. Will we finish higher than 12th place - almost certainly not.

This way my overriding frustration. (Thought it probably was a pen TBF).

They made a lot of subs, we didnt. Eze was dead on his feat by about 70 mins. Think their fresh legs made the difference.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 18 Sep 23 4.28pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Ref Watch on Sky this morning dealt with the issue most efficiently by ignoring it altogether. They briefly discussed whether Diaby should have got a penalty but no mention of anything else. Presumably even Dermot Gallagher couldn't defend the ref on this one.

Noticed this too. It gets harder and harder to not come to the conclusion we don’t count for Sky. They had looked at every controversial incident across the weekend games, including as you say the non handball for Villa, the only really contentious moment in the game, and possibly one of the most contentious decisions of the weekend they completely ignore. It took five minutes to make what was almost certainly a wrong decision, yet Sky ignore it, and Millwall, think they ain’t liked.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 18 Sep 23 4.34pm

Originally posted by palace chick

What we have been asking for, is that the ref and VAR make the correct decision. No doubt it looks a pen in real time. Certainly doesn’t when you look at it slowed down on a screen. Ref made the wrong decision after having time to re examine it. Villa being at home, crowd in his ear probably swayed it. Don’t believe we would have got that penalty if it was down Villa’s end after the ref had viewed it in my opinion. I think these decisions should be decided by the VAR but even then we have seen them making incorrect decisions :-(

The ref could never have been 100% positive after watching it back, and to give a pen that he knew full well would settle the result was highly questionable .

 

pssguy Flag 18 Sep 23 4.39pm

Originally posted by palace chick

What we have been asking for, is that the ref and VAR make the correct decision. No doubt it looks a pen in real time. Certainly doesn’t when you look at it slowed down on a screen. Ref made the wrong decision after having time to re examine it. Villa being at home, crowd in his ear probably swayed it. Don’t believe we would have got that penalty if it was down Villa’s end after the ref had viewed it in my opinion. I think these decisions should be decided by the VAR but even then we have seen them making incorrect decisions :-(

That makes no sense. Virtually all visits to the screen correctly result in an overturn. The crowd can hardly blame the ref if England had followed the norm, He can just shrug his shoulders and say "sorry Villa fans I did my best to give you the game"

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 18 Sep 23 5.54pm

Blimey, this has to be a 1st, Garth Crooks agreeing with PaddyMac about 'that' penalty . . . [Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 18 Sep 23 8.55pm

It’s taken till this afternoon to get over that result on Saturday. I think the way the match panned out it just wasn’t going to be our day. The players out injured, Roy missing and Ayew going off after 20 minutes, capped it all.

Then to be leading up till the 87 minute and then conceding , just rubbed salt into the wound. The penalty fiasco has gone from my thoughts for the moment until something on a par happens again like that.

As for Villa they most probably deserved it, but I will watch what happens to them over the coming weeks to see how their fortunes go, and the same goes for Darren England he really has put himself top of the list on ref watch!

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 18 Sep 23 8.59pm

We haven't heard from CR himself, but that was a fantastic tackle, so well done Chris.

 

Pierre Flag Purley 18 Sep 23 9.19pm

It wasn't the marginal penalty decision or the stupid VAR fiasco that cost us the game on Saturday.
It was not scoring another goal from one of the opportunities we had earlier in the second half to go 2-0 up in the first place.

Then Palace could have possibly managed and 'weathered' the Villa onslaught better in the latter stages of the game.

We don't have the same strength in depth in the squad as a lot of Premiership teams, but we should have used more of them on Saturday.
As It's been said, some of our guys were struggling by around 70-75 minutes and fresh legs would have really made a difference.

 

PatrickA Flag London 18 Sep 23 9.28pm

I wonder if the majority of fans would like to do away with VAR.
The idea was to have objective assessment and take away doubt.
To my mind many assessments continue to be subjective and doubts remain with contentious decisions every week.
I believe it has also led to a poorer standard of refereeing, with their diminished authority and failure to make decisions.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 19 Sep 23 5.52am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I wonder if the majority of fans would like to do away with VAR.
The idea was to have objective assessment and take away doubt.
To my mind many assessments continue to be subjective and doubts remain with contentious decisions every week.
I believe it has also led to a poorer standard of refereeing, with their diminished authority and failure to make decisions.

Its is even worse for the lino , he actually has little to do these days but tie his laces and confirm who's throw it is . Reminds me of when I used to 'run the line ' on a Sunday ,The ref would say just follow my lead , dont flag for anything as it just confuses them . lol

 

taylors lovechild Flag 19 Sep 23 8.09am

At half-time I think most of us would agree Villa were the better team. As has been said, while perhaps a bit fortunate to get in front once we were we had several opportunities to kill the game off so the penalty incident shouldn't have mattered. I know it sounds harsh given his goal tally but Edouard probably should have more goals and assists as his decision making and final pass have been poor this season, and it was the same on Saturday.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 19 Sep 23 9.00am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I wonder if the majority of fans would like to do away with VAR.
The idea was to have objective assessment and take away doubt.
To my mind many assessments continue to be subjective and doubts remain with contentious decisions every week.
I believe it has also led to a poorer standard of refereeing, with their diminished authority and failure to make decisions.

Taking that further, I question whether the majority of Managers and players would also like to do away with it.

Frustrating though incorrect refereeing decisions used to be, ultimately they could be put down to human error and only getting one brief moment to make a decision.

VAR should have largely eliminated those types of errors but it hasn't. Why ? As I posted earlier, decisions are still subjective and the same people are making the same mistakes even with the available technology.

Rule changes and their interpretations have not helped either. I thought the Forest ' handball ' last night captured all that is currently wrong in that one incident.

VAR is sucking the life out of the game.

It's time that the paying public and the playing community had an opportunity to discard it if that's what is wanted. Not have it imposed by the authorities that continue to spoil the game in so many ways.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 19 Sep 23 9.11am

I couldn't watch on Saturday but sounds like Richards was immense. With Guehi, Andersen, Richards and Holding there aren't many sides in the division with better CB options.

With Edoaurd and Mateta suddenly coming good too, if we could sign a RB and LW in January we'd be in pretty good shape.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 19 Sep 23 10.08am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Taking that further, I question whether the majority of Managers and players would also like to do away with it.

Frustrating though incorrect refereeing decisions used to be, ultimately they could be put down to human error and only getting one brief moment to make a decision.

VAR should have largely eliminated those types of errors but it hasn't. Why ? As I posted earlier, decisions are still subjective and the same people are making the same mistakes even with the available technology.

Rule changes and their interpretations have not helped either. I thought the Forest ' handball ' last night captured all that is currently wrong in that one incident.

VAR is sucking the life out of the game.

It's time that the paying public and the playing community had an opportunity to discard it if that's what is wanted. Not have it imposed by the authorities that continue to spoil the game in so many ways.

It's pretty widely accepted that VAR has not been as successful as it was lauded to be before we had it. It was supposed to be a simple solution to correct the human officiating errors occurring every game. It's turned into a beast that doesn't even address the issue it was brought in for, and become clear that these decisions aren't as straight forward as first thought. There's always going to be discussions about what is something (i.e. a penalty) and what isn't. Those discussions shouldn't be about VAR.

There is a future for it, but not in this incarnation. I'm of the view that it needs to be removed, reassessed and then reimplemented once a more accurate solution is devised.



 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 19 Sep 23 11.31am

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

It's pretty widely accepted that VAR has not been as successful as it was lauded to be before we had it. It was supposed to be a simple solution to correct the human officiating errors occurring every game. It's turned into a beast that doesn't even address the issue it was brought in for, and become clear that these decisions aren't as straight forward as first thought. There's always going to be discussions about what is something (i.e. a penalty) and what isn't. Those discussions shouldn't be about VAR.

There is a future for it, but not in this incarnation. I'm of the view that it needs to be removed, reassessed and then reimplemented once a more accurate solution is devised.



No.

What needs to happen is the removal of politics from decisions.

The referee's position as the final decider should be removed and a panel of VAR officials should have the final say. The ref should be there to implement decisions on the pitch, but not govern them. You have subordinate VAR people who are afraid to question senior officials, and you have refs going against common sense, and taking 5 minutes to do so, even when VAR has asked them to review their original decisions, like on Saturday at Villa.

Also, VAR needs to be used more often. For corners and throw in decisions which could be re watched in seconds.

Other sports have more sensible rules, but sadly football seems to be controlled by idiots.


Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (19 Sep 2023 11.33am)

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 19 Sep 23 11.38am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

No.

What needs to happen is the removal of politics from decisions.

The referee's position as the final decider should be removed and a panel of VAR officials should have the final say. The ref should be there to implement decisions on the pitch, but not govern them. You have subordinate VAR people who are afraid to question senior officials, and you have refs going against common sense, and taking 5 minutes to do so, even when VAR has asked them to review their original decisions, like on Saturday at Villa.

Also, VAR needs to be used more often. For corners and throw in decisions which could be re watched in seconds.

Other sports have more sensible rules, but sadly football seems to be controlled by idiots.


Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (19 Sep 2023 11.33am)

Agreed! And as you say corners and throw ins need to be immediate decisions. Not there for that just yet. But we are for decisions like Saturdays penalty. Don’t ask the ref to look at it. Tell him, it’s a penalty or not a penalty.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 19 Sep 23 11.48am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

No.

What needs to happen is the removal of politics from decisions.

The referee's position as the final decider should be removed and a panel of VAR officials should have the final say. The ref should be there to implement decisions on the pitch, but not govern them. You have subordinate VAR people who are afraid to question senior officials, and you have refs going against common sense, and taking 5 minutes to do so, even when VAR has asked them to review their original decisions, like on Saturday at Villa.

Also, VAR needs to be used more often. For corners and throw in decisions which could be re watched in seconds.

Other sports have more sensible rules, but sadly football seems to be controlled by idiots.


Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (19 Sep 2023 11.33am)

I agree, but it's in a state now that it is becoming too damaging to the game. Remove it and correct it. If that's by creating new tech to help, or removing/re-educating the idiots that control it, whichever works.
What's annoying is that other countries/organisations VAR has seen to have worked fairly well. I have good memories of VAR in the Word Cup. (maybe i've just blanked it out!)

Many times it's been suggested that just because VAR have said the ref should review their decision, doesn't mean the ref should change their decision - In fact people were saying that there was too much pressure for the ref to accept the decision of the VAR team. Which is it - Go blindly with VAR or allow the Ref some level of control?
No-one can agree.. and until we have a foolproof system, no-one will.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 19 Sep 23 12.41pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

No.

What needs to happen is the removal of politics from decisions.

The referee's position as the final decider should be removed and a panel of VAR officials should have the final say. The ref should be there to implement decisions on the pitch, but not govern them. You have subordinate VAR people who are afraid to question senior officials, and you have refs going against common sense, and taking 5 minutes to do so, even when VAR has asked them to review their original decisions, like on Saturday at Villa.

Also, VAR needs to be used more often. For corners and throw in decisions which could be re watched in seconds.

Other sports have more sensible rules, but sadly football seems to be controlled by idiots.


Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (19 Sep 2023 11.33am)

I absolutely hate the phrase ‘the referee is sticking with…’.

This implies subjectivity around the whole thing which is nonsense as is the whole ‘sending the referee to look at the monitor’. They’ve tinkered with the rules so much of late you’d think at least one of the halfwits would have some idea of parameters necessary to make a decision.

The fact we now have all these amendments, bonkers rules, a referee and whole team watching cameras, who still frequently get decisions wrong, just shows how little intelligence there is in the game.

You either have to conclude that they have no idea what constitutes a foul or otherwise, they’re unable to use the technology available or they’re cheating/bias in some way. Perhaps it’s all three. Should be a real one in x amount of times circumstance that the correct decision is hard to reach. Not numerous times every weekend and frequently wrong.

You’ve got f-ing cameras and an abundance of technology available, at the very least you have to understand the rules/game and should be able to make decisions within seconds. Still miles off it. Rather than mitigate any abuse referees and officials get it’s just added further fuel to the fire in evidencing the grievances that are and always have been there.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Page 12 of 13 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Aston Villa vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread