This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
The anti-Semitism displayed on here many some posters is shocking, it's like a Labour party or militant Islamic forum. The "liberal left", hard left, showbiz luvvies and many in the media are very pro-Palestine and, although they deny it, many are anti-Semitic. To them, the Palestinians are the perennial victims while nasty evil Jewish Israel are always going to be the baddies. To this end, pro-Palestinian demonstrations are always going to be handled with kid gloves. We don't want to upset the Muslims, you know. Look at the Football Association's refusal to light the Wembley Arch in Israel's colours for fear of "a backlash from some communities". Oh yeah, don't want to upset the Muslims. Someone on here has likened Israel's actions, or potential actions, as "Ethnic cleansing". After what happened during the Holocaust that is a disgusting thing to say, and totally wrong. Israel wants to destroy Hamas. That's not ethnic cleansing, that's getting rid of a threat. Yet, the aim of Hamas is wipe the state of Israel off the face of the earth. That sounds to me like ethnic cleansing, but because it is Palestinians saying it, that's fine. Palestinian civilians are and will continue to get killed. Hamas knew how Israel would react when they attacked, so from the onset they were perfectly willing to sacrifice civilians in Gaza. People need to remember who actually started this present conflict. Hamas started it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
It isn't a question of forgiveness, it is a question of playing to the American tune. If there isn't a decent memorial to those Brits who died in Palestine trying to hold that sh1t-hole together, then there should be. Sadly, such an act would be pounced on by the whole range of vested interests as anti something. It just isn't worth the candle. Yep. There's no solution worthy of humanity now. However, this 'solution' did make me smile.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Actually, from later interviews, those terrorists claimed not to hate the British. The Arabs did, but that was because of Balfour - one reason the Jews liked us. Another is that we had provided safe haven for Jews since the middle ages, that we had successfully fought the NAZIS, that some of them were British or had fond memories of visiting, and that much of their ranks had (irony of irony) been trained by the British! No, they didn't hate us. We were just in the way. As Stirling has said, it really makes no difference what they said afterwards. I have no great love for Israel, but in the end we all have to pick sides. The West sides with Israel. There is no room for complex moral issues and ideals in war. If your enemy wants to kill you, then you must stop them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Yep. There's no solution worthy of humanity now. However, this 'solution' did make me smile. Yes it is funny. And I am not lost to the humour, but must nevertheless mention one snag. The largely right wing hard line Christian base who vehemently support Israel, largely on religious grounds, are also overwhelmingly (and one of my favourite ironies) antisemites! So thick, they genuinely do not equate Israelis with e.g. the Shulman family who run the successful clothing shop on their high street. The New Israel will continue to be surrounded by people who hate them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by nhp61
The "liberal left", hard left, showbiz luvvies and many in the media are very pro-Palestine and, although they deny it, many are anti-Semitic. To them, the Palestinians are the perennial victims while nasty evil Jewish Israel are always going to be the baddies. To this end, pro-Palestinian demonstrations are always going to be handled with kid gloves. We don't want to upset the Muslims, you know. Look at the Football Association's refusal to light the Wembley Arch in Israel's colours for fear of "a backlash from some communities". Oh yeah, don't want to upset the Muslims. Someone on here has likened Israel's actions, or potential actions, as "Ethnic cleansing". After what happened during the Holocaust that is a disgusting thing to say, and totally wrong. Israel wants to destroy Hamas. That's not ethnic cleansing, that's getting rid of a threat. Yet, the aim of Hamas is wipe the state of Israel off the face of the earth. That sounds to me like ethnic cleansing, but because it is Palestinians saying it, that's fine. Palestinian civilians are and will continue to get killed. Hamas knew how Israel would react when they attacked, so from the onset they were perfectly willing to sacrifice civilians in Gaza. People need to remember who actually started this present conflict. Hamas started it. There is too much to unpick in this (I won't bother) but you do realise that much of this country's liberal, luvvy left are Jews?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
As Stirling has said, it really makes no difference what they said afterwards. I have no great love for Israel, but in the end we all have to pick sides. The West sides with Israel. There is no room for complex moral issues and ideals in war. If your enemy wants to kill you, then you must stop them. As an outsider to this conflict, I don't think it's possible, or even helpful, to pick a side. People should absolutely speak out and denounce acts of terrorism, war crimes and atrocities when they occur – Zionists, Palestinians, then Israel and Hamas have both been regularly guilty of those since the beginning of all this. But that doesn't mean you need to take a side and suddenly become blind to their own past horrors. Reading more and more about the origins and history of this conflict, the real blame lies first with Napoleon and the French, then the British and finally the UN. Edited by SW19 CPFC (13 Oct 2023 1.45pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
As an outsider to this conflict, I don't think it's possible, or even helpful, to pick a side. People should absolutely speak out and denounce acts of terrorism, war crimes and atrocities when they occur – Zionists, Palestinians, then Israel and Hamas have both been regularly guilty of those since the beginning of all this. But that doesn't mean you need to take a side and suddenly become blind to their own past horrors. Reading more and more about the origins and history of this conflict, the real blame lies first with Napoleon and the French, then the British and finally the UN. Edited by SW19 CPFC (13 Oct 2023 1.45pm) We can all have our opinions about the rights and wrongs of this situation, but when someone is threatening your safety, it becomes irrelevant. I'd rather keep out of it, but our wonderful politicians have made that impossible. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (13 Oct 2023 1.53pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Do you adhere to the view that ANY criticism of Israel is an attack on all Jews? Corbyn (who I don't like) said till he was blue in the face that he wasn't antisemitic but anti aspects of Zionism, and made policies, while in local government, supporting Jewish cemeteries etc. Yet people still throw the A-S rock at him. Many do. It is one of the most insidious forms of oppression of free speech today. If Israel behaves badly, why is it wrong to say so? Bad conduct is bad no matter who commits it and no matter what the provocation. Israel prides itself on being the sole presence of intelligent democracy in an otherwise basket case of a region so as to operate to higher standards than Hamas. It also has a right to defend itself; but it must do so proportionately and in compliance with international law. If it steps beyond that (which it very much is) then surely somebody has to call them to account. We should not be cowed by the accusation that to do so would make us antisemitic. Certainly not. Do you adhere to the view that criticism of Islamists is an attack on all Muslims? Edited by georgenorman (13 Oct 2023 1.57pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Slimey Toad
I've just watched a film about the extremist settlers on the WB via Al Jazeera (yes I know they have their agenda). However, they're as nutty as IS. A young woman, Western-dressed (could have been a young Amy Winehouse) calmly said she hated Arabs (they can't bring themselves to say Palestinian, 'they're all the same' I have never seen anything like this on mainstream TV. Edited by Slimey Toad (13 Oct 2023 7.18am) The settlers are mainly brought in for that purpose. Usually from Somalia and Russia. One could argue that Israel views them as ‘other’ and somewhat expendable.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
We can all have our opinions about the rights and wrongs of this situation, but when someone is threatening your safety, it becomes irrelevant. I'd rather keep out of it, but our wonderful politicians have made that impossible. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (13 Oct 2023 1.53pm) Maybe so, but I'm not fully aligned with the government on this one. Some of the content of Shapps statements yesterday were ridiculous.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by nhp61
The "liberal left", hard left, showbiz luvvies and many in the media are very pro-Palestine and, although they deny it, many are anti-Semitic. To them, the Palestinians are the perennial victims while nasty evil Jewish Israel are always going to be the baddies. To this end, pro-Palestinian demonstrations are always going to be handled with kid gloves. We don't want to upset the Muslims, you know. Look at the Football Association's refusal to light the Wembley Arch in Israel's colours for fear of "a backlash from some communities". Oh yeah, don't want to upset the Muslims. Someone on here has likened Israel's actions, or potential actions, as "Ethnic cleansing". After what happened during the Holocaust that is a disgusting thing to say, and totally wrong. Israel wants to destroy Hamas. That's not ethnic cleansing, that's getting rid of a threat. Yet, the aim of Hamas is wipe the state of Israel off the face of the earth. That sounds to me like ethnic cleansing, but because it is Palestinians saying it, that's fine. Palestinian civilians are and will continue to get killed. Hamas knew how Israel would react when they attacked, so from the onset they were perfectly willing to sacrifice civilians in Gaza. People need to remember who actually started this present conflict. Hamas started it. Exactly, well said.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Yes it is funny. And I am not lost to the humour, but must nevertheless mention one snag. The largely right wing hard line Christian base who vehemently support Israel, largely on religious grounds, are also overwhelmingly (and one of my favourite ironies) antisemites! So thick, they genuinely do not equate Israelis with e.g. the Shulman family who run the successful clothing shop on their high street. The New Israel will continue to be surrounded by people who hate them. It's not lost on me that they often support those who actually don't like them very much....ie the Christian who likes Ben Shapiro because Ben shares their views on trannies and socialism. However, there is a growing divide within the US right on this very matter.....the Christian boomers and much of gen X are burned in but the younger crowd have started to question and pushback. Some of it can be called antisemitic but a lot of it isn't in my opinion. They look at their corrupt politicians....Democrat and Republicans alike...look at the amount of money they have and start asking questions why they all seem to align so really strongly on one particular issue. Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Oct 2023 2.42pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
It's not lost on me that they often support those who actually don't like them very much....ie the Christian who likes Ben Shapiro because Ben shares their views on trannies and socialism. However, there is a growing divide within the US right on this very matter.....the Christian boomers and much of gen X are burned in but the younger crowd have started to question and pushback. Some of it can be called antisemitic but a lot of it isn't in my opinion. They look at their corrupt politicians....Democrat and Republicans alike...look at the amount of money they have and start asking questions why they all seem to align so really strongly on one particular issue. Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Oct 2023 2.42pm) Nothing worse for Israel's' future prospects than the "browning" of the west.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Sheks Crows Eye
Nothing worse for Israel's' future prospects than the "browning" of the west. Well, let's not fall into the idea that all Jews think the same way of course. Right wing pro European Jews are out there...I was red pilled by one. Jared Taylor has significant funding from Jewish backers and Tommy Robinson is a full on Zionist who is just coming back from a holiday there and his funding for restarting the EDL is probably Israeli. However, the reality is that...collectively (a minority aren't)....all ethnic minorities within host cultures are instinctively against them. The evidence for that is easy to see in voting patterns. Indeed, out of the ethnic groups white Europeans are the least racist in this way (why Obama and others can still get elected).....but it's true even for whites just not as strong. If you look specifically at Jews in Europe/US, you find that they vote around 70 percent left.....While in Israel itself it's either right wing or pretty even. It's just general human nature. If you look at the 'it's the Jews' argument it goes something like this: If you weaken foreign nationalism then another Holocaust can never happen (it's probably counter productive). The thinking is that the more the west 'browns' the more they will fight each other....and who will be the Moses to lead them to harmony? I don't think it works like that but I think what you need to understand is that people mostly act instinctively and I've never been a person who thinks there's some grand conspiracy in these terms.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Maybe so, but I'm not fully aligned with the government on this one. Some of the content of Shapps statements yesterday were ridiculous. That's great, but let's see how aligned you are when it all kicks off on our streets.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
That's great, but let's see how aligned you are when it all kicks off on our streets. You often remind me of Chicken Little.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
You often remind me of Chicken Little. And you remind me of Kentucky fried chicken. Too salty and bad for the nation's health.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Well, let's not fall into the idea that all Jews think the same way of course. Right wing pro European Jews are out there...I was red pilled by one. Jared Taylor has significant funding from Jewish backers and Tommy Robinson is a full on Zionist who is just coming back from a holiday there and his funding for restarting the EDL is probably Israeli. However, the reality is that...collectively (a minority aren't)....all ethnic minorities within host cultures are instinctively against them. The evidence for that is easy to see in voting patterns. Indeed, out of the ethnic groups white Europeans are the least racist in this way (why Obama and others can still get elected).....but it's true even for whites just not as strong. If you look specifically at Jews in Europe/US, you find that they vote around 70 percent left.....While in Israel itself it's either right wing or pretty even. It's just general human nature. If you look at the 'it's the Jews' argument it goes something like this: If you weaken foreign nationalism then another Holocaust can never happen (it's probably counter productive). The thinking is that the more the west 'browns' the more they will fight each other....and who will be the Moses to lead them to harmony? I don't think it works like that but I think what you need to understand is that people mostly act instinctively and I've never been a person who thinks there's some grand conspiracy in these terms.
Agree with everything you're saying, as an anecdote I have noticed a lot of center-left types, some jews here in the US waking up to whats going on. The openly pro-palestine/hamas protests, the blood chants...etc, etc The irony of these same people inviting the wolf to dine at kitchen table for the past two decades. I can’t believe that only 7 years ago the thing that most excited Leftists was affordable health care in this country. They really became sickos, each depravity worse than the last, to the point that they’re excusing, if not cheering on, snuff videos. Edited by Sheks Crows Eye (13 Oct 2023 3.27pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Sheks Crows Eye
Agree with everything you're saying, as an anecdote I have noticed a lot of center-left types, some jews here in the US waking up to whats going on. The openly pro-palestine/hamas protests, the blood chants...etc, etc The irony of these same people inviting the wolf to dine at kitchen table for the past two decades. I can’t believe that only 7 years ago the thing that most excited Leftists was affordable health care in this country. They really became sickos, each depravity worse than the last, to the point that they’re excusing, if not cheering on, snuff videos. Edited by Sheks Crows Eye (13 Oct 2023 3.27pm) Totally agree. We are living in times where reactions to major events are less measured and more emotional, be it left or right....escalation and polarisation are on the menu. When it comes to war in our modern age I don't mind admitting that's freaky scary. I think the west leaders are a reflection of that....It's quite incredible that instead of the very best talent being available to voters, instead they get people only fit to tow the money line. Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Oct 2023 3.39pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.