You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace v Bournemouth match thread
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Crystal Palace v Bournemouth match thread


Page 12 of 12 << First< 8 9 10 11 12
rikz Flag Croydon 07 Dec 23 9.27pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Which is entirely irrelevant when comparing the scoring rate of players who all play in that division.

Wow

If it's that easy, who's top scorer in league 2, let's just sign him in Jan.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 08 Dec 23 9.10am

Originally posted by palace99

Schlupp has essentially been a bit part player for the last 10 years with both us and Leicester. Never a regular, often used to cover injuries and because of his versatility.
With Olise injured and Zaha leaving having him as the only LW option for the first 3 to 4 months of the season is bizarre. His confidence is shot.

Clyne was a decent stop gap option when AWB left. We are now 4 years on and we have the same stop gap. Unbelievable.

Richards in CM as a stop gap away from home made some sense. Playing him at home was a bizarre selection - he looked lost and can't believe he wasn't subbed at half time.

Hughes should be a fixture with Doucoure injured, however, he has been woeful recently. The fact that Richards started in front of him should be a wake up call. However, he is just so slow not sure he can improve that much. He's 28 but plays like he was 38!


Schlupp bit part player nice joke for us every week his names on the starting line up and has been for all Roys years at the club.

The only times he may not start is in cup games or if he is out for injury/personal reasons otherwise he always starts under Roy.

You have shown either are not following Palace on regular basis or here get a reaction from others.

Richards is not really a CM he is a CB.

As is the case with Roy he doesn't use players strengths and wants to drop people into his system expecting them to all do it which is why Hughes at times looks so poor. (He is average Prem player you have in squad)

I was at this game the vibe in the ground was not good and didn't help with it being cold plus the transport problems (With that disgraceful display plus many other games be how the manager can expect fans to get behind them shows he has no clue)

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

XKudu Flag The Midlands, England 08 Dec 23 9.25am

If we don’t sign a striker in January we deserve to fail. This Right Back & Striker (lack of) is costing us. I also think ‘Rabbit in the Highlights’ Mitchell has been found out as being distinctly average which is a shame because we all had high hopes for him. He very rarely has any end product when he ventures forward and looks utterly petrified when defending most of the time. I wonder whether it was a slight muscle strain (as reported) or an anxiety attack that made him depart the other night.

Add a Left Back to the list.

Edited by XKudu (08 Dec 2023 9.29am)

 

MabbsWasKing Flag 08 Dec 23 9.51am

Firstly I have never booed Palace and I hope I never will. Bournemouth was awful but you have to take the rough with the smooth if you are a fan and sometimes there is plenty of rough!
Bottom line the squad is too small, the Club didn’t get the players it wanted in the summer and we are limited by FFP and how much the shareholders are prepared to invest.
I don’t believe that bringing in a new manager this season will improve anything as he would just inherit Roy’s problems.
On the small squad we had a centre back crisis a few years back so SP must have been aware of the danger but couldn’t do anything about it.
There are a number of players, being paid well, that are now not Premier League squad standard , in my view…..Clyne, Thomkins, Riederwald, Hughes. There is Ferguson who just can’t get fit. There are the youngsters who Roy clearly doesn’t believe are yet strong enough to take the risk with. There are others who should be just squad players….Schlupp, Ward and Mateta. That is a lot of salary for players that aren’t up to it!
I think playing Richard in midfield shows how desperate Roy is….he can’t trust Jairo there because he can’t win a challenge, he can’t trust Hughes there because he is incapable of tracking his runner, and he doesn’t think Ozoe is yet up to the challenge. Richard is a premier league standard centre half not a midfielder or full back.
I am not expecting more than 3 points by the end of this year and SP is then going to have to be really pragmatic in the January window if he can’t offload some players.
A tough year for Eagles but I am here for the ride.

Up the Palace.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 08 Dec 23 9.54am

Originally posted by MabbsWasKing

Firstly I have never booed Palace and I hope I never will. Bournemouth was awful but you have to take the rough with the smooth if you are a fan and sometimes there is plenty of rough!
Bottom line the squad is too small, the Club didn’t get the players it wanted in the summer and we are limited by FFP and how much the shareholders are prepared to invest.
I don’t believe that bringing in a new manager this season will improve anything as he would just inherit Roy’s problems.
On the small squad we had a centre back crisis a few years back so SP must have been aware of the danger but couldn’t do anything about it.
There are a number of players, being paid well, that are now not Premier League squad standard , in my view…..Clyne, Thomkins, Riederwald, Hughes. There is Ferguson who just can’t get fit. There are the youngsters who Roy clearly doesn’t believe are yet strong enough to take the risk with. There are others who should be just squad players….Schlupp, Ward and Mateta. That is a lot of salary for players that aren’t up to it!
I think playing Richard in midfield shows how desperate Roy is….he can’t trust Jairo there because he can’t win a challenge, he can’t trust Hughes there because he is incapable of tracking his runner, and he doesn’t think Ozoe is yet up to the challenge. Richard is a premier league standard centre half not a midfielder or full back.
I am not expecting more than 3 points by the end of this year and SP is then going to have to be really pragmatic in the January window if he can’t offload some players.
A tough year for Eagles but I am here for the ride.

Up the Palace.

Agree all round there, good post.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

crvenaeagle Flag 08 Dec 23 9.56am

Originally posted by MabbsWasKing

Firstly I have never booed Palace and I hope I never will. Bournemouth was awful but you have to take the rough with the smooth if you are a fan and sometimes there is plenty of rough!
Bottom line the squad is too small, the Club didn’t get the players it wanted in the summer and we are limited by FFP and how much the shareholders are prepared to invest.
I don’t believe that bringing in a new manager this season will improve anything as he would just inherit Roy’s problems.
On the small squad we had a centre back crisis a few years back so SP must have been aware of the danger but couldn’t do anything about it.
There are a number of players, being paid well, that are now not Premier League squad standard , in my view…..Clyne, Thomkins, Riederwald, Hughes. There is Ferguson who just can’t get fit. There are the youngsters who Roy clearly doesn’t believe are yet strong enough to take the risk with. There are others who should be just squad players….Schlupp, Ward and Mateta. That is a lot of salary for players that aren’t up to it!
I think playing Richard in midfield shows how desperate Roy is….he can’t trust Jairo there because he can’t win a challenge, he can’t trust Hughes there because he is incapable of tracking his runner, and he doesn’t think Ozoe is yet up to the challenge. Richard is a premier league standard centre half not a midfielder or full back.
I am not expecting more than 3 points by the end of this year and SP is then going to have to be really pragmatic in the January window if he can’t offload some players.
A tough year for Eagles but I am here for the ride.

Up the Palace.

Most sensible post I've read all week.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 08 Dec 23 10.06am

Originally posted by MabbsWasKing

Firstly I have never booed Palace and I hope I never will. Bournemouth was awful but you have to take the rough with the smooth if you are a fan and sometimes there is plenty of rough!
Bottom line the squad is too small, the Club didn’t get the players it wanted in the summer and we are limited by FFP and how much the shareholders are prepared to invest.
I don’t believe that bringing in a new manager this season will improve anything as he would just inherit Roy’s problems.
On the small squad we had a centre back crisis a few years back so SP must have been aware of the danger but couldn’t do anything about it.
There are a number of players, being paid well, that are now not Premier League squad standard , in my view…..Clyne, Thomkins, Riederwald, Hughes. There is Ferguson who just can’t get fit. There are the youngsters who Roy clearly doesn’t believe are yet strong enough to take the risk with. There are others who should be just squad players….Schlupp, Ward and Mateta. That is a lot of salary for players that aren’t up to it!
I think playing Richard in midfield shows how desperate Roy is….he can’t trust Jairo there because he can’t win a challenge, he can’t trust Hughes there because he is incapable of tracking his runner, and he doesn’t think Ozoe is yet up to the challenge. Richard is a premier league standard centre half not a midfielder or full back.
I am not expecting more than 3 points by the end of this year and SP is then going to have to be really pragmatic in the January window if he can’t offload some players.
A tough year for Eagles but I am here for the ride.

Up the Palace.

Yer up the Palace! agree with every word. A real fan ,and a realist to boot.

Edited by Putitout (08 Dec 2023 10.07am)

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 08 Dec 23 11.38am

Originally posted by MabbsWasKing

Firstly I have never booed Palace and I hope I never will. Bournemouth was awful but you have to take the rough with the smooth if you are a fan and sometimes there is plenty of rough!
Bottom line the squad is too small, the Club didn’t get the players it wanted in the summer and we are limited by FFP and how much the shareholders are prepared to invest.
I don’t believe that bringing in a new manager this season will improve anything as he would just inherit Roy’s problems.
On the small squad we had a centre back crisis a few years back so SP must have been aware of the danger but couldn’t do anything about it.
There are a number of players, being paid well, that are now not Premier League squad standard , in my view…..Clyne, Thomkins, Riederwald, Hughes. There is Ferguson who just can’t get fit. There are the youngsters who Roy clearly doesn’t believe are yet strong enough to take the risk with. There are others who should be just squad players….Schlupp, Ward and Mateta. That is a lot of salary for players that aren’t up to it!
I think playing Richard in midfield shows how desperate Roy is….he can’t trust Jairo there because he can’t win a challenge, he can’t trust Hughes there because he is incapable of tracking his runner, and he doesn’t think Ozoe is yet up to the challenge. Richard is a premier league standard centre half not a midfielder or full back.
I am not expecting more than 3 points by the end of this year and SP is then going to have to be really pragmatic in the January window if he can’t offload some players.
A tough year for Eagles but I am here for the ride.

Up the Palace.

You do have the rough with the smooth. But it just feels very rough atm.

Roy is taking a lot of stick, and he deserves some.

We do need to understand as fans that he sees these players every day, so if he picks Richards as CDM or Clyne as LB etc its because he trusts the others even less.

However we play with no desirable tempo or style, and when we go 1-0 down we do more of the same, usually with JMP subbed in. I'm desperate to see us do something drastically different. even stick Richards up top and pump balls up at him. Anything to avoid limping to another loss. That is on Roy.

Ultimately the buck can only stop with Parish and Doug. When fit we have a competitive 11. But are now in a position with no LB or CDM against potentailly 3 of the toughest games of the season.

We cant cry about injuries, every team has them.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 08 Dec 23 11.51am

Paying for 3 previous light transfer windows where suitable replacements were not brought on board. Only centre midfield has been beefed up. With an average amount of PL injuries (some teams have had a fair few more) the squad looks very lightweight and unbalanced. Edouard's lack of effort to even try to stretch for a cross in the 1st half fairly summed up where we are at, at the moment. Looks increasingly like we will have less points than games around the New Year, a barometer for possible relegation, meaning the owners will have to make some tough choices.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

palace chick Flag South Croydon 08 Dec 23 11.57am

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

Paying for 3 previous light transfer windows where suitable replacements were not brought on board. Only centre midfield has been beefed up. With an average amount of PL injuries (some teams have had a fair few more) the squad looks very lightweight and unbalanced. Edouard's lack of effort to even try to stretch for a cross in the 1st half fairly summed up where we are at, at the moment. Looks increasingly like we will have less points than games around the New Year, a barometer for possible relegation, meaning the owners will have to make some tough choices.

I would say our midfield is the weakest it’s been for many a season and all we are missing at the moment is Dacoure. Even with him it’s not been that strong this season?

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 08 Dec 23 12.00pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

You do have the rough with the smooth. But it just feels very rough atm.

Roy is taking a lot of stick, and he deserves some.

We do need to understand as fans that he sees these players every day, so if he picks Richards as CDM or Clyne as LB etc its because he trusts the others even less.

However we play with no desirable tempo or style, and when we go 1-0 down we do more of the same, usually with JMP subbed in. I'm desperate to see us do something drastically different. even stick Richards up top and pump balls up at him. Anything to avoid limping to another loss. That is on Roy.

Ultimately the buck can only stop with Parish and Doug. When fit we have a competitive 11. But are now in a position with no LB or CDM against potentailly 3 of the toughest games of the season.

We cant cry about injuries, every team has them.

But that doesn’t make him right.

I think we’ve seen enough of Roy over the years to know he is conservative to the extreme in player selections - I have no doubt that another manager would look at our squad and find very different solutions to the same injuries.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 08 Dec 23 12.01pm

Originally posted by palace chick

I would say our midfield is the weakest it’s been for many a season and all we are missing at the moment is Dacoure. Even with him it’s not been that strong this season?

And Eze.

Our best midfield is Lerma Doucoure Eze, which is a strong trio.


 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 08 Dec 23 12.28pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

And Eze.

Our best midfield is Lerma Doucoure Eze, which is a strong trio.


I don’t believe Eza makes it into a strong midfield. Perhaps just behind a centre forward is his position. If anything he makes a midfield weaker because of his lack of tackling / winning the ball. We need a strong midfield 3/4 for which we only have Lerma and Dacoure. Olise also is part of a 4 but again his strength is going forward but as we saw on Wednesday he had 2/3 on him every time he got the ball and also had a poor game like the rest of our team. It’s a squad game these days and we don’t have a strong one at all. Plus we don’t even have a strong 11 to start with, let alone sitting on the bench :-(

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 08 Dec 23 12.37pm

Originally posted by palace chick

I don’t believe Eza makes it into a strong midfield. Perhaps just behind a centre forward is his position. If anything he makes a midfield weaker because of his lack of tackling / winning the ball. We need a strong midfield 3/4 for which we only have Lerma and Dacoure. Olise also is part of a 4 but again his strength is going forward but as we saw on Wednesday he had 2/3 on him every time he got the ball and also had a poor game like the rest of our team. It’s a squad game these days and we don’t have a strong one at all. Plus we don’t even have a strong 11 to start with, let alone sitting on the bench :-(

Eze is a midfielder as he is a playmaker. I wouldn't get too caught up on debating what constitutes 'a midfield' but would argue ours is two holding players with a playmaker/link to the forward line ahead of them.

To echo EDN, I believe Doucoure and Lerma holding with Eze ahead of them is our strongest midfield.

Johnstone, Guehi, Andersen, Lerma, Doucoure, Eze, Olise (RW) and for now Ayew (LW) is the core of our team. Beyond that we have players just making up the numbers with very few if none worthy of being considered in that cohort.

Mitchell, Ward, Edouard and potentially Ayew are filling positions we would ideally strengthen if we were able to spend money and recruit like other PL teams, which apparently we cannot. We're vulnerable from attacks down the wing and blunt in front of goal. Until this changes, we're going to struggle.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 08 Dec 23 12.48pm

Originally posted by palace chick

I don’t believe Eza makes it into a strong midfield. Perhaps just behind a centre forward is his position. If anything he makes a midfield weaker because of his lack of tackling / winning the ball. We need a strong midfield 3/4 for which we only have Lerma and Dacoure. Olise also is part of a 4 but again his strength is going forward but as we saw on Wednesday he had 2/3 on him every time he got the ball and also had a poor game like the rest of our team. It’s a squad game these days and we don’t have a strong one at all. Plus we don’t even have a strong 11 to start with, let alone sitting on the bench :-(

That's if you are judging a midfield on physical strength alone, which nobody does. What are you hoping for 3 holding midfielders? Don't say it too loud, Roy might go with it.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 08 Dec 23 1.29pm

Originally posted by palace chick

I don’t believe Eza makes it into a strong midfield. Perhaps just behind a centre forward is his position. If anything he makes a midfield weaker because of his lack of tackling / winning the ball. We need a strong midfield 3/4 for which we only have Lerma and Dacoure. Olise also is part of a 4 but again his strength is going forward but as we saw on Wednesday he had 2/3 on him every time he got the ball and also had a poor game like the rest of our team. It’s a squad game these days and we don’t have a strong one at all. Plus we don’t even have a strong 11 to start with, let alone sitting on the bench :-(

Strange comment , v Luton Eze made 3 tackles which was 2 more than any other player bar the full backs also 3 and he was only on the pitch for 40 minutes .Lerma a DM who played the whole game didn't make any ,Doucoure who went off in the second half made one

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 08 Dec 23 1.47pm

Eze,s overal contributions have improved under Hodgson almost 100%. But hasn’t anyone noticed that without his goal, and assist contribution we struggle in the way we did even at WH. This was apparent even in pre season. Without him we didn’t fire on al cylinders .He is a mid fielder ,but if you are going to need his vital work up front the rest of the mid field has to balance. We don’t carry him ,we literally are not much without him, and we always struggle to win games without his quality.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 09 Dec 23 9.01am

Originally posted by palace chick

I don’t believe Eza makes it into a strong midfield. Perhaps just behind a centre forward is his position. If anything he makes a midfield weaker because of his lack of tackling / winning the ball. We need a strong midfield 3/4 for which we only have Lerma and Dacoure. Olise also is part of a 4 but again his strength is going forward but as we saw on Wednesday he had 2/3 on him every time he got the ball and also had a poor game like the rest of our team. It’s a squad game these days and we don’t have a strong one at all. Plus we don’t even have a strong 11 to start with, let alone sitting on the bench :-(

Both were signed in the last 3 transfer windows. The only area that I can see bar the goalkeeper (which I think we have overcooked now) where we have made some in roads.

Looking at todays injury list for the PL the average number of players out is around 7. If you take those out of the squad you have 18 players to pick, 16 if you remove goalies. The PL is the most demanding league physically and if you don't have a good level of squad depth you are going to struggle. So if you have a weak squad and not prepared to blood home growns you have to be very active in the transfer market. We haven't for 3 windows.

Roy is a pragmatic manager, in the mould of Pardew although he might of been more stubborn. In the FA Cup season it was only the fact that the team had enough points by Xmas to be comfortable. The wheels well and truly fell off after that and we narrowly escaped relegation. Next season he was found out and toast. Just hope the management don't go down this route with Roy and hold out too long. The worry is that just like Pards he might be "cut some slack" with the management.

Roy's comments about the players recently have seemed odd. He was full of praise of the new players emerging and then said they weren't ready, all in one sentence !! If he believes in them that much then give them a go.

Talk of only entering the loan market to "shore" up the squad does not fill me with confidence. Don't know the rules but I thought we were only allowed 2 loanees from the PL ? If so we need a lot more than that and loanees even from there are dicey, foreign ones even more so.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

southnorwoodhill Flag 09 Dec 23 9.14am

Eze's a talent, and we're better with him than without obviously. I'm not so certain he's worth anything near some of the figures bandied about on here, mainly because he appears injury prone.

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 09 Dec 23 4.59pm

Same scoreline against Manure

 


Pro USA & Israel

Page 12 of 12 << First< 8 9 10 11 12

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace v Bournemouth match thread