You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace v Sheffield United Match thread
November 16 2026 3.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Crystal Palace v Sheffield United Match thread


Page 12 of 18 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >
Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 31 Jan 24 7.43am

Originally posted by Painter

Bet your happier, when we lose. We won, Olise was worth anyones entrance fee alone.

You know what Painter I think I have been, there is no denying Olise is something else he is most probably a better player than Wilf was but without the attitude.

But if you were there last night, and I’m sure you were that was not an easy watch and we were clueless!

 

MFW94 Flag Sutton 31 Jan 24 7.44am

Easy for people to moan that we are nothing without Eze and Olise - thats kind of the whole point of having them - 2 match winners that a lot of other clubs down the bottom dont have.
Also both games theyve played at home together this season weve scored 3 goals in both games.

People have short memories, we did this every season with Wilf in the side, atleast now we have 2.
Subs were the obvious subs to make when you are 3-2 up in a must win I am afraid, as much as I would like to see franca play it just wasnt realistic last night. The game plan was clearly to hang on after the eze and olise went off and I am totally okay with that considering we arent actually any good without them
3 points was more important than the performance tonight. Saturday however will be a completely different ball game.

 

PatrickA Flag London 31 Jan 24 7.45am

With regard to the gripe that you mentioned about the space afforded to opposition wide players, this is something I’ve long been aware of and concerned by.
Hodgson has previously said that he’s less concerned about when the ball is out wide with his reasoning being that if the full backs don’t block the cross the central defenders will deal with them in the penalty area.
Hodgson is more concerned with being compact in and around our penalty area, blocking spaces and defending that area in numbers.
This means that our full backs are sometimes left exposed defending 2 on 1 and that crosses aren’t always stopped.
It’s a dangerous game as there are many adept crossers of the ball in the Premier League and our central defenders and goalkeepers are not the most commanding or dominant of players.
We have not defended well by and large this season and the absence of Doucoure shielding in front of the penalty area has left a massive gap we’ve shown no sign of being able to fill.

Originally posted by The Dolphin

The positives are that we won the game, got a valuable 3 points and that Olise and Eze played like mem possessed when they were on the field.
I also that that Mateta and Ayew were excellent as well.
We looked like we had a plan with the two of them on the pitch but no plan when they went off.
Which brings me to the negatives -
We allowed Sheffield United to score two goals and in the last 20 mins or so allowed them to look like a top side.
We had no plan in place once Eze and Olise went off.
Franca could have come on and allowed us to keep up the pressure but Roy decided to go negative and it nearly backfired.
Any team would miss not having Eze and Olise on the field but we are clueless without them.
Roy and Ray should be on top of that stuff and yet it appeared they just stood and watched with no coaching from the sidelines.
If we stay up - which if we keep those two fit and the additions to the squad then we should then it will be despite Roy and not because of him - he can't leave too soon for me.
One last gripe - why do our (and maybe other teams) full backs give the wide players so much space?
Week after week the ball gets sprayed out wide and there is no one within 20 yards or so?
Both goals last night came from just that scenario - full backs getting sucked in to the middle.
A strange one which I will never understand.
Glad we won and just hope that Batman and Robin are fit to face the weed on Saturday - love it that Luton thrashed them (even though it doesn't help us) but old habits die hard!

 

pheasant plucker Flag Lanzarote 31 Jan 24 8.02am

Originally posted by rollercoaster

Sick to death of the negative Roy comments. That is it!
Play him, don't play him, take him off, don't take him off, got to go, negative, positive, give it a rest for F*** Sake.

-.-' -.-'

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 31 Jan 24 8.03am

Originally posted by Badger11

Agreed. He is a big unit but like Jairo I am not sure he is very mobile. I don't wish to criticise a young player but so far he had not impressed without doing anything wrong.

I think tonight's appearance was fine he came on to protect the lead and put himself about. I think for the rest of the season Roy will use him in that role but no way is he ready to hold down a place in the team.

Here's hoping he improves.

18 years old

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 31 Jan 24 8.05am

Originally posted by PatrickA

With regard to the gripe that you mentioned about the space afforded to opposition wide players, this is something I’ve long been aware of and concerned by.
Hodgson has previously said that he’s less concerned about when the ball is out wide with his reasoning being that if the full backs don’t block the cross the central defenders will deal with them in the penalty area.
Hodgson is more concerned with being compact in and around our penalty area, blocking spaces and defending that area in numbers.
This means that our full backs are sometimes left exposed defending 2 on 1 and that crosses aren’t always stopped.
It’s a dangerous game as there are many adept crossers of the ball in the Premier League and our central defenders and goalkeepers are not the most commanding or dominant of players.
We have not defended well by and large this season and the absence of Doucoure shielding in front of the penalty area has left a massive gap we’ve shown no sign of being able to fill.

Worked against man City

 

pssguy Flag 31 Jan 24 8.11am

Originally posted by EddieMac

Olise is worth at least 100 million if Antony and Grealish are worth what they are.

They're probably 15 and 40 million pound players, respectively. Grealish has regressed since he left Villa. Olise is far superior to either of them

 

PatrickA Flag London 31 Jan 24 8.18am

Didn’t work v Newcastle where Tripper destroyed us.
Isolated examples either way don’t prove a point.
We do leave spaces out wide , preferring to concentrate on defending the penalty area
There is of course a counter argument that if we concentrated on defending wide areas we could leave gaps in the middle.
Both methods have risks, but we have looked vulnerable to crosses this season and although Guehi and Anderson are excellent players it could be argued they are not as good as defending the box as e.g Dann, Cahill, Delaney, Tompkins.

Originally posted by silvertop

Worked against man City

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 31 Jan 24 8.22am

With an organised defence we would have won 3 or 4 nil last night. That’s the impact of Olise & Eze - we should have been out of sight when they went off. That we scraped home 3-2 and were set up to fail at the back with players out of position - that’s the impact of the manager.

 

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 31 Jan 24 8.24am

Originally posted by Aray

They have won nothjng away from home and have 11 points. They are sh!t.

I was at the game. We had them pinned for most of the game until the manager decided we should shut up shop.

When they scored after TWENTY FIVE SECONDS- helped by our out of position RB forgetting he wasn’t playing central- their fans sang - we’re winning an away, how sh!t must you be? We’re winning away.

If that doesn’t land with you. Then nothing will.

After 25secs we lost the game no we won when i last looked at the score line, and was on top they had very little chances after that , wood work has saved teams we have played but god forbid them hitting our wood work , all i hear was we was lucky not us unlucky when we done it ,
If you go to the game thinking we are going to lose your view of the game will be negative no matter what ,
After 50+ years of supporting this club i have never gone to a game thinking we will lose and never will , i done 3 seasons not missing a game when we was in the 3rd division and 2nd division , thats home and away and cups , so enjoy the wins dont look for reason why we did ,
we have hopefully 2 attack minded players signed and maybe a loan coming , see what happens when we go all out attack so you feel happy with us getting trashed because we dont have anyone back defending , look for the positives not negative's or you end up like you

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 31 Jan 24 8.30am

Originally posted by MFW94

Easy for people to moan that we are nothing without Eze and Olise - thats kind of the whole point of having them - 2 match winners that a lot of other clubs down the bottom dont have.
Also both games theyve played at home together this season weve scored 3 goals in both games.

People have short memories, we did this every season with Wilf in the side, atleast now we have 2.
Subs were the obvious subs to make when you are 3-2 up in a must win I am afraid, as much as I would like to see franca play it just wasnt realistic last night. The game plan was clearly to hang on after the eze and olise went off and I am totally okay with that considering we arent actually any good without them
3 points was more important than the performance tonight. Saturday however will be a completely different ball game.

I disagree, even though we brought on defensive players to hold on to 3 points it was unbalanced and nearly cost us. Franca for Eza would have balanced us better with Schlupp for Olise. Pleased for the 3 points but still worry where the next 3 are coming from. Surprised Henderson got the nod to start as well?

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 31 Jan 24 8.31am

A welcome three points, Eze and Olise superb, Hendersen worries everyone, think Johnstone must be leaving this window, poor decision to drop Clyne for Richards, IMO, Richards has done well in DM role, Lerma is the worry for me, poor player, Richards, Hughes, Ozoh and hopefully Wharton better than him, dont sell Mateta, i would like to see Morgan Whittaker on loan to buy before deadline shuts, and Reiss Nelson as a 6 month lone, cant afford to take a chance with O or Es injury.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

southnorwoodhill Flag 31 Jan 24 8.33am

We just about scraped past a really poor team. On the other hand Brighton were absolutely spanked by a team that were written off as relegation favourites. It should make the game against Brighton very interesting.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 31 Jan 24 8.36am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

We just about scraped past a really poor team. On the other hand Brighton were absolutely spanked by a team that were written off as relegation favourites. It should make the game against Brighton very interesting.

Luton have found an aggressive way to play in the PL that gets them points. Looking like more points will be needed to stay up than was thought a few months ago.

 

MFW94 Flag Sutton 31 Jan 24 8.41am

Franca has played about 70 mins since signing, I really want him to play but it just wasnt realistic in a close game to lob him on. I dont think schlupp should be anywhere near the starting 11 but I dont mind him as a sub.
I agree about Henderson, still not as confident as I am with Johnstone.

Originally posted by palace chick

I disagree, even though we brought on defensive players to hold on to 3 points it was unbalanced and nearly cost us. Franca for Eza would have balanced us better with Schlupp for Olise. Pleased for the 3 points but still worry where the next 3 are coming from. Surprised Henderson got the nod to start as well?

 

MFW94 Flag Sutton 31 Jan 24 8.48am

My biggest worry would be andersons form - first goal last night him and Richards positioning was awful, like they thought they were still playing as 3 CB's.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 31 Jan 24 8.51am

Originally posted by Davepalace707

Luton have found an aggressive way to play in the PL that gets them points. Looking like more points will be needed to stay up than was thought a few months ago.

I reckon it’s between us, Luton, Everton and Forest for the third relegation spot. We should have enough to stay up, but we must start defending better. Luton have made their home ground a bit of a fortress but they are useless away. Everton may still be deducted more points. Forest are very average. We are by no means out of trouble.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 31 Jan 24 8.55am

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

You know what Painter I think I have been, there is no denying Olise is something else he is most probably a better player than Wilf was but without the attitude.

But if you were there last night, and I’m sure you were that was not an easy watch and we were clueless!

It was a great watch, a competitive game with individual skill, not quite sure what you are expecting!

 

adelaar Flag Edgware 31 Jan 24 9.03am

Originally posted by MFW94

Easy for people to moan that we are nothing without Eze and Olise - thats kind of the whole point of having them - 2 match winners that a lot of other clubs down the bottom dont have.
Also both games theyve played at home together this season weve scored 3 goals in both games.

People have short memories, we did this every season with Wilf in the side, atleast now we have 2.
Subs were the obvious subs to make when you are 3-2 up in a must win I am afraid, as much as I would like to see franca play it just wasnt realistic last night. The game plan was clearly to hang on after the eze and olise went off and I am totally okay with that considering we arent actually any good without them
3 points was more important than the performance tonight. Saturday however will be a completely different ball game.

Talksport last night were saying Palace basically have nothing to offer without Olise and Eze. They are also injury prone, so if they don't play where do we create anything from?
Have to hope they can both stay fit for the remainder of the season.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 31 Jan 24 9.07am

Originally posted by mtp1958

and yet again we win and people make excuses for the other team you lot are by far the least knowledgeable fans in the world , oh we are nothing without olise and eze should have better subs we havent got 180 million to sit on the bench you morons , its nothing todo with opinions it just hatred toward Roy and CRYSTAL PALACE FC go and support a bigger team had enough of these so called supporters ,

COYP

I object to being called a Moron..!!

Bloody keyboard warrior..!!

 

Page 12 of 18 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace v Sheffield United Match thread