You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread
November 20 2026 12.40pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Benteke thread


Page 121 of 166 < 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 24 Aug 19 9.03am

Originally posted by grumpymort


Nothing to explain if you can't understand it you don't understand the game and how the system works.

it's not always about goals

Benteke is still being called up for Belgium

You come out with so much rubbish you remind me of the idiots you hear down the pub very low iq.

It's simple you pay 35m you don't let that go for free you want some return and considering a Chinese club did offer 15m for him that shows he currently has that value.

The facts show he has scored goals for many seasons in this league and only reason he has not been scoring is the system and poor service since Roy came in other strikers have also struggled.

If Big Sam was still in charge Benteke would be scoring or assisting with goals

It was no doubt in a newspaper a Chinese club offered £15 mil for him. If that’s true then hopefully he’ll reject us. There’s been other Chinese bids for players that never materialised.

The system he’s played in is A reason but other reasons are the sitters he’s missed, the ones he’s not read or been there for or just his dopey, gormless brain or non football brain is just no fvcking good. I’ve seen dozens of easy chances in the last 2 years. Loads of them.

The irony of you calling me an idiot is really amusing. You’re in the top few on this website, especially in Palace talk.

How long have you been saying we should extend Benteke’s contract to ‘protect our investment.’ Since you read it or during the last year or two you’ve been moaning like fvck, often on stuff that you’ve been lambasted for because all your opinions have a default of someone suffering from severe irritability.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (24 Aug 2019 9.09am)

 


COYP

southnorwoodhill Flag 24 Aug 19 9.13am

Originally posted by EddieMac

If he is signing a new contract it is because he wants to stay at Palace as there are always buyers and takers for premier league players. You may not think he is worth anything but believe me in todays market even with his recent goal scoring record he is still worth a lot of money.

He doesnt have to have a change of heart, players get sold all the time even though they really dont want to move. So in a years time if the club decise they want him gone then he will be gone. Players generally do not want to stay at clubs where they are not wanted. (Benteke at Liverpool)

It makes perfect sense to get him tied down to a new deal.

Your saying get 100k off the wage bill but are letting 15-20 million walk out the door. The maths dont add up.

No club is going to pay £15/20 mil. He'll be a year older, millions of falsely earned pounds richer.
He couldn't score in a brothel with a bundle of £50 notes tied to his nob - he's f***ing useless. Making excuses that we don't play to his strengths? He doesn't have any - can't head, can't shoot, can't run with the ball, can't anticipate play, can't out jump markers, list goes on.

The wider question to ask is why is he still in the team?

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 24 Aug 19 9.19am

Originally posted by chris123

Well he isn't, and Benteke doesn't score or look like scoring - can't work out why he's playing let alone being extended. Our problem is scoring goals and the main reason is our number 9 doesn't do his job.

Unfortunately there is no real competition, that's one reason why we should of bought in the transfer window. He has about 60 Prem goals, Ayew about 20 and Wickham 7. None are firing so he will get the boots at the moment. Tekkers won't walk unless there is something better on the table or he loses his place in the team. There is no pressure for him to do anything, on or off the field.

Edited by Booted Eagle (24 Aug 2019 9.24am)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 24 Aug 19 9.20am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

No club is going to pay £15/20 mil. He'll be a year older, millions of falsely earned pounds richer.
He couldn't score in a brothel with a bundle of £50 notes tied to his nob - he's f***ing useless. Making excuses that we don't play to his strengths? He doesn't have any - can't head, can't shoot, can't run with the ball, can't anticipate play, can't out jump markers, list goes on.

The wider question to ask is why is he still in the team?

Because he’s usually the only one to pick from, because either Wickham is our injured or Sorloth is even worse. And that comes down to us buying a player so expensive with wages so high that all those eggs in one basket has fvcked us. Yes, hiring FDB and then Roy one year later, like Parish does because he has slightly more of a football brain than Benteke, is a reason, but so are the many many many easy chances.

We’re littered with people from top to bottom in the wrong place or work position, costing the club fortunes.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 24 Aug 19 9.22am

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

Unfortunately there is no real competition, that's one reason why we should of bought in the transfer window. Tekkers won't walk unless there is something better on the table or he loses his place in the team. There is no pressure for him to do anything, on or off the field.

Yep, no wonder he doesn’t mind trotting out as the only striker we have. It’s so farcical it’s embarrassing. Stubborn bollox from Parish. Benteke might be thick, but he’s not thick enough to not realise how desperate we become to play him as long as we’re paying him.

 


COYP

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 24 Aug 19 9.39am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Because he’s usually the only one to pick from, because either Wickham is our injured or Sorloth is even worse. And that comes down to us buying a player so expensive with wages so high that all those eggs in one basket has fvcked us. Yes, hiring FDB and then Roy one year later, like Parish does because he has slightly more of a football brain than Benteke, is a reason, but so are the many many many easy chances.

We’re littered with people from top to bottom in the wrong place or work position, costing the club fortunes.

Yes, too many wrong decisions/ management, bad investment and application at all levels. The team looked unfit and clueless (yet again) last weekend but I would have to blame the hierarchy as much as the players.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 24 Aug 19 10.08am

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

Yes, too many wrong decisions/ management, bad investment and application at all levels. The team looked unfit and clueless (yet again) last weekend but I would have to blame the hierarchy as much as the players.

I blame Sheffield United.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 24 Aug 19 10.08am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

No club is going to pay £15/20 mil. He'll be a year older, millions of falsely earned pounds richer.
He couldn't score in a brothel with a bundle of £50 notes tied to his nob - he's f***ing useless. Making excuses that we don't play to his strengths? He doesn't have any - can't head, can't shoot, can't run with the ball, can't anticipate play, can't out jump markers, list goes on.

The wider question to ask is why is he still in the team?

TBF he can head the ball, the rest I agree 100% with. His biggest problem is he is not an instinctive goal scorer. At this level shooting should be an automatic reflex. The only automatic reflex he has is that inane grimace he puts on his face after missing another sitter. I would drop him for Ayew all day long and go 4-3-3

 

slubglurge Flag welling 24 Aug 19 10.30am

He is at the wrong club with the wrong tactics for him. Because we play left footers on the right and right footers on the left means they have to check before crossing enabling defenders to set themselves and easily clear. Big Sam got the best out of him

 

JohnB Flag 24 Aug 19 10.32am

Originally posted by grumpymort


He has changed his game up but look at the service he is getting in those short clips he doesn't get that now.

the other thing is he is having to do much more work in other areas because that is how roy plays and the game has changed compared to back when he was at Villa.

so really that video is useless in trying to prove any point.

the evidence is look at his palace record and how he has played under different managers and the systems used that shows a pattern.

The people saying we wouldn't get 15m for him are clueless and shows again how so many people in here just don't have any idea about the game.

If you can give an example of a striker that has moved for £15m, that is 29 years old and has a record of 1 in 13 over the last few years, I will bow down to your superior football intelligence.

The last transfer that is comparable to what your suggesting is Rondon, who scored 15 in 38 last season compared to Benteke's 1 in 19. Rondon had 9 assists compared to Benteke's 1.

If you based worth purely on return, Rondon is about 7 or 8 times the return of Benteke and Rondon went for £16m. I'm not saying that's how transfer fees are calculated but it also highlights just how ridiculous it is to think any club would pay £15m for Benteke and his wages of £6m a year.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 24 Aug 19 11.05am

grumpy is just one of those irritable and unhappy people who disagrees with everyone no matter what. Contrarian for the sake of it. I feel sorry for him.

 


COYP

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 24 Aug 19 1.43pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

He is at the wrong club with the wrong tactics for him. Because we play left footers on the right and right footers on the left means they have to check before crossing enabling defenders to set themselves and easily clear. Big Sam got the best out of him

And who is to blame for that...The Manager!!!

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

Den1923 Flag 24 Aug 19 2.06pm

Originally posted by susmik

And who is to blame for that...The Manager!!!



Not really, he can only play the cards that dealt out by Parish/Freeman, they are the one's who should be blamed!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 24 Aug 19 3.00pm

Originally posted by Den1923



Not really, he can only play the cards that dealt out by Parish/Freeman, they are the one's who should be blamed!

So you’re saying Roy cannot play Zaha on the right and Townsend on the left at any point in a 90 minute match? What’s in Roy’s cards that says he can’t? While we’re at it, why do we only attack teams at Selhurst once all of the opposition are behind the ball, and then predictably offer no threat whatsoever? This happens several times a match.

There’s several to blame in all this.

The owners, Roy, Benteke, Zaha, although I feel his frustration when we plan to keep Benteke the wardrobe.

 


COYP

Den1923 Flag 24 Aug 19 4.18pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

So you’re saying Roy cannot play Zaha on the right and Townsend on the left at any point in a 90 minute match? What’s in Roy’s cards that says he can’t? While we’re at it, why do we only attack teams at Selhurst once all of the opposition are behind the ball, and then predictably offer no threat whatsoever? This happens several times a match.

There’s several to blame in all this.

The owners, Roy, Benteke, Zaha, although I feel his frustration when we plan to keep Benteke the wardrobe.


I do not disagree with anything here, what I am saying is that Roy has never really been supported in any of the recent transfer windows and he has had to put up with what Parish/Freeman can dish up and frankly that is not very much. His options are limited by the players he has at his disposal. He really cannot be blamed for trying to make a silk purse out of a sow's ear!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 24 Aug 19 5.08pm

Originally posted by Den1923


I do not disagree with anything here, what I am saying is that Roy has never really been supported in any of the recent transfer windows and he has had to put up with what Parish/Freeman can dish up and frankly that is not very much. His options are limited by the players he has at his disposal. He really cannot be blamed for trying to make a silk purse out of a sow's ear!

True. But he could play some other than 4-4-2 with players played out of position. There are other formations that suit them better.

I didn’t count Man U before the match and I don’t aftdr as it’s a almost a completely different sport. Great great result though obviously. Usual business next week.

 


COYP

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 24 Aug 19 7.33pm

Originally posted by Den1923



Not really, he can only play the cards that dealt out by Parish/Freeman, they are the one's who should be blamed!

Sorry to disagree but Roy has more cards in his hand if he chose to use them but he wont. He sticks to the same old line up week after week and does not use his subs to change a game...UNTIL TODAY when we saw what can happen when he decides to use his subs earlier. He went against the grain today and I would say woke up from his normal sleepy mode and did what most managers do and that is change the game.
Roy has younger players that he could use that we saw in pre season who I thought are worth a chance to play in the first team. But he wont it is always his favourites in the same old set up.
Lets hope he learnt something today and starts changing things around in the next few matches.

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 25 Aug 19 8.27am

Given this is the Benteke thread credit where credit is due, it was his excellent tackle on Pogba that won us the ball for the winning goal. His most telling bit of football for a while.

 

Den1923 Flag 25 Aug 19 1.57pm

Originally posted by susmik

Sorry to disagree but Roy has more cards in his hand if he chose to use them but he wont. He sticks to the same old line up week after week and does not use his subs to change a game...UNTIL TODAY when we saw what can happen when he decides to use his subs earlier. He went against the grain today and I would say woke up from his normal sleepy mode and did what most managers do and that is change the game.
Roy has younger players that he could use that we saw in pre season who I thought are worth a chance to play in the first team. But he wont it is always his favourites in the same old set up.
Lets hope he learnt something today and starts changing things around in the next few matches.

The pre-season was far from being termed as great, clearly he did not think we had the young talent that currently are to the standard required for PL otherwise as a manager with his knowledge and experience he would be selecting them, especially so, as the squad is fairly ancient and limited in talent for this league despite the win yesterday.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 25 Aug 19 2.03pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

Given this is the Benteke thread credit where credit is due, it was his excellent tackle on Pogba that won us the ball for the winning goal. His most telling bit of football for a while.

maybe we can convert Benteke into a defender ? cos he still aint scoring goals.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Page 121 of 166 < 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread