This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Slimey Toad
There's being honest and saying it like it is, and just being stupid. Why the damn? I know it's only one word but the rest of what he said was more or less his opinion, which does stand up. Can you hear in your own post how you have succumbed to the insanity?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Can you hear in your own post how you have succumbed to the insanity? Oh please. Calm down. A lot of people on this forum quite rightly don't like anti-Semitism. It isn't polite to point out that a particular Jew has a big nose. It's just common sense.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Starkey used poor language.
Neither should lose their jobs and if I was at University, these are the people whose lectures I would be queuing up to attend. Because they have genuine opinions that trouble and make you question all sorts. That is the point. Stirring the pot. But neither threatened nor encouraged others to violence. Universities should be places that encourage the freest of speech. Should revel in the extremes but instead are now nothing more than exercises in money-making. And are increasingly prey to some sinister forces. My daughter attends a top 10 British university and was telling me about the Chinese Government encouraging its students all attending to vote for certain candidates in the NUS elections. And given that her establishment is a Russel Group one, with all the research grants and project,makes the Chinese pressure even more worrying. Let that be the centre of investigations rather than people expressing opinions and wanting to push debates to the extreme ends.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Slimey Toad
Oh please. Calm down. A lot of people on this forum quite rightly don't like anti-Semitism. It isn't polite to point out that a particular Jew has a big nose. It's just common sense. So an opinion is not allowed if the language used is idiosyncratic and or it offends someone or offends someone by proxy? This is a dangerous path don't you think. So if someone is Jewish you can't criticise them? Surely it would be rude to tell anyone they had a big nose but that would make it no less true or untrue.
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
You miss the point. We live in a world where you can't hold the 'wrong' opinion. It doesn't matter what that opinion is. Who is deciding what is 'wrong' or 'unacceptable' and why? Money is usually the answer. I didn’t even read what it was for. Some right wing black commentators where saying the George Floyd isn’t the person to make a martyr. I think the same is true for David Starky. f*** him - he’s dick.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
I didn’t even read what it was for. Some right wing black commentators where saying the George Floyd isn’t the person to make a martyr. I think the same is true for David Starky. f*** him - he’s dick. He isn't. He was a violent criminal. Not a good comparison.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Starkey used poor language. However, Starkey has always held firm opinions. I hear that in the past he disavowed Enoch Powell so essentially I'm not quite sure where he stands on non European immigration into the country. What is clear however is that double standards are clearly being implemented. If Cambridge had sacked their non white academic for stating that 'white lives don't matter - as white lives' then I could accept their position....while not agreeing with the free speech punishment. However, as we see here, because Starkey is an old white male, no such protections exist for him. I'm still waiting for discover this 'white privilege' because all I'm seeing is the opposite.
One more point |
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Starkey used poor language. However, Starkey has always held firm opinions. I hear that in the past he disavowed Enoch Powell so essentially I'm not quite sure where he stands on non European immigration into the country. What is clear however is that double standards are clearly being implemented. If Cambridge had sacked their non white academic for stating that 'white lives don't matter - as white lives' then I could accept their position....while not agreeing with the free speech punishment. However, as we see here, because Starkey is an old white male, no such protections exist for him. I'm still waiting for discover this 'white privilege' because all I'm seeing is the opposite. Have any non-white academics said that? This seems like quite an academic argument.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
So an opinion is not allowed if the language used is idiosyncratic and or it offends someone or offends someone by proxy? This is a dangerous path don't you think. So if someone is Jewish you can't criticise them? Surely it would be rude to tell anyone they had a big nose but that would make it no less true or untrue. So John Terry considered Anton Ferdinand to be a c***, but as he was black he called him a black c***. What sort of unsophisticated bubble do you live in? Sorry if I'm coming across rude but I won't have my opinion undermined by a throwaway comment like 'succumbing to the insanity'.
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
He isn't. He was a violent criminal. Not a good comparison. George Floyd was killed by a incompetent policemen for trying to us a fake $20 bill. David Starkey resigned from his position as a unpaid honorary fellow, where you have to do no work, for saying: "Slavery was not genocide otherwise there wouldn't be so many damn blacks in Africa or Britain would there? An awful lot of them survived." Not sure the consequences are the same either. That’s extremely provocative statement and will take quite a long and contrived explanation along with a leap of faith to claim its non-offensive. In my view, most things that need a long explanation to justify their point of view are generally bulls***. Its pretty obviously offensive, and I don’t think one of the best university in the world should be represented by someone prone to saying something so stupid. On an change of topic. Oxford and Cambridge are full of rich kids sniffing drugs up their noises. A lot of people from poorer background sell those posh kids the drugs. Whilst I think it’s too late for most drug dealers and I couldn’t care less what happens to them, if you take away the demand, you take away the supply. If there’s no supply, maybe less young black kids will be enticed into crime, stabbed/arrested/hassled by the police. If BLM stopped all this s*** about taking a knee, saying people’s names, and defunding the police, but instead said, we want rich white people to stop taking coke and tougher penalties for those found in possession of drugs for recreational use, then I might respect them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Slimey Toad
So John Terry considered Anton Ferdinand to be a c***, but as he was black he called him a black c***. What sort of unsophisticated bubble do you live in? Sorry if I'm coming across rude but I won't have my opinion undermined by a throwaway comment like 'succumbing to the insanity'.
If you think that any of this is worth getting worked up about then you have succumbed to the insanity of curtailing opinion and sometimes fact to avoid offending.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
If you think that any of this is worth getting worked up about then you have succumbed to the insanity of curtailing opinion and sometimes fact to avoid offending. So (assuming you are white) calling a white person a b****** is OK but if they are black a black b****** rather than just a b****** is OK. You obviously have never been in a normal workplace or situation. I would rather not get into a mouth frothing silly argument with someone I disagree with on this forum. I would just say you are as opinionated, unable to hear the other side, and as judgemental as your chosen foes. And I hate all this BLM s*** as well!
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
George Floyd was killed by a incompetent policemen for trying to us a fake bill. David Starkey resigned from his position as a unpaid honorary fellow, where you have to do no work, for saying: "Slavery was not genocide otherwise there wouldn't be so many damn blacks in Africa or Britain would there? An awful lot of them survived." Not sure the consequences are the same either. That’s extremely provocative statement and will take quite a long and contrived explanation along with a leap of faith to claim its non-offensive. In my view, most things that need a long explanation to justify their point of view are generally bulls***. Its pretty obviously offensive, and I don’t think one of the best university in the world should be represented by someone prone to saying something so stupid. On an change of topic. Oxford and Cambridge are full of rich kids sniffing drugs up their noises. A lot of people from poorer background sell those posh kids the drugs. Whilst I think it’s too late for most drug dealers and I couldn’t care less what happens to them, if you take away the demand, you take away the supply. If there’s no supply, maybe less young black kids will be enticed into crime, stabbed/arrested/hassled by the police. If BLM stopped all this s*** about taking a knee, saying people’s names, and defunding the police, but instead said, we want rich white people to stop taking coke and tougher penalties for those found in possession of drugs for recreational use, then I might respect them. Both of our statement about Floyd are correct. Whether Starkey was technically right or wrong or offensive to someone should not cause him to lose his job or the ability to get one in future. He might be a tosser but that is another matter.
Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (03 Jul 2020 9.29pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Slimey Toad
So (assuming you are white) calling a white person a b****** is OK but if they are black a black b****** rather than just a b****** is OK. You obviously have never been in a normal workplace or situation. I would rather not get into a mouth frothing silly argument with someone I disagree with on this forum. I would just say you are as opinionated, unable to hear the other side, and as judgemental as your chosen foes. And I hate all this BLM s*** as well! I am not saying that at all, as should be apparent from what I actually wrote. I'm also not trying to argue about what the convention is either.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I am not saying that at all, as should be apparent from what I actually wrote. I'm also not trying to argue about what the convention is either. You did. Insults are insults but we are now supposed to believe that an insult that includes a racial/cultural/religious description is somehow magnitudes worse than one without.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Slimey Toad
You did. Insults are insults but we are now supposed to believe that an insult that includes a racial/cultural/religious description is somehow magnitudes worse than one without. They are. The police investigated at Chelsea when a player (Stirling?) was called a Black c*** but concluded it was all OK since he was actually called a Manc c***. It’s not that long ago that c*** would have been the worst part of that sentence.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Slimey Toad
You did. Insults are insults but we are now supposed to believe that an insult that includes a racial/cultural/religious description is somehow magnitudes worse than one without. That is not what you said. It is there in print. Racial etc descriptions added to insults also include White , Honkey or any other name you care to mention describing a European. Is that reasonable? This is rather a sidetrack argument.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I thought Universities promote professors with racist views? Or is that if they are only the right views. I don't agree with what Starkey says but he should have been allowed to clarify his views to his bosses before they pulled the trapdoor. I agree with this and all you’ve said after. Can’t be &rsed to explain personally. Saying ‘damn blacks’ is pretty damning. Oops. On the nights of the riots he said on Newsnight that ‘white chavs had turned black’, which is really the urban street part of young black Britain so he dodges this if he doesn’t mean that black people are trouble. But he then said David Lammy sounds white, which is inferring something along the lines of black people aren’t well spoken or he’s surprised if one is or something. If he can’t find suitable words or fair opinions then should he be speaking in public as a Cambridge lecturer? Same for that Gopal tw@t.
COYP |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.