You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?
November 22 2026 6.05am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?


Page 124 of 280 < 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 >
Grumbles 02 May 22 8.54pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

The authoritarianism and hatred on the left is just incredible.

Wanting to use the treason act because people disagree with the government policy. This country isn't at war and people are allowed opinions.

Incredible.

Perhaps people should just shut up and give them the manufactured consent their authoritarianism craves.....perhaps they have far more in common with Putin than they realise.

Edited by Stirlingsays (02 May 2022 7.41pm)

God knows who you are talking on the left perhaps it just the norm majority seeing Putinistas for the appease-cick cowards they really are.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 May 22 8.57pm

Originally posted by W12

I am actually proposing we do nothing in Ukraine. Am I a coward?

I remember when cowardice was not fighting for the survival of your own people. Now it’s not putting a certain flag on your social media profile.

We aren’t doing anything in Ukraine but I’m talking about people on social media spreading their superior knowledge and opinion we should turn a blind eye and provide no assistance at all. It’s fairly obvious a lot of these people wouldn’t say this to people with their country and freedom being chucked away. Remember how many Ukrainians have gone back to risk their lives for their country’s independence. More brave than those saying we should do nothing at all in home comfort.

I just think you’re pro Russia for some bizarre reason

 


COYP

BlueJay Flag UK 02 May 22 8.57pm

Originally posted by W12

And maybe more specific about the alleged war crimes. I fear we are just demonising Russians as much as anything.

I actually went to lengths earlier in the thread to do this for one poster and it was pointless, because it all just leads to the next 'no, prove this' , 'it could've been x instead' 'crisis actors' yada yada. I got down to street level, address and footage an an elderly couple getting blown to pieces by a Russian tank and still always another comeback.

Your threshold for any crime said to have been committed by Russians would be so high it's pointless. No mass grave, no torture, no bombardment would mean a hill of beans. If you honestly believe that a widescale invasion of Ukraine by Russia where thousands of civilians are likely dead has solely resulted in 'war crimes' by 'Ukranian neo nazis' then that pretty much says it all I'm afraid. It's war, this stuff happens on both sides, but it's a kick in the teeth for a besieged people to solely blame them for their own torture and death as they are bombed to hell. Countless Ukranians (far from only being in Russian heavy areas) have met this fate.


Edited by BlueJay (02 May 2022 9.01pm)

 

W12 02 May 22 9.03pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

There are actual videos of war crimes being committed in this war. There is a lot of footage. They are there if people want to find the raw realities. Some horrible stuff has been done and video footage of people driving knifes into the eyes of a POW isn't lying or propaganda.

Apparently being curious enough to actually investigate this stuff means that you're putting yourself forward as superior.....for feck's sake....no one is stopping people from actually checking stuff out. I say check it out and come to your own conclusions, what I think is only for me.

Do you think the people commenting on actual war crimes have done anything other than read news reports? I doubt it.

War crimes get carried out by terrible and damaged people and you will find them on all sides of any conflict. I don't doubt that the Russians have carried out war crimes but as there is less footage on their side.....I suspect that's been ordered or maybe it hasn't because it's more of a professional army....I don't know.

I want the situation in Burka investigated and when that report comes out I will be interested. I have questions that I would like to see answered but occam's razor suggests that Russian war crimes happened there.

I remember that the Ukraine said they would investigate the video of Ukrainians shooting Russian POWs in the knees and leaving them to die would be investigated......that was weeks ago and there's nothing.

This seems to be the best breakdown of what happened in Busha because it’s referenced with a timeline and media reports etc. Dates are important here. I’ve not seen evidence off Russian was crimes on an scale (I agree war crimes happen in all large wars on both sides)

Well worth a read in full. [Link]

 

Stirlingsays Flag 02 May 22 9.03pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

Pretty sure he was just making a broad point about those taking a startlingly heavily Russian centred stance on the issue. Possibly to a wider extent commenting on the 'alt media intelligentsia' types on social media who scoff at 'normies' and mainstream while so unquestionably being spoon fed specific social and political takes that they become a more out there, more pronounced and predictable version of what they themselves criticise. If others don't get a free rise, they don't deserve one either.

I was told to 'f*** off to Ukraine' and fight for them a few pages back by someone for defending Russia. If that's what someone thinks in the moment so be it. The argument of questioning arming Ukrainians I suppose is that it's very easy to throw others to the wolves from the comfort of your own home.

In the past I've often had some time for your views and sometimes you will post on matters which I agree with.

As I've said previously I personally have no special dislike for you even though you think it's fine to talk about my family, which really should be off road.

However, on topics we don't agree on you tend to get personally offended and become very angry. You aren't averse to making up narratives....which no doubt you personally believe....but which are your own reaching assumptions. I think you do this out of personal animosity and dislike.

Ok fine, but I'm tired of this, that's why I don't reply to your obvious criticisms. I've rather converse with those who aren't two posts away from pointlessly calling you a pr1ck.

I think it's just best we don't post at each other because it doesn't go well.

Apparently even past posters I regarded well now think I should be exported. Maybe I'm just getting older but I'm getting rather fed up with this.

Edited by Stirlingsays (02 May 2022 9.05pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 May 22 9.06pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

There are actual videos of war crimes being committed in this war. There is a lot of footage. They are there if people want to find the raw realities. Some horrible stuff has been done and video footage of people driving knifes into the eyes of a POW isn't lying or propaganda.

Apparently being curious enough to actually investigate this stuff means that you're putting yourself forward as superior.....for feck's sake....no one is stopping people from actually checking stuff out. I say check it out and come to your own conclusions, what I think is only for me.

Do you think the people commenting on actual war crimes have done anything other than read news reports? I doubt it.

War crimes get carried out by terrible and damaged people and you will find them on all sides of any conflict. I don't doubt that the Russians have carried out war crimes but as there is less footage on their side.....I suspect that's been ordered or maybe it hasn't because it's more of a professional army....I don't know.

I want the situation in Burka investigated and when that report comes out I will be interested. I have questions that I would like to see answered but occam's razor suggests that Russian war crimes happened there.

I remember that the Ukraine said they would investigate the video of Ukrainians shooting Russian POWs in the knees and leaving them to die would be investigated......that was weeks ago and there's nothing.

I don’t doubt any of that. It’s war. It’s horrible and causes people to carry out evil acts. Russia is the invader. Sure we can understand why they’ve invaded, for the purposes of negotiations, but an invader is an invader, and they aren’t just after the Russian identity part of Ukraine. It’s the people who’ve said we shouldn’t have done anything that make me just want to not listen to their opinions again. I know that’s not what you’ve said and I haven’t replied to your posts either. I agree there’s going to have to be some peace talks or this won’t ever end, but I don’t like the idea of a Europe where we just leave countries to be taken over at will. We haven’t and I believe we’ve done the right thing morally and strategically beneficial and safer longer term.

 


COYP

W12 02 May 22 9.09pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

I actually went to lengths earlier in the thread to do this for one poster and it was pointless, because it all just leads to the next 'no, prove this' , 'it could've been x instead' 'crisis actors' yada yada. I got down to street level, address and footage an an elderly couple getting blown to pieces by a Russian tank and still always another comeback.

Your threshold for any crime said to have been committed by Russians would be so high it's pointless. No mass grave, no torture, no bombardment would mean a hill of beans. If you honestly believe that a widescale invasion of Ukraine by Russia where thousands of civilians are likely dead has solely resulted in 'war crimes' by 'Ukranian neo nazis' then that pretty much says it all I'm afraid. It's war, this stuff happens on both sides, but it's a kick in the teeth for a besieged people to solely blame them for their own torture and death as they are bombed to hell. Countless Ukranians (far from only being in Russian heavy areas) have met this fate.


Edited by BlueJay (02 May 2022 9.01pm)

Which elements of that could in no way be true?

 

Grumbles 02 May 22 9.15pm

Originally posted by W12

Which elements of that could in no way be true?

circa 80% of the Ukrainian bit.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 May 22 9.17pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

In the past I've often had some time for your views and sometimes you will post on matters which I agree with.

As I've said previously I personally have no special dislike for you even though you think it's fine to talk about my family, which really should be off road.

However, on topics we don't agree on you tend to get personally offended and become very angry. You aren't averse to making up narratives....which no doubt you personally believe....but which are your own reaching assumptions. I think you do this out of personal animosity and dislike.

Ok fine, but I'm tired of this, that's why I don't reply to your obvious criticisms. I've rather converse with those who aren't two posts away from pointlessly calling you a pr1ck.

I think it's just best we don't post at each other because it doesn't go well.

Apparently even past posters I regarded well now think I should be exported. Maybe I'm just getting older but I'm getting rather fed up with this.

Edited by Stirlingsays (02 May 2022 9.05pm)

I edited that because what I meant to say was maybe, instead of their ‘’leave them to suffer a loss of freedom’’ from home comfort safety they should try out Ukraine or Russian rule, or no freedom of experiment Russia. Actually no freedom at all as they’d be in jail for holding a piece of plain paper.

And actually you got angry at me for some reason when I was referring to the typical attention craving idiots on social media. I know you agreed on Ukraine defending itself and to some extent the donations of weapons, but there hasn’t been any progression onto peace talks. With that we aren’t actually that far apart. It’s the people on social media who somehow think being anti whatever and whatever the cost to innocent people and their liberty is fine, and it’s fine as theirs isn’t at risk right now.

 


COYP

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 02 May 22 9.17pm

So much utter nonesense on this thread.
The Russians are the wrong'uns - it is clear and obvious.
The apologists and the outright supporters of them on here should be ashamed of themselves.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 02 May 22 9.19pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I don’t doubt any of that. It’s war. It’s horrible and causes people to carry out evil acts. Russia is the invader. Sure we can understand why they’ve invaded, for the purposes of negotiations, but an invader is an invader, and they aren’t just after the Russian identity part of Ukraine. It’s the people who’ve said we shouldn’t have done anything that make me just want to not listen to their opinions again. I know that’s not what you’ve said and I haven’t replied to your posts either. I agree there’s going to have to be some peace talks or this won’t ever end, but I don’t like the idea of a Europe where we just leave countries to be taken over at will. We haven’t and I believe we’ve done the right thing morally and strategically beneficial and safer longer term.

Well I can respect that view.

Yes, Russia started this, a 'pro Russia' stance isn't really appropriate, when really the 'contrarian' viewpoint should really be a 'pro peace' one.

However, personally I don't think giving a huge number of weapons into the Ukraine is going to end well for us.

My point is that economically this is extremely negative and for the vulnerable people in the world. A quick war where we provided humanitarian aid and sanctioned Russia.....while reinforcing Nato countries was....in my view...the least damaging stance to take.

A cold war, which splits the world, and puts a lot of people back to the economic seventies, is the most damaging.

Similar to my covid position my position is that the consequences of our response are far worse than the war itself......I don't go all in on a bad hand, and I think that's what we had.

That isn't 'pro Russian', I just view it as playing the odds....the least damage to my people.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 May 22 9.19pm

Originally posted by W12

Which elements of that could in no way be true?

Bl00dy hell. There’s no hope here

 


COYP

W12 02 May 22 9.28pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Well I can respect that view.

Yes, Russia started this, a 'pro Russia' stance isn't really appropriate, when really the 'contrarian' viewpoint should really be a 'pro peace' one.

However, personally I don't think giving a huge number of weapons into the Ukraine is going to end well for us.

My point is that economically this is extremely negative and for the vulnerable people in the world. A quick war where we provided humanitarian aid and sanctioned Russia.....while reinforcing Nato countries was....in my view...the least damaging stance to take.

A cold war, which splits the world, and puts a lot of people back to the economic seventies, is the most damaging.

Similar to my covid position my position is that the consequences of our response are far worse than the war itself......I don't go all in on a bad hand, and I think that's what we had.

That isn't 'pro Russian', I just view it as playing the odds....the least damage to my people.

Russian and Ukraine are supplying huge amounts of wheat and grain to Africa. Huge famine is likely and millions will die. Just one consequence of this s*** show.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 May 22 9.30pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Well I can respect that view.

Yes, Russia started this, a 'pro Russia' stance isn't really appropriate, when really the 'contrarian' viewpoint should really be a 'pro peace' one.

However, personally I don't think giving a huge number of weapons into the Ukraine is going to end well for us.

My point is that economically this is extremely negative and for the vulnerable people in the world. A quick war where we provided humanitarian aid and sanctioned Russia.....while reinforcing Nato countries was....in my view...the least damaging stance to take.

A cold war, which splits the world, and puts a lot of people back to the economic seventies, is the most damaging.

Similar to my covid position my position is that the consequences of our response are far worse than the war itself......I don't go all in on a bad hand, and I think that's what we had.

That isn't 'pro Russian', I just view it as playing the odds....the least damage to my people.

Unfortunately there’s many who’ve said they feel Russia had to, or were right to etc etc. plus the we do nothing whatsoever stance. That isn’t pro peace. That’s more pro-me and fvck them. They really are out there. Some may have included the economic hits. Sometimes some things become bigger than economics alone. If we were that European country and the rest of Europe fvcked us off I wonder how their opinion would change. They also include Zellensky’s a tranny and they’re corrupt etc. just which country isn’t now? Us? Yeah right. Oh and the neo nazi excuses.

A quick war as you suggest is another term for quick surrender and easy walkover. Let’s hope there’s some negotiations soon and everyone saves face. I expect there will have to be written agreements seeing as neither sides can trust each other and maybe for good reason.

 


COYP

Stirlingsays Flag 02 May 22 9.30pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I edited that because what I meant to say was maybe, instead of their ‘’leave them to suffer a loss of freedom’’ from home comfort safety they should try out Ukraine or Russian rule, or no freedom of experiment Russia. Actually no freedom at all as they’d be in jail for holding a piece of plain paper.

And actually you got angry at me for some reason when I was referring to the typical attention craving idiots on social media. I know you agreed on Ukraine defending itself and to some extent the donations of weapons, but there hasn’t been any progression onto peace talks. With that we aren’t actually that far apart. It’s the people on social media who somehow think being anti whatever and whatever the cost to innocent people and their liberty is fine, and it’s fine as theirs isn’t at risk right now.

I thought you were calling me a coward. I apologise if I got my wires crossed.

While criticisms of Russia are fine, the Ukraine itself wasn't that much better, however I agree obviously they are the invaded party here.

I think early on I agreed with the the donations of weapons but I now think I was wrong.....I think it's extending the war and causing far more death than would have been the case. I've changed to Orban's position on that....humanitarian aid and appropriate sanctions.....not risking WW3 and implementing worldwide economic disaster.

Essentially I'm not seeing any serious attempts being made for peace and I think that's because the west just wants to prolong an attrition war....otherwise terms would have been reached already and lives saved.

I've always agreed with the right of the Ukrainians to defend themselves but the position now isn't Ukraine v Russia, it's Nato/Ukraine v Russia.....well, that's a bit different.

A lot of conscripts are being forced to give their lives here and I must admit, I'm not comfortable with conscription....I know there has been a demonstration of wives and daughters in the Ukraine recently over this....and considering how the Ukrainians are cracking down on dissent that takes something.

I'll add demonstrations have been attempted in Russia too and I support that as well.

Edited by Stirlingsays (02 May 2022 9.48pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

BlueJay Flag UK 02 May 22 9.43pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

In the past I've often had some time for your views and sometimes you will post on matters which I agree with.

As I've said previously I personally have no special dislike for you even though you think it's fine to talk about my family, which really should be off road.

However, on topics we don't agree on you tend to get personally offended and become very angry. You aren't averse to making up narratives....which no doubt you personally believe....but which are your own reaching assumptions. I think you do this out of personal animosity and dislike.

Ok fine, but I'm tired of this, that's why I don't reply to your obvious criticisms. I've rather converse with those who are two posts away from calling you a pr1ck.

I think it's just best we don't post at each other because it doesn't go well.

Apparently even past posters I regarded well now think I should be exported. Maybe I'm just getting older but I'm getting rather fed up with this.

Edited by Stirlingsays (02 May 2022 9.04pm)

Actually I have only ever objected to the way that you yourself talk about your own family. A rather important distinction. And you're the one constantly bringing that up (just as you've done here).

The only reason I aimed that term at you is that you frequently pull the 'i'll say what I like to you and you can stick it' card with crap conduct that would never occur face to face, and yet when the favour is returned you endlessly whine about it as it's it's entirely terrible and unforgivable. You did act like a pr!ck, so you'll be told that you are one. If people act with decency that's unlikely to happen. Have you considered the number of people you seem to butt heads with might say something about you other than that you're some kind of 'free thinker'?

I'm not sure what the point of this side track is. I was making on topic point about Ukraine and had already basically said I have little more to add because it's pointless. You were clearly angry at others so you look for a continuation here. No thanks. Sure I sometimes take the bait, not a great trait. Where you are right is that it's a waste of time to pick you up on anything because your desire to be taken seriously and to attempt to demean imagined 'political opposites', trumps your ability to listen. But again, I somewhat blame the Internet for that. Plus, it's hard in this format to avoid people because you'd have to mentally blot out much of what is posted. I notice you have the same issue with Wisbech Eagle. In all realistic terms I'm more than happy to join the queue of those making for the exits in terms of giving you time of day and it seems you're in agreement. That is certainly the most appropriate reply, yes.


Edited by BlueJay (02 May 2022 9.45pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 02 May 22 9.46pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

Actually I have only ever objected to the way that you yourself talk about your own family. A rather important distinction. And you're the one constantly bringing that up (just as you've done here).

The only reason I aimed that term at you is that you frequently pull the 'i'll say what I like to you and you can stick it' card with crap conduct that would never occur face to face, and yet when the favour is returned you endlessly whine about it as it's it's entirely terrible and unforgivable. You did act like a pr!ck, so you'll be told that you are one. If people act with decency that's unlikely to happen. Have you considered the number of people you seem to butt heads with might say something about you other than that you're some kind of 'free thinker'?

I'm not sure what the point of this side track is. I was making on topic point about Ukraine and had already basically said I have little more to add because it's pointless. You were clearly angry at others so you look for a continuation here. No thanks. Sure I sometimes take the bait, not a great trait. Where you are right is that it's a waste of time to pick you up on anything because your desire to be taken seriously and to attempt to demean imagined 'political opposites', trumps your ability to listen. But again, I somewhat blame the Internet for that. Plus, it's hard in this format to avoid people because you'd have to mentally blot out much of what is posted. I notice you have the same issue with Wisbech Eagle. In all realistic terms I'm more than happy to join the queue of those making for the exits in terms of giving you time of day and it seems you're in agreement. That is the most appropriate reply.

Edited by BlueJay (02 May 2022 9.45pm)

Thank you.

I think it's for the best.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 May 22 9.48pm

Originally posted by W12

Russian and Ukraine are supplying huge amounts of wheat and grain to Africa. Huge famine is likely and millions will die. Just one consequence of this s*** show.

Not that I think I this is fine in any way because I said this would be a consequence of lockdowns and all that, but unfortunately this kind of fall out is inevitable with war. Churchill had to make such calls and now some use it to brand him a racist. Russia still had to experience a resistance I’m afraid, even with the consequences spreading to others. Taking over neighbours at will is unacceptable, and it’s worth noting again it isn’t just the parts of Ukraine with Russian identity either.

 


COYP

Stirlingsays Flag 02 May 22 9.49pm

Originally posted by W12

Russian and Ukraine are supplying huge amounts of wheat and grain to Africa. Huge famine is likely and millions will die. Just one consequence of this s*** show.

Total disaster.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 02 May 22 9.50pm

I've been out all day enjoying lovely weather in west Cornwall, walking in woods full of bluebells and wild garlic.

Meanwhile, in Ukraine people are seeing their country torn apart, are separated from their loved ones and unsure if they will ever see a bluebell again. All because of an evil despot leading an equally evil regime.

I then read the bickering on here, caused by some who want to blame the west for, in their opinion, creating circumstances which allowed this to happen.

There is a right time for introspection, reflection and lesson learning. That time is when this is all over and the whole can be seen in its context. Now is the time for unity of purpose and not criticism of our, or any western government. Such criticism can give comfort to the enemy, as it will be picked up by them and presented as a confirmation of their stance to their own people.

As it is totally pointless, because it isn't going to change the past, or the way we now respond, why do it? Causing heat without creating any light is a complete waste of energy. We all need to conserve energy.

To further muddy the water by suggesting that to call for restraint is just the action of an "authoritarian left" just makes things worse.

This isn't a left v right disagreement. This is all of us v Putin argument. It's a good v evil battle in its purest sense. One than common sense says there is only one side that decent people can stand on.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Page 124 of 280 < 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?