Quote Stirlingsays at 07 Mar 2015 1.59pm
Quote legaleagle at 07 Mar 2015 1.20pm
One person's perceived obfuscation might be another person's perception of a populist headline message acting as obfuscation for a wider underlying reality
Interesting question for you Stirling...
The SWP are every bit as anti-EU as UKIP. But,you indicate you wouldn't take your "I don't care about anything but the EU policy" logic as far as voting for them if they ever had a bigger profile than UKIP I presume, since you indicate you draw the line at voting for "leftists".
But,if the "right wing" aspect of things beyond opposition to the EU does come into it for you (as it seems it does), that would include policies/a stance beyond simple attitude to the EU.
Let me pose you a hypothetical question to take your stated stance further. Suppose the BNP (clearly a part of the right more than of the left) ever got a high public profile and in the meantime UKIP had imploded, would you vote for them because they are fervently anti-EU and not of the left and you logically wouldn't give a (to use your word) "feck" about any of their other policies/stances/members/politicians?
I respect the anti EU position of some of the hard left.....though I'm not hard left and I suspect that the SWP don't have a problem with the levels of immigration we have....I'd have to check that out....Still, if they were the only anti EU show in town I would consider voting for them.
If I were going to support the BNP then I could have done that before UKIP emerged as a force. I don't believe in politics based upon a person's skin pigment.
I'd probably go back to the anti EU wing of the Tory party or....I'd protest vote with the hard left.
You even asking me that question comes across to me as more evidence of cynicism....Fishing for a racial element. I don't disguise my politics. I'm culturally biased, not racially.....I'm a mild ethnocentric..with the modification that I prefer the culture I'm used to rather than thinking it's necessarily superior to others......Unlike some of the left I can spot the difference between ethnocentrism and racism.
Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Mar 2015 2.03pm)
Utter nonsense.You deflect from a legitimate question about the logic of something you yourself posted by inferring a suggestion I was fishing for a (as you term it) "racial element" in your party choice.That says more about your internal processing than it does about the question posed.
I am simply exploring the logic of your interesting line that you don't care at all about UKIP's policies etc when deciding who to vote for, other than that they are strongly anti-EU and in essence of the "right",so long as they are in a prime position in terms of being an anti-EU party. If that's your stance,fair enough.But,its perfectly legitimate to follow it through to what might happen if UKIP died a death and you carried your present stance forward in a consistent way.
Unlike you,I take an interest in the breadth of a party's policies when considering which to vote for,if any.The interesting and revealing bits about a party can be in the policy small print,and also in the actions of its politicians (often their unguarded moments and policy flips reveal much about a party)and anything disturbing to me about elements of its membership,taking all these into account to some degree.As opposed to, in your stated case, not giving a "feck" about such things provided you feel strongly in sympathy with the party's main flagship policy and the party is of the "right".
ps.I am glad to see you are taking a keen interest in the differences between race and ethnicity
Edited by legaleagle (07 Mar 2015 5.48pm)