This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Johnny Eagles at 04 Dec 2014 10.50pm
Quote sanitycheck at 04 Dec 2014 8.49pm
Quote TUX at 04 Dec 2014 8.18pm
Quote Johnny Eagles at 04 Dec 2014 4.36pm
Quote sanitycheck at 04 Dec 2014 4.13pm
Ha ha ha! Now who's judging people on the personal and not on the substance of their views!? The views of Cameron *as a person* are only of value if they have proper substance. The views of Cameron as *prime minister* are frankly more relevant than those of some bbc three celebrity. He is leader of a governing party which received over 10 million votes at the last election. Which is my entire point about Russell Brand. Either you have a legitimate platform for your political views - eg, several million votes for the organisation you lead. Or you have a particularly insightful, scholarly or intellectually substantial take on the world (eg, Thomas Piketty). Brand has neither.
Jeez, I just realised that I'm talking to a chap who believes 'Call me Dave' and his several million votes automatically means that he is worth listening to. What next, he has 'insight and a substantial intellect'?
This guy just loves his binary way of looking at the world "You're either this, or you're that". Ermm no, it's a bit more complex than that mate.
This makes me think you're really rather dim. Let me try and explain the point again using simple language. Cameron is leader of the Tories. You might disagree with him. You might not vote for his party. But 10 million people did vote for them. In a democracy that means the political arguments he makes matter because he REPRESENTS the views of lots of people. That is how parliamentary democracy works. The same goes for the leaders of other parties, for trade unions, for employers associations and so on. Please explain to me what platform Russell Brand has. Who does he represent? His Twitter followers?
In an ideal world. In reality, pressure groups and large corporate interests have far more influence over government than the desires of individual voters, which has kind of brought us to this situation where people are identifying with such 'political heavy weights' as Farange and Brand. Largely down to their media 'credentials', neither really represents an opposition or alternative, only a situation where its 'interesting' to the media to provide coverage. There are much better people for the media to talk to about 'alternatives to capitalism' that Russell Brand kind dumbs down. But then people like that might get taken seriously.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Johnny Eagles at 05 Dec 2014 10.21am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 05 Dec 2014 9.32am
In an ideal world. In reality, pressure groups and large corporate interests have far more influence over government than the desires of individual voters, which has kind of brought us to this situation where people are identifying with such 'political heavy weights' as Farange and Brand. Largely down to their media 'credentials', neither really represents an opposition or alternative, only a situation where its 'interesting' to the media to provide coverage. There are much better people for the media to talk to about 'alternatives to capitalism' that Russell Brand kind dumbs down. But then people like that might get taken seriously. But I'm not talking about influence over government. I'm talking about influence over public opinion. For which the biggest single factor is coverage in the media. Pressure groups deserve media coverage depending, I would say, on the two criteria I mentioned. In the words of The Jam 'The Public gets what the Public Wants' but then arguably Russell Brand is himself popular and has an impact on public opinion - Whilst I'm not really interested in hearing watered down Kropotkin and Orwell, he is at least using his celebrity status to do something more than sell carbonated beverages or hawk crisps. In an age where apathy defines political habits, having celebrities who actually engage, however annoyingly, in political discourse is a decent change. After all, what is politics really but a celebrity popularity contest (I know some people engage deeply in political beliefs and discourse, but most people its about the sound bytes and how they feel about the candidate or leader).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Brand has 8.6 million twitter followers!!?
...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread... |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.