You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 9 dead in USA Church Shooting.
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

9 dead in USA Church Shooting.


Page 13 of 14 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Jun 15 9.48am

Quote Stuk at 22 Jun 2015 6.26pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Jun 2015 5.14pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 4.35pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Jun 2015 4.22pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 3.09pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 3.06pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 2.55pm

How many innocent people were executed in the last ten years of the death penalty? If less then 35, then I would say we would be ahead of the game in having a death penalty.

Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 2.56pm)

I would say that if a single innocent person was executed, ever, then you have all the reason you need for not having the death penalty.


Not too bothered about the 35+ people killed by the released murderers then?

The option isn't simply kill them or release them. There's the third option of not letting them out, to kill again.


I think you have to have some capacity by which 'society forgives and freedom' can be earned, even allowing for very serious crimes. Only those who have given a whole life tariff should arguably face the inevitability of death behind bars.

If someone goes on a rampage with either a gun, machete or any other weapon that should be a starting point for a whole life tariff regardless of how many people they killed or injured.

I'd put those who plant bombs in the same bracket too, regardless of their "cause".

[Link]

Another prime example.

Depends, on whether he is mentally ill or not. If he is, then it is more complicated, because if he responds well to treatment, then it becomes increasingly difficult to retain someone under full secure psychiatric care (although its rare for someone to be released fully into the community, its not unheard of either).

I remember this case, because at the time everyone was saying it was an Islamic attack.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 23 Jun 15 1.22pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jun 2015 9.48am

Quote Stuk at 22 Jun 2015 6.26pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Jun 2015 5.14pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jun 2015 4.35pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Jun 2015 4.22pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 3.09pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 22 Jun 2015 3.06pm

Quote derben at 22 Jun 2015 2.55pm

How many innocent people were executed in the last ten years of the death penalty? If less then 35, then I would say we would be ahead of the game in having a death penalty.

Edited by derben (22 Jun 2015 2.56pm)

I would say that if a single innocent person was executed, ever, then you have all the reason you need for not having the death penalty.


Not too bothered about the 35+ people killed by the released murderers then?

The option isn't simply kill them or release them. There's the third option of not letting them out, to kill again.


I think you have to have some capacity by which 'society forgives and freedom' can be earned, even allowing for very serious crimes. Only those who have given a whole life tariff should arguably face the inevitability of death behind bars.

If someone goes on a rampage with either a gun, machete or any other weapon that should be a starting point for a whole life tariff regardless of how many people they killed or injured.

I'd put those who plant bombs in the same bracket too, regardless of their "cause".

[Link]

Another prime example.

Depends, on whether he is mentally ill or not. If he is, then it is more complicated, because if he responds well to treatment, then it becomes increasingly difficult to retain someone under full secure psychiatric care (although its rare for someone to be released fully into the community, its not unheard of either).

I remember this case, because at the time everyone was saying it was an Islamic attack.



He is and unbelievably he's been found not guilty.

I don't care if he's mental or not, but he's definitely guilty of killing someone in a very gruesome way. He should still get life, as anyone capable of that is never not going to be a danger to society.

 


Optimistic as ever

sydtheeagle Flag England 23 Jun 15 2.11pm

Quote Stuk at 23 Jun 2015 1.22pm

He is and unbelievably he's been found not guilty.

I don't care if he's mental or not, but he's definitely guilty of killing someone in a very gruesome way. He should still get life, as anyone capable of that is never not going to be a danger to society.

On an emotional level I agree. But it's still a decision best left to the experts.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Jun 15 2.19pm

Quote Stuk at 23 Jun 2015 1.22pm

He is and unbelievably he's been found not guilty.

I don't care if he's mental or not, but he's definitely guilty of killing someone in a very gruesome way. He should still get life, as anyone capable of that is never not going to be a danger to society.

Legally he's incapable of being guilty.

Not guilty by way of insanity, which means he is held indefinite treatment. By way of UK law, he lacked capacity for his actions, and as such is not guilty under the definition of mens and actus rae, which establish the definition of his crimes.

The only way he can be released is by demonstration of successful psychiatric treatment (typically then released on a gradual basis into society). Its rare, though not unheard of, for patients to be fully integrated back into a community after successful intervention, most usually end up somewhere in between like sheltered accommodation etc.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 23 Jun 15 4.06pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jun 2015 2.11pm

Quote Stuk at 23 Jun 2015 1.22pm

He is and unbelievably he's been found not guilty.

I don't care if he's mental or not, but he's definitely guilty of killing someone in a very gruesome way. He should still get life, as anyone capable of that is never not going to be a danger to society.

On an emotional level I agree. But it's still a decision best left to the experts.

It's simply not worth the risk. It's never the experts that suffer the consequences, it's another member of Joe Public.

The experts also have a very, very dubious track record, particularly in this part of the country it would seem.

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

 


Optimistic as ever

Stuk Flag Top half 23 Jun 15 4.07pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jun 2015 2.19pm

Quote Stuk at 23 Jun 2015 1.22pm

He is and unbelievably he's been found not guilty.

I don't care if he's mental or not, but he's definitely guilty of killing someone in a very gruesome way. He should still get life, as anyone capable of that is never not going to be a danger to society.

Legally he's incapable of being guilty.

Not guilty by way of insanity, which means he is held indefinite treatment. By way of UK law, he lacked capacity for his actions, and as such is not guilty under the definition of mens and actus rae, which establish the definition of his crimes.

The only way he can be released is by demonstration of successful psychiatric treatment (typically then released on a gradual basis into society). Its rare, though not unheard of, for patients to be fully integrated back into a community after successful intervention, most usually end up somewhere in between like sheltered accommodation etc.



But the escape option is somewhat easier in a hospital than in a prison.

 


Optimistic as ever

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Jun 15 4.32pm

Quote Stuk at 23 Jun 2015 4.07pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jun 2015 2.19pm

Quote Stuk at 23 Jun 2015 1.22pm

He is and unbelievably he's been found not guilty.

I don't care if he's mental or not, but he's definitely guilty of killing someone in a very gruesome way. He should still get life, as anyone capable of that is never not going to be a danger to society.

Legally he's incapable of being guilty.

Not guilty by way of insanity, which means he is held indefinite treatment. By way of UK law, he lacked capacity for his actions, and as such is not guilty under the definition of mens and actus rae, which establish the definition of his crimes.

The only way he can be released is by demonstration of successful psychiatric treatment (typically then released on a gradual basis into society). Its rare, though not unheard of, for patients to be fully integrated back into a community after successful intervention, most usually end up somewhere in between like sheltered accommodation etc.



But the escape option is somewhat easier in a hospital than in a prison.

He'll be in one of the secure units. They've never had an escape from a secure unit, which arguably tops most prisons.

Springfield excepted.


Edited by jamiemartin721 (23 Jun 2015 4.41pm)

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Jun 15 4.40pm

Quote Stuk at 23 Jun 2015 4.06pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jun 2015 2.11pm

Quote Stuk at 23 Jun 2015 1.22pm

He is and unbelievably he's been found not guilty.

I don't care if he's mental or not, but he's definitely guilty of killing someone in a very gruesome way. He should still get life, as anyone capable of that is never not going to be a danger to society.

On an emotional level I agree. But it's still a decision best left to the experts.

It's simply not worth the risk. It's never the experts that suffer the consequences, it's another member of Joe Public.

The experts also have a very, very dubious track record, particularly in this part of the country it would seem.

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

In none of those cases were people who'd be sectioned for murder actually involved in murders on release. Although in fairness Springfield psychiatric hospital sounds utter turd. Also of course sometimes you have no choice but to release people (absurdly even if they don't want to leave)

That said, caution is necessary, and I think that whilst some people who respond really well to treatment can be released into the community, that should be the exception rather than the rule, and even then it should be regulated with support and monitoring by community mental health workers.

My worry is that people tend to be released more for 'economic' rather than medical reasons.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 23 Jun 15 4.49pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jun 2015 4.40pm

Quote Stuk at 23 Jun 2015 4.06pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jun 2015 2.11pm

Quote Stuk at 23 Jun 2015 1.22pm

He is and unbelievably he's been found not guilty.

I don't care if he's mental or not, but he's definitely guilty of killing someone in a very gruesome way. He should still get life, as anyone capable of that is never not going to be a danger to society.

On an emotional level I agree. But it's still a decision best left to the experts.

It's simply not worth the risk. It's never the experts that suffer the consequences, it's another member of Joe Public.

The experts also have a very, very dubious track record, particularly in this part of the country it would seem.

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

In none of those cases were people who'd be sectioned for murder actually involved in murders on release. Although in fairness Springfield psychiatric hospital sounds utter turd. Also of course sometimes you have no choice but to release people (absurdly even if they don't want to leave)

That said, caution is necessary, and I think that whilst some people who respond really well to treatment can be released into the community, that should be the exception rather than the rule, and even then it should be regulated with support and monitoring by community mental health workers.

My worry is that people tend to be released more for 'economic' rather than medical reasons.


You can't be sectioned for murder as this case has proved. You can be sectioned, but not sectioned and guilty of murder.

As I said, to me it's not worth the risk. Or the potential cost savings.

 


Optimistic as ever

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 24 Jun 15 9.10am

I've said it before on similar emotive topics where an individual has committed an atrocity, and my view remains that if you decide to act in an inhuman way, you do not deserve to be treated as one.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 24 Jun 15 9.36am

Quote dannyh at 24 Jun 2015 9.10am

I've said it before on similar emotive topics where an individual has committed an atrocity, and my view remains that if you decide to act in an inhuman way, you do not deserve to be treated as one.

The key phrase though is decide. If you're say, suffering from paranoid schizophrenia, the capacity responsibility is diminished. In these cases, they don't think those two cats and woman is a demon, they know with certainty, which tends to lead to such dramatic consequences.

Of course, in the instance of the shooter, he appears to have been more or less capable of rationalizing his actions, planning them in advance and his escape afterwards, which suggests to me, on surface reading, a person capable of responsibility. He might be somewhat disturbed, have some history of mental illness or personality disorder, but his actions lack the 'spontaneity and irrationality' of a 'diseased' mind.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 24 Jun 15 9.37am

Quote Stuk at 23 Jun 2015 4.49pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jun 2015 4.40pm

Quote Stuk at 23 Jun 2015 4.06pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jun 2015 2.11pm

Quote Stuk at 23 Jun 2015 1.22pm

He is and unbelievably he's been found not guilty.

I don't care if he's mental or not, but he's definitely guilty of killing someone in a very gruesome way. He should still get life, as anyone capable of that is never not going to be a danger to society.

On an emotional level I agree. But it's still a decision best left to the experts.

It's simply not worth the risk. It's never the experts that suffer the consequences, it's another member of Joe Public.

The experts also have a very, very dubious track record, particularly in this part of the country it would seem.

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

In none of those cases were people who'd be sectioned for murder actually involved in murders on release. Although in fairness Springfield psychiatric hospital sounds utter turd. Also of course sometimes you have no choice but to release people (absurdly even if they don't want to leave)

That said, caution is necessary, and I think that whilst some people who respond really well to treatment can be released into the community, that should be the exception rather than the rule, and even then it should be regulated with support and monitoring by community mental health workers.

My worry is that people tend to be released more for 'economic' rather than medical reasons.


You can't be sectioned for murder as this case has proved. You can be sectioned, but not sectioned and guilty of murder.

As I said, to me it's not worth the risk. Or the potential cost savings.

Notably paranoid schizophrenics fall into a higher risk category, I'd definitely be wary of releasing someone with paranoid schizophrenia who had killed someone.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

DeSouza Flag In a cave 25 Jun 15 11.30am

Sorry if this has already been covered but if Roof is deemed to have mental health issues or worse, a history of mental health diagnosis where do his parents stand (legally) in supplying him with a handgun for his birthday?

 


*BUMP*

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 25 Jun 15 11.50am

WHAT !?

how dare you suggest his parents might be at fault, don't you know it's the fault of his teachers, the police, the black preacher, society, Obama, Cameron, the Queen, and some dog called Burnard.

Parents responsible for their children ? The very thought .

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Jun 15 12.31pm

I blame the flags

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

DeSouza Flag In a cave 25 Jun 15 12.32pm

Quote dannyh at 25 Jun 2015 11.50am

WHAT !?

how dare you suggest his parents might be at fault, don't you know it's the fault of his teachers, the police, the black preacher, society, Obama, Cameron, the Queen, and some dog called Burnard.

Parents responsible for their children ? The very thought .

As I don't have children myself I feel it is the only logical conclusion I can come to.

 


*BUMP*

TheJudge Flag 25 Jun 15 1.14pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 25 Jun 2015 12.31pm

I blame the flags


Ha. Funny.

I wonder what we are really up against sometimes with race related crimes. Is it a hard wired dislike/mistrust of people who are different? Or a loathing of a particular race/cultural behavior/religion ? Is it just the perception that a certain racial group make your life less safe/pleasant/easy by their very existence ?

My money is on all of the above to some extent.

Is there any way to combat this beyond mutually approved segregation ?

I would propose a greater willingness to live together in the community rather than separately and discouraging religious and cultural behaviour (possibly flags) designed in part to separate people from other groups.

In short, we need to encourage familiarity and homogenize culture nationally. This will not stop people hating each other, since we always seem to find a reason, but it will be a step in the right direction.

 

Old Chap Flag Orpington 25 Jun 15 1.47pm

Was sent this - not sure if the numbers are accurate but ........

IMG_1284.JPG Attachment: IMG_1284.JPG (61.66Kb)

 


Trivial fact - Palace used to win 5-1 at least once a season, maybe next season?

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Jun 15 2.31pm

Quote TheJudge at 25 Jun 2015 1.14pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 25 Jun 2015 12.31pm

I blame the flags


Ha. Funny.

I wonder what we are really up against sometimes with race related crimes. Is it a hard wired dislike/mistrust of people who are different? Or a loathing of a particular race/cultural behavior/religion ? Is it just the perception that a certain racial group make your life less safe/pleasant/easy by their very existence ?

My money is on all of the above to some extent.

Is there any way to combat this beyond mutually approved segregation ?

I would propose a greater willingness to live together in the community rather than separately and discouraging religious and cultural behaviour (possibly flags) designed in part to separate people from other groups.

In short, we need to encourage familiarity and homogenize culture nationally. This will not stop people hating each other, since we always seem to find a reason, but it will be a step in the right direction.

My suspicion is that its a learned ignorance from their parents, in which people avert blame from themselves onto others, typically less fortunate than themselves.

Biologically I think it has a basis in how we relate as humans to things, either by seeing them as similar or dissimilar. Racists invariably will see differences between cultures and people as more far more significant than similarities, non-racists likely see similarities as significant.

Social science experimentation demonstrates that you can very quickly exploit this into an increasingly hostile scenario (Blue Eyes, Brown Eyes and the Stanford Prison Experiment), even when the defining characteristics are meaningless, especially where authority to hate another group is given, or permitted by 'respected' individuals.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Jun 15 2.36pm

Quote Old Chap at 25 Jun 2015 1.47pm

Was sent this - not sure if the numbers are accurate but ........

More or less. But there is no link between owning a gun and killing someone with it, and you'd be a liar and a communist to think otherwise....

What worries me more about Americans is the generally casual attitude towards the idea of guns and what constitutes 'responsible gun ownership', and the hysterical shrieking that is US Politics (Gun Control = No Guns is a nonsense, the US needs and has gun controls in law - Sawn off Shotguns are illegal for example, fully automatic weapons have very tight restrictions on ownership, sale and distribution).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 13 of 14 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 9 dead in USA Church Shooting.