This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by matt_himself
If you can't work that out for yourself, then I can understand why you think this is episode is 'not a problem'. I'd like to know what YOU think specifically is anti semetic about her post?
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
I hope its for something not shown, because the rest of the statement isn't anti-Semitic as it occurs in a comparative example to dismiss the reply of the holocaust. Its critical, but is it purely anti-Semitic or just the 'shrill cry of the racial top trump card'. Probably the later. I'd like to see what stemmed the question 'what debit do we owe the Jews' though. That's probably the most concerning. Unless were going to reduce anti-Semitic as being anything critical of actions undertaken by some Jewish people or comparing the Holocaust to something. Its not worthy that the only use of Jews as a generalisation, is the question. Peoples words are oft quoted without even including the rest of the sentence, let alone in what respects. So much is taken out of context.
|
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
I'd like to know what YOU think specifically is anti semetic about her post? It's blaming a body of people for contributing to enabling the slave trade without any academic evidence provided supporting the claims. The tone of language, singling out the term 'the Jews' comes over as showing distain. If someone was to say that 'the Muslims' are responsible for discriminating against women, gays and 'infidels' then you and your sort would claim this tone and use of language is islamophobic and refers to a 'minority' and the 'majority' of Muslims, whereas you and your sort seem comfortable with the use of the term 'the Jews' to broad brush and portray people of Jewish origin of being a singular group and possessing singular views & objectives. What do YOU think?
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02 |
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
Peoples words are oft quoted without even including the rest of the sentence, let alone in what respects. So much is taken out of context.
Resurrect the thread if you want so we can point out that at worst it's a moral issue as with any legal investment such as your pension fund holding Israeli FTSE listed stock.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by matt_himself
It's blaming a body of people for contributing to enabling the slave trade without any academic evidence provided supporting the claims. Upon looking around a bit on the subject - I would like to change my position. As the evidence of the statement, is based on a falsehood. The role played in the slave trade by Jewish citizens was very minimal and it would be unfair to single it out as worth mentioning as other ethnic groups, notably white Christians, were far more significant in the profit and proliferation of the trade. Whilst some Jewish people and financiers were involved in the slave trade, they were not overly represented of the populations they came from. As such, the statement is anti-Semitic, because it falsely associates Jewish people role in the Slave trade, as a means of co-opting the horrors of the Slave trade as an argument against the 'Holocaust' retort. Of course, had there been a significance of Jewish finance and involvement in the slave trade then it wouldn't really have been anti-semetic. A generalisation is acceptable, when its applicable and defensible. Once you dismiss the basis of the generalisation then it becomes about ignorance and the willing acceptance of stereotypes. Sack her.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Upon looking around a bit on the subject - I would like to change my position. As the evidence of the statement, is based on a falsehood. The role played in the slave trade by Jewish citizens was very minimal and it would be unfair to single it out as worth mentioning as other ethnic groups, notably white Christians, were far more significant in the profit and proliferation of the trade. Whilst some Jewish people and financiers were involved in the slave trade, they were not overly represented of the populations they came from. As such, the statement is anti-Semitic, because it falsely associates Jewish people role in the Slave trade, as a means of co-opting the horrors of the Slave trade as an argument against the 'Holocaust' retort. Of course, had there been a significance of Jewish finance and involvement in the slave trade then it wouldn't really have been anti-semetic. A generalisation is acceptable, when its applicable and defensible. Once you dismiss the basis of the generalisation then it becomes about ignorance and the willing acceptance of stereotypes. Sack her. Slavery has been a symptom of humanity for thousands of years. Is pointing the finger at any one group really significant in any context? Didn't white slave traders often buy their slaves from Black African slave traders? Does that mean we should call black people out for causing their own plight? People use others for profit end of story. Slavery still happening in some places and in any case we now have migrant labour to keep the rich man rich instead, the next best thing. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (05 May 2016 3.45pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
Peoples words are oft quoted without even including the rest of the sentence, let alone in what respects. So much is taken out of context.
If a Kipper made some of these comments, would you support them and say they 'were taken out of context'? Your willingness to blame conspiracies and brush this under the carpet is sickening.
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02 |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Upon looking around a bit on the subject - I would like to change my position. As the evidence of the statement, is based on a falsehood. The role played in the slave trade by Jewish citizens was very minimal and it would be unfair to single it out as worth mentioning as other ethnic groups, notably white Christians, were far more significant in the profit and proliferation of the trade. Whilst some Jewish people and financiers were involved in the slave trade, they were not overly represented of the populations they came from. As such, the statement is anti-Semitic, because it falsely associates Jewish people role in the Slave trade, as a means of co-opting the horrors of the Slave trade as an argument against the 'Holocaust' retort. Of course, had there been a significance of Jewish finance and involvement in the slave trade then it wouldn't really have been anti-semetic. A generalisation is acceptable, when its applicable and defensible. Once you dismiss the basis of the generalisation then it becomes about ignorance and the willing acceptance of stereotypes. Sack her. Insurance is based on the slave trade but given that certain classes such as motor insurance are a legal requirement they unfortunately can't be boycotted. Further, a particular German firm insured the concentration camps... Neither of these to my knowledge having any Jewish investors. To be honest, her ignorance combined with that of those defending her is the most infuriating thing. Edited by johnfirewall (05 May 2016 3.59pm)
|
|
|
Not a Labour MP this time but quotes Finkelstein, who is referenced by the left in defence of Naz Shah etc.
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by johnfirewall
Insurance is based on the slave trade but given that certain classes such as motor insurance are a legal requirement they unfortunately can't be boycotted. Further, a particular German firm insured the concentration camps... Neither of these to my knowledge having any Jewish investors. To be honest, her ignorance combined with that of those defending her is the most infuriating thing. Edited by johnfirewall (05 May 2016 3.59pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
There were some Dutch ones as well.
|
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
Does that justify her anti Semitic ranting? No. Please answer my question above. I answered yours.
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02 |
|
| legaleagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
Peoples words are oft quoted without even including the rest of the sentence, let alone in what respects. So much is taken out of context.
Much as it astonishes me to find myself agreeing with Matthew on a topic,I think he has a point on aspects of this Nick. You and I would (rightly) quickly call foul if the same hoary old generalisations and stereotyping were trotted out about say,Muslims,or say people of Asian origin.But,when it comes to Jews it seems at times the sense of outrage or criticism is less in some quarters,and its perfectly acceptable for some to typecast a wider group based on negative actions of a few being singled out ...the issue should be slave financiers and traders per se in this example. The mere fact of her mind focusing on the ethnicity of one group of people involved in a practice unfortunately resonates with the hoary old canards of all Jews being able to readily be stereotyped in a certain negative way. If she was writing about slave trade participants per se without discriminating by seemingly only focusing on the ethnicity of some people,no problem.But what is the reason why she elects to seemingly focus on one particular group out of many involved in slave trading,in terms simply of their ethnicity. Its naff and "unprogressive". The reality is that there was an appalling "African holocaust" arising from the slave trade. Many national groups and ethnicities were involved,including Europeans,Arabs,Jews and even some African "collaborators".So,to focus on a particular ethnic group present (and one at that which was forced because of prejudice in Europe to largely have to earn a living in the "trading" sector,so a presence of some kind in any widespread trading activity at the time is hardly surprising)is dodgy.Ironically, it reminds me in a funny way of some early trade unions in South Africa who called for revolution and equality...but only for the group that suited them...whites,while having no ideological dfficulties with racism..! I understand your frustration about topics like the Panama papers going off the news pages (though I wouldn't rule out the possibility of that leak not being a million miles unconnected to Langley,Virginia) but a dodgy view is a dodgy view whether expressed by someone who's general political stance we agree with or oppose, and however much the prevalence of such views is being exaggerated and twisted.And ,yes, the current focus on anti-semitism within the Labour Party is being taken up by most of the media IMO to be used for Labour bashing purposes and flows from a classic piece of Lynton Crosbyesque political campaigning, ...but that doesn't mean that as a result some people with offensive views aren't rightly being outed as such. Edited by legaleagle (05 May 2016 9.11pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
I mentioned her earlier, so it's not another one! I read her comments on the link, could you explain what you think is anti semetic about them. Aren't you a teacher? Either way, surely you know what a definite article is for. Replace "the Jews" with "the Muslims" and you'd have been all over that. And quite right you would have been too. Edited by NickinOX (05 May 2016 9.07pm)
If you come to a fork in the road, take it. |
|
|
Originally posted by legaleagle
Much as it astonishes me to find myself agreeing with Matthew on a topic,I think he has a point on aspects of this Nick. You and I would (rightly) quickly call foul if the same hoary old generalisations and stereotyping were trotted out about say,Muslims,or say people of Asian origin.But,when it comes to Jews it seems at times the sense of outrage or criticism is less in some quarters,and its perfectly acceptable for some to typecast a wider group based on negative actions of a few being singled out ...the issue should be slave financiers and traders per se in this example. The mere fact of her mind focusing on the ethnicity of one group of people involved in a practice unfortunately resonates with the hoary old canards of all Jews being able to readily be stereotyped in a certain negative way. If she was writing about slave trade participants per se without discriminating by seemingly only focusing on the ethnicity of some people,no problem.But what is the reason why she elects to seemingly focus on one particular group out of many involved in slave trading,in terms simply of their ethnicity. Its naff and "unprogressive". The reality is that there was an appalling "African holocaust" arising from the slave trade. Many national groups and ethnicities were involved,including Europeans,Arabs,Jews and even some African "collaborators".So,to focus on a particular ethnic group present (and one at that which was forced because of prejudice in Europe to largely have to earn a living in the "trading" sector,so a presence of some kind in any widespread trading activity at the time is hardly surprising)is dodgy.Ironically, it reminds me in a funny way of some early trade unions in South Africa who called for revolution and equality...but only for the group that suited them...whites,while having no ideological dfficulties with racism..! I understand your frustration about topics like the Panama papers going off the news pages (though I wouldn't rule out the possibility of that leak not being a million miles unconnected to Langley,Virginia) but a dodgy view is a dodgy view whether expressed by someone who's general political stance we agree with or oppose, and however much the prevalence of such views is being exaggerated and twisted.And ,yes, the current focus on anti-semitism within the Labour Party is being taken up by most of the media IMO to be used for Labour bashing purposes and flows from a classic piece of Lynton Crosbyesque political campaigning, ...but that doesn't mean that as a result some people with offensive views aren't rightly being outed as such. Edited by legaleagle (05 May 2016 9.11pm) I hope agreeing with me doesn't make you feel dirty. I completely agree. The stereotyping of the money fixated Slave enabling Jew is the imaginary she has presented, whether consciously or unconsciously. If someone in politics used similar imagery to portray the Irish as retards who are only able to perform the lowest form of manual labour, this would would be rightly slammed as unacceptable. I don't get how anyone can excuse her language or tone. Edited by matt_himself (05 May 2016 10.59pm)
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02 |
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by matt_himself
I hope agreeing with me doesn't make you feel dirty. I completely agree. The stereotyping of the money fixated Slave enabling Jew is the imaginary she has presented, whether consciously or unconsciously. If someone in politics used similar imagery to portray the Irish as retards who are only able to perform the lowest form of manual labour, this would would be rightly slammed as unacceptable. I don't get how anyone can excuse her language or tone. Edited by matt_himself (05 May 2016 10.59pm) Fair enough. Using the Jews as opposed to some Jews and the connotations therein does render it anti-Semitic. That said, I have it on good authority that the woman does a lot of anti racist work. However the press furore about anti semitism seems to miss some stuff out... [Link] (yes it's whataboutery, but does expose how the press are out for Corbyn) No doubt that it will die down now the elections have happened.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Slavery has been a symptom of humanity for thousands of years. Is pointing the finger at any one group really significant in any context? Didn't white slave traders often buy their slaves from Black African slave traders? Does that mean we should call black people out for causing their own plight? People use others for profit end of story. Slavery still happening in some places and in any case we now have migrant labour to keep the rich man rich instead, the next best thing. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (05 May 2016 3.45pm) Probably true, historically speaking though, the significance of the slave trade from Africa also needs to be seen in a wider context than race. For example, whilst slavery was abhorrent, the treatment of white working classes was particularly pleasant either, and was also a system of cruelty in the name of profit. The tendency to reduce Slavery, and the holocaust, to racial justifications is a simplification that undermines the real horrors of the regimes in question.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
Fair enough. Using the Jews as opposed to some Jews and the connotations therein does render it anti-Semitic. That said, I have it on good authority that the woman does a lot of anti racist work. However the press furore about anti semitism seems to miss some stuff out... [Link] (yes it's whataboutery, but does expose how the press are out for Corbyn) No doubt that it will die down now the elections have happened. Yes, a lot of the left do, but only for the specific groups they support, that's the whole fcuking point of this thread which you seem to be missing after half a dozen pages. Ron Atkinson brought through a lot of black players. Does that preclude him from being racist? His views dictate by all definitions that he is. You've continuously denied any of this is actually racist or even anti-Semitic anyway, so you've invalidated your own point.
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by johnfirewall
Yes, a lot of the left do, but only for the specific groups they support, that's the whole fcuking point of this thread which you seem to be missing after half a dozen pages. Ron Atkinson brought through a lot of black players. Does that preclude him from being racist? His views dictate by all definitions that he is. You've continuously denied any of this is actually racist or even anti-Semitic anyway, so you've invalidated your own point.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.