You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Forest Hill stabbing
November 22 2026 1.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Forest Hill stabbing


Page 13 of 22 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 16 Dec 16 12.48pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

That really is not true. There is a clearly defined organisation that has encouraged attacks by Muslims who's very strength is to radicalise individuals for the benefit of their cause.There are multiple examples of this which has cost hundreds of lives in Europe. You know this full well, and yet you deliberately try blur the truth to imply that there is some sort of an equal islamaphobic organisation,which is drivel.

I think there is a parallel between how IS calls for attacks and how the tabloid media operates, in that they both feed into the language of justified violence (to different degrees), and can have a profound impact on certain, possibly vulnerable, people.

There is definitely a difference between attacks perpetrated by IS and its members, and those 'done in its name' by the 'inspired', typically the first involves multiple, planned and calculated individuals, that are resourced towards a strategic outcome (such as the Paris attacks or the Charlie Hebdo attack), and more 'chaotic' spontaneous attacks such as Bastille Day and the shooting spree in the US.

These latter attacks seem more like the result of 'psychiatric pressure' than real planned conspiracies of terror, and often have a personalised element (typically seen when people engage in spree shootings).

The first, are terrorists attacks, but the latter typically are claimed after the event, more as a matter of convenience. Something like the Paris attacks was orchestrated specifically towards a political goal and backed to succeed by IS affilates, where as the 'Muslim Spree Shootings' in the US, typically is self funded, by people who at best have periphery connection to Islamist groups and no really adherence to their agenda, political aims or objectives.

The media does tend to blur this difference, for convenience, whilst being rather focused when its more of a domestic issue. Especially tabloids who arguably have a large demographic market that crosses into some of those right wing factions.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Dec 16 12.50pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Can we clarify that, to you, if a Muslim commits a crime it's because they are a terrorist. But if a non Muslim commits a similar crime they are a Barking lone wolf

Crime?

What stealing a Bycicle?

As usual you are blurring because you know your argument is twaddle. Repeating it over and over does not make it any less stupid.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Dec 16 1.06pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I think there is a parallel between how IS calls for attacks and how the tabloid media operates, in that they both feed into the language of justified violence (to different degrees), and can have a profound impact on certain, possibly vulnerable, people.

There is definitely a difference between attacks perpetrated by IS and its members, and those 'done in its name' by the 'inspired', typically the first involves multiple, planned and calculated individuals, that are resourced towards a strategic outcome (such as the Paris attacks or the Charlie Hebdo attack), and more 'chaotic' spontaneous attacks such as Bastille Day and the shooting spree in the US.

These latter attacks seem more like the result of 'psychiatric pressure' than real planned conspiracies of terror, and often have a personalised element (typically seen when people engage in spree shootings).

The first, are terrorists attacks, but the latter typically are claimed after the event, more as a matter of convenience. Something like the Paris attacks was orchestrated specifically towards a political goal and backed to succeed by IS affilates, where as the 'Muslim Spree Shootings' in the US, typically is self funded, by people who at best have periphery connection to Islamist groups and no really adherence to their agenda, political aims or objectives.

The media does tend to blur this difference, for convenience, whilst being rather focused when its more of a domestic issue. Especially tabloids who arguably have a large demographic market that crosses into some of those right wing factions.


I'm not sue you can know the causative factor for an attack by an individual as opposed to a potentially organised attack. The latter might or might not be directly orchestrated by a central command but it is very fact that radical influence needs no traditional organisation that makes it so dangerous. When two local men cut the head off a local priest, are they unstable or acting for the perceived cause? How do you decide, and what does it actually matter? The result is the same.
In the end we are now at risk from attacks by radicalised Muslims and that is what the majority concern themselves with. I see no point in indulging in a self loathing session and somehow blame ourselves for the situation and perpetuating the idea of a far right uprising like Gusset or Legal who seem to have a warped sense of the big picture.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 16 Dec 16 1.27pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Crime?

What stealing a Bycicle?

As usual you are blurring because you know your argument is twaddle. Repeating it over and over does not make it any less stupid.

very droll, you know exactly why I meant.

I'll couch the question (you haven't really answered yet) in a different way.

How is shouting 'I want to kill a Muslim' before stabbing someone not connected to Islamaphobia?

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 16 Dec 16 1.34pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

This is a chicken and egg argument which has no validity.
There is no doubt that our global policy over decades might have caused resentment in certain regions but the current era of Islamic radicalism is about Saudi Arabian influence the conflict in Iraq. It has nothing to do with anyone's attitude toward Muslims. That is an apologists argument. Resentment toward Islam is a result of the perceived threat it poses and a dislike of it's attitude toward western values.


Do you not think seeing (often based on no evidence) headlines about Muslims all of the time would have an effect on the muslim population. Bare in mind, a lot of people will just parrot what they read without questioning it, so they then become anti muslim (based on the fact ISIS are c***s- which thy are - and start treating them as second class citizens. This won't help integration will it? In fact wouldn't that make some people turn against the host country.

Imagine if newspapers on the costa's started printing 'Brits are c***s' type headlines. Would the ex pats feel comfortable with this and view their hosts in the same way?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Dec 16 1.40pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

very droll, you know exactly why I meant.

I'll couch the question (you haven't really answered yet) in a different way.

How is shouting 'I want to kill a Muslim' before stabbing someone not connected to Islamaphobia?

I have answered you.
Until the mental health of the culprit is established, the question cannot be reasonably answered.
Your daft habit of asking questions you already know the answers to, reveals your motivations.

BTW, you did not answer my previous question.

Let me ask you what positives you think will come from huge over population and within that eventuality, further division created by the continuing increase in the numbers of foreign nationals and their future children to the existing population?

Don't say there will be a financial one because that is laughable, not to mention unsustainable in the long term.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (16 Dec 2016 1.49pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Dec 16 1.42pm

Originally posted by nickgusset


Do you not think seeing (often based on no evidence) headlines about Muslims all of the time would have an effect on the muslim population. Bare in mind, a lot of people will just parrot what they read without questioning it, so they then become anti muslim (based on the fact ISIS are c***s- which thy are - and start treating them as second class citizens. This won't help integration will it? In fact wouldn't that make some people turn against the host country.

Imagine if newspapers on the costa's started printing 'Brits are c***s' type headlines. Would the ex pats feel comfortable with this and view their hosts in the same way?

More chicken and egg apologist nonsense with a nice dose of exaggeration.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 16 Dec 16 2.46pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I have answered you.
Until the mental health of the culprit is established, the question cannot be reasonably answered.
Your daft habit of asking questions you already know the answers to, reveals your motivations.

BTW, you did not answer my previous question.

Let me ask you what positives you think will come from huge over population and within that eventuality, further division created by the continuing increase in the numbers of foreign nationals and their future children to the existing population?

Don't say there will be a financial one because that is laughable, not to mention unsustainable in the long term.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (16 Dec 2016 1.49pm)

There will be problems for the whole planet with regards to migration with rising sea waters, displacement through war, and some places becoming uninhabitable because of climate changes.

To help against divisions, let's not be so ignorant about people who just want somewhere safe to live and work to pay their way.

Your Enoch Powellesque rants are great examples of catastrophising. Blimey you'd think the papers were using fear of others scaremongering to help keep the divisions and suspicion of others. In no way does it exacerbate the problem.

I thought you lot were happy with Brexit, we're taking our country back type no more foreigners new Dawn we've entered. Why are you still going on about mass overpopulation. If you were Lebanese, you might have a point as their population has gone through the roof.

Where are your figures / forecasts for future uncontrolled immigration (despite UK border patrols being pretty tight) or is your argument based on a hunch formed by completely dismissing one side of the argument because it doesn't fit your worldview.

Edited by nickgusset (16 Dec 2016 2.52pm)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 16 Dec 16 2.49pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

More chicken and egg apologist nonsense with a nice dose of exaggeration.

Great use of abstract nouns rather than unpicking the argument. I'll have a go...

Spouting third reichist superior race guff with no hint of reason.


Easy innit.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Dec 16 3.20pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

There will be problems for the whole planet with regards to migration with rising sea waters, displacement through war, and some places becoming uninhabitable because of climate changes.

To help against divisions, let's not be so ignorant about people who just want somewhere safe to live and work to pay their way.

Your Enoch Powellesque rants are great examples of catastrophising. Blimey you'd think the papers were using fear of others scaremongering to help keep the divisions and suspicion of others. In no way does it exacerbate the problem.

I thought you lot were happy with Brexit, we're taking our country back type no more foreigners new Dawn we've entered. Why are you still going on about mass overpopulation. If you were Lebanese, you might have a point as their population has gone through the roof.

Where are your figures / forecasts for future uncontrolled immigration (despite UK border patrols being pretty tight) or is your argument based on a hunch formed by completely dismissing one side of the argument because it doesn't fit your worldview.

Edited by nickgusset (16 Dec 2016 2.52pm)

You know the issues but you seem blind to the consequences of those issues. The current levels of migration will be tiny compared to the future. We have to have a policy to avoid the potential disaster coming out way. You talk about it like it is only a possibility, but it will happen Britain has finite resources.

And your protestations about ignorance are laughable in the grand scheme. Humans are humans, that doesnt change. When we are pressured by environmental factors, we react instinctively to protect what we have. That will never change. More pressure on resources will only mean more friction. Your desire to see a hippy dippy world of love and hand holding is a fantasy, as it always has been.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Dec 16 3.22pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Great use of abstract nouns rather than unpicking the argument. I'll have a go...

Spouting third reichist superior race guff with no hint of reason.


Easy innit.

I'd invite you to provide an example of this by me anywhere on this site.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 16 Dec 16 3.24pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I have answered you.
Until the mental health of the culprit is established, the question cannot be reasonably answered.
Your daft habit of asking questions you already know the answers to, reveals your motivations.

BTW, you did not answer my previous question.

Let me ask you what positives you think will come from huge over population and within that eventuality, further division created by the continuing increase in the numbers of foreign nationals and their future children to the existing population?

Don't say there will be a financial one because that is laughable, not to mention unsustainable in the long term.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (16 Dec 2016 1.49pm)


Being mentally ill doesn't exclude you from being influenced by media. If anything it probably makes you more susceptible to influence. Whilst people who end up going mental and stabbing someone may be mentally unstable and irrational, that isn't to say that they are devoid of reason, its just that their reasoning may not make sense objectively.

Even when you look a spree shooters, you tend to find that there are patterns to who they shoot, and people they choose not to shoot. The mentally ill are capable of reasoning, its just distorted significantly from how normal reasoning works.

If someone went out and stabbed people they thought were Muslims, you could probably expect to find some kind of association to anti-muslim extremism or an unhealthy obsession with issues around the media and Islam.

Like that guy who thought killing someone was on the orders of the Queen of the Damned. Turns out he did have a very unhealthy fixation with that crap movie, watching it hundreds of times.

He was always likely to become a threat, its just the illness tends to focus around a kind of fetish. A lot of terrorists are probably the same if they're not part of a group.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Dec 16 3.39pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721


Being mentally ill doesn't exclude you from being influenced by media. If anything it probably makes you more susceptible to influence. Whilst people who end up going mental and stabbing someone may be mentally unstable and irrational, that isn't to say that they are devoid of reason, its just that their reasoning may not make sense objectively.

Even when you look a spree shooters, you tend to find that there are patterns to who they shoot, and people they choose not to shoot. The mentally ill are capable of reasoning, its just distorted significantly from how normal reasoning works.

If someone went out and stabbed people they thought were Muslims, you could probably expect to find some kind of association to anti-muslim extremism or an unhealthy obsession with issues around the media and Islam.

Like that guy who thought killing someone was on the orders of the Queen of the Damned. Turns out he did have a very unhealthy fixation with that crap movie, watching it hundreds of times.

He was always likely to become a threat, its just the illness tends to focus around a kind of fetish. A lot of terrorists are probably the same if they're not part of a group.

The difference being that the intention of films, news stories etc is to make money, where as there is a clear link between Muslim extremist propaganda and terrorism. At worst one could accuse the media of irresponsibility. I believe it is also slightly disingenuous to compare the acts of the genuinely mentally disturbed to those who adopt a cause. Were members of the IRA all mentally disturbed or just some of them, or none of them? Who knows and what difference does it make to the victims?

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (16 Dec 2016 3.41pm)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 16 Dec 16 4.03pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

The difference being that the intention of films, news stories etc is to make money, where as there is a clear link between Muslim extremist propaganda and terrorism. At worst one could accuse the media of irresponsibility. I believe it is also slightly disingenuous to compare the acts of the genuinely mentally disturbed to those who adopt a cause. Were members of the IRA all mentally disturbed or just some of them, or none of them? Who knows and what difference does it make to the victims?

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (16 Dec 2016 3.41pm)

Thats true, and it shouldn't be seen as mitigating those terrible actions. I doubt members of IS or the PIRA were notably mentally ill. Such people don't tend to function well as part of a group. Like that Brevik guy in Norway, he had been involved with any number of far right groups, but also failed to fit in there, as he did in society in general.

But I suspect if you poke around loyalist violence and republican violence, you'll find people who claimed to be acting for the IRA or UVF / in their name, who weren't part of either organisation. Typically anti-social people like psychotics, don't even fit in well with extremists (in fact probably less so, because of the rules they tend to have).

'Lone wolfs' as they say, tend to not fit in anywhere. Like the kid from Exeter (early Muslim Extremist attempted suicide bombing) or the guy who shot up the US gay club. These aren't really 'terrorists' other than by convenience of description. They lack the political agenda, patience, social structure and coherence of being part of something 'greater' than themselves.

They're just likely as not people who's mental health issues have become focused by the bigger issues of the world around them.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 16 Dec 16 4.05pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I'd invite you to provide an example of this by me anywhere on this site.

I've joined the post post truth revolution innit.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 16 Dec 16 4.11pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

The difference being that the intention of films, news stories etc is to make money, where as there is a clear link between Muslim extremist propaganda and terrorism. At worst one could accuse the media of irresponsibility. I believe it is also slightly disingenuous to compare the acts of the genuinely mentally disturbed to those who adopt a cause. Were members of the IRA all mentally disturbed or just some of them, or none of them? Who knows and what difference does it make to the victims?

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (16 Dec 2016 3.41pm)

I think we can say that, but we can also see that in an expanded sense, in that they also tend to promote certain values and ideas. Its interesting how many American Action Movies revolve around a single, lone man, often an ordinary joe, resolving a problem through fairly indiscriminate violence, typically with a firearm (and that this is portrayed as being just and right).

Then we have all those US gun deaths, spree shootings etc, and how the NRA etc and Congress talk in terms of good guys, bad guys and guns. Arguably paralleling those kind of action flicks, where in the good guy with the gun kills the baddies etc...

Society and its art are very entwined, and reflect each other. Groups like IS are unforgivable in the material they produce, and the influence it has. But we also have a nasty tendency to assume that we ourselves are blameless in our own cultural output.

And in terms of terrorism, the numbers killed by terrorist propaganda in the UK probably is easily eclipsed by the passive absorption of 'good harmless action flicks'....

Thats not a defence of terrorism, but about how easily we abdicate our own responsibility for violence within society.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Dec 16 4.22pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Thats true, and it shouldn't be seen as mitigating those terrible actions. I doubt members of IS or the PIRA were notably mentally ill. Such people don't tend to function well as part of a group. Like that Brevik guy in Norway, he had been involved with any number of far right groups, but also failed to fit in there, as he did in society in general.

But I suspect if you poke around loyalist violence and republican violence, you'll find people who claimed to be acting for the IRA or UVF / in their name, who weren't part of either organisation. Typically anti-social people like psychotics, don't even fit in well with extremists (in fact probably less so, because of the rules they tend to have).

'Lone wolfs' as they say, tend to not fit in anywhere. Like the kid from Exeter (early Muslim Extremist attempted suicide bombing) or the guy who shot up the US gay club. These aren't really 'terrorists' other than by convenience of description. They lack the political agenda, patience, social structure and coherence of being part of something 'greater' than themselves.

They're just likely as not people who's mental health issues have become focused by the bigger issues of the world around them.

All you say is logical.
The complexity of the issues are undeniable and drawing a clear distinction between mental illness and abhorrent behaviour is tricky even for professionals.

What I don't like is how the blurred lines on the periphery of the subject are used to apologise for extremism and murder.
Joe Cox was murdered by an apparently sane man with Nazi preoccupations and a grudge, but to most people he would be described as a nut case or oddball. After the event, the clinical definition doesn't really count for much other than for sentencing. Most importantly, he was not encouraged to kill by a well organised and well resourced group who are an enemy of the West and all it stands for. At worst he was encouraged by books about Nazi Germany and a very small group of neo Nazi f***wits.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Dec 16 4.35pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I think we can say that, but we can also see that in an expanded sense, in that they also tend to promote certain values and ideas. Its interesting how many American Action Movies revolve around a single, lone man, often an ordinary joe, resolving a problem through fairly indiscriminate violence, typically with a firearm (and that this is portrayed as being just and right).

Then we have all those US gun deaths, spree shootings etc, and how the NRA etc and Congress talk in terms of good guys, bad guys and guns. Arguably paralleling those kind of action flicks, where in the good guy with the gun kills the baddies etc...

Society and its art are very entwined, and reflect each other. Groups like IS are unforgivable in the material they produce, and the influence it has. But we also have a nasty tendency to assume that we ourselves are blameless in our own cultural output.

And in terms of terrorism, the numbers killed by terrorist propaganda in the UK probably is easily eclipsed by the passive absorption of 'good harmless action flicks'....

Thats not a defence of terrorism, but about how easily we abdicate our own responsibility for violence within society.

Absolutely true, but to compare the effects of exposure to the values portrayed in films and the spread of Islamic extremism is rather facile.

All stimulus effects behaviour and it is the deliberate intent of that stimulus, if any, that is the issue.
Certainly propaganda has been spread through film and news but one could hardly compare Dirty Harry to the motives of a real film of the beheading of a Westerner or a call to murder as many people as possible in a theatre.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Dec 16 4.37pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

I've joined the post post truth revolution innit.

If you mean you are a lying b******, then yes.

 

johnfirewall Flag 16 Dec 16 5.52pm

Do we even know who the bloke was?

Clearly more mental in this untargeted knife rampage than the average Jihadi, who are arguably on par with Thomas Mair in their misguided but planned attacks.

While not squeaky clean, blaming the media and these labels is everything that's wrong with modern politics. I mean which papers do ISIS read? And why not commit an abhorrent act if people will jump to your defense when The Mail paint you as a religious fundamentalist.


Edited by johnfirewall (16 Dec 2016 5.52pm)

 

Page 13 of 22 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Forest Hill stabbing