This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by hedgehog50
Spot on Jamie, I was about to post something similar myself. (Pity your grasp of history slackens when you keep on saying the DUP are as bad as Sin Fein/IRA.) Both sides engaged in the murder of British Citizens, its just the Loyalists weren't killing British Soldiers and bombing English cities. I don't see that as making them any better, just that they saw themselves as being on 'our side'.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Chamberlain tried to avoid a war that we could not win. Without events making America and Russia get involved, we would have been a part of greater Germany. I am suggesting that Labour would do anything to get power regardless of the damage done.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
Hindsight. After WW1, no one had the stomach for another conflict and we did not rearm. If we had become more militaristic after WW1 and squashed Germany, you revisionists would be saying we were aggressive imperialists. I'm still blaming Hitler for WW2 myself.
|
|
| hedgehog50 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
The Obama of the 1930s
We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell] |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Probably not. Neither the US or Russia entered the war until the British Military had achieved successes in Africa. Now the British probably wouldn't have been able to win the war without the US and Russia, but once the Battle of Britain was won, Germany was never going to be able to invade. In all likelihood, if the US hadn't gotten involved, the Soviet Union would have consumed Europe or if the two had maintained peace, most of Europe would have been occupied Germany. By 1941 the fate of the UK is pretty much secured from Invasion. Que? I think you'll find that the Soviets entered the war against the Axis when it found millions of German soldiers pouring over the border. Operation Sea lion was little more than a pipedream once Hitler ordered the bombers to stop attacking RAF airfields.
Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune) |
|
| hedgehog50 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Mr_Gristle
Que? I think you'll find that the Soviets entered the war against the Axis when it found millions of German soldiers pouring over the border. Operation Sea lion was little more than a pipedream once Hitler ordered the bombers to stop attacking RAF airfields. Quite happy to be their pals until Hitler doubled-crossed them though.
We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell] |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Probably not. Neither the US or Russia entered the war until the British Military had achieved successes in Africa. Now the British probably wouldn't have been able to win the war without the US and Russia, but once the Battle of Britain was won, Germany was never going to be able to invade. In all likelihood, if the US hadn't gotten involved, the Soviet Union would have consumed Europe or if the two had maintained peace, most of Europe would have been occupied Germany. By 1941 the fate of the UK is pretty much secured from Invasion. I don't agree. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (05 Jul 2017 6.57pm) Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (05 Jul 2017 6.57pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Hmmm so the Loyalists never bombed NI or murdered Catholics in order to subvert British Politics and democracy. Its a bit like arguing who was better Hitler or Stalin, there's no gain, because neither is acceptable. Protestants had a democratic majority. There was no need for any Loyalist to kill to subvert democracy.
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle
Saw the thread title, skipped straight to the final page to see if she'd signed yet & got a WW2 history lesson. I'm not quite intrigued enough to read the whole thread to unravel the tangent. Basically it's deflecting away from May's s***eness. It evolved from a comment that Corbyn would be friends with Hitler if it got him into power.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I don't agree.
This is becoming a much more interesting thread :-) Hrolf, I tend to agree that if WW2 had remained a one-front war then the UK would have eventually had to negotiate some sort of armistice. Eventually being the operative word. I also think that the Soviets were starting defeat fully in the face in the early autumn of 1941 before the weather bailed them out. The outcome in Europe was decided at Kursk in 1943. From that point, the only "winner" in Europe was going to be the Soviets and the only thing to argue about was "how long". If it wasn't for the Manhattan Project, I reckon you would have seen T-34s rolling through Paris and another evacuation across the Channel.
Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune) |
|
|
Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle
Saw the thread title, skipped straight to the final page to see if she'd signed yet & got a WW2 history lesson. I'm not quite intrigued enough to read the whole thread to unravel the tangent. We're trying to decide if she's better / worse / equivalent to Chamberlain, Stalin or Hitler. We haven't got to Mussolini or Hirohito yet.
Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune) |
|
|
Originally posted by Mr_Gristle
This is becoming a much more interesting thread :-) Hrolf, I tend to agree that if WW2 had remained a one-front war then the UK would have eventually had to negotiate some sort of armistice. Eventually being the operative word. I also think that the Soviets were starting defeat fully in the face in the early autumn of 1941 before the weather bailed them out. The outcome in Europe was decided at Kursk in 1943. From that point, the only "winner" in Europe was going to be the Soviets and the only thing to argue about was "how long". If it wasn't for the Manhattan Project, I reckon you would have seen T-34s rolling through Paris and another evacuation across the Channel.
Possible. Of course it could have gone the other way if Churchill had his way.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mr_Gristle
We're trying to decide if she's better / worse / equivalent to Chamberlain, Stalin or Hitler. We haven't got to Mussolini or Hirohito yet. Thanks for the synopsis mate. I vote for Pol Pot. Floating voter me.
|
|
| pefwin |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by wordup
Sixtus Dominic Boniface Christopher Rees-Mogg for PM Wasn't Sixtus a character in Carry on Cleo?
"Everything is air-droppable at least once." "When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support." |
|
|
Originally posted by Mr_Gristle
This is becoming a much more interesting thread :-) Hrolf, I tend to agree that if WW2 had remained a one-front war then the UK would have eventually had to negotiate some sort of armistice. Eventually being the operative word. I also think that the Soviets were starting defeat fully in the face in the early autumn of 1941 before the weather bailed them out. The outcome in Europe was decided at Kursk in 1943. From that point, the only "winner" in Europe was going to be the Soviets and the only thing to argue about was "how long". If it wasn't for the Manhattan Project, I reckon you would have seen T-34s rolling through Paris and another evacuation across the Channel.
I think you may be right there and Churchill was worried enough to ask his generals for a plan for war against Russia on July 1st 1945, this would meant the German army on our side. The letter was discovered by Michael Portillo at the national archive but there the trail ends. Probably they were all sh****d out by then.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mr_Gristle
This is becoming a much more interesting thread :-) Hrolf, I tend to agree that if WW2 had remained a one-front war then the UK would have eventually had to negotiate some sort of armistice. Eventually being the operative word. I also think that the Soviets were starting defeat fully in the face in the early autumn of 1941 before the weather bailed them out. The outcome in Europe was decided at Kursk in 1943. From that point, the only "winner" in Europe was going to be the Soviets and the only thing to argue about was "how long". If it wasn't for the Manhattan Project, I reckon you would have seen T-34s rolling through Paris and another evacuation across the Channel.
Spot on. The weather delay let the Soviet industrial machinery ramp up its production of war materiel, churning out literally thousands of tanks and planes, as well as removing entire factories and populations away from the western USSR and to safety in the east. As regards your last point- probably right. This was part of the thinking behind 'Operation Unthinkable', a US-UK pre-emptive strike against the Soviets, that would almost certainly have been doomed to failure against the Soviet forces (Allied forces would have been heavily outnumbered both in tanks and men in the West).
|
|
|
Originally posted by leifandersonshair
Spot on. The weather delay let the Soviet industrial machinery ramp up its production of war materiel, churning out literally thousands of tanks and planes, as well as removing entire factories and populations away from the western USSR and to safety in the east. "Tankengrad" in the Urals comes to mind. They still needed two more monumental Hitler strategic howlers in 1942 to stay in the game. (Having the oilfields within his grasp but becoming fixated on Stalin(Volgo)grad and not going full-bore at either Murmansk with Finnish support or Leningrad without them.) A bitter draw was still on the table after Stalingrad, IMO. After Zitadelle.....no chance.
Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune) |
|
|
Originally posted by Mr_Gristle
"Tankengrad" in the Urals comes to mind. They still needed two more monumental Hitler strategic howlers in 1942 to stay in the game. (Having the oilfields within his grasp but becoming fixated on Stalin(Volgo)grad and not going full-bore at either Murmansk with Finnish support or Leningrad without them.) A bitter draw was still on the table after Stalingrad, IMO. After Zitadelle.....no chance. Agreed. Stalingrad was a disaster, and the failure to eliminate the Soviet pockets on the Don meant the Russians had ready made bridgeheads to hit the flanks of the Axis forces. That, plus the refusal to allow the 6th army to try and break out, was probably the most serious error in the south on the Eastern front. The defence of Leningrad showed how difficult it would be to break a static Soviet defence- the Axis forces were sucked into overcommitting at Stalingrad and never really recovered on the Eastern front. The failure to go full tilt for Moscow is more debatable- there for the taking before German forces were diverted, and the delay meant additional armies were raised to defend the capital. Perhaps a fear of repeating Napoleon's mistake and ending with a burned out city, failing to have the desired effect on enemy morale?
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Mr_Gristle
"Tankengrad" in the Urals comes to mind. They still needed two more monumental Hitler strategic howlers in 1942 to stay in the game. (Having the oilfields within his grasp but becoming fixated on Stalin(Volgo)grad and not going full-bore at either Murmansk with Finnish support or Leningrad without them.) A bitter draw was still on the table after Stalingrad, IMO. After Zitadelle.....no chance. By 1942 its all over for Germany, its just a question of when and to who. Whilst the Russian winter was definitely a factor, its important to realise just how over stretched the German supply lines were, and how effective pockets of soviet resistance and partisans were at harrying these lines. Plus the German treatment of the Ukrainians and Russians they overran pretty much encouraged partisans and resistance. Zhukov's defence of Moscow is inspired in its use of both military and civil defence planning. But even if the winter had been mild (by Russian standards) the German advance had ground to halt due to supply problems (food, ammunition, spare parts for transports). Notably the later Autumn on the Eastern Front saw huge rain falls, which the German forces struggled greatly with (being a mechanised assault combined arms - they relied on rapid mobility). But it wasn't just the Winter. The German Army advanced to far, too fast. The faced constant problems securing their supply lines, the mud ground their advance to a halt, and when they hit cities where the soviet army had dug in, they found it difficult to utilise their mechanised infantry effectively. Plus the couldn't maintain the kind of casualties that the Soviets could. Zhukov managed to keep replenishing Soviet Armies at Moscow on an almost miraculous basis. The Germans were never going to beat the Soviets once their Blitzkrieg had broken down, and in the case of the Eastern Front it was too effective, they advanced too quickly, too far to be reequipped.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.