You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Arsenal Match Thread
November 16 2026 8.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Arsenal Match Thread


Page 13 of 15 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >
Happiness Stan Flag Itchycoo Park 28 Dec 17 10.23pm

Thought that was a really frustrating performance. Played so weakly in defence with no aggression or bite. Thought their first two goals were soft, especially the second, which was awful from Benteke. The only time we really got in their faces they were rocked by it, then we went back into standing off. Should have just gone at them from the start and battled them. Benteke was so weak and lacked aggression. Really sick of him now. One goal all season is a joke for such an expensive player. Sako was just garbage when he game on, surprise surprise. Kelly was w*** all night, and at fault for the first goal. Loftus Cheek one of the most overrated players we've had IMHO. Decent in short bursts, but so inconsistent and drifts out of games, wasteful tonight too.

Tomkins played ok, and Zaha was our only threat going fwd. We really are such a one man band it's embarrassing. Luka was ok but gives the ball away too cheaply. Lots of easily intercepted chips and floated balls instead of drilling them...

Sorry to sound overly critical, but that game really got to me, far more than many recent ones TBH. Just thought they were there for the taking, and we weren't up for it. Point(s) dropped IMHO.

 


"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 28 Dec 17 10.24pm

Originally posted by johnno42000

I don't think we were as good as we can be which is disappointing but there were patches of the match where I thought we imposed ourselves and we looked good. We pressed them high and they made mistakes.

Wilshere is nowhere near as good as De Bruyne though and we will get murdered if we give him the amount of room on Sunday that we gave Wilshere tonight. So much of Man City's play comes through him.

My suggestion would be to put the defender with the greatest stamina on a man to man marking job on De Bruyne, basically follow him over the whole pitch and don't give him an inch.

And leave Benteke out for MacArthur....need no free passengers when Pep comes to town!

 

boo909 Flag Figeac 28 Dec 17 10.25pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

The problem is that when we go up against teams with less quality than Arsenal we downgrade our performance accordingly.


I'm not 100% sold on this myself but could it not be that we do better against attacking teams, when they're not worried about losing they tend to come forwards more, the smaller teams are more worried about losing so park the bus more, just a thought.

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 28 Dec 17 10.28pm

Originally posted by johnno42000

I don't think we were as good as we can be which is disappointing but there were patches of the match where I thought we imposed ourselves and we looked good. We pressed them high and they made mistakes.

Wilshere is nowhere near as good as De Bruyne though and we will get murdered if we give him the amount of room on Sunday that we gave Wilshere tonight. So much of Man City's play comes through him.

My suggestion would be to put the defender with the greatest stamina on a man to man marking job on De Bruyne, basically follow him over the whole pitch and don't give him an inch.

Shackling De Bruyne would be useful but you can guarantee that Silva will return from Spain and run us a merry dance like he always does. Need to shackle him as well. Unfortunately they have so much quality they will find the space. Who knows they will come a cropper one game, let's hope it is Sunday.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 28 Dec 17 10.29pm

Originally posted by Happiness Stan

Thought that was a really frustrating performance. Played so weakly in defence with no aggression or bite. Thought their first two goals were soft, especially the second, which was awful from Benteke. The only time we really got in their faces they were rocked by it, then we went back into standing off. Should have just gone at them from the start and battled them. Benteke was so weak and lacked aggression. Really sick of him now. One goal all season is a joke for such an expensive player. Sako was just garbage when he game on, surprise surprise. Kelly was w*** all night, and at fault for the first goal. Loftus Cheek one of the most overrated players we've had IMHO. Decent in short bursts, but so inconsistent and drifts out of games, wasteful tonight too.

Tomkins played ok, and Zaha was our only threat going fwd. We really are such a one man band it's embarrassing. Luka was ok but gives the ball away too cheaply. Lots of easily intercepted chips and floated balls instead of drilling them...

Sorry to sound overly critical, but that game really got to me, far more than many recent ones TBH. Just thought they were there for the taking, and we weren't up for it. Point(s) dropped IMHO.

You missed out the worst player on the pitch....schlupp. had an absolute nightmare

 

askyourself Flag 28 Dec 17 10.30pm

I thought Jules had a good game. One save in particular from Ozil.

 


We move in the direction of our thoughts.
Just think a little.

Happiness Stan Flag Itchycoo Park 28 Dec 17 10.31pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

You missed out the worst player on the pitch....schlupp. had an absolute nightmare

He has no brain. A decent athlete but not got the footballing IQ to make it. Still prefer him to PVA though...

 


"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"

banksy Flag Norwich 28 Dec 17 10.32pm

Someone who was really poor and could have won us the game tonight was L-Cheek. Near the end he first shot into three Arsenal defenders when Wilf was ahead and to his right and available in front of goal and then a few moments later shot selfishly versus passing. Really pissed me off that he has admitted he wants to start scoring, But don't try to do it for the glory at the wrong time. Be a team player Ruben!

 

johnno42000 Flag 28 Dec 17 10.35pm

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

Shackling De Bruyne would be useful but you can guarantee that Silva will return from Spain and run us a merry dance like he always does. Need to shackle him as well. Unfortunately they have so much quality they will find the space. Who knows they will come a cropper one game, let's hope it is Sunday.

I see your point but from what I've seen of them this season it is De Bruyne who instigates a lot of their attacks passing to Silva etc. I know Silva is an excellent player but it seems to be De Bruyne who gives the ball to him a lot. One thing is for certain we can't give either the room we gave Wilshere this evening.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

lefty27 Flag ipswich 28 Dec 17 10.36pm

Originally posted by xomnea

I count 2/3 where if he had bothered to run across his defender he would have had a tap in. But he didn’t, because he stands idle.

The ‘he’s getting no service’ line is the most short sighted used on this site, If hes not moving into the right areas, none of the crosses are going to be ‘quality’.

If he gambles and scores 2/3 tap ins, the service was excellent.

Edited by xomnea (28 Dec 2017 10.18pm)

Edited by xomnea (28 Dec 2017 10.18pm)

Yeh I guess, if he moved across the defenders he’d score 2/3 a game, just like the last prolific premier league Palace striker, I forget his name.... scape goating on this site, always one player, mental. There were plenty of players that made mistakes tonight, support the team, they win and they lose.

 

xomnea Flag 28 Dec 17 10.42pm

Originally posted by lefty27

Yeh I guess, if he moved across the defenders he’d score 2/3 a game, just like the last prolific premier league Palace striker, I forget his name.... scape goating on this site, always one player, mental. There were plenty of players that made mistakes tonight, support the team, they win and they lose.

Not scape goating anyone, thought Tekkers general work ethic and contribution tonight was pretty decent.

Just making the point that you can’t blame a ‘lack of quality service’ if you don’t have a striker that is prepared to gamble into the mixer. He does that, taps in, the ball looks good.

A winger who has to use skill and is running at pace before putting a ball in isn’t always going to drop it onto his head, the fact they’re putting it into a dangerous area (i.e between the defender but far enough away from the keeper) would make it enough of a quality ball if we had a striker who every now and then decided to give everything to get on the end of something.

 

WJK1960 Flag 28 Dec 17 11.09pm

Happiness Stan

Thought that was a really frustrating performance. Played so weakly in defence with no aggression or bite. Thought their first two goals were soft, especially the second, which was awful from Benteke. The only time we really got in their faces they were rocked by it, then we went back into standing off. Should have just gone at them from the start and battled them. Benteke was so weak and lacked aggression. Really sick of him now. One goal all season is a joke for such an expensive player. Sako was just garbage when he game on, surprise surprise. Kelly was w*** all night, and at fault for the first goal. Loftus Cheek one of the most overrated players we've had IMHO. Decent in short bursts, but so inconsistent and drifts out of games, wasteful tonight too. Tomkins played ok, and Zaha was our only threat going fwd. We really are such a one man band it's embarrassing. Luka was ok but gives the ball away too cheaply. Lots of easily intercepted chips and floated balls instead of drilling them...Sorry to sound overly critical, but that game really got to me, far more than many recent ones TBH. Just thought they were there for the taking, and we weren't up for it. Point(s) dropped IMHO.

Think this is rather harsh. It was from Sako's cross that Zaha headed wide, and although he missed a good chance himself, Sako showed good energy when he came on. I can't see how Kelly was directly reponsible for the first goal as the cross came from from the other side of the area. Arsenal a very good side but if our finishing had been better (a familiar refrain) we could have got a draw or even a win. I think we can take positives out of this, but let's rest our best players against City and go again against Southampton.


 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 28 Dec 17 11.19pm

On train home so haven’t seen replays - should Sanchez have been flagged offside for their first & was the second a foul on Kelly?

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 28 Dec 17 11.31pm

Sorry ferret but have to disagree. It certainly was not a foul and Oliver had a decent game I think. Wilf in the first half was making a lot of fuss about "fouls" that weren't

Originally posted by chateauferret

With that ref? A pen for us? Are you joking?

He was so biased it beggared belief. I don't think he gave Wilf a single decision in the whole game.


 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 28 Dec 17 11.50pm

Arsenal were quality at times tonight and we only stayed in the game because of good defending and goalkeeping first half.

Even when we got the equaliser and had a decent spell they looked capable going up a gear and ultimately the difference was them having one of the best players in the world.

Even so with a bit of luck and composure in the last third we could have nicked a draw

No complaints and keep going as we are we'll be ok.

Ref was awful - on incident second half where Wilshere fell over and we were bearing down on goal really stands out.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 29 Dec 17 12.26am

Originally posted by xomnea

I count 2/3 where if he had bothered to run across his defender he would have had a tap in. But he didn’t, because he stands idle.

The ‘he’s getting no service’ line is the most short sighted used on this site, If hes not moving into the right areas, none of the crosses are going to be ‘quality’.

If he gambles and scores 2/3 tap ins, the service was excellent.

Edited by xomnea (28 Dec 2017 10.18pm)

Edited by xomnea (28 Dec 2017 10.18pm)

after the Leicester game MOTD highlighted about four occasions where Benteke was too late with his run - they thought his anticipation would improve as he got fitter after his injury, but he never got free of his markers tonight when we got behind them, which we did several times, and the way Zaha has improved his movement so he can receive the ball in a better position to attack the full back is striking (well done Roy) - Benteke could with improving his movement and anticipation

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 29 Dec 17 12.28am

Originally posted by lefty27

Yeh I guess, if he moved across the defenders he’d score 2/3 a game, just like the last prolific premier league Palace striker, I forget his name.... scape goating on this site, always one player, mental. There were plenty of players that made mistakes tonight, support the team, they win and they lose.

Benteke deserves every bit of criticism, he is not a scape goat but a player who picks up a huge wage and consistently fails to deliver not just with goals but a positive contribution to the team in terms of application, movement and inspiration. I would go as far to say that his performance tonight was shameful.
I am also curious to know what you thought he brought to the team this evening?

 


Bring back Brolin

merganser Flag 29 Dec 17 12.48am

We created plenty of goal scoring situations, but we wasted them. If our front runners had shown more focus, we could have sneaked a win. I thought everyone put in a decent shift, including the unfairly-maligned Schlupp, Tekkers and Kelly. It was a typical Palace performance with abundance of endeavour almost making up for lack of technique. Great to see Andros on the scoresheet with a well-taken goal.

 

Mathers Flag 29 Dec 17 1.01am

Player ratings;

Speroni-6- a couple of decent saves in the first half. Unfortunately age is certainly catching up on him and he simply doesn’t command his box as well as most prem goalies. Although he is our best option right now we need a proper 1st choice in jan.

Kelly-3-at fault for 1st goal with a nothing attempt to block the rebound. Offers nothing going forward and a liability in defence. Calling him a “utility player” doesn’t mask the fact he is turd. Should have been replaced much, much earlier than 80 min.

Tomkins-7- subtlety becoming our best defender. Having a decent run in the team and played well again. Strong header for his goal; if only it was 5 mins earlier we may have pushed on.

Dann-5- another night whereby he looked like he was running in treacle. Has stepped up in recent weeks after losing Sakho but tonight drifted back to the poor performances which led to him being dropped. Needs to wake up before the next game or we will be ruined.

Shlupp-6- done well and tried to push on as much as possible. Comfortably holding down the LB spot at the moment which may signal a move for PVA in Jan.

Milo-5- sloppy in possession and off the pace by his high standards. Happy to put it down as just a poor night and move on.

Cabaye-5- didn’t seem injured but replaced after 50 mins? Only player that doesn’t seem able to play 90...ever! Poor set pieces- as per usual- and generally saw the game pass him by. Can’t see why we would bother offering a new contract at the moment.

Townsend-7- always runs himself into the ground and looks to deliver into the box. Glad he bagged his 1st of the season and hope he can kick on.

Loftus-Cheek- 4- winner of dick of the day. Lazy, weak and wasteful when in decent positions. Could have been a different outcome if he had looked up instead of greedily going alone and was rightfully taken off.

Zaha-8- one of his poorer games and still comfortably our best player. Our only player who looks like creating something magical. If Van Dijk is worth £75mill in this window then Wilf is worth £100mill. Sell him in jan and we are relegated, simple!

Benteke-4- one step forward (goal and performance against Leicester) and 2 steps back with tonight. Balls bouncing off him all night and never looked a threat. Even when we managed to whip in a cross he was never in the right position. If we can find some mugs willing to pay £20 mill then we should snap their hands off.

 

banksy Flag Norwich 29 Dec 17 2.08am

Good analysis Mathers. As I said in a post earlier this evening RLC could have won us the game if he hadn't been so selfish. Where is his superlative England performance of a few weeks ago? Where is it for us, the Eagles?

 

Page 13 of 15 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Arsenal Match Thread