You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window Summing Up
November 16 2026 8.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Transfer Window Summing Up


Page 13 of 18 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >
Dangermouse Flag Hastings 01 Feb 18 12.55pm

I'm in the disappointed with the window brigade, but mainly because we are a Zabaleta challenge on Wilf, Andros, Luka away from a severe dent to our chances.
Palace are like many in this league, just making up the numbers, like it or not, it's a fact. The only chance we have of challenging is if an Abramovich comes in for us. Sadly though because of FFP rules or as they should be called, keep the status quo rules, that is very unlikely.
We have no real chance, bar that one rare season of winning anything. Success to teams like us is staying up and a cup run every 5 years. At the moment like other clubs we have a different manager every season approach, which has so far worked. Now no one on here has a crystal ball and can guarantee that if Pulis was still here we'd be doing any better or if Pardew had stayed we'd be down. If Sam had stayed who knows how we'd be doing?
Now Parish takes a lot of hits for the walk outs, but if it was my club and I wasn't happy with the transfer targets or style of football, I'd definitely do something about it and because everyone on here has big opinions and believe they are right, you all would do the same. Don't argue.
Now because no one has a crystal ball we don't know our buying or wage budget and we sure as hell don't know what happened in any negotiations. The fact we wanted a loan deal for Amadou and we held the keeper over till the Summer suggests maybe we couldn't go any higher, I don't know? Plus selling a place on our bench to a player playing regularly can't be easy. Getting a proven quality starter in this window is also difficult. We seriously lucked out with Luka in my opinion.
So slagging off anyone at the club for all their efforts this month, especially when they are doing the best they can seems very churlish to me. If money was no object I'm sure we'd have got all we wanted, but you can't spend over what you believe is right. One Jordon Mutch scenario is too many, why risk adding to it? Perspective is needed and personally I don't think any of the bottom 10 had great windows.
Saying all that, I really, really wanted a new no.1 keeper.


 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Feb 18 1.07pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

I'm in the disappointed with the window brigade, but mainly because we are a Zabaleta challenge on Wilf, Andros, Luka away from a severe dent to our chances.
Palace are like many in this league, just making up the numbers, like it or not, it's a fact. The only chance we have of challenging is if an Abramovich comes in for us. Sadly though because of FFP rules or as they should be called, keep the status quo rules, that is very unlikely.
We have no real chance, bar that one rare season of winning anything. Success to teams like us is staying up and a cup run every 5 years. At the moment like other clubs we have a different manager every season approach, which has so far worked. Now no one on here has a crystal ball and can guarantee that if Pulis was still here we'd be doing any better or if Pardew had stayed we'd be down. If Sam had stayed who knows how we'd be doing?
Now Parish takes a lot of hits for the walk outs, but if it was my club and I wasn't happy with the transfer targets or style of football, I'd definitely do something about it and because everyone on here has big opinions and believe they are right, you all would do the same. Don't argue.
Now because no one has a crystal ball we don't know our buying or wage budget and we sure as hell don't know what happened in any negotiations. The fact we wanted a loan deal for Amadou and we held the keeper over till the Summer suggests maybe we couldn't go any higher, I don't know? Plus selling a place on our bench to a player playing regularly can't be easy. Getting a proven quality starter in this window is also difficult. We seriously lucked out with Luka in my opinion.
So slagging off anyone at the club for all their efforts this month, especially when they are doing the best they can seems very churlish to me. If money was no object I'm sure we'd have got all we wanted, but you can't spend over what you believe is right. One Jordon Mutch scenario is too many, why risk adding to it? Perspective is needed and personally I don't think any of the bottom 10 had great windows.
Saying all that, I really, really wanted a new no.1 keeper.

Indeed.

Ordure has been heaped on Parish and Freedman without anyone knowing all the facts about the complex,convoluted and protracted discussions and the sheer frustrations these can cause.

Without a doubt the club have worked like trojans to secure targets but as in life you don't always get what you want.The Recruitment team do NOT just burst into life during the 'Window' - a great deal of effort is expended before the 'Window' opens but this is just not recognised or appreciated.Supporters can be critical of course but there are often good reasons why more signings haven't come to fruition.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 01 Feb 18 1.11pm

My summing up - we are going to have to rely on the established players to keep us up and pray we don't get any more injuries

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Feb 18 1.17pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

My summing up - we are going to have to rely on the established players to keep us up and pray we don't get any more injuries

Pretty much what I overheard someone say today.

His view is that we have just bought unknown 'Cover' players who have only played in lesser leagues and at the end of the day might not be good enough in a tense relegation battle in the rarified atmosphere of the PL.Suffice to say he wasn't impressed !

 

Winch Eagle Flag Fleet, Hampshire 01 Feb 18 1.31pm

Okay.... So....

Maybe I should have elaborated (as I have obviously vexed you!!!)

The need to cover certain areas of the pitch vs who we released vs who we brought in...

RLC - 100% great signing as with Riedewald.
Sakho already part of last years squad so secured but not moving forward on numbers.
Tim - Cover or competition for Ward.

Out:

Campbell
Flamini
Ledley
Fryers
Mandanda

Long Term injuries:

Papa
Wickham

So we lost or could not pick 7 (including only having 2 keepers and 1 forward)

Maths aside most would agree we did not have great depth in certain areas.

Ian Holloway... er no.

Please read the WHOLE post... lack of activity in the summer....!

Originally posted by alaneagle1

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

FOUR signings in the Summer.
THREE last January (not counting SAKHO).
THREE now.
Total TEN.
Are you Ian Holloway. ?

 


Winch Eagle

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 01 Feb 18 1.46pm

Maybe one or two of these players will come good. I wouldn't bet on it with our past record though. Only established players seem to have come in and done adequately. Some of them have been pretty poor too. The last 'unknown' I can remember coming good is Ian Wright. Ward has been decent and wasn't much money - that's about it. Seems he is off to wherever Pulis is at the end of the season anyway.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Username Flag Horsham 01 Feb 18 1.52pm

Originally posted by Winch Eagle

Okay.... So....

Maybe I should have elaborated (as I have obviously vexed you!!!)

The need to cover certain areas of the pitch vs who we released vs who we brought in...

RLC - 100% great signing as with Riedewald.
Sakho already part of last years squad so secured but not moving forward on numbers.
Tim - Cover or competition for Ward.

Out:

Campbell
Flamini
Ledley
Fryers
Mandanda

Long Term injuries:

Papa
Wickham

So we lost or could not pick 7 (including only having 2 keepers and 1 forward)

Maths aside most would agree we did not have great depth in certain areas.

Ian Holloway... er no.

Please read the WHOLE post... lack of activity in the summer....!


Of these only one was worth keeping, and he would have been a squad player at best (Campbell).

We wouldn't be in a better situation now with Joe Ledley as our midfield cover.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Painter Flag Croydon 01 Feb 18 2.06pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Maybe one or two of these players will come good. I wouldn't bet on it with our past record though. Only established players seem to have come in and done adequately. Some of them have been pretty poor too. The last 'unknown' I can remember coming good is Ian Wright. Ward has been decent and wasn't much money - that's about it. Seems he is off to wherever Pulis is at the end of the season anyway.

Have you heard of Bolasie and Jedinak, both signed by Freeman, who just happens to be instrumental in our recent signings.

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 01 Feb 18 2.15pm

We are only a keeper away from it being a decent enough window. We might have to pick up someone on a free transfer to tide us over till the end of the season should we get any goalkeeper injuries.

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 01 Feb 18 2.20pm

I think what has happened for us is a bit of reality this window.Obviously I would have liked more players coming in this window and for those coming in to have been better known however we are not able to. Purchasing players like Benteke and Sakho has made us supporters expect that every window. If you ignore the cash rich clubs such as Man city and look at other sides purchases this window many have broken their transfer records and they have not spent the money we spent for Benteke. So we have a transfer record signing similar to Everton and Spurs, Both clubs with much more financial muscle. In retrospect would we have been better getting players in 10-20 million bracket? Certainly we may have had better squad depth. I think we were trying to get 2 strikers over the line yesterday but WH poached one, remember Moyes was once manager there so I am sure that helped. Lille messed us about and I suspect Amadou will come in summer possibly at a lower price. GK on a free in summer so we hope no injuries to WH or JS

 

Norway Eagle Flag Singapore 01 Feb 18 2.23pm

It is a bad window ...as always?.
Let us just hope Roy and the Staff can get us trough the storms coming up!
Once again SP is to slow with transfer business and that guy never learns it seemes.
WE got Benteke and Sakho and those whee expencive deals for a "little club" like ours. so we have to get used to live in limbo land.
Next window is at summer and maybe some of you guy can camp outside his office with posters that we need to get players in NOW rather then later.
When this thing happens at every window,,, something is clearly wrong.But he got the final word though unless someone is holding him by his ears,,,, wonder though?

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 01 Feb 18 2.25pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

My summing up - we are going to have to rely on the established players to keep us up and pray we don't get any more injuries

Agree 100%. The purchases this transfer window certainly have one eye on the future rather than the hear and now.

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 01 Feb 18 2.28pm

3 squad players is a gamble but it is not an outrageous one. Roy has the tactical knowledge and skill to keep us up but he does need a bit of luck with injuries. One or two more in key positions and we'll go down. I hope that if we stay up Roy has been promised some proper signings in the summer.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Maine Eagle Flag USA 01 Feb 18 2.28pm

Originally posted by Willo

Indeed.

Ordure has been heaped on Parish and Freedman without anyone knowing all the facts about the complex,convoluted and protracted discussions and the sheer frustrations these can cause.

Without a doubt the club have worked like trojans to secure targets but as in life you don't always get what you want.The Recruitment team do NOT just burst into life during the 'Window' - a great deal of effort is expended before the 'Window' opens but this is just not recognised or appreciated.Supporters can be critical of course but there are often good reasons why more signings haven't come to fruition.

Its a good shout that we fans do not know what has actually gone on with individual situations and negotiations.

All we can see is who signs and who doesnt, and what the parties publicly state.

I am OK with us missing out on Amadou, as I dont think its a vital signing. Sorloth might come good, he looks like he can play a bit. Jach is one for the future and at 2 mil, who cares if he is a flop. And Rakip may turn out to be good also but isnt fit.

The big issue for me is that our manager made a point of stating many, many times that we needed to get a keeper in. We should have actually addressed this in the last window, which compounds not addressing it in this window.

Signing another goalkeeper was more important than the Jach and Rakip signings. We desperately also needed a striker so that was on a par with the goalie signing, especially with Sako now crocked.

To my first point, I agree with you that we dont know what goes on, but something doesn't smell right with our approach to transfers. It seems to me that Parish has put his pride ahead of getting another keeper in and meeting our manager's (not lofty) expectations.

He can now laugh at Getafe in the summer when we sign the guy for free, but what about between now and then when we really, really urgently and desperately needed to sign another keeper.

It seems that we played chicken with Getafe. We like to play chicken in transfer windows, sometimes it works out like with Sakho. Sometimes it doesn't, like with Niasse.

So we played chicken again on a keeper, and we couldnt get Ronnow over the line in time, once again. Sounds exactly like the last window with trying to sign a striker.

Would be great if we would actually learn our lessons and address the vital signings and actually get them over the line. Yes the selling clubs can move the goalposts, yes January is a tough window, but the people running the club need to find a way to address critical signings, and it is clear that from Hodgson's multiple comments on the topic this month, a goalie was a vital signing. Good chairman and sporting directors find a way to get those areas addressed. Its hard, and the other side is tough to deal with........but they find a way.

Once again we failed to address a vital signing.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

AERO Flag 01 Feb 18 2.36pm

Is a third goalie worth all this fuss .Very unusual for keepers to get injured,and as much as I don’t like Wayne,he isn’t doing too bad and we still have Julian .Think a proven forward was more urgent.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 01 Feb 18 2.37pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Lille did not screw us at all.

The player, Amadou, is valued at 18 millions.

So that's what they wanted.

What would SP's reaction be to a similar loan deal for a Palace star, he would laugh it off, rightly.

But you can't have it both ways SP.


I believe we offered that. We had a binding agreement to make full payment in the summer, with a downpayment via the loans system of £2m so it's reported. I also believe Lille would have been happy to take that had they been more on the ball regarding bringing back a loanee to cover Amadou's position.

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 01 Feb 18 2.41pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

You make a good case apart from the keeper.

We could've sorted that out earlier. No excuses there. It was possible and probably not going to cost much more from abroad or just a loan.

I tend to disagree re the keeper. We did everything reasonable to get Guaita & it was Getafe that put up a wall. Once it had been reported in Spain that we had a deal for him to join us on a free when his contract expires they changed their tune & tried to get a replacement in. They failed to do this (the replacement they found won't be joining until next season) so said a final 'no' to the deal. Hopefully their loss & our gain in the medium term - assuming there is an agreement & he does actually join us.

Plan B was Ronnow & that was simply too late for Brondby to get someone in for which you can lay blame with Parish/Dougie but it is probably fair to say they were operating within a budget & FFP constraints & confident the Amadou situation would've been resolved.

Hindsight's a wonderful thing, let's just hope WH starts performing better with a decent back four in front of him like he has in the past, although that relies on Sakho & Tomkins staying fit for the rest of the season...

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 01 Feb 18 2.42pm

My thoughts keep comming back to Roy’s evaluation of the squad being that he is very happy with his first choice eleven but feels that our backup needs strengthening.
Well on the basis that Roy would have had input into the three signings he will now be a happier man than he was before the window as he has three extra players who he thinks will strengthen the squad.
So there we have it a strengthened squad and 14 games to go which should be enough to get the extra 12 or so points we need.
Be positive boys and girls !
COYP

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 01 Feb 18 2.45pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Its a good shout that we fans do not know what has actually gone on with individual situations and negotiations.

All we can see is who signs and who doesnt, and what the parties publicly state.

I am OK with us missing out on Amadou, as I dont think its a vital signing. Sorloth might come good, he looks like he can play a bit. Jach is one for the future and at 2 mil, who cares if he is a flop. And Rakip may turn out to be good also but isnt fit.

The big issue for me is that our manager made a point of stating many, many times that we needed to get a keeper in. We should have actually addressed this in the last window, which compounds not addressing it in this window.

Signing another goalkeeper was more important than the Jach and Rakip signings. We desperately also needed a striker so that was on a par with the goalie signing, especially with Sako now crocked.

To my first point, I agree with you that we dont know what goes on, but something doesn't smell right with our approach to transfers. It seems to me that Parish has put his pride ahead of getting another keeper in and meeting our manager's (not lofty) expectations.

He can now laugh at Getafe in the summer when we sign the guy for free, but what about between now and then when we really, really urgently and desperately needed to sign another keeper.

It seems that we played chicken with Getafe. We like to play chicken in transfer windows, sometimes it works out like with Sakho. Sometimes it doesn't, like with Niasse.

So we played chicken again on a keeper, and we couldnt get Ronnow over the line in time, once again. Sounds exactly like the last window with trying to sign a striker.

Would be great if we would actually learn our lessons and address the vital signings and actually get them over the line. Yes the selling clubs can move the goalposts, yes January is a tough window, but the people running the club need to find a way to address critical signings, and it is clear that from Hodgson's multiple comments on the topic this month, a goalie was a vital signing. Good chairman and sporting directors find a way to get those areas addressed. Its hard, and the other side is tough to deal with........but they find a way.

Once again we failed to address a vital signing.

This is all fair comment however if this was your own money and someone said you could possibly save £3m or £4m by delaying a transfer 4 months would you do it? I know I would. Yes, we need a keeper, but is that going to be the difference between us staying up and going down this season, I don't think so. Please don't say that sort of money is small beer, because it is not.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 01 Feb 18 2.55pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

He can now laugh at Getafe in the summer when we sign the guy for free, but what about between now and then when we really, really urgently and desperately needed to sign another keeper.

Do we actually have an agreement with him to sign him in the summer when his existing contract has expired as we could end up losing him to someone else when he becomes a free agent

 

Page 13 of 18 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window Summing Up