You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 7.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 13 of 71 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >
bicycle repair man 19 Oct 18 4.37pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

interested to hear what those in the stand think of a no-numbered-seats policy. I'm sure it'd be initially difficult, and fractious, but would soon settle.

With the proposed singing section, there's nothing to say it wouldn't dilute over time. (if it ever gets going). Then what...

...what's needed is constant evolution and dynamism. people trying to congregate in little groups to get things going.

what's not needed --atmosphere wise at least-- is the same old faces sitting for decades in the same old seats.

You'll be a "same old face" one day.

 

kenners46 Flag sydenham village 19 Oct 18 4.42pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig


what's not needed --atmosphere wise at least-- is the same old faces sitting for decades in the same old seats.


Edited by kenners46 (19 Oct 2018 5.41pm)

 

BuckinghamshireEagle Flag 19 Oct 18 5.43pm

Originally posted by SnapperKain

I'm not surprised at the u-turn as ultimately Parish is a marketing man and when marketing the club, the HF give something for the TV cameras to point at.

I wonder if the u-turn was brought about by Sky suggesting to the club that without the HF contributing to the Selhurst atmosphere the cameras would not be there very often going forward. After all, the entertainment on the pitch is hardly scintillating. A reduction in a TV income would be a financial blow to the company.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 19 Oct 18 6.11pm

Originally posted by BuckinghamshireEagle

I wonder if the u-turn was brought about by Sky suggesting to the club that without the HF contributing to the Selhurst atmosphere the cameras would not be there very often going forward. After all, the entertainment on the pitch is hardly scintillating. A reduction in a TV income would be a financial blow to the company.


Without googling(coz i cant be asred) my belief is, that Sky/BT are obliged to screen ALL EPL clubs a minimum of agreed times.


NOW, in saying that & with nicking George Orwell, All EPL clubs are equal, BUT Man Ure are more equal than the rest . . . Summat like that, i think

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

cpj Flag Kent 19 Oct 18 6.33pm

Originally posted by Jamesey

This article is on the whole sympathetic and fair (IMHO) in today's South London Press
Couldn't seem to share so have copied it below.


Crystal Palace News
 
Crystal Palace fans’ anger at ousting from their seats

19th October 2018 Calum Fraser

BY CALUM FRASER
calum@slpmedia.co.uk

Dozens of fans are outraged as football chiefs plan to move them out of season ticket seats that some have held for decades.

Crystal Palace bosses have given the go-ahead to plans to clear a section of Selhurst Park to concentrate a group of fans known as the Holmesdale Fanatics (HF) in a bid to create a “central singing section”.

But this means that scores of season ticket holders, many of whom have held their seats since the Holmesdale Stand was built in 1995, will have to be dispersed around the stadium.

Stephen Kingdom, 48, a Selhurst Park regular since 1984, said: “I think we are all in shock that the club can treat long-term loyal fans in this way, especially when in September they put out a statement explaining why this would be the wrong thing to do.

“The club have clearly been considering this move for a long time, but at no time have they consulted with affected fans.It really feels like – now we’re in the Premier League – we don’t matter to the club anymore.”

The HF were negotiating with the club chiefs over the summer to make room for their singing section. The HF want to be moved from a corner of the stand, block B, to the centre behind the goals, block E.

But the club released a statement on September 2 saying they would not follow through with the plans because they felt “it would be hugely unfair and disruptive”.

Another statement was then released on September 26 reversing this decision. Up to 400 season tickets were pledged to the HF starting next year.
Mr Kingdom, who works in the charity sector, said: “The club’s U-turn makes it feel like this is a panicky decision; and it certainly doesn’t seem thought through.

It’s clear, for example, that the club haven’t thought about the impact on fans whose seats are near the proposed new singing section.”

The fans who will lose their seats will be offered a discounted price on different season tickets. The fans are not happy with this because they will be at the back of the queue for season tickets as other supporters will be given the chance to renew their tickets first.

According to club figures 92 per cent of season ticket holders renew their seat every year.

One aggrieved fan, who has been attending games for almost 40 years, said: “We’ve been through all the highs and lows with the club.

That often means more lows than highs with Palace, but we have always been there.

“Suddenly we’re being thrown out of our seats and told, well you have to scrabble around for what are probably going to be the worst seats in the stadium.”

Mr Kingdom is part of a small group of fans which met part-owner and chairman Steve Parish on Wednesday night.

He said: “I’m pleased that Steve Parish has finally offered to meet some of us. I will, of course, listen to what he has to say.
But it really is at least a year too late. And I and a handful of others can’t represent all 400 affected fans: he really needs to engage with all of us.”

A spokesman for Crystal Palace said: “There is overwhelming support among our fans for the creation of a new, expanded singing section in the central block of the Holmesdale Road stand, creating a wall of sound that we believe will create a unique Premier League atmosphere at Selhurst Park.
“We are working with season ticket holders in Block E, who, regrettably, will have to be relocated next season, to ensure we make this as painless as possible.

“We understand the upheaval this will inevitably cause some season ticket holders, and the chairman will be meeting a group of those affected in the coming weeks to discuss arrangements.”

Their editorial also mentioned it along the lines of 'what price loyalty?'.

 

rednblue4eva Flag Norwood 19 Oct 18 6.36pm

Originally posted by Leecpfc

This ^ and Parish is included. The whole matter is disgusting. What happens if the HF decide next year that they want to move again?

I’m sure when the main stand gets redeveloped (with safe standing?) the HF will demand specific seats

 

rednblue4eva Flag Norwood 19 Oct 18 6.44pm

Originally posted by Jamesey

This article is on the whole sympathetic and fair (IMHO) in today's South London Press
Couldn't seem to share so have copied it below.


Crystal Palace News
 
Crystal Palace fans’ anger at ousting from their seats

19th October 2018 Calum Fraser

BY CALUM FRASER
calum@slpmedia.co.uk

Dozens of fans are outraged as football chiefs plan to move them out of season ticket seats that some have held for decades.

Crystal Palace bosses have given the go-ahead to plans to clear a section of Selhurst Park to concentrate a group of fans known as the Holmesdale Fanatics (HF) in a bid to create a “central singing section”.

But this means that scores of season ticket holders, many of whom have held their seats since the Holmesdale Stand was built in 1995, will have to be dispersed around the stadium.

Stephen Kingdom, 48, a Selhurst Park regular since 1984, said: “I think we are all in shock that the club can treat long-term loyal fans in this way, especially when in September they put out a statement explaining why this would be the wrong thing to do.

“The club have clearly been considering this move for a long time, but at no time have they consulted with affected fans.It really feels like – now we’re in the Premier League – we don’t matter to the club anymore.”

The HF were negotiating with the club chiefs over the summer to make room for their singing section. The HF want to be moved from a corner of the stand, block B, to the centre behind the goals, block E.

But the club released a statement on September 2 saying they would not follow through with the plans because they felt “it would be hugely unfair and disruptive”.

Another statement was then released on September 26 reversing this decision. Up to 400 season tickets were pledged to the HF starting next year.
Mr Kingdom, who works in the charity sector, said: “The club’s U-turn makes it feel like this is a panicky decision; and it certainly doesn’t seem thought through.

It’s clear, for example, that the club haven’t thought about the impact on fans whose seats are near the proposed new singing section.”

The fans who will lose their seats will be offered a discounted price on different season tickets. The fans are not happy with this because they will be at the back of the queue for season tickets as other supporters will be given the chance to renew their tickets first.

According to club figures 92 per cent of season ticket holders renew their seat every year.

One aggrieved fan, who has been attending games for almost 40 years, said: “We’ve been through all the highs and lows with the club.

That often means more lows than highs with Palace, but we have always been there.

“Suddenly we’re being thrown out of our seats and told, well you have to scrabble around for what are probably going to be the worst seats in the stadium.”

Mr Kingdom is part of a small group of fans which met part-owner and chairman Steve Parish on Wednesday night.

He said: “I’m pleased that Steve Parish has finally offered to meet some of us. I will, of course, listen to what he has to say.
But it really is at least a year too late. And I and a handful of others can’t represent all 400 affected fans: he really needs to engage with all of us.”

A spokesman for Crystal Palace said: “There is overwhelming support among our fans for the creation of a new, expanded singing section in the central block of the Holmesdale Road stand, creating a wall of sound that we believe will create a unique Premier League atmosphere at Selhurst Park.
“We are working with season ticket holders in Block E, who, regrettably, will have to be relocated next season, to ensure we make this as painless as possible.

“We understand the upheaval this will inevitably cause some season ticket holders, and the chairman will be meeting a group of those affected in the coming weeks to discuss arrangements.”

How does one block at the back of a stand create “a wall of sound”?

 

rednblue4eva Flag Norwood 19 Oct 18 6.54pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig


what's not needed --atmosphere wise at least-- is the same old faces sitting for decades in the same old seats.

Why?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 19 Oct 18 6.57pm

Originally posted by SnapperKain

I'm not surprised at the u-turn as ultimately Parish is a marketing man and when marketing the club, the HF give something for the TV cameras to point at.

The Crystals give something much better

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 19 Oct 18 7.00pm

Originally posted by rednblue4eva

How does one block at the back of a stand create “a wall of sound”?

By standing up, waving flags, banging, drums & letting off flares/smoke bombs. This then creates a ripple effect across the whole of the LH.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Lal Flag Thornton Heath 19 Oct 18 7.18pm

They not aloud to stand up it's going to be a sit down singing section that's what the club told. me.Then we all know that want happen it be standing non stop for 90 plus minutes just like in blocks A - D.

 

BuckinghamshireEagle Flag 19 Oct 18 7.21pm

Originally posted by eagleman13


Without googling(coz i cant be asred) my belief is, that Sky/BT are obliged to screen ALL EPL clubs a minimum of agreed times.


In round numbers teams get £1.2 million per game televised with a minimum of £12 million even if you are on tv less than 10 times. Last year we had 12 appearances. If we only get 10 or less this year it will cost the club at least £2.5 million, maybe more.

 

Jamesey Flag Wandsworth 19 Oct 18 9.02pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

interested to hear what those in the stand think of a no-numbered-seats policy. I'm sure it'd be initially difficult, and fractious, but would soon settle.

With the proposed singing section, there's nothing to say it wouldn't dilute over time. (if it ever gets going). Then what...

...what's needed is constant evolution and dynamism. people trying to congregate in little groups to get things going.

what's not needed --atmosphere wise at least-- is the same old faces sitting for decades in the same old seats.


The rules of this forum prevent me from saying what I really think about the sheer ignorance and lack of insight of these particular views.

Well, people in little groups to get things going is what Block E supporters have been doing before this poster was presumably born (judging by the immaturity of the post).

As one of the "same old faces" am I forgiven for sitting in different seats in various parts of the ground for several decades? Apologies for not banging a drum or bellowing chants but I'm just a faithful and aged fan - but not an "atic" obviously.

Edited by Jamesey (19 Oct 2018 9.11pm)

 


Nothing is fool-proof - fools are too ingenious

fan Flag Caterham 19 Oct 18 9.04pm

I sit in Block E and am affected by all this. Anyway I need some facts How many seats in total are there in LH?
What percentage of these are held by season ticket holders at present? If 400 are going to be moved at present are there even 400 seats available assuming HF give up their 100? and say 95%% of current holders renew?

And finally what chance of say 4 people [family etc] being able to sit together without having to move to a completely different part of ground?

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 19 Oct 18 9.27pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

You'll be a "same old face" one day.

already am.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 19 Oct 18 9.36pm

Originally posted by rednblue4eva

Why?

because when the same old faces sit in the same old seats for decades, their human nature -- which generally tends to be polite, inhibited, and not inclined to shouting -- slowly comes to the fore. And once they've gone a few games not singing, it just gets harder and harder to get them (I actually count myself) going. mix it up a bit amd maybe things would be more lively.

All seater stadia and perpetual seat renewals are killing the atmosphere in English football. If that doesn't reverse, one day it'll kill the game too.

Also, just to be clear, I'm no great fan of the HF. many many t***s among them. but I do like a great atmosphere. sp has also played an absolute stinker.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 19 Oct 18 9.44pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

because when the same old faces sit in the same old seats for decades, their human nature -- which generally tends to be polite, inhibited, and not inclined to shouting -- slowly comes to the fore. And once they've gone a few games not singing, it just gets harder and harder to get them (I actually count myself) going. mix it up a bit amd maybe things would be more lively.

All seater stadia and perpetual seat renewals are killing the atmosphere in English football. If that doesn't reverse, one day it'll kill the game too.

Also, just to be clear, I'm no great fan of the HF. many many t***s among them. but I do like a great atmosphere. sp has also played an absolute stinker.

The real killer of atmosphere in English football is the sh!tty Sky cameras the club and HF are playing up to.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 19 Oct 18 9.54pm

Originally posted by Jamesey

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

interested to hear what those in the stand think of a no-numbered-seats policy. I'm sure it'd be initially difficult, and fractious, but would soon settle.

With the proposed singing section, there's nothing to say it wouldn't dilute over time. (if it ever gets going). Then what...

...what's needed is constant evolution and dynamism. people trying to congregate in little groups to get things going.

what's not needed --atmosphere wise at least-- is the same old faces sitting for decades in the same old seats.


The rules of this forum prevent me from saying what I really think about the sheer ignorance and lack of insight of these particular views.

Well, people in little groups to get things going is what Block E supporters have been doing before this poster was presumably born (judging by the immaturity of the post).

As one of the "same old faces" am I forgiven for sitting in different seats in various parts of the ground for several decades? Apologies for not banging a drum or bellowing chants but I'm just a faithful and aged fan - but not an "atic" obviously.

Edited by Jamesey (19 Oct 2018 9.11pm)

I'm almost 50, hold down a very responsible job managing lots of people (generally with good feedback and little rancour, which is quite a feat given the pressures of my job).i also have two moderately well balanced kids. I simply happen to hold a radically different view on this to most people, including you. it doesn't make you right or me wrong (or vice versa). it means we hold different views but I'm in a small minority. at least on here.

my view is one of principle. that principle is that we should never have gone down the path of perpetual renewals...

as it happens I do massively sympathise with those in the LH. What I feel is there needs change to generate atmosphere.

and I managed to respond politely, and without name calling. which I also regard as mature behaviour.

Edited by Ginger Pubic Wig (19 Oct 2018 10.04pm)

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Jamesey Flag Wandsworth 19 Oct 18 10.18pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I'm almost 50, hold down a very responsible job managing lots of people (generally with good feedback and little rancour, which is quite a feat given the pressures of my job).i also have two moderately well balanced kids. I simply happen to hold a radically different view on this to most people, including you. it doesn't make you right or me wrong (or vice versa). it means we hold different views but I'm in a small minority. at least on here.

my view is one of principle. that principle is that we should never have gone down the path of perpetual renewals...

as it happens I do massively sympathise with those in the LH. What I feel is there needs change to generate atmosphere.

and I managed to respond politely, and without name calling. which I also regard as mature behaviour.

Edited by Ginger Pubic Wig (19 Oct 2018 10.04pm)


Thanks for your sensible and considered reply. I admit I had you down as a leftie Sussex Uni student so I am surprised.

In retrospect I wish you no offence and respect your views with which I obviously disagree!

However one last statement from me on this thread at least - Atmosphere doesn't always equate with noise...

 


Nothing is fool-proof - fools are too ingenious

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Oct 18 11.10pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid


The real killer of atmosphere in English football is the sh!tty Sky cameras the club and HF are playing up to.

If and when we get relegated then of course the SKY coverage of our games will be greatly reduced.

In this scenario, one can only speculate as to how many of the HF will still be in regular attendance, whilst I suspect the die-hard season ticket holders in Block E who have supported the club through thick and thin and are going to be displaced, will in the main still stay loyal to the cause.

Edited by Willo (19 Oct 2018 11.12pm)

 

Page 13 of 71 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic