You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Southampton Match Thread
November 16 2026 6.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Southampton Match Thread


Page 13 of 14 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
The Dolphin Flag 31 Jan 19 7.51am

I watched MoD this morning and that tackle on Townsend was a straight red and yet the Referee just watched it and let it go.
The tackle on Wilf near their box in the second half was assault and yet not even a free kick or a booking.
Inconsistent is the polite way of describing Marriner's performance - biased cheat is a better way!

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 31 Jan 19 8.31am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I watched MoD this morning and that tackle on Townsend was a straight red and yet the Referee just watched it and let it go.
The tackle on Wilf near their box in the second half was assault and yet not even a free kick or a booking.
Inconsistent is the polite way of describing Marriner's performance - biased cheat is a better way!

Didn’t watch MOD, did they question the foul on Tomkins (flattened him) in the box?

 

askyourself Flag 31 Jan 19 8.56am

From a S'ampton fan site
[Link]
"Reality check - we are an extremely ordinary team with very little flair and no attacking edge. We got more than we deserved today against a Palace team that were better than us pretty much all round.
Am I the only one that feels we cheated Zaha? - he was the best player on the pitch, he was scythed down by Bednarak who was lucky not to get a red and fouled by JWP who then mock threw the ball at his face for the sending off incident (yes the clapping is petty - but be honest if that situation was in reverse we'd be mad at the ref for not calling a foul). Thought JWP's reaction was immature.
Terrible performance all round. Take the point and count ourselves lucky. Let's not have another 11-day break if that's the result. What's the story with Bertrand and Lemina for goodness sake - when will we ever see them again? We lack class. Yoshida needed back too."

 


We move in the direction of our thoughts.
Just think a little.

Bangell Flag Oxford 31 Jan 19 9.04am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

PVA is having a poor, poor season and was once again at fault for their goal today.

Agreed. Sometimes his attitude looks a little concerning.

 

YT Flag Oxford 31 Jan 19 9.27am

Originally posted by Bangell

Agreed. Sometimes his attitude looks a little concerning.

One could argue that he (PVA) has now cost us 4 or 5 points this season through his poor defending, solely against Southampton.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 31 Jan 19 9.36am

Respect the point as Fat Sam used to say, as well as getting a point ourselves we stopped a team around us winning, which is vital, beat Fulham and it’ll be a good weeks work

Check me out, mr positive

Edited by monkey (31 Jan 2019 9.37am)

 

YT Flag Oxford 31 Jan 19 9.44am

Originally posted by monkey

Respect the point as Fat Sam used to say, as well as getting a point ourselves we stopped a team around us winning, which is vital, beat Fulham and it’ll be a good weeks work

Check me out, mr positive

Edited by monkey (31 Jan 2019 9.37am)

No, I actually agree with you. However it’s the typical Palace feeling of disappointment of yet another couple of points p!ssed up the wall through a combination of our own ineptitude and dreadful refereeing.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

jimruss Flag Sidcup 31 Jan 19 9.45am

Originally posted by askyourself

From a S'ampton fan site
[Link]
"Reality check - we are an extremely ordinary team with very little flair and no attacking edge. We got more than we deserved today against a Palace team that were better than us pretty much all round.
Am I the only one that feels we cheated Zaha? - he was the best player on the pitch, he was scythed down by Bednarak who was lucky not to get a red and fouled by JWP who then mock threw the ball at his face for the sending off incident (yes the clapping is petty - but be honest if that situation was in reverse we'd be mad at the ref for not calling a foul). Thought JWP's reaction was immature.
Terrible performance all round. Take the point and count ourselves lucky. Let's not have another 11-day break if that's the result. What's the story with Bertrand and Lemina for goodness sake - when will we ever see them again? We lack class. Yoshida needed back too."

A very honest and pretty accurate assessment.

Terrible tackle on Wilf which was a straight red all day long, how the ref didn't give anything espescially as it was right in front of him beggars belief. JWP tackle on Wilf which led to the red was a booking I thought, a pretty shocking performance from who I considered to be one of the better refs.

Ultimately poor defending and poor game management by Roy cost us a vital win, I'd have taken a draw before the game so can't complain too much but we really should have put the game to bed.


 

AERO Flag 31 Jan 19 9.47am

When the F A access wills card , will they also access Marinas terrible performance ?

 

AERO Flag 31 Jan 19 9.47am

Oops Wilfs card

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Jan 19 9.52am

Originally posted by YT

One could argue that he (PVA) has now cost us 4 or 5 points this season through his poor defending, solely against Southampton.

As I mentioned when he signed and a few times since then, PVA is not the best defensively, often switching off and not looking over his shoulder.He is better coming forward than defending but this seems to be true of many modern full-backs.

 

jimruss Flag Sidcup 31 Jan 19 10.01am

Originally posted by Willo

As I mentioned when he signed and a few times since then, PVA is not the best defensively, often switching off and not looking over his shoulder.He is better coming forward than defending but this seems to be true of many modern full-backs.

He doesn't really have anyone pushing him for a place, he's guaranteed to play every game when fit, if his performances drop which they generally have he still plays

 

The Dolphin Flag 31 Jan 19 10.07am

Originally posted by palace chick

Didn’t watch MOD, did they question the foul on Tomkins (flattened him) in the box?

No they didn't but then it is MoD and we only got a few minutes.
They were more interested in Wilf but even they were mildly sympathetic.
Wilf was fouled 4 times - officially - how many unofficially - maybe another 4?
He should be able to cope with that shouldn't he?
I do accept though that the bad ones that go completely unpunished are a disgrace.
I wonder whether Marriner will get sanctioned?
It won't be this weekend I guess as they were already chosen before last night but the assessor will have watched that display last night and cringed and then checked his betting account I hope!

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 31 Jan 19 10.09am

Originally posted by Bangell

Or a professional footballer with a brain, who knows when facing Wilf to wind him up and you'll profit. If we came up against a team whose best player could be so simply nullified, we'd demand that our players do it.

yep - there have been plenty of players over the years that the players and crowd knew to wind up and they'd end up hitting the self destruct button - Barton, Bowyer etc. - and it won us points and matches.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 31 Jan 19 10.22am

I was thinking back to one moment last night which I really appreciated. After Wilf gets the red Sakho seems to put it upon himself to act as avenger for the injustice and attempts to run through the Saints team. He seemed to lose his cool for a minute and show some real passion. It didn't work but I found myself shouting 'Come on Sakho!' at the screen. Sometimes I do miss the old days when players were allowed to show their emotion without social media and forums lambasting them for 'lack of professionalism'.

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 31 Jan 19 10.32am

I don't think their goal can be blamed on PVA. Just watched a re run of the game. Their goal came about when they took off one of their 3 centre backs and brought on another midfielder. Around the same time Ayew and Zaha were swapping positions the end result meant Ward Prowse was not marked for the entire period of the build to the goal ( In fact the Saints fans were screaming for the ball to go out to WP in the early stages of the build up ) When it finally did PVA was 1 player against 2 in the 6 yard box which should never happen. It was a good tactical change by the Saints boss and we were slow to react and probably Zaha should have tracked the run in hindsight.

 

becky Flag over the moon 31 Jan 19 10.33am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

No they didn't but then it is MoD and we only got a few minutes.
They were more interested in Wilf but even they were mildly sympathetic.
Wilf was fouled 4 times - officially - how many unofficially - maybe another 4?
He should be able to cope with that shouldn't he?
I do accept though that the bad ones that go completely unpunished are a disgrace.
I wonder whether Marriner will get sanctioned?
It won't be this weekend I guess as they were already chosen before last night but the assessor will have watched that display last night and cringed and then checked his betting account I hope!

Whether he is able to cope with it or not, he shouldn't have to! That is what the Laws of the game are there for - to punish those that break them and hurt, injure and sometimes end the careers of other fellow professionals.

All the focus seems to be on Wilf, and how he should have comported himself better. When are we going to have the important big open debate about referees and their (albeit human) failings ...... or favouritism (as admitted by Clattenburg) or possibly even corruption (and let's not pretend that there are massive sums of gambling money involved in football these days.... remember the floodlights going out all over the country by the far eastern syndicates)?

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

liamsean92 Flag Croydon 31 Jan 19 11.16am

I'm sick to death with Zaha's continual petulance and immaturity. This not only means he'll miss Fulham but the 1st yellow counts on his total, which is now 7 or 8. 10 gets him a 2 match ban and it will happen.

Hodgson should have seen what was happening and hooked him immediately Southampton equalised. The fact we only made 1 sub, to their 3 (again!!) was the main reason 2 points were dropped.

The BBC showed 6 fouls on Zaha, and Townsend, and they were all shocking. We only committed one bad foul in return. The ref had a dreadful game. Tomkins and Kouyate also injured. Bolasie is available. We might need him!

 

fledgling Flag Beckenham 31 Jan 19 11.38am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I was thinking back to one moment last night which I really appreciated. After Wilf gets the red Sakho seems to put it upon himself to act as avenger for the injustice and attempts to run through the Saints team. He seemed to lose his cool for a minute and show some real passion. It didn't work but I found myself shouting 'Come on Sakho!' at the screen. Sometimes I do miss the old days when players were allowed to show their emotion without social media and forums lambasting them for 'lack of professionalism'.

Loved that too. Reminded me of when he took control vs. Chelsea last season at home. He won the ball high up the pitch, drove at the defence then laid the ball off and the move resulted in a goal. Great determination and passion.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 31 Jan 19 11.48am

Originally posted by liamsean92

I'm sick to death with Zaha's continual petulance and immaturity. This not only means he'll miss Fulham but the 1st yellow counts on his total, which is now 7 or 8. 10 gets him a 2 match ban and it will happen.

Hodgson should have seen what was happening and hooked him immediately Southampton equalised. The fact we only made 1 sub, to their 3 (again!!) was the main reason 2 points were dropped.

The BBC showed 6 fouls on Zaha, and Townsend, and they were all shocking. We only committed one bad foul in return. The ref had a dreadful game. Tomkins and Kouyate also injured. Bolasie is available. We might need him!

There were plenty of blatant fouls on our players. I think the worst was on Tomkins because the Southampton player Romeau was intent on taking him out ... he wasn't even watching the ball. Romeau appears to be a pedigree thug and I think he got away with everything last night irrespective of three pairs of eyes officiating. Not impressed with Southampton if that is the level of their play nowadays. Feel sorry for Zaha but there's no excuse for his stupid behaviour.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Page 13 of 14 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Southampton Match Thread