You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Singing Section
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Singing Section


Page 13 of 18 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >
Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Oct 19 11.04pm

Originally posted by cols123

In need of any salt and vinegar for that chip in your shoulder?

Anyone who experienced the appalling atmosphere at the beginning of last season when the HF weren't around knows that this season the atmosphere has been leaps and bounds ahead of that, and the move has been good.

Your point about the rest of the ground not getting involved in chants would be all the more apparant if the HF weren't there! Deathly silence springs to mind.

Moaning about there being new songs that people dont know is laughable. Pride of south london, we love you and many others took their time to bed in. Cant you moan about the burgers or something else instead.

Edited by cols123 (21 Oct 2019 10.56pm)

Oh, I am sure he will. But not instead.

[Link]

 

cpj Flag Kent 22 Oct 19 9.50am

Sorry but I just don't get the purpose of singing random songs for the whole game irregardless of what is happening on the pitch. They might as well sing Queen's greatest hits if it's just a question of making noise. Back in the day, the crowd would respond accordingly depending on whether we were winning or needed to get a goal. Now it's just an irritating background noise.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Oct 19 9.56am

Originally posted by cpj

Sorry but I just don't get the purpose of singing random songs for the whole game irregardless of what is happening on the pitch. They might as well sing Queen's greatest hits if it's just a question of making noise. Back in the day, the crowd would respond accordingly depending on whether we were winning or needed to get a goal. Now it's just an irritating background noise.

It goes wrong as soon as one song is sung for the first 20 minutes.

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Oct 19 10.03am

Someone who went to Selhurst Park recently for the first time said he expected much more of the 'Singing section' adding words to the effect that it was hardly the yellow wall of Dortmund.He was very disappointed and based on what he witnessed believes that they have been over-hyped.

 

AERO Flag 22 Oct 19 10.33am

No it’s certainly not Dortmund ! And probably over hyped,But certainly better than at least half the premiere league. Let’s wait and hear Arsenals wall of sound on Sunday ?

 

BrolinT Flag Selhurst 22 Oct 19 12.24pm

Originally posted by Dean_CPFC

Crystal Palace ‘ultras’: Ninety relentless minutes amongst the Holmesdale Fanatics

[Link]

What a brilliant article!!

It seems incredulous that even a journalist can come down, see its worth and praise the section for what it is, while a minority of our own fans still seem opposed.

I'm in the main stand and it's louder than it's ever been and IMO there is real scope for this being allowed to grow even bigger. It's clear the creativity and commitment from this group is in place for us all to play a bigger role in taking it up yet a further notch.

Selhurst has been enjoyable this season - the section is consistent and a real spectacle. Let's keep pushing this forward and stop sniping at our own.

 

AERO Flag 22 Oct 19 3.32pm

Excellent post . Some on here not happy if they’re not criticising.

 

est1905 Flag 22 Oct 19 4.47pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

And there I was expecting your usual high level of positivity.

I am positive about a great many things. Cannot, hand on heart think of anything positive to say about HF. Sure the pundits that never come to Selhurst, watch on tv or listen to other reporters ill informed opinions think they are great. Scratch the surface and for me they are starting to become divisive and toxic in the stands.
I am entitled to my opinion and I personally would prefer match days without them.
Didn't miss them before the were there, didn't miss them during their little hissy fit boycott, wouldn't miss them if they decided to stop going to the games from now onwards.

 

est1905 Flag 22 Oct 19 4.54pm

Originally posted by cols123

In need of any salt and vinegar for that chip in your shoulder?

Anyone who experienced the appalling atmosphere at the beginning of last season when the HF weren't around knows that this season the atmosphere has been leaps and bounds ahead of that, and the move has been good.

Your point about the rest of the ground not getting involved in chants would be all the more apparant if the HF weren't there! Deathly silence springs to mind.

Moaning about there being new songs that people dont know is laughable. Pride of south london, we love you and many others took their time to bed in. Cant you moan about the burgers or something else instead.

Edited by cols123 (21 Oct 2019 10.56pm)

I think you need to be educated on what that phrase actually means. You make no sense.
Its all about opinions, you wont change mine. Yours? Maybe you'll always love them. Even if they try and bully your elderly Grandad or rough up your sister, or try and force two teenagers out of the food/drink que who were minding their own business waiting to be served but because there are only two of them and they may look a bit weedy I guess that's fine eh?
I've both heard of instances of this from HF as well as witnessed with my own eyes/ears. So I repeat, I don't like them. That's my choice. You want to love them because they bang a drum loudly and bounce up and down? knock yourself out.

 

est1905 Flag 22 Oct 19 4.57pm

Originally posted by AERO

Excellent post . Some on here not happy if they’re not criticising.

Again, a lazy retort. I praise many things that are deserving of praise. You just don't like it because HF are far more deserving of criticism.

 

Tomas Brolin 12 Flag 23 Oct 19 11.00am

Originally posted by est1905

I am positive about a great many things. Cannot, hand on heart think of anything positive to say about HF. Sure the pundits that never come to Selhurst, watch on tv or listen to other reporters ill informed opinions think they are great. Scratch the surface and for me they are starting to become divisive and toxic in the stands.


What a bitter, sad sack you are. Luckily, your opinion counts for very little when you see how they're valued by the club and most of us.

Just look at Joel Ward's facebook [Link]

He posts a pic of the display and says: "I want to say a BIG thank you to everyone involved, this was a special moment. I had no idea it was happening and am blown away by the continued support.. #oneclubtogetherinbattle @cpfc"

Clearly directed at all those who spent a whole week apparently in a basement working on this display.

It is crazy there is a minority of people bitter towards them when they provide such quality moments as this at the club that are clearly REALLY appreciated by players and fans alike.

But you carry on with your own weird agenda - which seems really out of touch when you see the likes of Ward's comments.

Edited by Tomas Brolin 12 (23 Oct 2019 11.18am)

Edited by Tomas Brolin 12 (23 Oct 2019 11.43am)

 

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 23 Oct 19 12.43pm

Originally posted by est1905

Scratch the surface and for me they are starting to become divisive and toxic in the stands.

Surely you're on a wind up. They've just done a banner talking about unity and battling together, that 99% of supporters thought was excellent. Then Joel ward backed it on social media. They ended the game with we love you which was a great positive moment. They're the exact opposite of toxic and divisive, it's unfortunately the minority like yourself who are bringing the negativity!!

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 23 Oct 19 12.44pm

Originally posted by Tomas Brolin 12

What a bitter, sad sack you are. Luckily, your opinion counts for very little when you see how they're valued by the club and most of us.

Just look at Joel Ward's facebook [Link]

He posts a pic of the display and says: "I want to say a BIG thank you to everyone involved, this was a special moment. I had no idea it was happening and am blown away by the continued support.. #oneclubtogetherinbattle @cpfc"

Clearly directed at all those who spent a whole week apparently in a basement working on this display.

It is crazy there is a minority of people bitter towards them when they provide such quality moments as this at the club that are clearly REALLY appreciated by players and fans alike.

But you carry on with your own weird agenda - which seems really out of touch when you see the likes of Ward's comments.

Edited by Tomas Brolin 12 (23 Oct 2019 11.18am)

Edited by Tomas Brolin 12 (23 Oct 2019 11.43am)

WOW, joined today & this is your 1st post, you'll go far on here. FYI, I don't like the HF, not because of their drum, not because of their obscure songs & not even because of their bouncing up n down, I don't like them because of their 'bully-boy' tactics of fellow fans.

Edited by eagleman13 (23 Oct 2019 12.44pm)

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Tomas Brolin 12 Flag 23 Oct 19 4.04pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

WOW, joined today & this is your 1st post, you'll go far on here.

My 'first post' highlighted the joy and support a player felt he got from a section of our fanbase. As supporters, we should be proud that moments like this are happening - Very rare at other clubs!!

Hardly a contentious first post, is it? All the facts are there - Joel was clearly buzzing from the display that was backed and supported by all of us Palace fans.

It's really quite simple.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Oct 19 4.20pm

Originally posted by Tomas Brolin 12

My 'first post' highlighted the joy and support a player felt he got from a section of our fanbase. As supporters, we should be proud that moments like this are happening - Very rare at other clubs!!

Hardly a contentious first post, is it? All the facts are there - Joel was clearly buzzing from the display that was backed and supported by all of us Palace fans.

It's really quite simple.

From my humble point of view the Joel Ward banner was a wonderful gesture recognising a player who has been a true servant of the club and of course he was delighted to see it.

In terms of the HF, of course they bring some colour and noise to Selhurst Park and I recognise the time and effort they expend to produce the displays.

However I just wish they would carry out their displays of fervent support from a sedentary position - I believe my views on standing in all-seater stadia have been well documented on HOL !

 

est1905 Flag 23 Oct 19 5.56pm

Originally posted by Tomas Brolin 12

What a bitter, sad sack you are. Luckily, your opinion counts for very little when you see how they're valued by the club and most of us.

Just look at Joel Ward's facebook [Link]

He posts a pic of the display and says: "I want to say a BIG thank you to everyone involved, this was a special moment. I had no idea it was happening and am blown away by the continued support.. #oneclubtogetherinbattle @cpfc"

Clearly directed at all those who spent a whole week apparently in a basement working on this display.

It is crazy there is a minority of people bitter towards them when they provide such quality moments as this at the club that are clearly REALLY appreciated by players and fans alike.

But you carry on with your own weird agenda - which seems really out of touch when you see the likes of Ward's comments.

Edited by Tomas Brolin 12 (23 Oct 2019 11.18am)

Edited by Tomas Brolin 12 (23 Oct 2019 11.43am)

Much as you'd like to you don't speak for the whole club (or most). You love them, good for you. I don't. You call me bitter. Strange as you know zero about me. Name calling doesn't add weight to your argument.
I am not in the minority. I have sat in the lower or upper Holmesdale for 24 years and during that time I have met and got to know at least 50, probably closer to 100 fans that also sit in that stand. Not one, not ONE thinks the HF are anything special and most hate them for their attitude towards fellow fans. I do not know the whole club and unlike you I don't profess to speak for them either but based on the percentage of the Holmesdale that I know (that's the Holmesdale who have to sit/stand near to them and are directly affected by their actions) I would say it is you that's in the minority.
But don't worry, I don't imagine you are a bitter sad sack about it. Bit of a hero worshipper to spotty teenagers but not bitter!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Oct 19 6.01pm

Originally posted by est1905

Much as you'd like to you don't speak for the whole club (or most). You love them, good for you. I don't. You call me bitter. Strange as you know zero about me. Name calling doesn't add weight to your argument.
I am not in the minority. I have sat in the lower or upper Holmesdale for 24 years and during that time I have met and got to know at least 50, probably closer to 100 fans that also sit in that stand. Not one, not ONE thinks the HF are anything special and most hate them for their attitude towards fellow fans. I do not know the whole club and unlike you I don't profess to speak for them either but based on the percentage of the Holmesdale that I know (that's the Holmesdale who have to sit/stand near to them and are directly affected by their actions) I would say it is you that's in the minority.
But don't worry, I don't imagine you are a bitter sad sack about it. Bit of a hero worshipper to spotty teenagers but not bitter!

I have heard this view expressed by fellow supporters.
I happen to believe that the HF haven't lived up to expectations.

 

est1905 Flag 23 Oct 19 6.19pm

Originally posted by Dean_CPFC

Surely you're on a wind up. They've just done a banner talking about unity and battling together, that 99% of supporters thought was excellent. Then Joel ward backed it on social media. They ended the game with we love you which was a great positive moment. They're the exact opposite of toxic and divisive, it's unfortunately the minority like yourself who are bringing the negativity!!

While I fully and completely accept the overwhelming majority of HOL seem to love and adore HF. But.... The HOL is not the majority of Palace fans. Not even close, so attempting to make out you are in the majority because this small message board (and yes it is small, very small in comparison to other football club message boards) generally loves them is wide of the mark.
I'm not bitter as has been suggested and I certainly don't attack or name call that do think they are great. And I agree, the banner was outstanding. I never said it wasn't. Not everything they do is divisive.
But the reality is, the closer people are to them the less people you will find that like them.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 23 Oct 19 6.20pm

Originally posted by est1905

Much as you'd like to you don't speak for the whole club (or most). You love them, good for you. I don't. You call me bitter. Strange as you know zero about me. Name calling doesn't add weight to your argument.
I am not in the minority. I have sat in the lower or upper Holmesdale for 24 years and during that time I have met and got to know at least 50, probably closer to 100 fans that also sit in that stand. Not one, not ONE thinks the HF are anything special and most hate them for their attitude towards fellow fans. I do not know the whole club and unlike you I don't profess to speak for them either but based on the percentage of the Holmesdale that I know (that's the Holmesdale who have to sit/stand near to them and are directly affected by their actions) I would say it is you that's in the minority.
But don't worry, I don't imagine you are a bitter sad sack about it. Bit of a hero worshipper to spotty teenagers but not bitter!

Is the reply of the year.

Tips hat.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Tomas Brolin 12 Flag 23 Oct 19 8.23pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Is the reply of the year.

Tips hat.

eagleman13 and est1905 are the same posters. There surely can't be two bitter, cranky and quite frankly on the verge of a breakdown posters on one message board! Check it out mods.

 

Page 13 of 18 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Singing Section