This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
I see that the royal family have issued a statement saying that any form of racism will be dealt with internally - otherwise known as doing a Milivojevic.
|
|
|
Originally posted by martin2412
You're the one who reckons that you don't need intent to be a racist, so is the old lady a racist ? I’d suggest re reading both my post and the original post that I was replying to. You’ve missed the boat entirely. Quite simply, to use your sentence and align it correctly with the point I was making - ‘you don’t need intent to be racist’. Note the absence of ‘a’. Very important that as it was the entire crux of my original post. So using your example, without explaining the history of it that I would really hope you’d know about, she has used a word that is at best pretty offensive and at worst a racial slur. Let’s say we go with the worst case interpretation here for the sake of debate, and that a character witness would vouch for her not having a racist bone in her body. First off, yes she is being racist. That much is obvious. Does that make her a racist? No. But I never said that - I said a racist term or act is still racist whether you’re ignorant of its meaning or not. Intent makes it worse, sure, but it doesn’t change the meaning. See above law analogy. Logic. What a b******.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Cpfc1861
Hate to be the guy to accuse somebody of bulls*** but does anybody find meghan raising the mental health issue with HR weird surely a doctor would be more appropriate I reckon she never raised anything she's full of s*** also if they truly felt a member was racist they would name them they're either being ambigious for a future interview or it didn't happen. Bearing in mind Harry was patron of some mental health charities, at the time, I would suspect he would know someone who could help, if he knew about it. The woman was playing to a script and is full of bs
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Ill never cease to find it amazing that fairly simplistic concepts about context and language are so hard for so many to understand. Further, that people simply can’t seem to grasp that language and meanings evolve. They’re changing all the time. The world, and language, doesn’t stand still. Yes, I thought I'd chime in as clearly those words are routinely not used in the same way or for the same purpose. The post was either a lack of acknowledgement of real world behaviour, or an intentional denial of it.
|
|
|
An Aussie view, top comments about Princess Anne's kids
One more point |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by martin2412
I see that the royal family have issued a statement saying that any form of racism will be dealt with internally - otherwise known as doing a Milivojevic. They are certainty at a distinct disadvantage in dealing with this because it's not really an option for the royals to get into a soap opera back and forth. That's important to factor in when the other party has no such restrictions. To even go ahead with this Oprah interview there becomes a need to push and portray the very worst and to possibly exaggerate. A lot of their anger is really with the press, and I don't really see the Royal Family as being able to do anything about that anyway so there was an inevitability to this where an individualistic person enters the family. The Trump card will always be that the Royals were entirely non judgemental of Prince Andrew and so there is little to no scope of having any issue with anything Meghan says or does in comparison. They're caught in a tough stuff where they're probably best off just saying nothing. Any further contributions just add fuel to the fire.
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
I’d suggest re reading both my post and the original post that I was replying to. You’ve missed the boat entirely. Quite simply, to use your sentence and align it correctly with the point I was making - ‘you don’t need intent to be racist’. Note the absence of ‘a’. Very important that as it was the entire crux of my original post. So using your example, without explaining the history of it that I would really hope you’d know about, she has used a word that is at best pretty offensive and at worst a racial slur. Let’s say we go with the worst case interpretation here for the sake of debate, and that a character witness would vouch for her not having a racist bone in her body. First off, yes she is being racist. That much is obvious. Does that make her a racist? No. But I never said that - I said a racist term or act is still racist whether you’re ignorant of its meaning or not. Intent makes it worse, sure, but it doesn’t change the meaning. See above law analogy. Logic. What a b******. Nope. If you were to go on social media and spout off that the old lady was being racist, this would stir up all the snowflakes (I'm thinking about being offended by that term as it was used as an insult by Rudolph Walker in 'Love Thy Neighbour' You stated in your response to the 'pa*i ' comment a couple of posts back that you were amazed that some people can't grasp the idea of context, well when it suits it seems.
|
|
|
Agree. One small detail. Mike Tindall, Zara Phillips’ husband, has been caught claiming small amounts of furlough with their multi million fortune.
COYP |
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Cpfc1861
Hate to be the guy to accuse somebody of bulls*** but does anybody find meghan raising the mental health issue with HR weird surely a doctor would be more appropriate I reckon she never raised anything she's full of s*** also if they truly felt a member was racist they would name them they're either being ambigious for a future interview or it didn't happen. That was my reaction too. Surprised the Royal family even have a HR department. She did no research, but she seems to have completely misunderstood that its not work, it's a duty and a trade off. She pulls ribbons in exchange for living in a Palace. When she decided she didn't like being as busy as she is, and didn't like the negative publicity she decided to kick up a fuss, and probably got told that she needs to take the rough with the smooth. You can't pick and choose, especially when you live off a massive grant. And, if you've got a security issue involving your child, even a minor one, you don't tell the whole f***ing world about it. We'll done s*** for brains, Archie has now got a massive target, and it's all because you wanted to continue a row with the press to score points. Have they really thought through all the comments they made about the commonwealth being racist. She might see it as point scoring against the Royals. The commonwealth might not be great, but it is a stabilising factor. Destabilise a couple of countries and she'll be putting lives at risk.... this is why the Royals are always so careful. They've got 100's of years of knowledge of what its like to run a constitutional monarchy. Although the reoccurring theme throughout is that Megan thinks she knows better.
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Ill never cease to find it amazing that fairly simplistic concepts about context and language are so hard for so many to understand. Further, that people simply can’t seem to grasp that language and meanings evolve. They’re changing all the time. The world, and language, doesn’t stand still. And the fact you are shutting down the discussion as quickly as possible explains why we are all walking on eggshells incase someone gets offended.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Society of Editors' claim that UK media not racist labelled 'laughable' Dozens of journalists of colour sign letter rejecting claim racism not a factor in Duchess of Sussex coverage. Wernt the white ones invited for their opinion and why not? Maybe this is racist but only the act of not asking them!
|
|
|
Originally posted by martin2412
Nope. If you were to go on social media and spout off that the old lady was being racist, this would stir up all the snowflakes (I'm thinking about being offended by that term as it was used as an insult by Rudolph Walker in 'Love Thy Neighbour' You stated in your response to the 'pa*i ' comment a couple of posts back that you were amazed that some people can't grasp the idea of context, well when it suits it seems. Can’t argue with logic I’m afraid. Answer the point rather than segueing into some completely unrelated secondary hypothesis. Have no idea what Twitter and snowflakes may or may not do as a result of me hypothetically doing something. Context is everything but again, it doesn’t make the use of a racist word non-racist, in any scenario. It might provide lenience but certainly not exoneration. It does, however, determine whether a person could be deemed a racist or not. Unarguable. If you think any word with meaning, let alone a racist one can be stripped of said meaning due to pleading ignorance or general idiocy then... well I’d say I’d be surprised but as I’m continually reminded on practically a minute by minute basis there’s a lot of morons in the world.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
And the fact you are shutting down the discussion as quickly as possible explains why we are all walking on eggshells incase someone gets offended. No no. Adding. Adding to the discussion
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Can’t argue with logic I’m afraid. Answer the point rather than segueing into some completely unrelated secondary hypothesis. Have no idea what Twitter and snowflakes may or may not do as a result of me hypothetically doing something. Context is everything but again, it doesn’t make the use of a racist word non-racist, in any scenario. It might provide lenience but certainly not exoneration. It does, however, determine whether a person could be deemed a racist or not. Unarguable. If you think any word with meaning, let alone a racist one can be stripped of said meaning due to pleading ignorance or general idiocy then... well I’d say I’d be surprised but as I’m continually reminded on practically a minute by minute basis there’s a lot of morons in the world. All this stuff about language is just like Newspeak in '1984', its purpose is to try to stop people being able to articulate subversive thoughts.
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Can’t argue with logic I’m afraid. Answer the point rather than segueing into some completely unrelated secondary hypothesis. Have no idea what Twitter and snowflakes may or may not do as a result of me hypothetically doing something. Context is everything but again, it doesn’t make the use of a racist word non-racist, in any scenario. It might provide lenience but certainly not exoneration. It does, however, determine whether a person could be deemed a racist or not. Unarguable. If you think any word with meaning, let alone a racist one can be stripped of said meaning due to pleading ignorance or general idiocy then... well I’d say I’d be surprised but as I’m continually reminded on practically a minute by minute basis there’s a lot of morons in the world. So the person who last night complained about racism is himself a racist?
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Society of Editors' claim that UK media not racist labelled 'laughable' Dozens of journalists of colour sign letter rejecting claim racism not a factor in Duchess of Sussex coverage. If the media are racist, why are they taking money from a racist institution? Money over principals?
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Can’t argue with logic I’m afraid. Answer the point rather than segueing into some completely unrelated secondary hypothesis. Have no idea what Twitter and snowflakes may or may not do as a result of me hypothetically doing something. Context is everything but again, it doesn’t make the use of a racist word non-racist, in any scenario. It might provide lenience but certainly not exoneration. It does, however, determine whether a person could be deemed a racist or not. Unarguable. If you think any word with meaning, let alone a racist one can be stripped of said meaning due to pleading ignorance or general idiocy then... well I’d say I’d be surprised but as I’m continually reminded on practically a minute by minute basis there’s a lot of morons in the world. It is arguable, but you don't want to acknowledge it. The meaning of words can be misinterpreted, especially if you want them to be, and in my opinion this was probably the case in respect of the discussion about Archie's likely skin colour. I'm surprised you haven't called me a racist yet as you're getting there by calling anyone who doesn't agree with you a moron.
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Can’t argue with logic I’m afraid. Answer the point rather than segueing into some completely unrelated secondary hypothesis. Have no idea what Twitter and snowflakes may or may not do as a result of me hypothetically doing something. Context is everything but again, it doesn’t make the use of a racist word non-racist, in any scenario. It might provide lenience but certainly not exoneration. It does, however, determine whether a person could be deemed a racist or not. Unarguable. If you think any word with meaning, let alone a racist one can be stripped of said meaning due to pleading ignorance or general idiocy then... well I’d say I’d be surprised but as I’m continually reminded on practically a minute by minute basis there’s a lot of morons in the world. Interesting thread on bbs, most on there have stated it had no racist connotations and in fact, those with mixed race families have similar conversations about future children.
|
|
|
Originally posted by martin2412
It is arguable, but you don't want to acknowledge it. The meaning of words can be misinterpreted, especially if you want them to be, and in my opinion this was probably the case in respect of the discussion about Archie's likely skin colour. I'm surprised you haven't called me a racist yet as you're getting there by calling anyone who doesn't agree with you a moron. Anything is arguable, as this site proves. As for whether it’s worth arguing about or even contesting is another matter. Of course the meaning of words can be misinterpreted, especially if you don’t know the meaning in the first place. The context obviously can also be misinterpreted. That’s not up for debate. I’m responding to the exact example you provided, with a completely logical response. The word remains either at best offensive or at worst a racial slur if used in the context you described, regardless of intent. Ignorance is not a defence, nor does it make the word magically non-offensive or the statement itself non-racist. The days of tolerating some old boy drossing in the corner using continually using offensive, or worse, language that was acceptable to some in the 40s whilst others around him make screwy faces and laugh it off are over. Age and ignorance are not an excuse. The context of the royal discussion behind closed doors is entirely unknowable, and I’ve made this point already, it could have been in a perfectly acceptable context. For example pondering if his skin colour would lead to more negative press or discrimination. Not racist. To build on your random example though, saying ‘Hazza old boy, just how coloured is old Archibald going to be eh?’ - same as the granny. Ignorant or intentional. Irrelevant. TBF most people are morons. But disagreeing with someone is not a qualifier. Plenty of other factors at play
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.