You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is It Time For Roy To Go, Yes or NO
November 13 2026 7.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is It Time For Roy To Go, Yes or NO


Page 13 of 34 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >
AERO Flag 04 Jul 20 7.31pm

At the end of the day Roy is not going to be our manager for much longer one season more at most .So we should rebuild from now top to bottom and go again next season .

 

redshift Flag Toronto 04 Jul 20 7.40pm

Originally posted by Badger11

If Dyche is available this summer I think we should go for him, Roy is not getting any younger and the idea of a transition period or handover never works. You end up employing the best manager you can at the time you need them.

If Dyche is not available I am happy for Roy to continue for next season and then review.

We are not the only ones thinking along these lines. If I were Manchester United I would be thinking about Poch because he is available now end of next season he may not be.

I can't believe that if Dyche is leaving Burnley he would even consider Palace. Another small market team with no money and few concrete reasons to believe things will get better soon.
As to the question, I think we'll need to keep Roy. He's still our best bet but given his age we need to think replacement sooner rather than later.

 


Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth.

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 04 Jul 20 7.55pm

Originally posted by redshift

I can't believe that if Dyche is leaving Burnley he would even consider Palace. Another small market team with no money and few concrete reasons to believe things will get better soon.
As to the question, I think we'll need to keep Roy. He's still our best bet but given his age we need to think replacement sooner rather than later.

This is a good example as to how people mis-represent us and try to manage expectations down... our wage budget is roughly £32m per year more than Burnley’s.

Their highest ever transfer fees are;

- Gibson, £15m
- Wood, £15m
- Brady, £14m
- Gray, £11m

Ours are;

- Benteke, £32m
- Sakho, £30m
- Townsend, £15m
- Mili, £15m

This talk of Hodgson’s miracles is not based in any sort of reality.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 04 Jul 20 7.59pm

Originally posted by Eaglehamster

I wish an interviewer had asked Roy to explain his use of substitutes today.

We go 1 down: He subs a creative midfielder for a defensive midfielder

We are 2 down: He replaces a defender with Andros (hooray) and Benteke with a defender. So Andros has no target man to aim for.

Surely these tactics are from someone who has lost their marbles.

Today has put me in the 'Roy must go' camp.


I also thought Riedewald was one of our best players when Roy decided to haul him off after 60 mins for another defensive midfielder who’s far worst in possession.

No doubt he’ll be resigned for bench for the rest of the season now.

 

AERO Flag 04 Jul 20 8.08pm

Riedwald was good first half but ran out of steam .Begs the question why.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Jul 20 8.12pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Wage budget is far more indicative of squad quality, and the correlation between wage bill and league finish is far stronger than transfer spend/league finish.

Did Hodgson sign Sakho and Beneteke and agree to pay them in excess of £100k per week ?

These 2 players have been a financial drain on the club and have not merited either the transfer fees or wages paid. Although I would accept that both signings seemed good at the time.

Our transfer budget will remain tight while we have the likes of those two plus Zaha on our books ( and yes, I'm aware that Benteke's new contract may have been at reduced terms )

It's about time that some thought was given to a squad rebuild and who will oversee it given the short term contracts that Hodgson is employed under

 


Old, Ungifted and White

PatrickA Flag London 04 Jul 20 8.13pm

Absolutely agree about Riedewald playing well.
And yet I knew he would be hauled off and I mentioned it to my son at half time.
The only mistake I made was I thought it would be Mcarthy instead of Kouyate who would come on.
Please can somebody explain how those substitutions were designed to get us back in the game?
My son opined Hodgson was trying to protect the goal difference at 2-0 but then Leicester scores a third!

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 04 Jul 20 8.13pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

This is a good example as to how people mis-represent us and try to manage expectations down... our wage budget is roughly £32m per year more than Burnley’s.

Their highest ever transfer fees are;

- Gibson, £15m
- Wood, £15m
- Brady, £14m
- Gray, £11m

Ours are;

- Benteke, £32m
- Sakho, £30m
- Townsend, £15m
- Mili, £15m

This talk of Hodgson’s miracles is not based in any sort of reality.

But those are all players put on big contracts three or four years ago and are now in decline.

Townsends problems with niggling injury and consistency have been there since day one and wont be getting any better with age.

Age, injuries and inability to regain fitness mean Sakho is now looking on the way down (being kind).

WRT the wage bill Meyer is also a lightweight on £80k a week and IIRC Scott Dann negotiated a hefty and valuable contract when his stock with us was at its greatest.

Benteke doesn't require explanation other than his 20 from 23 good chances missed during 2017-18. This stuff about him just needing service and to get his confidence back is bollocks.


 

AERO Flag 04 Jul 20 8.36pm

Agree about Benteke can't have many supporters left had numerous balls to his feet today and couldn't control anything. Total waste of space should get rid of him and Sakho asap.

 

Sthlondonuk Flag STH NORWOOD 04 Jul 20 9.45pm

Agree Benteke should be equal to Ings or Giroud but is clumsy and seems to have no eye for a goal or where to be Think back to Kevin Phillips older player but seemed to know where the ball would be without chasing and almost all his shots were on target. Benteke should be moved on if anyone will take him

 

GMcC Flag Dubai 04 Jul 20 10.06pm

Yes - Roy should go now. And to have ambition of Dyche as a replacement, why? SP show some ambition please. Yes your Dutch project failed, but please don’t let that stifle any new ideas - what we are seeing now is not good enough - plan a boring at best and so safe - until we concede - then where is plan b c d e ?? Come on - have some balls!

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 04 Jul 20 10.49pm

Roy is not the problem?? How strange...
Whys its only Zaha fault would he not be bored by negative tactics, have you thought about that?
Why will he not be flexible with his only Plan A, why does Plan A have to be the same against Liverpool & Burnley. Everyone knows our Plan A.

Originally posted by Beetle

Roy’s not the problem, he’s not been given any funds for several seasons and we’ve been comfortable. The board should back him with some new players. Zaha wants to leave, but Palace have priced him out of the market. This season it’s been boring watching Palace but when I get my head right I recall losing at home to scunthorpe and Barnsley and suddenly things ain’t so bad. At least the board are being careful as surely no one wants administration again, but some excitement is needed. The sad thing is I didn’t go to the Watford game due to the drudgery of watching Palace this season, clearly with what has transpired since , I wish i had gone now.

Football without fans is actually ridiculous, I thought with the restart we might be a bit more exciting given we are virtually safe but apart from the Bournemouth game it’s the same old. That being said Palace being Palace are always liable to find a result against the so called top 6, but perhaps it’s best we don’t get the Europa league spots with the squad as is , as well as the fact no one will be able to go to the games if this behind closed doors continues.

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 04 Jul 20 10.53pm

HI Should go upstairs next year.... we hopefully have survived this season,, but based on this football and age of slow squad.. we are bottom 3 materiel next season"
Its the time to take a chance with a new manager, as Hodgson would go anyway next season... if the new manager fails, Warnock should be free for end of season survival... lol

Originally posted by AERO

At the end of the day Roy is not going to be our manager for much longer one season more at most .So we should rebuild from now top to bottom and go again next season .

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 04 Jul 20 10.59pm

Is that not proof over and over again, failure of tactics..
Its by chance we win, not his tactics

Meyer should have been on for some creativity, hope schupps can get back


Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I also thought Riedewald was one of our best players when Roy decided to haul him off after 60 mins for another defensive midfielder who’s far worst in possession.

No doubt he’ll be resigned for bench for the rest of the season now.

 

gerry theagle Flag newbury 04 Jul 20 11.01pm

Changing the subject slightly did anyone look at the Stats of the match, Leicester committed 18 fouls against our 8.
Most of those were committed against Ayew, Benteke and Zaha when we were in possession and trying to go forwards, not saying those attacks would have led to anytime but they were stopped before they even had a chance. Leicester are pretty clever at doing that, only two bookings, systematic fouling, bit like Watford.

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 04 Jul 20 11.05pm

Love it when people really dont understand, a forward needs a pass or a cross into a position where he can score from... Even a Vardy or Salah wouldnt score in our team. Bet you where moaning about Ayew last year?? He scores in a free role that suits him this season but as a number 9 as in Benteke role, he struggles does Ayew...

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

But those are all players put on big contracts three or four years ago and are now in decline.

Townsends problems with niggling injury and consistency have been there since day one and wont be getting any better with age.

Age, injuries and inability to regain fitness mean Sakho is now looking on the way down (being kind).

WRT the wage bill Meyer is also a lightweight on £80k a week and IIRC Scott Dann negotiated a hefty and valuable contract when his stock with us was at its greatest.

Benteke doesn't require explanation other than his 20 from 23 good chances missed during 2017-18. This stuff about him just needing service and to get his confidence back is bollocks.


 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 04 Jul 20 11.07pm

Manager cannot be responsible for awful individual mistakes (Guaita and Sakho for first goal) and accidents (Sakho slipping over) ..he is also not responsible for unbelievably awful passing and last but not least Zaha for not bothering.

 

lexmark87 Flag 04 Jul 20 11.15pm

it looks like the players are as bored as the fans with roys tactics.
please please retire your negativity is killing the joy of watching football.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 04 Jul 20 11.15pm

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

Love it when people really dont understand, a forward needs a pass or a cross into a position where he can score from... Even a Vardy or Salah wouldnt score in our team. Bet you where moaning about Ayew last year?? He scores in a free role that suits him this season but as a number 9 as in Benteke role, he struggles does Ayew...


I understand alright, he's spent three seasons playing like a right tart who cant score from three feet, run, hold the ball up or trap a bag of cement. Stop trying to defend the indefensible. What don't you understand about 20 missed chances from 23.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 04 Jul 20 11.20pm

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

Love it when people really dont understand, a forward needs a pass or a cross into a position where he can score from... Even a Vardy or Salah wouldnt score in our team. Bet you where moaning about Ayew last year?? He scores in a free role that suits him this season but as a number 9 as in Benteke role, he struggles does Ayew...


Liverpool was the only game where we failed in attack,

We had opportunities against Burnley and today against Liecester who are rightly in the top four, we need to strengthen and our manager is the best we can have to do that job.

 

Page 13 of 34 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is It Time For Roy To Go, Yes or NO