This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Palace v Leeds match thread
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
CT Charlie 07 Nov 20 7.49pm |
|
|
On the U.S. broadcast, they said that Eze's corner was his first of the season. Is that true? Was it his first free kick also?
If both are true, one wonders if a player has ever chalked up an assist and a goal on his first two set-piece opportunities.
|
EddieMac 07 Nov 20 7.51pm |
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
McCarthur MOTM, Riedewald, Dann, Eze and PVA not far behind.
Leeds are a great team to watch, but the arselicking of Bielsa is tedious. At this level, they are an easy team to work out and Roy masterfully did so today. We will truly see whether he is the tactical genius based on how he bounces back from this, if you don't change things up when it's clearly not working for you then you get what you deserve.
I agree. He has been battered 4-1 twice on the trot and still he doesn’t get slated for it. We live in a world where people don’t even watch teams play and have their own views they just follow the media. Leeds are a good team to watch but are far from the team some people would have us believe.
|
Phil’s Barber Crowborough 07 Nov 20 7.55pm |
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
There is scarcely a club in the Premiership that hasn't been criminally ripped off by VAR at least once since it was introduced. I agree. It is an awful and flawed system. As Mourinho said in a press conference following their game against the weed, he preferred how it was pre VAR and having seen how much damage it is doing to the game he wants to ditch it and revert to Goal Line Technology and the referee plus his (or her) two assistants.
|
kevlee born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 07 Nov 20 8.00pm |
|
|
Wilf, Eze, Jairo, Andros, great attacking potential. Why cant we do that every week? I also though Scott Dann was excellent and Clyne was 100% better than last week. Jeff Schlupp was very composed when he came on - a very experienced option off the bench. Don't change the team Roy unless you have to - although Cahill seems to be coming back - so Dann will be sacrificed? A great day and very happy!!
Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978
|
Pinkfluff1981 07 Nov 20 8.02pm |
|
|
What a difference a week makes....I’m still hoping for Roy to go, hopefully end of season when he’s surely had enough of setting up teams for defeat each week. We’ve got the players to do be dominating teams with possession and go for attacks as well. It was a good result, however I feel we did have the luck today. If it was evens on the luck then it wouldn’t have been so flattering for us. I still think we need a manager to push us forward as club and grow us into a team to play consistent football. At the moment we’re up and down. Yes we got 3 points against a Leeds team that I honestly thought would walk all over us... hang on. They did. Dominated possession, gave us a goal and if var was working would be a different result. One day we might win a match and actually sit back and say we scored some cracking goals, dominated play and looked unstoppable. Here’s hoping .
|
NEILLO Shoreham-by-Sea 07 Nov 20 8.03pm |
|
|
Roy got the team selection spot on today.
Leeds are relatively easy to play against so a good game for Eze to come into.
Yes, we had a spot of luck with the Bamford ' goal ', but the rules as they are + VAR result in breaks going for and against you. That combination is ruining the game.
Anyway, time to enjoy a Palace win and a Trump defeat - today is a good day....
Old, Ungifted and White
|
The Dolphin 07 Nov 20 8.07pm |
|
|
Dann can't play week in and out but with a break he should be fit and should start against Burnley.
Edited by The Dolphin (07 Nov 2020 8.07pm)
|
Casual Orpington 07 Nov 20 8.07pm |
|
Originally posted by kevlee
Wilf, Eze, Jairo, Andros, great attacking potential. Why cant we do that every week? I also though Scott Dann was excellent and Clyne was 100% better than last week. Jeff Schlupp was very composed when he came on - a very experienced option off the bench. Don't change the team Roy unless you have to - although Cahill seems to be coming back - so Dann will be sacrificed? A great day and very happy!!
Great result. Ayew definitely more suited to us than Batshui . Eze was great. Good overall performance, think that Clyne bottled it for their goal, should have gone through the ball , think he was worried about giving a penalty away, poor decision. 4-1, that’s a hiding.
|
PatrickA London 07 Nov 20 8.08pm |
|
|
Well it’s a game of opinions but I think we gain more than we lose through PVA’s involvement. He’s the only one of our defenders that moves forward with purpose and provides attacking impetus. He’s been with the club for a while and frankly I can’t recall him costing games through being targeted by the top teams. He occasionally makes stupid mistakes but not that many. Hodgson is not given to hyperbole and acclaims him as one of the best left backs in the division.
|
Phil’s Barber Crowborough 07 Nov 20 8.09pm |
|
|
Good to see in an improved team performance that individual performances were strong too. Clyne is improving and looking sharper and more comfortable with each game, Riedewald had another excellent game and Scott Dann was very good again. Ayew worked tirelessly and looked sharp and like Eze, his link up play with those around him was excellent. Eze looks so promising...
|
Ginger Pubic Wig Wickham de L'Ouest 07 Nov 20 8.16pm |
|
|
I have been disappointed by Clyne so far, but reckon he should now be ready to start delivering.
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.
|
Phil’s Barber Crowborough 07 Nov 20 8.18pm |
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
His arm was offside because he was pointing. The rules were followed to a tee. The stream i was watching today showed Bamford’s arm (the sleeved part of the short sleeved shirt) to be onside. I thought the new t-shirt rule meant it was only the part above the sleeve that could be adjudged to be offside?
|
kevlee born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 07 Nov 20 8.20pm |
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
I have been disappointed by Clyne so far, but reckon he should now be ready to start delivering.
His first game was a shocker and his second not much better - but there was a clear improvement today. He has still got a fair way to go - but he is improving and that's they key. He also seemed much fitter today.
Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978
|
steeleye20 Croydon 07 Nov 20 8.29pm |
|
|
Really impressed by the strength of the Palace bench.
Some very good personnel not even making it.
|
EddieMac 07 Nov 20 8.55pm |
|
Originally posted by kevlee
His first game was a shocker and his second not much better - but there was a clear improvement today. He has still got a fair way to go - but he is improving and that's they key. He also seemed much fitter today.
The bloke hadn’t played a match in a year then unexpectedly got launched into action. He deserves a lot of credit not critsim.
|
PA Bedfordshire 07 Nov 20 9.19pm |
|
Originally posted by becky
Yes, and it's a shame that that's the other 'ism that football hasn't addressed - after years of good, competant service as an assistant referee at this level, it's about time she was given the central role. She's earned it!
You’re right but it won’t happen. Apparently you have to decide whether to be a ref or an assistant ref and you don’t ever then move to other role. So no Assistant Refs will ever be actual refs (in the Premier League that is)
Edited by PA (07 Nov 2020 9.21pm)
|
BM 07 Nov 20 9.27pm |
|
|
Batshuayi is a deadly finisher but offers nothing else. Ayew is miles better and so is Benteke.
|
becky over the moon 07 Nov 20 9.28pm |
|
Originally posted by PA
You’re right but it won’t happen. Apparently you have to decide whether to be a ref or an assistant ref and you don’t ever then move to other role. So no Assistant Refs will ever be actual refs (in the Premier League that is)
Edited by PA (07 Nov 2020 9.21pm)
Hmmmm,but I'm not sure that was a choice that she was allowed to make. She referees in both the league and women's football at all levels (including internationals) so it seems it's just the Premier league that have a glass ceiling for women referees.
If it's to be broken one day, I hope that it's Sian that does it.
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers
|
BM 07 Nov 20 9.29pm |
|
Originally posted by kevlee
Wilf, Eze, Jairo, Andros, great attacking potential. Why cant we do that every week? I also though Scott Dann was excellent and Clyne was 100% better than last week. Jeff Schlupp was very composed when he came on - a very experienced option off the bench. Don't change the team Roy unless you have to - although Cahill seems to be coming back - so Dann will be sacrificed? A great day and very happy!!
Dropping Dann for Cahill would be mad. There seems to be this idea Cahill is first choice. It is based only on his past achievements. A steady option if we have injuries but that’s it.
|
Kant exeter 07 Nov 20 9.53pm |
|
|
“Football is dead. Cricket is my number 1 now.”
Cricket has had its equivalent of VAR for years and works well because the laws are sensible. 90% of the criticism directed at VAR is actually misdirected. VAR upholds the laws, and it’s the laws that most people don’t like. The laws say you are offside if your arm is off. The laws say it’s handball if the ball hits your arm unintentionally. Change the laws, not VAR. And by the way, if we did ditch VAR, imagine the outcry the next time we conceded a goal that was clearly offside, or conceded a penalty to an obvious dive or had a goal ruled out quite unfairly.
|