You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Manchester City v Palace Match Thread
November 16 2026 5.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Manchester City v Palace Match Thread


Page 13 of 18 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >
Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 17 Jan 21 10.59pm

Originally posted by Willo

Including the goalkeeper 9 of the 11 starting eleven were either in their 30s or going to be 30 this year.
Having to cover spaces and compete against a Man C team who move the ball so well is energy sapping.
Once we got the ball we couldn't get up the pitch and it really was like a training session for Man C.Our players must have been totally fatigued at the end of the game.

Edited by Willo (17 Jan 2021 10.43pm)

Worrying times. I’m hoping that Meyer has been moved out so that we can get a more dynamic midfield player in this window.

We don’t have the players at the moment to player further up the pitch either from a midfield or defensive perspective.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 17 Jan 21 11.04pm

This game was proof that a team full of "elderly statesmen" is not enough to keep us in PL. And Ward, MacArthur, Cahill, McCarty, Ayew is not getting younger. Please, please start introducing some younger players to the team - this dross will not carry us much longer.
Still, if we can win 4 of the last 19 games we ought to stay up. but my dearest these Hodgson tactics make you little to be proud of.
And as someone pointed out -most of the City goals were due to simple mistakes on our part. What was Townsend thinking when he just let Gundogan in for the second, MacArthurs cross that was picked up for the first, and Luka gave away a corner after his own passing mistake? Not to mention McCarty and that stupid push for the 4th?

 

thosewerethedays Flag Taba 17 Jan 21 11.06pm

I fell asleep

 


Bring back The HF!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Jan 21 11.09pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Worrying times. I’m hoping that Meyer has been moved out so that we can get a more dynamic midfield player in this window.

We don’t have the players at the moment to player further up the pitch either from a midfield or defensive perspective.

I have repeatedly referred to our aged squad as 'Dad's Army' and it contains players who are in the 'Twilight' of their careers and past their best.
Overall I don't hold it in as high a regard as perhaps many of our supporters.

I have had conversations with many who are not supporters and many have raised eyebrows at my judgement.
They have uttered words along the lines of "You have Sakho, Benteke, Batshuayi, Milivojevic, Townsend" etc etc. I then have to inform them that some of the players they mention are certainly NOT the players they were in their pomp.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Jan 21 11.16pm

Originally posted by thai-eagle

This game was proof that a team full of "elderly statesmen" is not enough to keep us in PL. And Ward, MacArthur, Cahill, McCarty, Ayew is not getting younger. Please, please start introducing some younger players to the team - this dross will not carry us much longer.
Still, if we can win 4 of the last 19 games we ought to stay up. but my dearest these Hodgson tactics make you little to be proud of.
And as someone pointed out -most of the City goals were due to simple mistakes on our part. What was Townsend thinking when he just let Gundogan in for the second, MacArthurs cross that was picked up for the first, and Luka gave away a corner after his own passing mistake? Not to mention McCarty and that stupid push for the 4th?

I keep mentioning about the aged squad, and the fact that their physicality will be tested even more this unusual season.
Players in the 'Twilight' of their careers are more susceptible to injury and injuries take longer to heal than they once did earlier in their careers.

I have been deeply concerned about our prospects this season but I suppose I have been dismissed as a doom monger spouting more abject negativity!

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 17 Jan 21 11.35pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Hahahaha, yes you’ve proved that many times with some of your comments. Hilarious.

I like fishing as well. seems I've landed one'

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

YoDougie Flag London 17 Jan 21 11.39pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

You missed the part where he said it’d be naive of him to think we’d pick up points against Arsenal and City.

I’ve read the transcript of his post match and I think it’s a disgrace, might not be the only one.

This reflects in his pre-match interviews too, having given glowing compliments for the opposition and opposition managers (Arteta especially the other day) - in addition to his remarks about how talented and brilliant John Stones is after the game today.

I do believe we should always show respect to the opponent, but Roy is basically delivering the motivation and belief to the other side to come out and beat us.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 18 Jan 21 12.07am

Message to SP. Steve why did you buy the silly old buzzard a quality young player like Eze. You knew he would knock all the flair out of him didnt you? We need two or three more like this boy to start going anywhere but please dont buy them for Roy because they would be on the bench at best

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 18 Jan 21 3.19am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

I like fishing as well. seems I've landed one'

Wayne Hennessey went fishing once.

He didnt catch anything.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Sherlock II Flag The Big Mango 18 Jan 21 4.53am

Originally posted by adelaar

Forget tonight. They are so many levels above us it's untrue.
West Ham and Wolves home next two. Need a win in one of those games and we are fine.
Let's all be realistic, we have a chronic lack of investment and the squad is old. I'm glad Roy said Wilf had a 'knock' we need him for the next two important games. Finishing 13th and above this season is success.
Don't like it? Support someone else.


Spot on. Many slow moving, slow reacting, Championship level players on their last legs. It's like trying to keep a worn out old banger running.

 


Originally Sherlock, the Holmesdale Online class Of 2001

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 18 Jan 21 6.07am

Originally posted by YoDougie

This reflects in his pre-match interviews too, having given glowing compliments for the opposition and opposition managers (Arteta especially the other day) - in addition to his remarks about how talented and brilliant John Stones is after the game today.

I do believe we should always show respect to the opponent, but Roy is basically delivering the motivation and belief to the other side to come out and beat us.

Agreed. Why not negotiate before the game to give them the 3 points and not bother to play so to save us fans the trouble, time and anguish?

 

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 18 Jan 21 6.15am

Originally posted by Sherlock II


Spot on. Many slow moving, slow reacting, Championship level players on their last legs. It's like trying to keep a worn out old banger running.

I SUPPORT PALACE. Finishing 11th or lower this season is Hodgeson type failure. Get some ambition man, and stop making excuses for privileged incompetence!!

 

BelfastEagle Flag 18 Jan 21 7.28am

Originally posted by Brinscalleagle2

Ok so we lost against a team far far superior to us in all respects. However what I saw was every member of our team doing their best and working extremely hard. The fact is we are nowhere near good enough to beat a team like CITEH playing the way they are. So let’s all chill out and save our criticism for when we lose to a team we have a chance of beating. COYP

This is the same world beating city team that managed to just overwhelm Brighton 1 0 in their previous game ?

The difference was that Brighton actually tried to have a go with more possession and shots.

However the game was effectively lost when Zaha didn’t play.


 

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 18 Jan 21 8.14am

Originally posted by BelfastEagle

This is the same world beating city team that managed to just overwhelm Brighton 1 0 in their previous game ?

The difference was that Brighton actually tried to have a go with more possession and shots.

However the game was effectively lost when Zaha didn’t play.


Man City were far more wasteful against Brighton, De Bruyne missed to far easier chancers then the goals yesterday before Foden score they then missed more in the second including the penatalty. Could easily have beaten Brighton 4-0.
To be fair to Brighton they hold on to the ball well so usually compete better with the bigger teams/ They don't create chances though and have drawn at home with both Sheff united and West Brom so so do we really want to follow their tactics?

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

Den1923 Flag 18 Jan 21 8.18am

Originally posted by Helmet46

He’s a good keeper but the panic within the team rubs off. It was the same problem Butland had at Stoke.

and they got relegated!

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 18 Jan 21 8.21am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Wayne Hennessey went fishing once.

He didnt catch anything.

He landed a history lesson

 

Aray Flag South London 18 Jan 21 8.23am

Why did I waste my evening watching that?
Was that another game without any shots on target?
With how many millions of striker talent on the bench?

Brighton lost to these guys 1-0
Similar story with Liverpool.

Yes we were always likely to lose without Wilf and the team were tired after the draw v Arsenal but we have become the club that good teams play to sort out their goal difference. It is worse than Pulis. Hyperbole? Remember he had very little talent in that team.

I've gone from anger to resignation. It is clear what is needed. Because of the weakness of the bottom 3 teams we'll probably avoid relegation battle this season. Problem is - a new squad AND a new manager is risky - but actually an opportunity. Which we will probably stuff up!

COYP!

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 18 Jan 21 8.26am

I see our players observed the social distancing rules last night so nothing for the PL bosses to worry about.

We never got near the City players.

Edited by Badger11 (18 Jan 2021 9.34am)

 


One more point

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 18 Jan 21 8.36am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Fvck the tactics all I saw was a group of players that were old, tired and couldn’t compete.

The last time we kept trying to go at a team of that level we conceded seven.

The plan would be to try to stay in it until the last ten and try to nick something. No more no less. Townsend’s mistake and Gundogan’s strike put an end to that. Once they’ve got the pressure off they’ll kill you.


Yep. Realistically with the resources we have available (even if that included Wilf and Schlupp) the best we could expect after the first half was to stay in the game as long as possible and hope to get a chance to score.

Yes we got results here the last two years but our squad (as Willo regularly reminds us) is ageing and creaking and that's NOT Hodgson's fault.

Also, for those who were asking why we didn't have any youngsters on the bench, I would say again:
- the U18s played on Saturday
- the U23s are playing at 1.00pm today.
Consequently, the likes of Pierrick, Banks, Woods and Matthews etc are better employed consolidating the clubs position in their new leagues.

The next 7 games are the ones that really matter - not last night's.

Finally, when asked what he put the performance down to, Pep answered quite simply "the quality of the players". Exactly.

Edited by doombear (18 Jan 2021 8.39am)

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 18 Jan 21 8.58am

Originally posted by Ketteridge

Man City were far more wasteful against Brighton, De Bruyne missed to far easier chancers then the goals yesterday before Foden score they then missed more in the second including the penatalty. Could easily have beaten Brighton 4-0.
To be fair to Brighton they hold on to the ball well so usually compete better with the bigger teams/ They don't create chances though and have drawn at home with both Sheff united and West Brom so so do we really want to follow their tactics?

I would of loved us to play last night the way Brighton did at Man City. They actually held the ball well and passed to their own players unlike us last night. Appreciate at this time we have more points than Brighton but the set up last night which wasn’t totally wrong was spoiled by our players making mistakes and the inability to be able to pass a ball to a fellow player. We used to be able to play like Brighton against the bigger teams but alas our ageing players can’t do it anymore. Sadly Brighton will eventually finish above us this season in my opinion unless we bring in a couple of younger quality midfielders and push up the field a bit further so that they support the forward play as well as the defence?

 

Page 13 of 18 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Manchester City v Palace Match Thread