You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Luton vs Crystal Palace match thread
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Luton vs Crystal Palace match thread


Page 13 of 16 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >
eaglesdare Flag 26 Nov 23 1.47pm

Palace...ruining weekends since 1861. Yet I still can't wait for our next game.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 26 Nov 23 1.48pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

Palace...ruining weekends since 1861. Yet I still can't wait for our next game.

LOL

 


One more point

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 26 Nov 23 2.39pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Have you considered that they might be under instruction from the manager not to venture too far forward too often? Roy does love his defensive "shape".

Doucoure had shown very little IMO when asked the question in the final third under Vieira and had lost his way by the time PV was sacked.

He's played 45 games and not managed a single goal. Lerma's obviously has had fewer games but his stats around attacking / team play aren't exactly inspiring.

Don't get me wrong they're solid defensively but it's rather like just having two more defenders.

The goals and guile have to come from somewhere and it feels a bit like we have another situation where we have a huge over reliance on a bit of magic from one or two players.


 

Jacey Flag 26 Nov 23 2.47pm

Extremely disappointing result losing to a very poor Luton side,who are best suited to the Championship at best.
We are surely better than this.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 26 Nov 23 3.01pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

The biggest worry for me with the way this season is going is not relegation. It is the fact that all our star players will want to leave because of the lack of progress.

I am not one to slate Roy all the time but what in the name of god was he doing dropping Ayew yesterday and playing Schlupp. Ayew has been close to our best player this season. He did the same with Doucoure at Everton. He is making big decisions and they are wrong.

Edited by EddieMac (26 Nov 2023 1.36pm)

Ayew had a long and arduous journey returning from International Duty. Therefore he started on the bench.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 26 Nov 23 3.18pm

It’s all just v depressing I’ve just seen Olise’s goal - fantastic. Yet for the second week in a row we couldn’t keep out a team - with not much real attacking threat - for the last ten minutes and see the game out. Sort it out Roy that’s your job and what you talk about all the time.

 

EddieMac Flag 26 Nov 23 3.54pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Ayew had a long and arduous journey returning from International Duty. Therefore he started on the bench.

Still no excuse to play Schlupp ahead of him. Schlupp is diabolical.

 

Far away fan Flag On the border of jungle 26 Nov 23 4.12pm

This year I say , Ray is not assistant manager, Palace will struggle to stay up , Crazy Parish has a idea well it will not work.

 

PatrickA Flag London 26 Nov 23 5.19pm

I'm normally the last person to defend Roy, but what options does he have as the side virtually picks itself?
For example,I would contend that a choice between Ward and Clyne or Mateta and Edouard or Hughes/Schlupp/Lerma is unlikely to be game changing.
The centre backs, keeper and left back pick themselves (in the absence of competition for Mitchell).
Roy has already given an indication that he doesn't believe the young players are ready, and I trust his judgement on this.
That being said, if Eze and Doucoure are out I hope Ahamada gets a chance to offer something different from midfield.

We finished last season well, even without Zaha, and this has possibly led to some complacency from the board around the need for strengthening.
This has come back to bite us.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Nov 23 5.28pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

I'm normally the last person to defend Roy, but what options does he have as the side virtually picks itself?
For example,I would contend that a choice between Ward and Clyne or Mateta and Edouard or Hughes/Schlupp/Lerma is unlikely to be game changing.
The centre backs, keeper and left back pick themselves (in the absence of competition for Mitchell).
Roy has already given an indication that he doesn't believe the young players are ready, and I trust his judgement on this.
That being said, if Eze and Doucoure are out I hope Ahamada gets a chance to offer something different from midfield.

We finished last season well, even without Zaha, and this has possibly led to some complacency from the board around the need for strengthening.
This has come back to bite us.

I garland these salient comments with concurrence.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 26 Nov 23 5.33pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

I'm normally the last person to defend Roy, but what options does he have as the side virtually picks itself?
For example,I would contend that a choice between Ward and Clyne or Mateta and Edouard or Hughes/Schlupp/Lerma is unlikely to be game changing.
The centre backs, keeper and left back pick themselves (in the absence of competition for Mitchell).
Roy has already given an indication that he doesn't believe the young players are ready, and I trust his judgement on this.
That being said, if Eze and Doucoure are out I hope Ahamada gets a chance to offer something different from midfield.

We finished last season well, even without Zaha, and this has possibly led to some complacency from the board around the need for strengthening.
This has come back to bite us.

Coaching, watching them day in day out. Thinking about how Luton might play against us. Thinking we have weaknesses at FB and how to mitigate that (against Luton FFS). Analysing what went wrong against Everton. Fixing it. Having a plan B.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 26 Nov 23 5.59pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

Palace...ruining weekends since 1861. Yet I still can't wait for our next game.

Is a never ending nightmare. I might support a League One team next season instead, preferably a London based one, like Millwall or Chelsea.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

PatrickA Flag London 26 Nov 23 6.07pm

The purpose of my post was to highlight the limited choice of players and options available to Roy.
It would certainly be difficult to highlight a player that is screaming to be included yet is being left out by Roy.
As regards his coaching methods and preparation for games, that is another matter.
But I doubt even Pep would be able to make Ward any faster, Edouard more aggressive, Hughes anything other than one paced or indeed instill more pace throughout the team.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 26 Nov 23 6.10pm

Originally posted by Davepalace707

Coaching, watching them day in day out. Thinking about how Luton might play against us. Thinking we have weaknesses at FB and how to mitigate that (against Luton FFS). Analysing what went wrong against Everton. Fixing it. Having a plan B.

I’m inclined to agree Dave. Watched the entirety of both Everton and Luton games and unless you hold the belief a manager’s role begins and ends at just picking XI each week, there’s much to poke holes in.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Den1923 Flag 26 Nov 23 7.18pm

We have to be realistic, the current squad has circa 6/7 who you could say are EPL quality. The balance for the starting 11 has to be picked from a bunch of players who are at best championship quality, younger player who have no experience in the lower league, or sick notes. If your core 6/7 get injured then your in even deeper brown stuff. Roy's hands are really limited because of poor transfer activity, Parish and his fellow directors are the problem they want to be in the EPL but they just do not want to spend the cash to do it and if the do spend, then, they make bad transfer decisions by signing players we don't need. This may well end badly!

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 26 Nov 23 7.33pm

Originally posted by Den1923

We have to be realistic, the current squad has circa 6/7 who you could say are EPL quality. The balance for the starting 11 has to be picked from a bunch of players who are at best championship quality, younger player who have no experience in the lower league, or sick notes. If your core 6/7 get injured then your in even deeper brown stuff. Roy's hands are really limited because of poor transfer activity, Parish and his fellow directors are the problem they want to be in the EPL but they just do not want to spend the cash to do it and if the do spend, then, they make bad transfer decisions by signing players we don't need. This may well end badly!

The crux of it, yes.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 26 Nov 23 7.44pm

Originally posted by Den1923

We have to be realistic, the current squad has circa 6/7 who you could say are EPL quality. The balance for the starting 11 has to be picked from a bunch of players who are at best championship quality, younger player who have no experience in the lower league, or sick notes. If your core 6/7 get injured then your in even deeper brown stuff. Roy's hands are really limited because of poor transfer activity, Parish and his fellow directors are the problem they want to be in the EPL but they just do not want to spend the cash to do it and if the do spend, then, they make bad transfer decisions by signing players we don't need. This may well end badly!

When you consider it, we could require at least four or five good signings next summer. That seems almost out of our reach. We're going to have to sell someone to fund it. We will then need to replace them too. The crux time is next season but mainly the summer transfer window. We need (require - not hope for) a right back, a left back, a left winger, a striker. Possibly we could get someone with versatility so they can play left or right. A winger/ inside forward perhaps.
Doucoure unlikely now with injury, so one of Olise, Guehi, Andersen, Eze needs to be sold. It's not looking crazy likely that any of Rak-Sakyi, Franca or Ahamada will be ready. Richards is a possible replacement but Tomkins even Holding not really. Enough said about Reidewald.
So big decisions await. Maybe we'll get a decent loan or even signing in January but I won't be holding my breath.

 


Red and Blue Army!

XKudu Flag The Midlands, England 26 Nov 23 7.50pm

Keep positive lads. The pain passes and we’ll fight again.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 26 Nov 23 9.46pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

When you consider it, we could require at least four or five good signings next summer. That seems almost out of our reach. We're going to have to sell someone to fund it. We will then need to replace them too. The crux time is next season but mainly the summer transfer window. We need (require - not hope for) a right back, a left back, a left winger, a striker. Possibly we could get someone with versatility so they can play left or right. A winger/ inside forward perhaps.
Doucoure unlikely now with injury, so one of Olise, Guehi, Andersen, Eze needs to be sold. It's not looking crazy likely that any of Rak-Sakyi, Franca or Ahamada will be ready. Richards is a possible replacement but Tomkins even Holding not really. Enough said about Reidewald.
So big decisions await. Maybe we'll get a decent loan or even signing in January but I won't be holding my breath.

And that's without factoring in the cost of the stadium redevelopment !

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 26 Nov 23 10.16pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

1. Wrong. In fact he would be a lot wealthier had he not sold his stake in GAC.

2. What do you define as '' world level '' then ? Are the Brentford and Brighton owners that ??

Then your other comments ;

Look at the players Roy was forced to put in before because he had no other option and they put in performances Mitchell was one of them so was a right back we received 50m for from United remember him.

Riedewald as well when had a chance left back looked very good even won player of month straight away dumped.

I see you are another jumping on the negative Edouard bandwagon yet what is his return rate this season so far for goals 5 goals out of 12 appa how is that poor for a team which is not great at creating plus if you work it out based on current rate he would hit 14 goals come end of the season that is a good return.

Roy has one way of doing things this is the issue and why we always struggle against teams we should either be beating or drawing with.

1. I stand by what I said. Hodgson isn't being forced to play Richards at right back while Ward and Clyne are available. So you have to assume that he doesn't rate him in that position.

2. Riedewald - good technique but too one paced. I don't see him as worthy of a left back position.

3. I'm not jumping on any negative Edouard bandwagon given that my view of him hasn't changed in the last 18 months. Agreed his goal return this season looks impressive. When he doesn't score, he contributes virtually nothing. It's going back a bit, but you may remember a player called Ian Rush who scored goals for fun but was also described as Liverpool's first line of defence. Edouard was described as '' timid '' in a write in The Times and that sums him up.

4. We all know that Roy has his methods. Like them or not, they get the results he needs to achieve his objectives.

1. complete nonsense you really need to do your home work. (Simon Jordan has more wealth when compared to Steve Parish who couldn't even afford to buy Palace himself this is when the club was not even worth hardly anything later on had to bring Americans in because again he couldn't fund it)

As I said he has made his most wealth from Palace which is true.

2. you are being stupid now commercial wise what has he done for the palace brand on a world scale nothing they do not even have distribution of merchandise.

How can you rate people without giving them game time.

I never said he should put Richards are right back.

You have missed the point about Riedewald he was a different player back then and Roy wanted him to change which he has now he is useless (You are being very selective with what you are seeing remove rose tinted specs)

Yes you are you said Ed was useless etc yet as i clearly showed how is 5 goals in 12 useless return for a team which creates very little and the season before people praised Wilf yet if you work out minutes to goals he was better again people moaning about him.

You clearly do not even watch the games.

Roy gets results how about these results lost to Everton and now Luton yes great results.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Page 13 of 16 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Luton vs Crystal Palace match thread