You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 22 2026 3.02am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

ukip (LOCKED)


Page 130 of 187 < 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 >
legaleagle Flag 15 Mar 15 9.04pm

Quote TheJudge at 15 Mar 2015 6.35pm

Quote legaleagle at 12 Mar 2015 12.46am

Quote TheJudge at 11 Mar 2015 2.03pm

Quote ghosteagle at 11 Mar 2015 1.02pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 Mar 2015 10.58am

Quote TheJudge at 10 Mar 2015 9.52pm

i See this thread is rolling on with the usual pro immigration propaganda.

There is a large towns worth of people coming here each year net and yet we have a massive housing shortage that the left bang on about. How is this good ?
We have Eastern European criminals hiding in Britain to avoid capture. How is this good ?

We have various religions and ideologies that have hated each other for hundreds of years now hating each other in Britain as well and preaching the politics of division. Then we have our own right wing idiots hating them all on top of that. How is this good ?

No, the only people who are happy are the business man and those who fly the flag of the rainbow nation despite the fact that the human race clearly has not evolved anything like enough to make it work.

So tell me why totally uncontrolled mass immigration is good for the average man in Britain again ? I can't remember.


Exactly.

The left keep pushing the economic argument and ignore or play down the effect on our infrastructure.

They will only call a halt to immigration when our water supply fails to cope with demand.... or will they?

Silly season already?

Presumably you still believe the spin.

Let me ask you how you think anyone can quantify financial benefit from immigration figures which are not measured properly ?

That would be a good trick.


Very few statistics,whether on immigration or anything else, are perfect but they can certainly be capable of indicating what the general situation is. Allowing for that,governments etc work on what they can for planning etc all the time.

As an example,statistics on Brits living in the EU. There's a lower statistic based on Brits being defined as people born here,and a higher one if Brits are defined as people holding British nationality.But,both stats aren't 100% due to those Brits living in the EU no stats pick up.Does that mean the statistics are not of some use as an indicator? Absolutely not.

It applies equally to statistics used to suggest a conclusion of overall pluses or minuses over immigration,so if you want to say the stats you criticise are useless because they are not 100% exact as indicators,it may well be that some of those that have helped shape your thinking are equally invalid (or valid) as a general indicator.

So,of course someone can quantify financial benefits based on statistics that may not be exactly perfect and it can usefully indicate the general nature of any financial benefits arising.If you are on a genuine quest to assess the statistical methodology used in the UCL study indicating significant financial benefits with an open mind,I think I posted a link to the report itself back on this thread somewhere or I can PM you one and you can examine their statistical and research methodology directly.If you think any input is too high or low, you can do a rough tweak to the outcome accordingly,and assess whether financial benefits remain generally positive.but be sure to adjust everything relevant not just a particular input or outcome that supports your point of view.

As for spin, it is hardly something confined to any one particular point of view. The same applies to "closed minds".

IMO our water supply is most likely to fail due to chronic under investment in new mains/pipes etc over the past 100 years plus,just like our sewage system in London.


Edited by legaleagle (12 Mar 2015 1.20am)

There is a wonderful irony in this post.

Since we are all told tha immigration is "good" for the country. What possible data can be used to confirm this when the data is totally inadequate ? Data is either reliable or it is not.
The ideat that financial is the defining factor to how "good" it is a deplorable idea anyway.

Has anyone stopped to consider just how much of our "bad" news these days is directly related to migrants or the offspring of migrants? It's the old adage that people always blame the foreigner but sometimes the truth is what it is and all the spin in the world can't change that.

And the last part of this post about the water system is typical of the pro immigration lobby.
Firstly. how can you invest or plan for something when you have no idea what capacity will be required ? Immigration numbers are increasing all the time.
And how is it possible for supposedly intelligent not to see that if more and more people want a slice of your cake, then you need a bigger cake. Britain's services, jobs and housing are creaking under the strain and I haven't even started on terrorism or crime.


Edited by TheJudge (15 Mar 2015 6.37pm)

Edited by TheJudge (15 Mar 2015 6.38pm)


Yes,but what is ironic is that the same argument applies just as much in relation to any data (let alone stories in the popular press) showing immigration is bad.

You go on to compound that irony by then seeking yourself to rely on "bad news" about immigrants as being a legitimate factor to draw conclusions from. Since when is the UK popular press coverage the basis for legitimate statistical analysis?

You believe immigration is responsible for many woes.You are perfectly entitled to that opinion Judge.I don't share it,whether generally or in relation to water provision/sewerage provision.Of course,numbers must be an element in planning.But that does not in itself enable a legitimate conclusion to be drawn that the main problem re for example water or sewerage provision relates to immigrants.

And in case you should stereotype me,I am not against immigration controls in principle if fair and non discriminatory re non EU nationals.Indeed, we have had controls in place for many many years.People overlook what a high proportion of overall immigration this accounts for. In relation to the EU,I believe freedom of movement of labour goes along with freedom of movement of goods and services.Further,that overall the benefits of EU membership outweigh the negatives.You can't have your cake and eat it.Don't throw the baby out with the bath water since IMO economically ,despite what the nostalgia dreamers say, we'd be fcuk-ed overall out of the EU.

But,as to your proposition that immigration is responsible for our ills ,including crime etc, no I have to completely disagree with you.Its exactly what they said about Jewish immigration 100-120 years ago and about immigrants from Asia and the West Indies 40-60 years ago.Same arguments then as now. The real cause of our problems is elsewhere, and "divide and rule" so people scapegoat groups at the bottom of the pile is as old as the hills.

 

TheJudge Flag 16 Mar 15 12.16pm

Quote legaleagle at 15 Mar 2015 9.04pm

Quote TheJudge at 15 Mar 2015 6.35pm

Quote legaleagle at 12 Mar 2015 12.46am

Quote TheJudge at 11 Mar 2015 2.03pm

Quote ghosteagle at 11 Mar 2015 1.02pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 Mar 2015 10.58am

Quote TheJudge at 10 Mar 2015 9.52pm

i See this thread is rolling on with the usual pro immigration propaganda.

There is a large towns worth of people coming here each year net and yet we have a massive housing shortage that the left bang on about. How is this good ?
We have Eastern European criminals hiding in Britain to avoid capture. How is this good ?

We have various religions and ideologies that have hated each other for hundreds of years now hating each other in Britain as well and preaching the politics of division. Then we have our own right wing idiots hating them all on top of that. How is this good ?

No, the only people who are happy are the business man and those who fly the flag of the rainbow nation despite the fact that the human race clearly has not evolved anything like enough to make it work.

So tell me why totally uncontrolled mass immigration is good for the average man in Britain again ? I can't remember.


Exactly.

The left keep pushing the economic argument and ignore or play down the effect on our infrastructure.

They will only call a halt to immigration when our water supply fails to cope with demand.... or will they?

Silly season already?

Presumably you still believe the spin.

Let me ask you how you think anyone can quantify financial benefit from immigration figures which are not measured properly ?

That would be a good trick.


Very few statistics,whether on immigration or anything else, are perfect but they can certainly be capable of indicating what the general situation is. Allowing for that,governments etc work on what they can for planning etc all the time.

As an example,statistics on Brits living in the EU. There's a lower statistic based on Brits being defined as people born here,and a higher one if Brits are defined as people holding British nationality.But,both stats aren't 100% due to those Brits living in the EU no stats pick up.Does that mean the statistics are not of some use as an indicator? Absolutely not.

It applies equally to statistics used to suggest a conclusion of overall pluses or minuses over immigration,so if you want to say the stats you criticise are useless because they are not 100% exact as indicators,it may well be that some of those that have helped shape your thinking are equally invalid (or valid) as a general indicator.

So,of course someone can quantify financial benefits based on statistics that may not be exactly perfect and it can usefully indicate the general nature of any financial benefits arising.If you are on a genuine quest to assess the statistical methodology used in the UCL study indicating significant financial benefits with an open mind,I think I posted a link to the report itself back on this thread somewhere or I can PM you one and you can examine their statistical and research methodology directly.If you think any input is too high or low, you can do a rough tweak to the outcome accordingly,and assess whether financial benefits remain generally positive.but be sure to adjust everything relevant not just a particular input or outcome that supports your point of view.

As for spin, it is hardly something confined to any one particular point of view. The same applies to "closed minds".

IMO our water supply is most likely to fail due to chronic under investment in new mains/pipes etc over the past 100 years plus,just like our sewage system in London.


Edited by legaleagle (12 Mar 2015 1.20am)

There is a wonderful irony in this post.

Since we are all told tha immigration is "good" for the country. What possible data can be used to confirm this when the data is totally inadequate ? Data is either reliable or it is not.
The ideat that financial is the defining factor to how "good" it is a deplorable idea anyway.

Has anyone stopped to consider just how much of our "bad" news these days is directly related to migrants or the offspring of migrants? It's the old adage that people always blame the foreigner but sometimes the truth is what it is and all the spin in the world can't change that.

And the last part of this post about the water system is typical of the pro immigration lobby.
Firstly. how can you invest or plan for something when you have no idea what capacity will be required ? Immigration numbers are increasing all the time.
And how is it possible for supposedly intelligent not to see that if more and more people want a slice of your cake, then you need a bigger cake. Britain's services, jobs and housing are creaking under the strain and I haven't even started on terrorism or crime.


Edited by TheJudge (15 Mar 2015 6.37pm)

Edited by TheJudge (15 Mar 2015 6.38pm)


Yes,but what is ironic is that the same argument applies just as much in relation to any data (let alone stories in the popular press) showing immigration is bad.

You go on to compound that irony by then seeking yourself to rely on "bad news" about immigrants as being a legitimate factor to draw conclusions from. Since when is the UK popular press coverage the basis for legitimate statistical analysis?

You believe immigration is responsible for many woes.You are perfectly entitled to that opinion Judge.I don't share it,whether generally or in relation to water provision/sewerage provision.Of course,numbers must be an element in planning.But that does not in itself enable a legitimate conclusion to be drawn that the main problem re for example water or sewerage provision relates to immigrants.

And in case you should stereotype me,I am not against immigration controls in principle if fair and non discriminatory re non EU nationals.Indeed, we have had controls in place for many many years.People overlook what a high proportion of overall immigration this accounts for. In relation to the EU,I believe freedom of movement of labour goes along with freedom of movement of goods and services.Further,that overall the benefits of EU membership outweigh the negatives.You can't have your cake and eat it.Don't throw the baby out with the bath water since IMO economically ,despite what the nostalgia dreamers say, we'd be fcuk-ed overall out of the EU.

But,as to your proposition that immigration is responsible for our ills ,including crime etc, no I have to completely disagree with you.Its exactly what they said about Jewish immigration 100-120 years ago and about immigrants from Asia and the West Indies 40-60 years ago.Same arguments then as now. The real cause of our problems is elsewhere, and "divide and rule" so people scapegoat groups at the bottom of the pile is as old as the hills.


And what exactly would that be ?

It seems to me that people have never wanted streams of foreigners coming into their neighbourhoods. Some have been born into that world and see it as the norm. Some older people still find it very hard to accept the changes that have taken place.
Back in the sixties when immigration was starting to accelerate, the likes of Griffiths tried to represent his constituents who did not want the problems associated with migrants to effect their area. Harold Wilson, one of the most cynical politicians ever, used the situation for political gain and even used a well known actor to run for the seat. He used the whole "race" issue as a political vehicle while accusing the Tory of the very same. Politics has remained in that mode ever since, using race as a political football when in reality race has nothing to do with it. Only far right idiots,self interest groups, including ethnic minorities and politicians talk about race. The rest of us have either been brainwashed by left wing propaganda or are just concerned by the practical issues that effect the local areas and the country with regard to large amounts of migrants coming here to settle.
There has been no attempt to be honest in this debate as politicians try to secure the White middle England and the ethnic vote.

 

reborn 16 Mar 15 12.46pm

I read today that UKIP want to bar children of immigrants from State Schools for 5 years?

Whilst there is a plausible case for controlling immigration, this smacks of apartheid by another name.

Lunacy.

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

TheJudge Flag 16 Mar 15 2.32pm

Quote reborn at 16 Mar 2015 12.46pm

I read today that UKIP want to bar children of immigrants from State Schools for 5 years?

Whilst there is a plausible case for controlling immigration, this smacks of apartheid by another name.

Lunacy.


How is that apartheid ? Many immigrants are white.

I don't know the sense of such a policy or even if UKIP have even really proposed it but people have to draw a distinction between race issues and immigration issues.
For sure a persons culture or religion might make integration difficult or near impossible but that is a seperate issue from numbers and pressure on services.

Edited by TheJudge (16 Mar 2015 2.32pm)

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 16 Mar 15 6.22pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 2.32pm

Quote reborn at 16 Mar 2015 12.46pm

I read today that UKIP want to bar children of immigrants from State Schools for 5 years?

Whilst there is a plausible case for controlling immigration, this smacks of apartheid by another name.

Lunacy.


How is that apartheid ? Many immigrants are white.

I don't know the sense of such a policy or even if UKIP have even really proposed it but people have to draw a distinction between race issues and immigration issues.
For sure a persons culture or religion might make integration difficult or near impossible but that is a seperate issue from numbers and pressure on services.

Edited by TheJudge (16 Mar 2015 2.32pm)

I think that shows your own prejudices as apartheid is not colour driven by definition.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Mar 15 6.48pm

Quote pefwin at 16 Mar 2015 6.22pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 2.32pm

Quote reborn at 16 Mar 2015 12.46pm

I read today that UKIP want to bar children of immigrants from State Schools for 5 years?

Whilst there is a plausible case for controlling immigration, this smacks of apartheid by another name.

Lunacy.


How is that apartheid ? Many immigrants are white.

I don't know the sense of such a policy or even if UKIP have even really proposed it but people have to draw a distinction between race issues and immigration issues.
For sure a persons culture or religion might make integration difficult or near impossible but that is a seperate issue from numbers and pressure on services.

Edited by TheJudge (16 Mar 2015 2.32pm)

I think that shows your own prejudices as apartheid is not colour driven by definition.


The only ever time that the word apartheid has been used to describe a political system was for describing a colour based system.

It isn't an unreasonable point to make.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

TheJudge Flag 16 Mar 15 7.34pm

Quote pefwin at 16 Mar 2015 6.22pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 2.32pm

Quote reborn at 16 Mar 2015 12.46pm

I read today that UKIP want to bar children of immigrants from State Schools for 5 years?

Whilst there is a plausible case for controlling immigration, this smacks of apartheid by another name.

Lunacy.


How is that apartheid ? Many immigrants are white.

I don't know the sense of such a policy or even if UKIP have even really proposed it but people have to draw a distinction between race issues and immigration issues.
For sure a persons culture or religion might make integration difficult or near impossible but that is a seperate issue from numbers and pressure on services.

Edited by TheJudge (16 Mar 2015 2.32pm)

I think that shows your own prejudices as apartheid is not colour driven by definition.

I'm not sure what prejudice yo think that would be but I understand your concern about such a system.

I would point out that if immigration had not been forced on the existing population and in such large numbers, no resentment or issue with the numbers using local services would exist.
In short the government and the EU between them have created this problem and they now want to blame people and call them names when they point this out.

There is a need for freedom of movement across borders but the numbers and the character of the migrant has to be controlled and assessed. The current system is uncontrolled and designed to suppress wage increases.
As a bi product we also now have a country filling up with cultures and religious factions that are ideologically opposed to each other and they will now continue their ridiculous conflicts in Britain.

 

legaleagle Flag 16 Mar 15 8.02pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 2.32pm

Quote reborn at 16 Mar 2015 12.46pm

I read today that UKIP want to bar children of immigrants from State Schools for 5 years?

Whilst there is a plausible case for controlling immigration, this smacks of apartheid by another name.

Lunacy.


How is that apartheid ? Many immigrants are white.

I don't know the sense of such a policy or even if UKIP have even really proposed it but people have to draw a distinction between race issues and immigration issues.
For sure a persons culture or religion might make integration difficult or near impossible but that is a seperate issue from numbers and pressure on services.

Edited by TheJudge (16 Mar 2015 2.32pm)

I agree that,for example,being averse to an influx of people of differing ethnicity or alternatively a plain averseness to numbers of immigrants with ethnicity not entering a person's thoughts in any way as in your expressed case, does not necessarily make someone a racist since,in the former case, ethnicity is based on a number of things other than race and race may not come into differing ethnicity at all.

I also do wonder how many of the people who don't like numbers of immigrants coming to live near them would feel exactly the same if the same numbers of immigrants were arriving but solely from Canada,New Zealand and Australia...

Apartheid,literally meaning "apartness" and the policy of "Separate Development" in South Africa, was of course premised on race in South Africa but in terms of the non-white parts of the community also involved seeking to create separate sub-groups,individual homelands for "separate" ethnic/tribal groups. All in all,people living "apart" with separate and differentiated access to things legally.

So,not that unreasonable to draw a general parallel between any proposed (if proposed) policies of "separate access" to things within the UK for different groups legally here and a policy of separate access to things in South Africa,allowing for the fact that there it was premised primarily on race as opposed to nationality,for which in part read "tribe/ethnic group".


Edited by legaleagle (16 Mar 2015 8.07pm)

 

TheJudge Flag 16 Mar 15 8.20pm

Quote legaleagle at 16 Mar 2015 8.02pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 2.32pm

Quote reborn at 16 Mar 2015 12.46pm

I read today that UKIP want to bar children of immigrants from State Schools for 5 years?

Whilst there is a plausible case for controlling immigration, this smacks of apartheid by another name.

Lunacy.


How is that apartheid ? Many immigrants are white.

I don't know the sense of such a policy or even if UKIP have even really proposed it but people have to draw a distinction between race issues and immigration issues.
For sure a persons culture or religion might make integration difficult or near impossible but that is a seperate issue from numbers and pressure on services.

Edited by TheJudge (16 Mar 2015 2.32pm)

I agree that,for example,being averse to an influx of people of differing ethnicity or alternatively a plain averseness to numbers of immigrants with ethnicity not entering a person's thoughts in any way as in your expressed case, does not necessarily make someone a racist since,in the former case, ethnicity is based on a number of things other than race and race may not come into differing ethnicity at all.

I also do wonder how many of the people who don't like numbers of immigrants coming to live near them would feel exactly the same if the same numbers of immigrants were arriving but solely from Canada,New Zealand and Australia...

Apartheid,literally meaning "apartness" and the policy of "Separate Development" in South Africa, was of course premised on race in South Africa but in terms of the non-white parts of the community also involved seeking to create separate sub-groups,individual homelands for "separate" ethnic/tribal groups. All in all,people living "apart" with separate and differentiated access to things legally.

So,not that unreasonable to draw a general parallel between any proposed (if proposed) policies of "separate access" to things within the UK for different groups legally here and a policy of separate access to things in South Africa,allowing for the fact that there it was premised primarily on race as opposed to nationality,for which in part read "tribe/ethnic group".


Edited by legaleagle (16 Mar 2015 8.07pm)


A fair point.
I would speculate that the issue of sheer numbers and pressure on housing and services etc would remain the same but would not be so visible since all those you mention are essentially of British decent anyway and would blend in so to speak. That would not however, disguise the financial and practical reality.
The cultural and religious issues would not exist of course.

 

legaleagle Flag 16 Mar 15 8.41pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 12.16pm


But,as to your proposition that immigration is responsible for our ills ,including crime etc, no I have to completely disagree with you.Its exactly what they said about Jewish immigration 100-120 years ago and about immigrants from Asia and the West Indies 40-60 years ago.Same arguments then as now. The real cause of our problems is elsewhere, and "divide and rule" so people scapegoat groups at the bottom of the pile is as old as the hills.

.........................................................................................................


And what exactly would that be ?

It seems to me that people have never wanted streams of foreigners coming into their neighbourhoods. Some have been born into that world and see it as the norm. Some older people still find it very hard to accept the changes that have taken place.
Back in the sixties when immigration was starting to accelerate, the likes of Griffiths tried to represent his constituents who did not want the problems associated with migrants to effect their area. Harold Wilson, one of the most cynical politicians ever, used the situation for political gain and even used a well known actor to run for the seat. He used the whole "race" issue as a political vehicle while accusing the Tory of the very same. Politics has remained in that mode ever since, using race as a political football when in reality race has nothing to do with it. Only far right idiots,self interest groups, including ethnic minorities and politicians talk about race. The rest of us have either been brainwashed by left wing propaganda or are just concerned by the practical issues that effect the local areas and the country with regard to large amounts of migrants coming here to settle.
There has been no attempt to be honest in this debate as politicians try to secure the White middle England and the ethnic vote.

........................................................................................................


What I do not suggest are the following:

1.That many people do not genuinely feel immigration has been/is excessive.

2. That many politicians have not shamelessly chosen and varied their position on issues surrounding "race" and immigration in the past 60 years for cynical political gain,on all parts of the political spectrum.

3.That the popular press over this period has not shamelessly tried to whip up hysteria over such issues,with the popular press having not zero influence in shaping public opinion

4.That there is not a legitimate discussion to be had over population numbers alongside many other issues ,but including overall migration figures in and out, and the benefits economically of, for example EU membership, and benefits of immigrants economically.Provided such discussion in not premised on ethnicity or race.What I object to is the plain aversity to differing ethnicities and the hankering for a "mythic" Britain which in which so much of the debate put forward by those opposing immigration seems to be based.

You ask me who/what I blame for our woes? I don't claim to have easy answers.But,for example, fundamental inadequacies in our education system do not seem to me to stem principally from numbers of immigrants.Problems from our water and sewerage system stem from fundamental underinvestment for over a hundred years.

If we look at housing shortages,they were very much there between the wars, when there was very little immigration.The problems with house price rises don't basically stem from or start with immigration, and rent levels stem primarily from abolition in 1980 of most rent controls coupled with the drive away from state provision of housing.

IMO (and of course not all will agree) and simplistically given I am not writing a 40 page analysis, our problems stem in significant part from increasingly becoming a society of greater income inequality and loss of access for social mobility.The "market" is God with profit to be pocketed often rather than re-invested;though that was our undoing economically from the late 19th century onwards,and the idea of "society" diminished.Blame the less fortunate being the mantra of the day.

The real causes of some of our problems being not immigrants but those elites which benefit from our society increasingly being one of "I'm Alright Jack,sod everyone else", increasing inequality, lack of equality of opportunity,envy of those at the bottom of the heap for the morsels they grab, and an "austerity" which in reality is simply a further vehicle for increasing inequality.But that's just my opinion as an old style Attlee Government social democrat,just an opinion and I have my "hard hat" ready!

Edited by legaleagle (16 Mar 2015 8.47pm)

 

legaleagle Flag 16 Mar 15 8.51pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 8.20pm

Quote legaleagle at 16 Mar 2015 8.02pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 2.32pm

Quote reborn at 16 Mar 2015 12.46pm

I read today that UKIP want to bar children of immigrants from State Schools for 5 years?

Whilst there is a plausible case for controlling immigration, this smacks of apartheid by another name.

Lunacy.


How is that apartheid ? Many immigrants are white.

I don't know the sense of such a policy or even if UKIP have even really proposed it but people have to draw a distinction between race issues and immigration issues.
For sure a persons culture or religion might make integration difficult or near impossible but that is a seperate issue from numbers and pressure on services.

Edited by TheJudge (16 Mar 2015 2.32pm)

I agree that,for example,being averse to an influx of people of differing ethnicity or alternatively a plain averseness to numbers of immigrants with ethnicity not entering a person's thoughts in any way as in your expressed case, does not necessarily make someone a racist since,in the former case, ethnicity is based on a number of things other than race and race may not come into differing ethnicity at all.

I also do wonder how many of the people who don't like numbers of immigrants coming to live near them would feel exactly the same if the same numbers of immigrants were arriving but solely from Canada,New Zealand and Australia...

Apartheid,literally meaning "apartness" and the policy of "Separate Development" in South Africa, was of course premised on race in South Africa but in terms of the non-white parts of the community also involved seeking to create separate sub-groups,individual homelands for "separate" ethnic/tribal groups. All in all,people living "apart" with separate and differentiated access to things legally.

So,not that unreasonable to draw a general parallel between any proposed (if proposed) policies of "separate access" to things within the UK for different groups legally here and a policy of separate access to things in South Africa,allowing for the fact that there it was premised primarily on race as opposed to nationality,for which in part read "tribe/ethnic group".


Edited by legaleagle (16 Mar 2015 8.07pm)


A fair point.
I would speculate that the issue of sheer numbers and pressure on housing and services etc would remain the same but would not be so visible since all those you mention are essentially of British decent anyway and would blend in so to speak. That would not however, disguise the financial and practical reality.
The cultural and religious issues would not exist of course.


You have hit the nail on the head I think.Not an aversion prominent in the minds of many to numbers affecting the economy etc, but an aversion to differing ethnicity and "blending in".

Edited by legaleagle (16 Mar 2015 8.52pm)

 

TheJudge Flag 16 Mar 15 8.55pm

Quote legaleagle at 16 Mar 2015 8.41pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 12.16pm


But,as to your proposition that immigration is responsible for our ills ,including crime etc, no I have to completely disagree with you.Its exactly what they said about Jewish immigration 100-120 years ago and about immigrants from Asia and the West Indies 40-60 years ago.Same arguments then as now. The real cause of our problems is elsewhere, and "divide and rule" so people scapegoat groups at the bottom of the pile is as old as the hills.

.........................................................................................................


And what exactly would that be ?

It seems to me that people have never wanted streams of foreigners coming into their neighbourhoods. Some have been born into that world and see it as the norm. Some older people still find it very hard to accept the changes that have taken place.
Back in the sixties when immigration was starting to accelerate, the likes of Griffiths tried to represent his constituents who did not want the problems associated with migrants to effect their area. Harold Wilson, one of the most cynical politicians ever, used the situation for political gain and even used a well known actor to run for the seat. He used the whole "race" issue as a political vehicle while accusing the Tory of the very same. Politics has remained in that mode ever since, using race as a political football when in reality race has nothing to do with it. Only far right idiots,self interest groups, including ethnic minorities and politicians talk about race. The rest of us have either been brainwashed by left wing propaganda or are just concerned by the practical issues that effect the local areas and the country with regard to large amounts of migrants coming here to settle.
There has been no attempt to be honest in this debate as politicians try to secure the White middle England and the ethnic vote.

........................................................................................................


What I do not suggest are the following:

1.That many people do not genuinely feel immigration has been/is excessive.

2. That many politicians have not shamelessly chosen and varied their position on issues surrounding "race" and immigration in the past 60 years for cynical political gain,on all parts of the political spectrum.

3.That the popular press over this period has not shamelessly tried to whip up hysteria over such issues,with the popular press having not zero influence in shaping public opinion

4.That there is not a legitimate discussion to be had over population numbers alongside many other issues ,but including overall migration figures in and out, and the benefits economically of, for example EU membership, and benefits of immigrants economically.Provided such discussion in not premised on ethnicity or race.What I object to is the plain aversity to differing ethnicities and the hankering for a "mythic" Britain which in which so much of the debate put forward by those opposing immigration seems to be based.

You ask me who/what I blame for our woes? I don't claim to have easy answers.But,for example, fundamental inadequacies in our education system do not seem to me to stem principally from numbers of immigrants.Problems from our water and sewerage system stem from fundamental underinvestment for over a hundred years.

If we look at housing shortages,they were very much there between the wars, when there was very little immigration.The problems with house price rises don't basically stem from or start with immigration, and rent levels stem primarily from abolition in 1980 of most rent controls coupled with the drive away from state provision of housing.

IMO (and of course not all will agree) and simplistically given I am not writing a 40 page analysis, our problems stem in significant part from increasingly becoming a society of greater income inequality and loss of access for social mobility.The "market" is God with profit to be pocketed often rather than re-invested;though that was our undoing economically from the late 19th century onwards,and the idea of "society" diminished.Blame the less fortunate being the mantra of the day.

The real causes of some of our problems being not immigrants but those elites which benefit from our society increasingly being one of "I'm Alright Jack,sod everyone else", increasing inequality, lack of equality of opportunity,envy of those at the bottom of the heap for the morsels they grab, and an "austerity" which in reality is simply a further vehicle for increasing inequality.But that's just my opinion as an old style Attlee Government social democrat,just an opinion and I have my "hard hat" ready!

Edited by legaleagle (16 Mar 2015 8.47pm)


Edited by TheJudge (16 Mar 2015 8.59pm)

 

TheJudge Flag 16 Mar 15 9.00pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 8.55pm

Quote legaleagle at 16 Mar 2015 8.41pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 12.16pm


But,as to your proposition that immigration is responsible for our ills ,including crime etc, no I have to completely disagree with you.Its exactly what they said about Jewish immigration 100-120 years ago and about immigrants from Asia and the West Indies 40-60 years ago.Same arguments then as now. The real cause of our problems is elsewhere, and "divide and rule" so people scapegoat groups at the bottom of the pile is as old as the hills.

.........................................................................................................


And what exactly would that be ?

It seems to me that people have never wanted streams of foreigners coming into their neighbourhoods. Some have been born into that world and see it as the norm. Some older people still find it very hard to accept the changes that have taken place.
Back in the sixties when immigration was starting to accelerate, the likes of Griffiths tried to represent his constituents who did not want the problems associated with migrants to effect their area. Harold Wilson, one of the most cynical politicians ever, used the situation for political gain and even used a well known actor to run for the seat. He used the whole "race" issue as a political vehicle while accusing the Tory of the very same. Politics has remained in that mode ever since, using race as a political football when in reality race has nothing to do with it. Only far right idiots,self interest groups, including ethnic minorities and politicians talk about race. The rest of us have either been brainwashed by left wing propaganda or are just concerned by the practical issues that effect the local areas and the country with regard to large amounts of migrants coming here to settle.
There has been no attempt to be honest in this debate as politicians try to secure the White middle England and the ethnic vote.

........................................................................................................


What I do not suggest are the following:

1.That many people do not genuinely feel immigration has been/is excessive.

2. That many politicians have not shamelessly chosen and varied their position on issues surrounding "race" and immigration in the past 60 years for cynical political gain,on all parts of the political spectrum.

3.That the popular press over this period has not shamelessly tried to whip up hysteria over such issues,with the popular press having not zero influence in shaping public opinion

4.That there is not a legitimate discussion to be had over population numbers alongside many other issues ,but including overall migration figures in and out, and the benefits economically of, for example EU membership, and benefits of immigrants economically.Provided such discussion in not premised on ethnicity or race.What I object to is the plain aversity to differing ethnicities and the hankering for a "mythic" Britain which in which so much of the debate put forward by those opposing immigration seems to be based.

You ask me who/what I blame for our woes? I don't claim to have easy answers.But,for example, fundamental inadequacies in our education system do not seem to me to stem principally from numbers of immigrants.Problems from our water and sewerage system stem from fundamental underinvestment for over a hundred years.

If we look at housing shortages,they were very much there between the wars, when there was very little immigration.The problems with house price rises don't basically stem from or start with immigration, and rent levels stem primarily from abolition in 1980 of most rent controls coupled with the drive away from state provision of housing.

IMO (and of course not all will agree) and simplistically given I am not writing a 40 page analysis, our problems stem in significant part from increasingly becoming a society of greater income inequality and loss of access for social mobility.The "market" is God with profit to be pocketed often rather than re-invested;though that was our undoing economically from the late 19th century onwards,and the idea of "society" diminished.Blame the less fortunate being the mantra of the day.

The real causes of some of our problems being not immigrants but those elites which benefit from our society increasingly being one of "I'm Alright Jack,sod everyone else", increasing inequality, lack of equality of opportunity,envy of those at the bottom of the heap for the morsels they grab, and an "austerity" which in reality is simply a further vehicle for increasing inequality.But that's just my opinion as an old style Attlee Government social democrat,just an opinion and I have my "hard hat" ready!

Edited by legaleagle (16 Mar 2015 8.47pm)


Edited by TheJudge (16 Mar 2015 8.59pm)

I don't disagree with a lot of what you say but I believe that just because there may be a number of factors that might effect a particular issue does not mean that their individual contribution are less significant.
In the example of water. Of course the system has seen under investment, as have other areas, but as it stands, an increase in numbers using it can only exacerbate an existing problem. The same with housing.
I believe that some are so keen to uphold the principle of multiculturalism and freedom of movement that they have buried their heads in the sands of denial.

 

legaleagle Flag 16 Mar 15 9.18pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 9.00pm


I don't disagree with a lot of what you say but I believe that just because there may be a number of factors that might effect a particular issue does not mean that their individual contribution are less significant.
In the example of water. Of course the system has seen under investment, as have other areas, but as it stands, an increase in numbers using it can only exacerbate an existing problem. The same with housing.
I believe that some are so keen to uphold the principle of multiculturalism and freedom of movement that they have buried their heads in the sands of denial.


It depends whether one views immigration as a crucial causal factor or not in the instances in question and whether any benefits arising from immigration or EU membership outweigh them.I don't but that's just my opinion.Another question worth asking is,does one believe that if we had no further immigration in any significant numbers, the elites I referred to would suddenly ensure and advocate for as strongly as some advocate against immigration, reinvestment in infrastructure as opposed to profit pocketing and whether,for example, a plethora of affordable new homes would result.I think not,based on the performance of those elites over the past century or more.

Edited by legaleagle (16 Mar 2015 9.19pm)

 

TheJudge Flag 16 Mar 15 9.36pm

Quote legaleagle at 16 Mar 2015 9.18pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 9.00pm


I don't disagree with a lot of what you say but I believe that just because there may be a number of factors that might effect a particular issue does not mean that their individual contribution are less significant.
In the example of water. Of course the system has seen under investment, as have other areas, but as it stands, an increase in numbers using it can only exacerbate an existing problem. The same with housing.
I believe that some are so keen to uphold the principle of multiculturalism and freedom of movement that they have buried their heads in the sands of denial.


It depends whether one views immigration as a crucial causal factor or not in the instances in question and whether any benefits arising from immigration or EU membership outweigh them.I don't but that's just my opinion.Another question worth asking is,does one believe that if we had no further immigration in any significant numbers, the elites I referred to would suddenly ensure and advocate for as strongly as some advocate against immigration, reinvestment in infrastructure as opposed to profit pocketing and whether,for example, a plethora of affordable new homes would result.I think not,based on the performance of those elites over the past century or more.

Edited by legaleagle (16 Mar 2015 9.19pm)

I can't say but I share you cynicism.
I would maintain that any problem that exists which involves pressure of numbers can only be exacerbated by more numbers. Whether the benefits of increased numbers can outweigh specific negatives is impossible to gauge since there are no accurate figures.
I would suggest that any evidence that demonstrated that specific negatives outweighed benefits would be dismissed by government and self interest groups anyway.
Therein lies the problem of the reality being presented by the establishment against anecdote and observation.
I would liken it to a situation where you met and had a cup of tea with an alien who landed his spaceship on your lawn but the government say flying saucers don't exist so it could not have happened.

 

reborn 18 Mar 15 9.13am

OMG, Pedants of the world unite!!

Apartheid can refer to any kind of segregation, race, sex, religion etc. I thought anyone with a basic knowledge of the English Language would know that, clearly not, so I apologise.

Preventing children of immigrants from receiving education is a terrible idea, only reinforcing the 'them and us' mentality which seems to be more and more prevalent.

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Mar 15 10.08am

Quote reborn at 18 Mar 2015 9.13am

OMG, Pedants of the world unite!!

Apartheid can refer to any kind of segregation, race, sex, religion etc. I thought anyone with a basic knowledge of the English Language would know that, clearly not, so I apologise.

Preventing children of immigrants from receiving education is a terrible idea, only reinforcing the 'them and us' mentality which seems to be more and more prevalent.

Indeed, preventing anyone from reasonable access to education is a terrible idea. The irony is that we generally seem to deny education access to people who need it most or those who would benefit most from it (Prison, Migrants, Poor).

For example, we should require all citizens speak reasonable English, and provide educational facilities and programs to ensure it, rather than just demand that they can pass the 'citizenship exam' part - Not because its the national language, but because it improves the capacity for integration and communication.

It probably shouldn't be limited to just migrants, given some of the conversational skills displayed by British Nationals.

Edited by jamiemartin721 (18 Mar 2015 10.09am)

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Mar 15 10.18am

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 9.36pm

Quote legaleagle at 16 Mar 2015 9.18pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 9.00pm


I don't disagree with a lot of what you say but I believe that just because there may be a number of factors that might effect a particular issue does not mean that their individual contribution are less significant.
In the example of water. Of course the system has seen under investment, as have other areas, but as it stands, an increase in numbers using it can only exacerbate an existing problem. The same with housing.
I believe that some are so keen to uphold the principle of multiculturalism and freedom of movement that they have buried their heads in the sands of denial.


It depends whether one views immigration as a crucial causal factor or not in the instances in question and whether any benefits arising from immigration or EU membership outweigh them.I don't but that's just my opinion.Another question worth asking is,does one believe that if we had no further immigration in any significant numbers, the elites I referred to would suddenly ensure and advocate for as strongly as some advocate against immigration, reinvestment in infrastructure as opposed to profit pocketing and whether,for example, a plethora of affordable new homes would result.I think not,based on the performance of those elites over the past century or more.

Edited by legaleagle (16 Mar 2015 9.19pm)

I can't say but I share you cynicism.
I would maintain that any problem that exists which involves pressure of numbers can only be exacerbated by more numbers. Whether the benefits of increased numbers can outweigh specific negatives is impossible to gauge since there are no accurate figures.
I would suggest that any evidence that demonstrated that specific negatives outweighed benefits would be dismissed by government and self interest groups anyway.
Therein lies the problem of the reality being presented by the establishment against anecdote and observation.
I would liken it to a situation where you met and had a cup of tea with an alien who landed his spaceship on your lawn but the government say flying saucers don't exist so it could not have happened.

Anecdotal evidence generally is unreliable, as its capacity for any kind of independent analysis is impossible. Also its entirely biased towards the experience of the recounting party. That said there are methods of analysis open towards collation of anecdotal evidence, such as discourse analysis, that specifically deal entirely with anecdotal sources (there is also Phenomenology and Psychoanalytical analysis - I'm biased towards social sciences as that's what I know) - All of these work with anecdotal sources.

Observational Evidence can be exceptionally reliable, provided its conducted to a specific methodology - infact almost all science is 'observational research'. However a lot of what people call observation is anectodal evidence, rather than observational evidence.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

chris-shot Flag Thornton Heath 18 Mar 15 2.07pm

In hard times, parties can easily take control by being Right-Wing and finding a scapegoat - for example the Nazis.

 

TheJudge Flag 18 Mar 15 7.39pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Mar 2015 10.18am

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 9.36pm

Quote legaleagle at 16 Mar 2015 9.18pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 9.00pm


I don't disagree with a lot of what you say but I believe that just because there may be a number of factors that might effect a particular issue does not mean that their individual contribution are less significant.
In the example of water. Of course the system has seen under investment, as have other areas, but as it stands, an increase in numbers using it can only exacerbate an existing problem. The same with housing.
I believe that some are so keen to uphold the principle of multiculturalism and freedom of movement that they have buried their heads in the sands of denial.


It depends whether one views immigration as a crucial causal factor or not in the instances in question and whether any benefits arising from immigration or EU membership outweigh them.I don't but that's just my opinion.Another question worth asking is,does one believe that if we had no further immigration in any significant numbers, the elites I referred to would suddenly ensure and advocate for as strongly as some advocate against immigration, reinvestment in infrastructure as opposed to profit pocketing and whether,for example, a plethora of affordable new homes would result.I think not,based on the performance of those elites over the past century or more.

Edited by legaleagle (16 Mar 2015 9.19pm)

I can't say but I share you cynicism.
I would maintain that any problem that exists which involves pressure of numbers can only be exacerbated by more numbers. Whether the benefits of increased numbers can outweigh specific negatives is impossible to gauge since there are no accurate figures.
I would suggest that any evidence that demonstrated that specific negatives outweighed benefits would be dismissed by government and self interest groups anyway.
Therein lies the problem of the reality being presented by the establishment against anecdote and observation.
I would liken it to a situation where you met and had a cup of tea with an alien who landed his spaceship on your lawn but the government say flying saucers don't exist so it could not have happened.

Anecdotal evidence generally is unreliable, as its capacity for any kind of independent analysis is impossible. Also its entirely biased towards the experience of the recounting party. That said there are methods of analysis open towards collation of anecdotal evidence, such as discourse analysis, that specifically deal entirely with anecdotal sources (there is also Phenomenology and Psychoanalytical analysis - I'm biased towards social sciences as that's what I know) - All of these work with anecdotal sources.

Observational Evidence can be exceptionally reliable, provided its conducted to a specific methodology - infact almost all science is 'observational research'. However a lot of what people call observation is anectodal evidence, rather than observational evidence.


Where did you copy that from ? Wiki ?

One of the frustrations of posting on a web site such as this is peoples inability to read posts properly and then replying to a small section of it by just repeating some well rehearsed mantra.

Understand. There is no reliable data to measure either the benefit of immigration or the numbers coming and going. The former is a product of the latter.
It is therefore political bunk to tell us categorically that immigration is "good" for the country.

It is perhaps good......for bankers, businessmen, oh, and immigrants.

Live in your delusion of liberal moralizing and statistical hogwash if you please but at least spell anecdotal properly when you trying to appear clever.

Edited by TheJudge (18 Mar 2015 7.43pm)

 

Page 130 of 187 < 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic