You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 22 2026 3.02am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

ukip (LOCKED)


Page 131 of 187 < 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 >
legaleagle Flag 18 Mar 15 8.00pm

Quote TheJudge at 18 Mar 2015 7.39pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Mar 2015 10.18am

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 9.36pm

Quote legaleagle at 16 Mar 2015 9.18pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 9.00pm


I don't disagree with a lot of what you say but I believe that just because there may be a number of factors that might effect a particular issue does not mean that their individual contribution are less significant.
In the example of water. Of course the system has seen under investment, as have other areas, but as it stands, an increase in numbers using it can only exacerbate an existing problem. The same with housing.
I believe that some are so keen to uphold the principle of multiculturalism and freedom of movement that they have buried their heads in the sands of denial.


It depends whether one views immigration as a crucial causal factor or not in the instances in question and whether any benefits arising from immigration or EU membership outweigh them.I don't but that's just my opinion.Another question worth asking is,does one believe that if we had no further immigration in any significant numbers, the elites I referred to would suddenly ensure and advocate for as strongly as some advocate against immigration, reinvestment in infrastructure as opposed to profit pocketing and whether,for example, a plethora of affordable new homes would result.I think not,based on the performance of those elites over the past century or more.

Edited by legaleagle (16 Mar 2015 9.19pm)

I can't say but I share you cynicism.
I would maintain that any problem that exists which involves pressure of numbers can only be exacerbated by more numbers. Whether the benefits of increased numbers can outweigh specific negatives is impossible to gauge since there are no accurate figures.
I would suggest that any evidence that demonstrated that specific negatives outweighed benefits would be dismissed by government and self interest groups anyway.
Therein lies the problem of the reality being presented by the establishment against anecdote and observation.
I would liken it to a situation where you met and had a cup of tea with an alien who landed his spaceship on your lawn but the government say flying saucers don't exist so it could not have happened.

Anecdotal evidence generally is unreliable, as its capacity for any kind of independent analysis is impossible. Also its entirely biased towards the experience of the recounting party. That said there are methods of analysis open towards collation of anecdotal evidence, such as discourse analysis, that specifically deal entirely with anecdotal sources (there is also Phenomenology and Psychoanalytical analysis - I'm biased towards social sciences as that's what I know) - All of these work with anecdotal sources.

Observational Evidence can be exceptionally reliable, provided its conducted to a specific methodology - infact almost all science is 'observational research'. However a lot of what people call observation is anectodal evidence, rather than observational evidence.


Where did you copy that from ? Wiki ?

One of the frustrations of posting on a web site such as this is peoples inability to read posts properly and then replying to a small section of it by just repeating some well rehearsed mantra.

Understand. There is no reliable data to measure either the benefit OR DETRIMENT of immigration or the numbers coming and going. The former is a product of the latter.
It is therefore political bunk to tell us categorically that immigration is "good" OR "BAD"for the country.

It is perhaps good......for bankers, businessmen, oh, and immigrants.

Live in your delusion of liberal moralizing and statistical hogwash if you please but at least spell anecdotal properly when you trying to appear clever.

Edited by TheJudge (18 Mar 2015 7.43pm)

Corrected for accuracy

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 18 Mar 15 10.47pm

Sorry bout the source, but some interesting points.
[Link]

*Awaits it's just lefty bulls*** response without salient arguments against the points it raises.

 

Hoof Hearted 19 Mar 15 10.27am

Quote nickgusset at 18 Mar 2015 10.47pm

Sorry bout the source, but some interesting points.
[Link]

*Awaits it's just lefty bulls*** response without salient arguments against the points it raises.


You should have put up an NSFW warning if you're going to post views of cnuts nick!

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 19 Mar 15 11.38am

200 plus pages of utter bollocks and I am still voting UKIP.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

ghosteagle Flag 19 Mar 15 11.44am

Quote matt_himself at 19 Mar 2015 11.38am

200 plus pages of utter bollocks and I am still voting UKIP.

My, UKIP have a big manifesto!

 

crystal balls Flag The Garden of Earthly Delights 19 Mar 15 12.15pm

Quote matt_himself at 19 Mar 2015 11.38am

200 plus pages of utter bollocks and I am still voting UKIP.


You and Farrago deserve each other. I hope you'll both be very happy.

 


I used to be immortal

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 19 Mar 15 12.45pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 19 Mar 2015 10.27am

Quote nickgusset at 18 Mar 2015 10.47pm

Sorry bout the source, but some interesting points.
[Link]

*Awaits it's just lefty bulls*** response without salient arguments against the points it raises.


You should have put up an NSFW warning if you're going to post views of cnuts nick!

So no counter argument. I'll take it you agree with the article then.

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 19 Mar 15 1.23pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 16 Mar 2015 6.48pm

Quote pefwin at 16 Mar 2015 6.22pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Mar 2015 2.32pm

Quote reborn at 16 Mar 2015 12.46pm

I read today that UKIP want to bar children of immigrants from State Schools for 5 years?

Whilst there is a plausible case for controlling immigration, this smacks of apartheid by another name.

Lunacy.


How is that apartheid ? Many immigrants are white.

I don't know the sense of such a policy or even if UKIP have even really proposed it but people have to draw a distinction between race issues and immigration issues.
For sure a persons culture or religion might make integration difficult or near impossible but that is a seperate issue from numbers and pressure on services.

Edited by TheJudge (16 Mar 2015 2.32pm)

I think that shows your own prejudices as apartheid is not colour driven by definition.


The only ever time that the word apartheid has been used to describe a political system was for describing a colour based system.

It isn't an unreasonable point to make.

odd for the grammar police, to play fast and loose with a dictionary, but when it suits..........

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

imbored Flag UK 19 Mar 15 3.35pm

Quote ghosteagle at 19 Mar 2015 11.44am

Quote matt_himself at 19 Mar 2015 11.38am

200 plus pages of utter bollocks and I am still voting UKIP.

My, UKIP have a big manifesto!

Haha

Edited by imbored (19 Mar 2015 3.36pm)

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 19 Mar 15 3.41pm

Quote crystal balls at 19 Mar 2015 12.15pm

Quote matt_himself at 19 Mar 2015 11.38am

200 plus pages of utter bollocks and I am still voting UKIP.


You and Farrago deserve each other. I hope you'll both be very happy.

Better than voting Milit*** and sending the country to the dogs.

You better think hard about that before you put your 'x' next to Labour.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

TheJudge Flag 19 Mar 15 3.49pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Mar 2015 10.47pm

Sorry bout the source, but some interesting points.
[Link]

*Awaits it's just lefty bulls*** response without salient arguments against the points it raises.


Jesus. The source is all important.

Does anyone believe that statistics are free from political bias any more ? Or even that the data is reliable in the first place.

Apply common sense for a change.

If you have a cake and 1 person eats it they have the whole cake. If 5 people eat it there is less for everyone. Absorb that statistic. We just can't afford more cakes and our increasing debt should tell you that. Considering that immigration is so "good" for the country it is odd that we are in so much debt. Maybe we should import the entire population of pakistan and India. That might do it.

 

Hoof Hearted 19 Mar 15 4.06pm

Quote nickgusset at 19 Mar 2015 12.45pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 19 Mar 2015 10.27am

Quote nickgusset at 18 Mar 2015 10.47pm

Sorry bout the source, but some interesting points.
[Link]

*Awaits it's just lefty bulls*** response without salient arguments against the points it raises.


You should have put up an NSFW warning if you're going to post views of cnuts nick!

So no counter argument. I'll take it you agree with the article then.


I wouldn't wipe my arse with that socialist rag mate.

 

imbored Flag UK 19 Mar 15 4.22pm

Quote TheJudge at 19 Mar 2015 3.49pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Mar 2015 10.47pm

Sorry bout the source, but some interesting points.
[Link]

*Awaits it's just lefty bulls*** response without salient arguments against the points it raises.


Jesus. The source is all important.

Does anyone believe that statistics are free from political bias any more ? Or even that the data is reliable in the first place.

Apply common sense for a change.

If you have a cake and 1 person eats it they have the whole cake. If 5 people eat it there is less for everyone. Absorb that statistic. We just can't afford more cakes and our increasing debt should tell you that. Considering that immigration is so "good" for the country it is odd that we are in so much debt. Maybe we should import the entire population of pakistan and India. That might do it.

We had better get everybody but one person to leave the country then, since apparently the size of the cake somehow never changes when population increases :P. Your made up stat is just as skewed as anything else posted here.

I doubt anyone truly knows the full benefit or otherwise of immigration, though of course people on both sides will claim how obvious it is that it's a positive or negative financially and otherwise. Typically I find it has more to do with who people want to live next door to. How people view their identity and so on.

Edited by imbored (19 Mar 2015 5.08pm)

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 19 Mar 15 4.51pm

Quote matt_himself at 19 Mar 2015 11.38am

200 plus pages of utter bollocks and I am still voting UKIP.


Actually, you've only written 198.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 19 Mar 15 5.15pm

Quote imbored at 19 Mar 2015 4.22pm

Quote TheJudge at 19 Mar 2015 3.49pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Mar 2015 10.47pm

Sorry bout the source, but some interesting points.
[Link]

*Awaits it's just lefty bulls*** response without salient arguments against the points it raises.


Jesus. The source is all important.

Does anyone believe that statistics are free from political bias any more ? Or even that the data is reliable in the first place.

Apply common sense for a change.

If you have a cake and 1 person eats it they have the whole cake. If 5 people eat it there is less for everyone. Absorb that statistic. We just can't afford more cakes and our increasing debt should tell you that. Considering that immigration is so "good" for the country it is odd that we are in so much debt. Maybe we should import the entire population of pakistan and India. That might do it.

We had better get everybody but one person to leave the country then, since apparently the size of the cake somehow never changes when population increases :P. Your made up stat is just as skewed as anything else posted here.

I doubt anyone truly knows the full benefit or otherwise of immigration, though of course people on both sides will claim how obvious it is that it's a positive or negative financially and otherwise. Typically I find it has more to do with who people want to live next door to. How people view their identity and so on.

Edited by imbored (19 Mar 2015 5.08pm)

If we have more people, we can make more cakes!

 

TheJudge Flag 19 Mar 15 6.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 19 Mar 2015 5.15pm

Quote imbored at 19 Mar 2015 4.22pm

Quote TheJudge at 19 Mar 2015 3.49pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Mar 2015 10.47pm

Sorry bout the source, but some interesting points.
[Link]

*Awaits it's just lefty bulls*** response without salient arguments against the points it raises.


Jesus. The source is all important.

Does anyone believe that statistics are free from political bias any more ? Or even that the data is reliable in the first place.

Apply common sense for a change.

If you have a cake and 1 person eats it they have the whole cake. If 5 people eat it there is less for everyone. Absorb that statistic. We just can't afford more cakes and our increasing debt should tell you that. Considering that immigration is so "good" for the country it is odd that we are in so much debt. Maybe we should import the entire population of pakistan and India. That might do it.

We had better get everybody but one person to leave the country then, since apparently the size of the cake somehow never changes when population increases :P. Your made up stat is just as skewed as anything else posted here.

I doubt anyone truly knows the full benefit or otherwise of immigration, though of course people on both sides will claim how obvious it is that it's a positive or negative financially and otherwise. Typically I find it has more to do with who people want to live next door to. How people view their identity and so on.

Edited by imbored (19 Mar 2015 5.08pm)

If we have more people, we can make more cakes!

Unfortunately not. You need money to buy the ingredients.
Whether the cake increases with the amount of people is the bone of contention. Why are we in so much debt when immigrants are arriving here in record numbers ?


 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 19 Mar 15 6.35pm

Quote TheJudge at 19 Mar 2015 6.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 19 Mar 2015 5.15pm

Quote imbored at 19 Mar 2015 4.22pm

Quote TheJudge at 19 Mar 2015 3.49pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Mar 2015 10.47pm

Sorry bout the source, but some interesting points.
[Link]

*Awaits it's just lefty bulls*** response without salient arguments against the points it raises.


Jesus. The source is all important.

Does anyone believe that statistics are free from political bias any more ? Or even that the data is reliable in the first place.

Apply common sense for a change.

If you have a cake and 1 person eats it they have the whole cake. If 5 people eat it there is less for everyone. Absorb that statistic. We just can't afford more cakes and our increasing debt should tell you that. Considering that immigration is so "good" for the country it is odd that we are in so much debt. Maybe we should import the entire population of pakistan and India. That might do it.

We had better get everybody but one person to leave the country then, since apparently the size of the cake somehow never changes when population increases :P. Your made up stat is just as skewed as anything else posted here.

I doubt anyone truly knows the full benefit or otherwise of immigration, though of course people on both sides will claim how obvious it is that it's a positive or negative financially and otherwise. Typically I find it has more to do with who people want to live next door to. How people view their identity and so on.

Edited by imbored (19 Mar 2015 5.08pm)

If we have more people, we can make more cakes!

Unfortunately not. You need money to buy the ingredients.
Whether the cake increases with the amount of people is the bone of contention. Why are we in so much debt when immigrants are arriving here in record numbers ?



Why are we in debt? Erm global crash followed by chronic cuts and massive underinvestment from an inept Chancellor.

 

TheJudge Flag 19 Mar 15 6.41pm

Quote nickgusset at 19 Mar 2015 6.35pm

Quote TheJudge at 19 Mar 2015 6.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 19 Mar 2015 5.15pm

Quote imbored at 19 Mar 2015 4.22pm

Quote TheJudge at 19 Mar 2015 3.49pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Mar 2015 10.47pm

Sorry bout the source, but some interesting points.
[Link]

*Awaits it's just lefty bulls*** response without salient arguments against the points it raises.


Jesus. The source is all important.

Does anyone believe that statistics are free from political bias any more ? Or even that the data is reliable in the first place.

Apply common sense for a change.

If you have a cake and 1 person eats it they have the whole cake. If 5 people eat it there is less for everyone. Absorb that statistic. We just can't afford more cakes and our increasing debt should tell you that. Considering that immigration is so "good" for the country it is odd that we are in so much debt. Maybe we should import the entire population of pakistan and India. That might do it.

We had better get everybody but one person to leave the country then, since apparently the size of the cake somehow never changes when population increases :P. Your made up stat is just as skewed as anything else posted here.

I doubt anyone truly knows the full benefit or otherwise of immigration, though of course people on both sides will claim how obvious it is that it's a positive or negative financially and otherwise. Typically I find it has more to do with who people want to live next door to. How people view their identity and so on.

Edited by imbored (19 Mar 2015 5.08pm)

If we have more people, we can make more cakes!

Unfortunately not. You need money to buy the ingredients.
Whether the cake increases with the amount of people is the bone of contention. Why are we in so much debt when immigrants are arriving here in record numbers ?



Why are we in debt? Erm global crash followed by chronic cuts and massive underinvestment from an inept Chancellor.

Oh of course. It's the Tory's fault.

Lol. Lucky we have all those immigrants to keeping our heads above water.

 

crystal balls Flag The Garden of Earthly Delights 19 Mar 15 8.38pm

Quote TheJudge at 19 Mar 2015 6.41pm

Quote nickgusset at 19 Mar 2015 6.35pm

Quote TheJudge at 19 Mar 2015 6.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 19 Mar 2015 5.15pm

Quote imbored at 19 Mar 2015 4.22pm

Quote TheJudge at 19 Mar 2015 3.49pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Mar 2015 10.47pm

Sorry bout the source, but some interesting points.
[Link]

*Awaits it's just lefty bulls*** response without salient arguments against the points it raises.


Jesus. The source is all important.

Does anyone believe that statistics are free from political bias any more ? Or even that the data is reliable in the first place.

Apply common sense for a change.

If you have a cake and 1 person eats it they have the whole cake. If 5 people eat it there is less for everyone. Absorb that statistic. We just can't afford more cakes and our increasing debt should tell you that. Considering that immigration is so "good" for the country it is odd that we are in so much debt. Maybe we should import the entire population of pakistan and India. That might do it.

We had better get everybody but one person to leave the country then, since apparently the size of the cake somehow never changes when population increases :P. Your made up stat is just as skewed as anything else posted here.

I doubt anyone truly knows the full benefit or otherwise of immigration, though of course people on both sides will claim how obvious it is that it's a positive or negative financially and otherwise. Typically I find it has more to do with who people want to live next door to. How people view their identity and so on.

Edited by imbored (19 Mar 2015 5.08pm)

If we have more people, we can make more cakes!

Unfortunately not. You need money to buy the ingredients.
Whether the cake increases with the amount of people is the bone of contention. Why are we in so much debt when immigrants are arriving here in record numbers ?



Why are we in debt? Erm global crash followed by chronic cuts and massive underinvestment from an inept Chancellor.

Oh of course. It's the Tory's fault.

Lol. Lucky we have all those immigrants to keeping our heads above water.

Of course, the GLOBAL crash wasn't the Tories doing, any more than it was Labour's; the clue is in the term that is used!

However, by 2010 the UK economy was in recovery, which was stalled due to the chronic cuts that Nick mentions. And as Osborne has met absolutely none of the targets he set himself, I'd also class him as inept.

What cannot be disputed is that the UK population is ageing, not as fast perhaps as Italy or Germany, but at an unsustainable rate nonetheless. The birth rate has increased in recent years as well, giving rise to a double whammy, more pensioners, living for longer, and more children in education.

Neither of these groups pay much in taxes and take a high proportion of benefits. State pensions already account for more than 50% of the welfare budget and this is set to increase to over 65% over the next 12 years.

To afford to support the demographic changes the UK, in common with a number of other countries, needs to either a)increase taxes greatly, b) cut pensions, child benefits massively and cut the education budget, or c) increase the number of working taxpayers.

The first two options don't look too good to me, maybe the third is the lesser "evil"? Japan, a country far more insular than the UK has been historically, is beginning to encourage immigrants for exactly the above reasons.

 


I used to be immortal

TUX Flag redhill 19 Mar 15 10.35pm

Quote nickgusset at 19 Mar 2015 6.35pm

Quote TheJudge at 19 Mar 2015 6.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 19 Mar 2015 5.15pm

Quote imbored at 19 Mar 2015 4.22pm

Quote TheJudge at 19 Mar 2015 3.49pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Mar 2015 10.47pm

Sorry bout the source, but some interesting points.
[Link]

*Awaits it's just lefty bulls*** response without salient arguments against the points it raises.


Jesus. The source is all important.

Does anyone believe that statistics are free from political bias any more ? Or even that the data is reliable in the first place.

Apply common sense for a change.

If you have a cake and 1 person eats it they have the whole cake. If 5 people eat it there is less for everyone. Absorb that statistic. We just can't afford more cakes and our increasing debt should tell you that. Considering that immigration is so "good" for the country it is odd that we are in so much debt. Maybe we should import the entire population of pakistan and India. That might do it.

We had better get everybody but one person to leave the country then, since apparently the size of the cake somehow never changes when population increases :P. Your made up stat is just as skewed as anything else posted here.

I doubt anyone truly knows the full benefit or otherwise of immigration, though of course people on both sides will claim how obvious it is that it's a positive or negative financially and otherwise. Typically I find it has more to do with who people want to live next door to. How people view their identity and so on.

Edited by imbored (19 Mar 2015 5.08pm)

If we have more people, we can make more cakes!

Unfortunately not. You need money to buy the ingredients.
Whether the cake increases with the amount of people is the bone of contention. Why are we in so much debt when immigrants are arriving here in record numbers ?



Why are we in debt? Erm global crash followed by chronic cuts and massive underinvestment from an inept Chancellor.

Because every pound that the Govt has ever borrowed from 'The Bank of England' is loaded with interest. It's not our bank just as the Federal Reserve is not the Americans bank. Privately owned and raping the public for years. ''Carlsberg don't lend money, but if they did..............''

We'll never be out of debt.

 

Page 131 of 187 < 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic