You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 21 2026 11.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Tommy Robinson (LOCKED)


Page 136 of 142 < 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 >
Stirlingsays Flag 14 Dec 18 1.40am

Originally posted by DanH

Do you genuinely think that’s far left thinking? For someone that gets a bit annoyed that Tommy is callled far right do you not just it’s a bit silly calling that far left. I don’t think you’re far right.

Edited by DanH (14 Dec 2018 1.28am)

You want me to answer seriously?

Ok, well....it's certainly true that judging people today by past historical perspectives (based on their race) and believing in de facto 'white privilege' and that 'white superiority' is a common problem....those ideas are straight out of the modern day far left ideological mindset....there are half true elements to the first two but the superiority thing....That's Hitler stuff and that's right on the very edge of even most far right beliefs.....Those who aren't trolling anyway.

Can I call you far left and know it....Nope.....I suspect that like me you believe in some of this and a little of that.....only you truly know.

You're probably a form of neo liberal progressive.....maybe you haven't finished formulating what you really believe in yet.....only you truly know.

But I did ask you what you didn't agree with from the far left and you didn't answer.


Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Dec 2018 10.12am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

cryrst Flag The garden of England 14 Dec 18 6.04am

Originally posted by steve1984

Meanwhile in Hungary the Government passed a law allowing employers to ask employees to work 400 hours of overtime per annum. The equivalent of an extra day / week.

But it gets better. The revised labour law requires employees to pay their employees overtime only after 3 years.

The median ave salary is about £650 / month gross, £325 take home.

But not many moslems, which I'm sure gives the ordinary working people some comfort.

That post without the muslim bit is what worries me about brexit and one reason i voted remain.
A lot of our labour laws come from Europe, and we are fairly well protected within them.
I do wonder that with control handed back to each company to a degree; that the protection might well reduce.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 14 Dec 18 6.24am

Sorry wrong thread but the post sort of morphed into two subjects.

 

W12 14 Dec 18 6.36am

Originally posted by pefwin

so in essence no one is worried about the radical alt right?

I’m more concerned about the number of people expressing perfectly reasonably opinions that are being labelled as this so they can be ignored.

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 14 Dec 18 8.29am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Who states that 'all Muslims are terrorists', no one.

Who states that 'all black males youths are criminals', no one.

What states this stuff about shaven white people?

Who states that?


Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Dec 2018 8.14pm)

I did wonder whose cage that would rattle...

Didn't realise I had to provide names. I was actually trying to make an even handed comment that I think we are seeing now, much as we did in the 70's a rise in casual racism across the board. Where people from all sides are quicker to make assumptions about others based on the colour of their skin or how they dress.

You have pointed out many examples of this yourself in your posts. Posts that quote the way incidents are reported.

I think the alt right and the far left are both guilty of feeding on this casual racism to their own ends.

But hey if the cap fits...

 

dannyboy1978 Flag 14 Dec 18 9.41am

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

I did wonder whose cage that would rattle...

Didn't realise I had to provide names. I was actually trying to make an even handed comment that I think we are seeing now, much as we did in the 70's a rise in casual racism across the board. Where people from all sides are quicker to make assumptions about others based on the colour of their skin or how they dress.

You have pointed out many examples of this yourself in your posts. Posts that quote the way incidents are reported.

I think the alt right and the far left are both guilty of feeding on this casual racism to their own ends.

But hey if the cap fits...

No.... people are drawing "assumptions" from these figures, not casual racism. Then when people raise concerns the left call them far right which people are not, they are just regular people reading the news , seeing the figures drawing conclusions. Facts are facts, we have a huge problem from a minority.

Screenshot_20181213-172619_Word.jpg Attachment: Screenshot_20181213-172619_Word.jpg (360.67Kb)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 14 Dec 18 9.58am

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

I did wonder whose cage that would rattle...

Didn't realise I had to provide names. I was actually trying to make an even handed comment that I think we are seeing now, much as we did in the 70's a rise in casual racism across the board. Where people from all sides are quicker to make assumptions about others based on the colour of their skin or how they dress.

You have pointed out many examples of this yourself in your posts. Posts that quote the way incidents are reported.

I think the alt right and the far left are both guilty of feeding on this casual racism to their own ends.

But hey if the cap fits...

You write in absolutes about how people believe 'all Muslims' this or 'all black people' that and so then you comment that 'people from all sides are quicker to make assumptions about others'.

Shouldn't you be including yourself in that?

It doesn't matter what someone thinks. What matters is how close to the truth what they think is.

A Jew living in Berlin in the thirties wouldn't' be right to think that all Germans hated him or her, but they would certainly be correct to believe that living around Germans wasn't good for them because a large enough section of them did......Still....lets criticise the 'casual racism'.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

steve1984 14 Dec 18 12.12pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Sigh.

So what would you like Hungary to do on immigration Stevie boy?

Presumably you mean what would I like the Hungarian Government to do on immigration?

I would like the Hungarian government to stop stealing billions of EU money whilst simultaneously corralling public opinion against the hand that feeds Orban's swiss bank account.

If the money was actually spent on what was intended, then the Hungarian economy might be stronger and the country might become a genuinely attractive destination for immigrants.

Needless to say I would also like it if the EU developed a spine and dealt with the corruption.

If or when Hungary has a problem with immigration in the way that Germany and the UK does then naturally it should decide what to do about it.

But Hungary's immigration problem is an entirely existential threat that has been deliberately created by a corrupt Government. Ironically enough, the millions of Euros spent by the Government on anti-immigration, anti-EU, anti Soros propaganda has gone straight into the pockets of the media companies owned by Orban's oligarchs. From whence it flows inexorably in the direction of Zurich.

[Link]


Edited by steve1984 (14 Dec 2018 12.14pm)

 

steve1984 14 Dec 18 1.03pm

The reality in Hungary is that they have a really bad labour shortage not a problem with immigrants.

Rumour has it that the reason for introducing a new law to increase the overtime to 400 hours pa was to secure investment from BMW for a new factory.

 

steve1984 14 Dec 18 1.14pm

But seeing how you're a fan of mono-culturalism or at least you'd prefer to live amongst your "own kind" you might find a trip to Hungary to be quite interesting. Certainly a lot easier than going all the way to Japan.

Theirs is an almost entirely mono-cultural society. I think about 98% of the population consider themselves to be ethically Hungarian.

100 years ago the situation was very different. Before the Treaty of Trianon in 1920 the Kingdom of Hungary (a state that was an equal partner with Austria in the Austro-Hungarian Empire) was 3 times larger in terms of territory.

But Hungarians were an ethnic minority in their own country.

Again somewhat ironically the issue which has united right wing nationalists since 1989 is this territorial loss which also resulted in the loss of about 3 million ethnic Hungarians whose ancestors still live in all the neighbouring countries.

The desire to see the former territory returned to what they see as its rightful sovereignty would result in millions of unwilling immigrants becoming de-facto Hungarian citizens.

And yet that is a problem that many nationalists say they would be willing to put up with in the name of "national justice".

Probably the experience of living in a country like this has a lot do with my entirely negative opinions about nationalism.

If you do decide to make a trip (which I can highly recommend) then look out for this ubiquitous equivalent to a GB plate. It's a map of pre-Trianon Hungary.

Try driving through Croatia with one of those on your car.

Edited by steve1984 (14 Dec 2018 1.23pm)

570127.jpg Attachment: 570127.jpg (42.48Kb)

 

steve1984 14 Dec 18 1.45pm

FYI Orban's Government granted these external Hungarians with the right to vote in Hungarian elections despite the fact that they aren't Hungarian citizens, don't live in Hungary and certainly don't pay Hungarian taxes.

They only need to prove their ethnicity.

Perhaps understandably they have a proclivity towards voting for Orban's Fidesz. Which helps to explain how he's able to win 66% of the seats in Parliament (on only 50% of the vote I should add).

What's your opinion on this? Would you be happy for ethnic Brits from South Africa, Australia or Canada to vote in a General election?

Edited by steve1984 (14 Dec 2018 1.46pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 14 Dec 18 2.12pm

Originally posted by steve1984

FYI Orban's Government granted these external Hungarians with the right to vote in Hungarian elections despite the fact that they aren't Hungarian citizens, don't live in Hungary and certainly don't pay Hungarian taxes.

They only need to prove their ethnicity.

Perhaps understandably they have a proclivity towards voting for Orban's Fidesz. Which helps to explain how he's able to win 66% of the seats in Parliament (on only 50% of the vote I should add).

What's your opinion on this? Would you be happy for ethnic Brits from South Africa, Australia or Canada to vote in a General election?

Edited by steve1984 (14 Dec 2018 1.46pm)

Yours post on this have been genuinely interesting.....cheers. We don't necessarily have to agree for me to appreciate and somewhat understand your perspective.

No is your answer....Based on what you said my view would be that once you no longer pay into the tax system for a country you don't get the right to a say on its policies.....Mind you I'd always keep the number of foreigners allowed in a country below a set percentage using workarounds....As in Japan.

While I definitely share the idea that countries should be protecting and advantaging their national identities and cultures above foreign ones....it doesn't extend to that.

I'm most strongly of the view that these eastern European are right not to allow significant non European immigration into their countries....it's the main reason they have been free of terrorist attacks. I don't think it's sensible to 'wait and see' if a problem occurs.....of course it will....it will occur and expand due to birth demographics.

However, that's a separate question from how corrupt or not a government is or the systems beneath it all.

I have the suspicion that all the former Soviet union states are like this and that it's a hangover from how those states were ran. I know a former Romanian who is a doctor there and a Youtuber who holds this view.....He doesn't think it's changing anytime soon.


Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Dec 2018 2.14pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 14 Dec 18 3.01pm

Originally posted by cryrst

That post without the muslim bit is what worries me about brexit and one reason i voted remain.
A lot of our labour laws come from Europe, and we are fairly well protected within them.
I do wonder that with control handed back to each company to a degree; that the protection might well reduce.

REDUCE? REDUCE? Don"t be silly cryrst, we can count on the CONservative Eton rifles boris or jacob to make sure the workers rights are FULLY implemented and with all the extra brexit cash coming our way, even improved! The CONS have the working mans rights at the front of their agenda, they have even given people the chance to be off the unemployment register with lots more jobs, record numbers i believe(although they might be one or two hours a day, not guaranteed, and we might call you at 5 am in the morning, or might not, so be available anyway!),,,,,,,,,but jobs none the less!

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 14 Dec 18 3.10pm

Originally posted by croydon proud

REDUCE? REDUCE? Don"t be silly cryrst, we can count on the CONservative Eton rifles boris or jacob to make sure the workers rights are FULLY implemented and with all the extra brexit cash coming our way, even improved! The CONS have the working mans rights at the front of their agenda, they have even given people the chance to be off the unemployment register with lots more jobs, record numbers i believe(although they might be one or two hours a day, not guaranteed, and we might call you at 5 am in the morning, or might not, so be available anyway!),,,,,,,,,but jobs none the less!

I don't want to rely on an external body for our rights. Parliament decides what these are and by extension the courts interpret them. If someone wanted to abolish the minimum wage and send children up chimney's I think the public would let their feelings be known at the next General Election.

 


One more point

Stirlingsays Flag 14 Dec 18 5.06pm

Something tells me that the solution to having problems with our own parliament isn't to be found in giving power to much larger external centralised and undemocratic bodies.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 14 Dec 18 5.12pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Something tells me that the solution to having problems with our own parliament isn't to be found in giving power to much larger external centralised and undemocratic bodies.

 


One more point

steve1984 14 Dec 18 6.24pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

..my view would be that once you no longer pay into the tax system for a country you don't get the right to a say on its policies.....Mind you I'd always keep the number of foreigners allowed in a country below a set percentage using workarounds....As in Japan.


Even if the fact that you no longer pay into the tax system wasn't through personal choice? I would agree that emigrants should relinquish their rights in their former country. But how should you feel if you find yourself to be a foreigner in your own country because some foreign powers (in this instance France, the UK and the USA) decided to donate your thousand year old homeland to another country?

As for keeping foreign residents at a fixed level, I would argue that it's always been a bit easier to implement for Japan or the UK because we are both island nations.

Maps of certain parts of Europe by comparison show the ethnic make-up of the population to resemble a patchwork quilt. Take the Banat for example a region of Central Europe that currently lies in modern Romania, Hungary and Serbia. Someone once said that if you put a chameleon on a map of the Banat, it wouldn't know what to do.

Living in Hungary provided me with a new perspective on the role of national borders in defining the territorial extent of nations culturally, ethnically, economically and politically.

For example when you stand in Komárom in Hungary and look across the Danube to Komárno in Slovakia. The similarity in the name is due to the fact that this was never two different places. At least not until 1920.

When instead of having to get in a boat (or in this day and age visit an airport) to visit another country you merely have to cross the road, you begin to question the role of the nation state in determining identity, loyalty and especially patriotism.

Edited by steve1984 (14 Dec 2018 6.42pm)

img-2-small580.jpg Attachment: img-2-small580.jpg (213.01Kb)

 

steve1984 14 Dec 18 6.37pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I'm most strongly of the view that these eastern European are right not to allow significant non European immigration into their countries....it's the main reason they have been free of terrorist attacks. I don't think it's sensible to 'wait and see' if a problem occurs.....of course it will....it will occur and expand due to birth demographics.

In the context of a nationalist solution to the problems of immigration, I would argue that it might be a little misleading or even disingenuous to only cite non European immigration as being a problem.

Historically Britain used emigration / immigration to pursue its colonial agenda most notably in Northern Ireland.

But the Hungarians were also "guilty" of oppressing national minorities in the former Kingdom of Hungary by for example denying them the right to become lawyers or refusing them the right to provide education in their own languages.

And indeed that lovely man Nicolae Ceausescu forcibly moved Romanians into the areas of Transylvania with a Hungarian majority in order to weaken the ethnic identity of those places.

In all three cases an attempt to impose or at least massively alter the ethnicity of a place has caused long term conflict and suffering whilst simultaneously damaging the health of that region's indigenous culture.

An indigenous culture that was distinctly multi-cultural.

Edited by steve1984 (14 Dec 2018 6.51pm)

 

steve1984 14 Dec 18 6.49pm

One of the reasons I went there in the first place was because I discovered that the Capital of Slovakia has three different names.

It had a population made up of three different ethnicities. Germans called it Pressburg, Hungarians Pozsony and Slovaks Bratislava. Not to mention the Jews who presumably also called it Pressburg.

I was intrigued to find out more about a place that seemed almost as cosmopolitan as my home town London.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 14 Dec 18 7.02pm

Originally posted by steve1984


Even if the fact that you no longer pay into the tax system wasn't through personal choice? I would agree that emigrants should relinquish their rights in their former country. But how should you feel if you find yourself to be a foreigner in your own country because some foreign powers (in this instance France, the UK and the USA) decided to donate your thousand year old homeland to another country?

As for keeping foreign residents at a fixed level, I would argue that it's always been a bit easier to implement for Japan or the UK because we are both island nations.

Maps of certain parts of Europe by comparison show the ethnic make-up of the population to resemble a patchwork quilt. Take the Banat for example a region of Central Europe that currently lies in modern Romania, Hungary and Serbia. Someone once said that if you put a chameleon on a map of the Banat, it wouldn't know what to do.

Living in Hungary provided me with a new perspective on the role of national borders in defining the territorial extent of nations culturally, ethnically, economically and politically.

For example when you stand in Komárom in Hungary and look across the Danube to Komárno in Slovakia. The similarity in the name is due to the fact that this was never two different places. At least not until 1920.

When instead of having to get in a boat (or in this day and age visit an airport) to visit another country you merely have to cross the road, you begin to question the role of the nation state in determining identity, loyalty and especially patriotism.

Edited by steve1984 (14 Dec 2018 6.42pm)

A nationality is a concept, it's a unifying idea to draw people who live in a similar location towards towards a common banner.....Whether one nation has control over a particular section of similar land or not isn't the point. Humans are more similar than they are different....but there are differences even if they are only cultural. So nationality is an agreed method between peoples who want to identify themselves.

It is an intrinsic part of being human. Most of us recognise that.....we are tribal at a rudimentary level. Supporting different football teams with different histories and attachments to different locations is just one reflection of that.

I remember having discussions with Jamie on the question of the relevance of nations and for him it made more sense to have an ethnic identity than a national one....though I don't want to say that he supported that either.

As I've noticed that my ethnic identity is under a longer term threat I've understood how these two interplays rub against each other.

For me the idea of nation has become rather a lost cause. It's something I'll defend but its value has reduced and withered. I know that for the English the light is dimly showing at the end of the tunnel. To change that dynamic would be enacting changes that I think would hurt me more than I'm willing to agree to....So instead I'm incredibly angry about it....Furious about it in fact.

I value my identity....and that's ok.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 136 of 142 < 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic