This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by silvertop
I was on the side of Parliament on that one; but that did not make it any more "democratic" (whatever that means?). The only sensible solution is to replace Truss with one candidate who the 5 major factions of the Tory party will support - good luck with that - and then put it to the people in a GE to underpin their mandate - which they won't as they will get creamed. Thus, 2 more years of political turmoil caused not by the system or the difficult environment but by a party that places clinging on to power above the country they are supposed to serve. People forgave the Tories for all the sleaze that brought in Blaire. Ask and I suspect most can't remember the end of the Major years: more their superior stewardship of the economy and world image. However, people still don't forgive Labour for the 1970s. I am afraid that when they come to vote in decades to come, people will talk about the Tory shambles that almost brought the country to its knees like they do about the Callaghan years. I tend to always agree with most of what you say, but think you are wrong on this. Our MPs are not supposed to "reflect" the views of their constituents. They are representatives and not delegates. Their job is to decide, in their collective wisdom and with the benefit of time and the opportunity to study and listen to experts, what is in our best interests. The Tory party members are no better off than the rest of us in that regard. Indeed, coming from a small group with similar outlooks, they are extremely biased in their approach.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I tend to always agree with most of what you say, but think you are wrong on this. Our MPs are not supposed to "reflect" the views of their constituents. They are representatives and not delegates. Their job is to decide, in their collective wisdom and with the benefit of time and the opportunity to study and listen to experts, what is in our best interests. The Tory party members are no better off than the rest of us in that regard. Indeed, coming from a small group with similar outlooks, they are extremely biased in their approach. I know what you are trying to say so I will decline the offer to get bogged down in semantics! Fact is, even if they were voted in by 20% of their constituency's population, they have promised to act in the best interests of 100%. If their duty and conscience (I know, more theory than practice) dictates that voting for X candidate will serve that 100% the best, then they have cast a vote for and in the name of c.100,000 people (whether their constituents agree with that or not).
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
The problem now is that since Brexit we haven’t the trade deals set up to export and grow ourselves out of this. It’s right in front of our eyes, yet even the PM and cabinet appear to have missed this, although no surprises there. There was clearly never a genuine attempt at this. Once Cummings was ejected due to Johnson being c***-struck, then it was as good as stymied. The biggest mistake was doing any kind of 'deal' with the EU. Should have been lots of smaller ones and just let the relationship evolve. Throw in Covid and it is obvious that a real Brexit has never been given a chance. The reality is that the UK is now effectively being run by the likes of Hunt. A full-on Remainer. We won the battle but suspect we are going to lose the peace. Except there is not going to be any peace. This does not go-away. English nationalism is our own chance of every truly being an independent nation. With a new political movement built around that. And that is going to be messy. But so be it. Better a mess then living in servility.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Perhaps you would like to clarify what you mean as "a real Brexit"? It might then be possible to comment on your views in a more reasoned manner.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
I am not taking sides here, but please provide ONE president who could cast the first stone. All are nuanced personalities; none are without fault and/or sin. Of course but Biden was being praised for not being a pathological liar, a pretty low bar you'd think, when he's no more truthful than the rest of them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Of course but Biden was being praised for not being a pathological liar, a pretty low bar you'd think, when he's no more truthful than the rest of them. I think the bar was set by his predecessor. In his case I am not sure Trump was a malicious, calculated liar (relatively). It was more a case of saying whatever came into his head with reckless disregard for whether it was true or false.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Maine Eagle
Joe Biden is doing fine, he’s not the sharpest tool in the shed, but experience and a steady hand counts for a lot in the White House. The main things I like about him are that he is not a sociopathic pathological liar, unable to form normal relationships with those around him and consumed by the need for attention, affection and wracked by paranoia and jealousy, with the conflict resolution skills of a 3 year old during a tantrum over not getting ice cream. Excellent, and I really enjoyed how he tucked in to a whopping ice cream while putting down the Truss trickle-down economic policy. 'Anyway it's up to Great Britain'.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I tend to always agree with most of what you say, but think you are wrong on this. Our MPs are not supposed to "reflect" the views of their constituents. They are representatives and not delegates. Their job is to decide, in their collective wisdom and with the benefit of time and the opportunity to study and listen to experts, what is in our best interests. The Tory party members are no better off than the rest of us in that regard. Indeed, coming from a small group with similar outlooks, they are extremely biased in their approach. So a group of 360 odd with similar outlooks have more wisdom than 160,000 with similar outlooks?
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
I think the bar was set by his predecessor. In his case I am not sure Trump was a malicious, calculated liar (relatively). It was more a case of saying whatever came into his head with reckless disregard for whether it was true or false. An interesting point, isn't it? Is malicious lying preferable to incompetence in a politician?
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
I think the bar was set by his predecessor. In his case I am not sure Trump was a malicious, calculated liar (relatively). It was more a case of saying whatever came into his head with reckless disregard for whether it was true or false. That was always my assessment but a very uninformed, anecdotal and not well researched one. With equal effort Biden seems to be just as unreliable for his own reasons but I would suggest his 'untruths' may be slightly more malevolent as opposed to reckless. Whilst a fan of neither I do still stand bemused with the stance that Biden is somehow an improvement upon Trump through characteristic assessment alone. Somebody who seems to be regarded as a proclaimer of untruths, senile (at best), unintelligent and riddled with 'family' problems is hardly the solution to anything. Furthermore, he seems to have a political history quite contradictory of the stance/character he is now trying to present which stinks of being disingenuous, deceitful and conniving. I care not much for US Politics, not because I see it as unimportant (it very obviously is) but as a charade masquerading as something other than that it ought be. The whole Trump vs Biden saga seems to be predicated upon this.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
That was always my assessment but a very uninformed, anecdotal and not well researched one. With equal effort Biden seems to be just as unreliable for his own reasons but I would suggest his 'untruths' may be slightly more malevolent as opposed to reckless. Whilst a fan of neither I do still stand bemused with the stance that Biden is somehow an improvement upon Trump through characteristic assessment alone. Somebody who seems to be regarded as a proclaimer of untruths, senile (at best), unintelligent and riddled with 'family' problems is hardly the solution to anything. Furthermore, he seems to have a political history quite contradictory of the stance/character he is now trying to present which stinks of being disingenuous, deceitful and conniving. I care not much for US Politics, not because I see it as unimportant (it very obviously is) but as a charade masquerading as something other than that it ought be. The whole Trump vs Biden saga seems to be predicated upon this. You'd also think the President of the USA would be proud to be American instead of claiming to be from somewhere his family left 200 years ago.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
You'd also think the President of the USA would be proud to be American instead of claiming to be from somewhere his family left 200 years ago. Once again, seems to be somewhat deceitful and disingenuous. Not that he's alone in that Presidential bracket but it's hardly a reason to favour him over Trump. He's about as Irish as a croissant.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
An interesting point, isn't it? Is malicious lying preferable to incompetence in a politician? I was commenting wholly on honesty rather than competence. You can probably be entirely dishonest and yet a brilliant statesman. Ask Machiavelli. On Trump, I don't think I need to comment on his competence as surely the facts speak for themselves.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Once again, seems to be somewhat deceitful and disingenuous. Not that he's alone in that Presidential bracket but it's hardly a reason to favour him over Trump. He's about as Irish as a croissant. Follows a long history of the Democrats aligning themselves to the important Irish American vote. And why Republican governments are (at least overtly) cozier to the UK, even (ironically) under Labour.
|
|
|
Originally posted by nead1
Perhaps you would like to clarify what you mean as "a real Brexit"? It might then be possible to comment on your views in a more reasoned manner.
I would have happily had a version of free-movement with EU countries but strictly limited immigration from outside of it. And any civil servant who dragged their feet, out straight away. In short, a far more brighter and bolder version than what we got. Yes, I accept Covid is/was the game changer on all sorts of levels but still, there was no sense of the dynamic. But now.,,we are sliding back into it on the back of all I can see as being an almost totally manufactured 'financial crisis'. So therefore England, which over-whelming voted for Brexit, needs to find its own way now. The UK is over.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
I would have happily had a version of free-movement with EU countries but strictly limited immigration from outside of it. And any civil servant who dragged their feet, out straight away. In short, a far more brighter and bolder version than what we got. Yes, I accept Covid is/was the game changer on all sorts of levels but still, there was no sense of the dynamic. But now.,,we are sliding back into it on the back of all I can see as being an almost totally manufactured 'financial crisis'. So therefore England, which over-whelming voted for Brexit, needs to find its own way now. The UK is over. Long term this could be viable, sure Short to medium term would be disastrous – you are aware how long it can take and how expensive/labour intensive it is to negotiate individual trade deals? Plus the fact that the economy would be tanking so fast in response to a clean break exit with no deal you'd be negotiating from a position of weakness. Ergo eliminating any benefits of this route entirely... Ultimately it would end up in a massive series of U-Turns...
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Long term this could be viable, sure Short to medium term would be disastrous – you are aware how long it can take and how expensive/labour intensive it is to negotiate individual trade deals? Plus the fact that the economy would be tanking so fast in response to a clean break exit with no deal you'd be negotiating from a position of weakness. Ergo eliminating any benefits of this route entirely... Ultimately it would end up in a massive series of U-Turns... Long term is the point. We voted to leave the EU because a majority of people wanted a different future for the UK. If we had a political leadership worthy of that title, it could have played it as a national project. Being honest about the sacrifices required. Instead we just got BS. A political elite, backed up the Civil Service, who had zero interest in the UK making the kind of structural changes necessary. When we end up back in the EU, it will be a case of stabbing England in the back. Time to go it properly alone.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Long term is the point. We voted to leave the EU because a majority of people wanted a different future for the UK. If we had a political leadership worthy of that title, it could have played it as a national project. Being honest about the sacrifices required. Instead we just got BS. A political elite, backed up the Civil Service, who had zero interest in the UK making the kind of structural changes necessary. When we end up back in the EU, it will be a case of stabbing England in the back. Time to go it properly alone. You can be as honest as you like about sacrifices but if it hits people hard what has happened over the last few days will always happen. Short term pain long term gain doesn’t work and will never work in government if it hits people in the pocket. Doesn’t matter how hard you sell them a long term dream Bit naive to think otherwise IMO. Also I’d wager not everyone who voted for brexit wanted your take on it. So what you’re saying is basically unachievable even if it might have worked long term Edited by SW19 CPFC (17 Oct 2022 7.45pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.