You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rumour: Pulis To Quit In The Summer
November 16 2026 1.41pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rumour: Pulis To Quit In The Summer


Page 14 of 17 < 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >
FinchleyEagle Flag 27 Jan 14 9.53am

Quote Ian J at 27 Jan 2014 9.04am

Quote npn at 27 Jan 2014 8.37am

Genuine question:

Is there any basis at all behind the board "interfering in football matters" or is it pure conjecture?

The only place I've heard it mentioned is on the HOL, and I've never seen it substantiated by any quotes from anyone who would actually know

Who knows but it has been carried by a few of the newspapers and more to the point has not been denied by either Parish or Pulis.

Steve Browett did mention something on the BBS but it was only half hearted and hardly emphatic.

So no basis then. Just filling column inches.

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 27 Jan 14 10.00am

Quote Kermit8 at 27 Jan 2014 7.29am

The really good unique thing about this particular Prem season is, surprisingly, is that there aren't just one or two sh1t teams as per but five or six. Five or six teams clubs that even with same squads would not necessarily come top or even in the top five in The Championship.

This is why we shouldn't panic about anything. Pulis leaving, no signings, etc, should they happen.

Last August We nearly all thought we'd be more or less relegated by now with only about 12-14 points on the board and adrift.

The reason we will stay up is because out of those five or six sh1t teams we have the best spirit. That won't change now. The others are in the quicksand and are fragile. We are not. We have character. Lots of it.

Bingo.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Jan 14 10.00am

Quote Ian J at 27 Jan 2014 9.02am

Quote Horsham_Eagle at 27 Jan 2014 8.42am

[But the owners of Cardiff and Hull don't interfere with the footballing side of the club at all. One changed the colours that they play in and the other wants a slight change to the club's name.

People do claim that if they don't get their own way that they might just walk away from the club but somehow I doubt it as it would mean writing off the sizeable debts that the clubs own them and no-ne is daft enough to cut off their noses to spite a few disgruntled fans.

I would say that undermining a previously successful manager, replacing the sporting director with someone who had no knowledge of football, and then bringing in a manager with no experience of managing in the premiership, and an average managerial record at best is definitely interfering in the football side of thigns

It would appear that the Sporting Director that he sacked had been acting way outside his terms of reference if the media reports are to be believed and he had lost confidence in his ability to perform.

What is so different about Tan "bringing in a manager with no experience of managing in the premiership, and an average managerial record at best" which you claim is "definitely interfering in the football side of things" and Steve Parish who appointed Dougie Freedman who had absolutely no experience of managing any club in any division whatsoever



Ian J, that's a selective memory if ever I've seen one. DF was offered the job because of a few reasons.

1) Nobody wanted to take it on. We know this because it was the same the previous year in admin when only Paul Hart was willing.

2) DF knew the whole squad as he'd been a coach or asst for 12 months.

3) He gave 2010 of what he needed adding (KG, Augustien), and how he could earn the points to stay up.

4) We were at rock bottom, he was starting out. Perfect fit. We grow together. Unfortunately DF wanted to go at his speed and couldn't go at the developing speed of Jedi, Zaha etc without being nudged by the board.

Don't compare Palace in 22nd place in the Championship with the squad and budget then, with Cardiff now.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (27 Jan 2014 10.19am)

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Jan 14 10.11am

Quote movingforward at 26 Jan 2014 10.47pm

Quote Dangermouse at 26 Jan 2014 10.44pm

Quote Kosowski at 26 Jan 2014 10.35pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 26 Jan 2014 10.32pm

Quote TomThePalaceFanatic at 26 Jan 2014 10.24pm

I agree that Jordan lacks business acumen. But the main difference between him and Parish is that Parish doesn't, and I think that's evident.

Tom, to some extent I agree with you here. Parish's achievements with TAG are far more substantial, and provide far more evidence of acumen, than anything from Jordan's career. But that makes the pig's ear he's making of running Palace all the harder to understand. For someone seemingly quite sharp, his obvious failure to run Palace effectively suggests that either his ego has got in the way of his business sense or he actually had no acumen to begin with. As I do not believe the latter to be true, I honestly think he is now so enamoured with himself that he can't get out of the way and let the football professionals around him do their jobs. I'm not sure what else you can conclude.


I despair. Admin to PL in 3 seasons with no debts and our owners are making a pigs ear of things.


I know brilliant ain't it?

with respect I think the poster means pigs ear of the summer transfer window and losing the players TP wanted this window


This thread doesn't surprise me anymore. Everyday you get sydtheeagle telling us exactly how incompetenmt Parish and the board are, but when players unwilling to accept relegation clauses, wages under £40k - £50k per week, for 130-180 weeks, he goes all quiet or logs off.

Then when someone who hasn't run their own business or company he cannot wait to tell one and all that he runs a business worth a 7 figure sum. Well that is miniscule compared to what is going on at the moment, and what he and others seem to conveniently forget is that football is unlike any other business, although now and then they use it to suit the point they're making. If you get relegated, your world and revenue is turned upside down. It isn't like any other business where you can make redundancies, move premises. These are fixed costs. If you told any of these people their fixed costs would rise by 400% tomorrow and they'd have to mortgage the house their missus loves to bits with the suspicion their clients might choose a competitor in 4 months time, you'd see their &rses squeak more than an un-escorted walk from New Cross to the Old Den decked in red and blue.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Jan 14 10.14am

Funny how people fully believe the spin on the Moody transfers at Cardiff. Does anybody not think that Tan would've seen the transfers one by one or week to week? Or did all the deals land in his email inbox all in one go? Dear boss, I've spent £10mil more than agreed. Regards, I. Moody.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Jan 14 10.17am

Interesting how also sydtheeagle has started in this thread by saying 'Parish should keep his mouth shut', to 'Why aren't we being told what is going on?' This is amongst threads where no clues as to how he or anyone else with this viewpoint thinks we should go about the wage and contract length demands of players already in £40k - £50k per week contracts. In all the states people have worked themselves into, they cannot grasp that you either have to spend very highly right now, or you wait a few days. Clubs cannot use more than the 25 man squads plus youngsters. It really is that straightforward yet people just don't want to accept it. Instead argue around and avoid the exact economics.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (27 Jan 2014 10.24am)

 


COYP

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 Jan 14 10.19am

Quote Rudi Hedman at 27 Jan 2014 10.00am

Quote Ian J at 27 Jan 2014 9.02am

Quote Horsham_Eagle at 27 Jan 2014 8.42am

[But the owners of Cardiff and Hull don't interfere with the footballing side of the club at all. One changed the colours that they play in and the other wants a slight change to the club's name.

People do claim that if they don't get their own way that they might just walk away from the club but somehow I doubt it as it would mean writing off the sizeable debts that the clubs own them and no-ne is daft enough to cut off their noses to spite a few disgruntled fans.

I would say that undermining a previously successful manager, replacing the sporting director with someone who had no knowledge of football, and then bringing in a manager with no experience of managing in the premiership, and an average managerial record at best is definitely interfering in the football side of thigns

It would appear that the Sporting Director that he sacked had been acting way outside his terms of reference if the media reports are to be believed and he had lost confidence in his ability to perform.

What is so different about Tan "bringing in a manager with no experience of managing in the premiership, and an average managerial record at best" which you claim is "definitely interfering in the football side of things" and Steve Parish who appointed Dougie Freedman who had absolutely no experience of managing any club in any division whatsoever


Ian J, that's a selective memory if ever I've seen one. DF was offered the job because of a few reasons.

1) Nobody wanted to take it on. We know this because it was the same the previous year in admin when only Paul Hart was willing.

2) DF knew the whole squad as he'd been a coach or asst for 12 months.

3) He gave 2010 of what he needed adding (KG, Augustien), and how he could earn the points to stay up.

4) We were at rock bottom, he was starting out. Perfect fit. We grow together. Unfortunately DF wanted to go at his speed and couldn't go at the developing speed of Jedi, Zaha etc without being nudged by the board.

Don't compare Palace in 22nd place in the Championship with the squad and budget then, with Cardiff now.


----------------------------------------------------

You beat me to it Rudi. Just not a sensible comment, we were in the poop and had to get a manager. And Dougie appears to have been the best of whoever was interviewed.

Tan created the need by disposing of a perfectly serviceable one. And as you say, it's not the same thing bringing in a new manager when you are in the Premiership, with the massively bigger scale and financial risks.

Mind you, it does look like it may have been a master stroke. Solskjaer appears to have all the right friends.

Edited by Mapletree (27 Jan 2014 10.20am)

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 27 Jan 14 10.23am

Pulis denies he will quit


[Link]

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

ElliottHutchins Flag Wakefield 27 Jan 14 10.25am

Lol. Thats the end of that Tabloid bollocks then. I knew it was all s***. Pulis isn't that sort of character. He is frustrated which is apparent to see for all but they've just added a bit on by saying he'll leave because of it.

We'll sign some decent players and Pulis will stay. Relax Frankie!

 


Ex-HOL Preview Bod
Prediction League - Runner Up 2003/04
HOL Cool Dude of the Season 2004/05

I was there - ElliottHutchins 19/12/2006

R.I.P. staffie & DJ Hardline

WingJohnson Flag Orpington 27 Jan 14 10.30am

That's good news. Relaxation time.

 


Cant we all just get along?

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Jan 14 10.34am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 27 Jan 2014 10.23am

Pulis denies he will quit

So much for the alleged "Fallout" with Parish which I stated was not true !

Is Pulis disappointed that he hasn't been able to secure certain targets ? YES
Is Pulis frustrated by the lack of signings ? YES
Has Pulis fallen out with Parish ? NO


 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Jan 14 10.39am

Quote ElliottHutchins at 27 Jan 2014 10.25am

Lol. Thats the end of that Tabloid bollocks then. I knew it was all s***. Pulis isn't that sort of character. He is frustrated which is apparent to see for all but they've just added a bit on by saying he'll leave because of it.

We'll sign some decent players and Pulis will stay. Relax Frankie!


Yesterday it wasn't in the interest to print lies, and now TP is hinting that. Shall we have a 20 page thread debating which paper is publishing the lies?....

Pulis told the South London Press: "It sells papers. I've never done that before and I'm not going to do that now.
"It is a lot of nonsense. I came here to do a job and I want to get that job done."

Of course he might leave in the Summer. Anyone might leave anywhere in the Summer. What matters is survival that is calculated properly. If that situation arises we'll know what we need to do with that open position and the squad.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (27 Jan 2014 10.40am)

 


COYP

Midlands Eagle Flag 27 Jan 14 10.47am

Quote Mapletree at 27 Jan 2014 10.19am

Quote Rudi Hedman at 27 Jan 2014 10.00am

Quote Ian J at 27 Jan 2014 9.02am

Quote Horsham_Eagle at 27 Jan 2014 8.42am

[But the owners of Cardiff and Hull don't interfere with the footballing side of the club at all. One changed the colours that they play in and the other wants a slight change to the club's name.

People do claim that if they don't get their own way that they might just walk away from the club but somehow I doubt it as it would mean writing off the sizeable debts that the clubs own them and no-ne is daft enough to cut off their noses to spite a few disgruntled fans.

I would say that undermining a previously successful manager, replacing the sporting director with someone who had no knowledge of football, and then bringing in a manager with no experience of managing in the premiership, and an average managerial record at best is definitely interfering in the football side of thigns

It would appear that the Sporting Director that he sacked had been acting way outside his terms of reference if the media reports are to be believed and he had lost confidence in his ability to perform.

What is so different about Tan "bringing in a manager with no experience of managing in the premiership, and an average managerial record at best" which you claim is "definitely interfering in the football side of things" and Steve Parish who appointed Dougie Freedman who had absolutely no experience of managing any club in any division whatsoever


Ian J, that's a selective memory if ever I've seen one. DF was offered the job because of a few reasons.

1) Nobody wanted to take it on. We know this because it was the same the previous year in admin when only Paul Hart was willing.

2) DF knew the whole squad as he'd been a coach or asst for 12 months.

3) He gave 2010 of what he needed adding (KG, Augustien), and how he could earn the points to stay up.

4) We were at rock bottom, he was starting out. Perfect fit. We grow together. Unfortunately DF wanted to go at his speed and couldn't go at the developing speed of Jedi, Zaha etc without being nudged by the board.

Don't compare Palace in 22nd place in the Championship with the squad and budget then, with Cardiff now.


----------------------------------------------------

You beat me to it Rudi. Just not a sensible comment, we were in the poop and had to get a manager. And Dougie appears to have been the best of whoever was interviewed.

I'm beginning to think that some people just like the sound of their own voices as they are fond of answering questions that haven't been asked and taking quotes out of context just for the sake of arguing.

Let's have a look at the timeline on this one.

1) In answer to the specific point that at least we don't have awful owners like Cardiff and Hull I comment that whilst they annoy supporters by changing the team's colours and trying to change the club's name at least they have pumped many millions into their clubs and they don't get involved in footballing matters.

2) Someone answers that Tan does get involved in football matters as he sacked a manager and replaced him with one that had no Premiership experience

3) I replied specifically to that point saying that Steve Parish did the same by sacking our manager and replacing him with someone with no managerial experience at all.

4) I am now accused of having a selective memory by one person and posting a reply that wasn't sensible by another.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 27 Jan 14 10.50am

Quote Willo at 27 Jan 2014 10.34am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 27 Jan 2014 10.23am

Pulis denies he will quit

So much for the alleged "Fallout" with Parish which I stated was not true !

Is Pulis disappointed that he hasn't been able to secure certain targets ? YES
Is Pulis frustrated by the lack of signings ? YES
Has Pulis fallen out with Parish ? NO


We all know that your style is to post as if you're in the know but in the denial issued by Tony Pulis he didn't mention whether he had fallen out with Steve Parish or not.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Jan 14 10.54am

Quote Ian J at 27 Jan 2014 10.50am

We all know that your style is to post as if you're in the know but in the denial issued by Tony Pulis he didn't mention whether he had fallen out with Steve Parish or not.

With respect, I don't set out to give any such impression so it is down to your interpretation of my comments.
Pulis of course never mentioned anything about an alleged "Fallout" probably because it is irrelevant.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Jan 14 11.03am

Quote Ian J at 27 Jan 2014 10.50am

Quote Willo at 27 Jan 2014 10.34am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 27 Jan 2014 10.23am

Pulis denies he will quit

So much for the alleged "Fallout" with Parish which I stated was not true !

Is Pulis disappointed that he hasn't been able to secure certain targets ? YES
Is Pulis frustrated by the lack of signings ? YES
Has Pulis fallen out with Parish ? NO


We all know that your style is to post as if you're in the know but in the denial issued by Tony Pulis he didn't mention whether he had fallen out with Steve Parish or not.


This isn't really going anywhere for you is it?

Tan does or doesn't get involved and Moody is now criticised heavily for overspending. Should he have kept quiet, should he have spoken up, or does he speak after it's gone t1ts up?

Hindsight is great, SP makes calculated decisions before that happens. If it goes wrong, some ownership of errors are made. I know who I'd rather have, and I know I'd rather have an owner who isn't acquiescent to every decision based on here and now whilst praying that having 1,2, or 3 £50k a week players for the next 3 seasons with everyone else on £15k or less isn't going to be a problem.

TP won't specifically deny there's tensions because quite frankly, that's day to day life when you have one party that wants one end of the spectrum because he's interested in his career and the consequences do not matter, versus the one who signs cheques off and has a bigger and longer-term responsibilty, which I'm glad he does.

 


COYP

tshepp897 Flag Dublin - Cabra 27 Jan 14 11.04am

Quote

Let's have a look at the timeline on this one.

1) In answer to the specific point that at least we don't have awful owners like Cardiff and Hull I comment that whilst they annoy supporters by changing the team's colours and trying to change the club's name at least they have pumped many millions into their clubs and they don't get involved in footballing matters.

2) Someone answers that Tan does get involved in football matters as he sacked a manager and replaced him with one that had no Premiership experience

3) I replied specifically to that point saying that Steve Parish did the same by sacking our manager and replacing him with someone with no managerial experience at all.

4) I am now accused of having a selective memory by one person and posting a reply that wasn't sensible by another.


I thought your original point was that he was different to Parish as he didn't get involved in footballing matters. Now your defense of that point is to claim they both did the same thing. That's very confusing logic.

Edited by tshepp897 (27 Jan 2014 11.17am)

 


The cellophane illusion of a starry sky / Stretched over an open sore.
Big Nothing

paulose17 Flag Sutton 27 Jan 14 11.05am

Now stop whinging everyone:


[Link]

 


Want a thread killed? Don't delay, special offer on two threads killed at the same time. Just contact paulose17 at the usual address.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Jan 14 11.07am

Quote tshepp897 at 27 Jan 2014 11.04am

Quote

Let's have a look at the timeline on this one.

1) In answer to the specific point that at least we don't have awful owners like Cardiff and Hull I comment that whilst they annoy supporters by changing the team's colours and trying to change the club's name at least they have pumped many millions into their clubs and they don't get involved in footballing matters.

2) Someone answers that Tan does get involved in football matters as he sacked a manager and replaced him with one that had no Premiership experience

3) I replied specifically to that point saying that Steve Parish did the same by sacking our manager and replacing him with someone with no managerial experience at all.

4) I am now accused of having a selective memory by one person and posting a reply that wasn't sensible by another.


I thought you're original point was that he was different to Parish as he didn't get involved in footballing matters. Now your defense of that point is to claim they both did the same thing. That's very confusing logic.


People tend to go round in circles when they do not answer a specific question. The question is, do you offer 1,2 or 3 players £40k - £50k per week for 130-180 weeks, plus transfer fees, plus signing on fees, plus agent fees, before next weekend when more players need the chance of top flight football.

sydtheeagle has also gone full circle with the owners should shut up to pipe up.

 


COYP

Midlands Eagle Flag 27 Jan 14 11.19am

Quote tshepp897 at 27 Jan 2014 11.04am

Quote

Let's have a look at the timeline on this one.

1) In answer to the specific point that at least we don't have awful owners like Cardiff and Hull I comment that whilst they annoy supporters by changing the team's colours and trying to change the club's name at least they have pumped many millions into their clubs and they don't get involved in footballing matters.

2) Someone answers that Tan does get involved in football matters as he sacked a manager and replaced him with one that had no Premiership experience

3) I replied specifically to that point saying that Steve Parish did the same by sacking our manager and replacing him with someone with no managerial experience at all.

4) I am now accused of having a selective memory by one person and posting a reply that wasn't sensible by another.


I thought you're original point was that he was different to Parish as he didn't get involved in footballing matters. Now your defense of that point is to claim they both did the same thing. That's very confusing logic.

It's only confusing as Rudy Hedman keeps mixing up quotes and replying to posts that I haven't made so for the sake of clarity I will yet again lay out a timeline

1) I have posted my views that Steve Parish interferes too much in footballing matters.

2) Someone replies that at least he isn't like the owners of Cardiff and Hull.

3) I reply saying that the owners of both Hull and Cardiff pump millions into their clubs and don't interfere in footballing matters

4) Someone else responds that Tan sacked his manager and replaced him with someone else so he is interfering in footballing matters

5) I reply saying that Steve Parish also sacked our manager and replaced him with someone else.

I don't consider the chairman and/or owner sacking the manager to be interfering in football matters as if they don't sack an underperforming manager who on earth will do it.

 

Page 14 of 17 < 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rumour: Pulis To Quit In The Summer