This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Quote johnfirewall at 17 Jul 2015 12.22pm
They were obviously waved in protest, still leaving 2 possible intentions. There are those unwilling to distinguish nationalism from racism even within England where there have been issues flying our own flag. I'm happy to concede that because the connations exist it therefore becomes racial rather than the sort of wind-up any leader might face in an area with dissident tendancies, but then the flag can never be about anything else which I think has the opposite effect. I'm only still participating in this thread because I have an issue with things being deemed offensive where the vast majority of usage is innocent. Perhaps I need a better gauge of what degree of usage is intentionally offensive. Presumably this would fall somewhere between a swastika 100% (of non-Sanskrit usage) and the St Georges at 10%. Overall HF meant nothing by it, although one poster alluded to appropriation of it for reasons other than the aesthetic.
Lend me a Tenor 31 May to 3 June 2017 John McIntosh Arts Centre with Superfly in the chorus |
|
|
It's a nice flag.
|
|
|
Quote mcduh at 17 Jul 2015 2.45pm
And here in the link below we see the young man who shot up the church in South Carolina, killing innocents while screaming misguided and misanthropic nonsense, an act which sparked off the debate over the Confederate flag once again.... And here is Anders Breivik in his fake military uniform next to a red Cross Pattee, supposed to symbolise the Knights Templar. Some people have associated the use of the Cross Pattee with Nazism, but does that make it's use racist? It is used by: The state of Montenegro Is the use by those organisations to be taken as an endorsement of Nazism, or of Breivik? Edited by blanksight (17 Jul 2015 3.03pm)
I'd rather be a FREE MAN in my grave |
|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 17 Jul 2015 2.25pm
Quote Superfly at 17 Jul 2015 11.57am
I just can't see it that way. They were either waving it through ignorance or to antagonise.
That is the precise opposite, because you aren't 'debating' but instead deciding for other people.....Like I say, where's the 'reasoned debate'. Aren't you just objecting to an alternative view? The 'ignorance' aspect is subjective on both sides and as for antagonising.....Well, every flag does that to someone or other.....It doesn't mean a person can't wave it......People should be asked why they are waving it.....What it means to you, doesn't mean it means the same to them. If someone is waving a flag in support of slavery or some other inhumanity then I agree action should be taken. But what I object to is a person stating that a flag only means 'this this and this' and that this is the only way to look at it. That is unreasonable to me. The confederate flag can be flown by people to mean other things than slavery....Independence from the North, Pride in a Southern identity. People should be given the benefit of the doubt before you stereotype them as racists.
I mentioned 'Reasoned Debate' as another poster was attempting to portray the flag waving in Oklahoma as innocent and well received when it was anything but. And in your last sentence - I didn't stereotype anyone as a racist. I clearly stated that I believe in this instance it was used without knowledge or intent of offense.
Some flags more than others. This one being high too up on the antagonising chart to be ignored. People should be asked why they are waving it No, really I don't think they should. Not in the stands of Selhurst Park anyway. It's not the intent but how it's percieved. Maybe if they were waiving another flag with a disclaimer about them not endorsing slavery but supprting Southern pride then maybe. I was too hasty when saying the flag is only used in ignorance or to annoy because as you point out, there are honorable reasons. But in this instance, in the stands of an English football ground with no historic connections, it can (in my unreasoned mind) only be a mistake or to annoy.
Lend me a Tenor 31 May to 3 June 2017 John McIntosh Arts Centre with Superfly in the chorus |
|
|
Most exalted demonstration of the Cross Pattee:
|
|
|
"Is country music ready to dissociate from the Confederate flag?"
see also: [Link] "The Confederate Flag is America's Swastika" What appears to be a halfway interesting piece in the Washington Post:
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.