Quote Hoof Hearted at 13 Sep 2015 1.15pm
Quote serial thriller at 13 Sep 2015 1.01pm
Quote matt_himself at 12 Sep 2015 8.08pm
Quote ChuFukka at 12 Sep 2015 7.53pm
Quote serial thriller at 12 Sep 2015 7.49pm
Quote matt_himself at 12 Sep 2015 6.59pm
Quote serial thriller at 12 Sep 2015 6.25pm
Minutes after his victory, Corbyn said the message is that people are “fed up with the injustice and the inequality” of Britain.
A very simple point, but one it's incredibly hard to argue with.
It's just a sound bite that means nothing and is swallowed by morons as heralding a new, golden age.
I can't wait to see what the next 99 days of his leadership bring...
I think it's salient because the UK is supposedly in a period of economic growth, unlike in Spain or Greece where similar movements have gathered pace, and I think the reason behind it is because many people, especially the young, do regard the country as unequal (which it of course is, massively) and unjust. Regardless of your political standpoint, this is a massive moment in British politics and one that came completely out of the blue. I think Corbyn's right as to where this discontent is coming from.
It would be a mistake to overstate the strength of this result though; to quote some guy on the BBS:
251,000 people felt shaken up enough to vote for him out of the 9,347,000 people who voted Labour in the last election. How many of those votes were mischievous will never be known either.
Basically, he's won the already converted. Time will tell whether he can go one better.
In his head 'it's massive'. Let him think that. It will soon all be revealed for what it is.
It is massive. It's possibly the biggest surprise in British politics since Attlee won in 45. We now have the leader of the opposition, voted in with an unprecedented mandate, putting forward a political position which hasn't been seen in decades. Why you feel the need to patronise me I don't know, I'm trying to engage in an intellectual discussion here, but oh well.
As for your point Chu, the important point about the number who voted Corbyn is that they are all now members of the Labour party, thus are active political agents. Labour has more than doubled its membership, meaning it's around 5/6 times greater than that of the Tories, and is back to levels no political party has seen in 30 years. Granted, these people don't guarantee him the number of votes needed to win an election, but what it means is that Labour's work force, required to leaflet, canvas, donate and drive their campaign, will be far greater. There are a lot of similarities between this and Obama's campaign for Presidency in 2008, where he relied on a large mobilisation of activists and supporters, which the Republican campaign ultimately couldn't cope with. It's not really right to view it as winning over the converted; more like unifying and mobilising the previously disparate groups who shared his political views.
Let's not forget too, Corbyn not only won over the £3 new members, he actually won more votes among longstanding Labour party members than his opponents. Yesterday's result, regardless of your political perspective, was emphatically significant.
Elections are won by votes from people that overwhelmingly are not members of any political party. They tend to vote for credible leaders - the following list were spectacularly non-credible leaders of Labour that led to disastrous election campaigns:-
Kinnock, Foot, Brown, Miliband (double whammy paired with Balls)..... now Corbyn
Only a fool would be encouraged by yesterday's leadership result... it will end in tears for the Labour Party... mark my words.
But membership is massively important. UKIP's rise to hold the highest number of MEPs would never have happened without the surge in membership they gained a few years ago. The SNP gaining nearly every seat in Scotland was triggered by a mass mobilisation of activists around the referendum. The Labour party itself was born out of a desire for parliamentary recognition by the Trade Union movement, and thus its successes (Attlee, Wilson, even Blair) have all had to rely on strong membership support (under Blair, membership nearly hit 500000 having been at half of that under Kinnock).
In fact your point about leaders only proves this point. Labour lost in 83 because of a split in party membership between them and the SDP, under Milliband it nudged 200000 but that's nothing really. As for being credible, well Attlee was seen as credible in 45, Wilson was seen as credible in 74, and their manifestos were to the left of anything that's come out of the Corbyn camp so far. Interesting times.
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4
|