Quote serial thriller at 15 Nov 2015 2.30pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 15 Nov 2015 1.54pm
Quote cornwalls palace at 15 Nov 2015 1.09pm
..but, not if everyone on earth thinks like a Nazi you knew the answer to that.
If everyone thinks the moon is made of cheese is that a good thing?
If everyone thinks that books that don't agree with official state dogma should be burned is that a good thing?
If everyone thinks that Jews should be exterminated is that a good thing? Indeed the Nazis wished to turn the Poles into slaves so I'm not even sure that they envisioned a world with only them in it.
Any society that replaces reason with dogma.....whether that dogma is religious or state leader inspired is a society that has turned its back on reason and the lessons of enlightenment.
Keep Britain secular.
But hasn't science, too, been used to justify atrocities? Throughout the 18th and 19th centuries, while Christianity was the backbone of pro-slavery arguments, the pseudo-science of phrenology, claiming that black people had smaller brains than white people and were therefore sub-human. On the subject of Nazis, biological justifications for the denigration of both Jews and disabled people were rife.
The point I'm trying to make is that to believe a religion is at fault for human vice is to think of religion as something fixed rather than as something fluid. Like all beliefs, it is something which is interpreted based on the environmental conditions in which it lives. The last caliphate, the Ottoman empire, was a place of religious pluralism, ethnic pluralism and tolerance of homosexuals, even while it shared many religious beliefs with IS. Why did they interpret the same holy scriptures and religious teachings so differently to those in Iraq and Syria currently? Probably because they lived in a (relatively) peaceful, prosperous society, rather than in a region which has been systematically carpet bombed for decades.
I'm an atheist, and because I am an atheist I view religion not in a spiritual sense but as a product of particular human societies. But to punish all Muslims is to do the exact opposite; it is to suggest that their is something inherent, transcendental in their beliefs.
That's why it's stupid to stop accepting asylum seekers after this attack on the grounds of their religion. Not only are you physically turning them back to the enemies we claim to share, but you are igniting an antagonism towards 'the West' in the refugees which IS absolutely thrive on.
Just how many straw man arguments do you put up here. Reading through the post I lost count.
It would be easier if you stuck to the arguments I made rather than extrapolate and then discuss different points that I haven't. I will refer to some points however before I need to attend to tomorrow's work.
A secular society can take many forms. It has developed since it's had a chance to the point where certain aspects of what secularists have fought for have created a modern society that's very attractive to many.
Eugenics is an area of interest to me and an exciting avenue for future human improvement. Misuse and errors in its applications from previous centuries ago have harmed its reputation but it has the potential to cure many of societies ills.
As for the Ottoman sultans, or caliphs, in the 18th and 19th centuries, it's true that they launched secular schools and promoted the education of women and had homosexuality decriminalised in 1858...Neither of which was a popular move amongst their far more religious populations it has to be said. The period of reformation known as the Tanzimat saw customary and religious laws being replaced in favour of secular European ones.
However, this has to be seen as one period of the Ottoman empire and definitely not representative of all of it.....However, despite being officially Islamic it has to be said that for most of the time the empire didn't take this title seriously until it saw its power crumbling......Then perhaps you wouldn't have waxed so happily over it.
Edited by Stirlingsays (15 Nov 2015 3.45pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|