You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 14 of 71 < 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >
Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 20 Oct 18 12.18am

Originally posted by Willo

If and when we get relegated then of course the SKY coverage of our games will be greatly reduced.

In this scenario, one can only speculate as to how many of the HF will still be in regular attendance, whilst I suspect the die-hard season ticket holders in Block E who have supported the club through thick and thin and are going to be displaced, will in the main still stay loyal to the cause.

People convieniently forget that the HF were formed in 2005 whilst we were in the Championship. Contrary to what many believe on here, they didn’t just appear when we got to the Premiership. They have been at least equally loyal as other season ticket holders over this 13 year period (in my opinion they do far more than other season ticket holders to back the team, so deserve all the preferential treatment they receive).

They of course haven’t been around since the stand opened, but you can’t blame them for that as most of them probably weren’t even born then. For all we know they could all be season ticket holders since a very young age but did not join the HF until they stopped going with their dads.

To suggest the HF might not be in regular attendance if we got relegated seems extremely unfair.


Edited by Midlands Eagle (20 Oct 2018 7.19am)

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 20 Oct 18 6.36am

Originally posted by Jamesey


Thanks for your sensible and considered reply. I admit I had you down as a leftie Sussex Uni student so I am surprised.

In retrospect I wish you no offence and respect your views with which I obviously disagree!

However one last statement from me on this thread at least - Atmosphere doesn't always equate with noise...


what else does it equate with, for you?

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

bicycle repair man 20 Oct 18 7.45am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

because when the same old faces sit in the same old seats for decades, their human nature -- which generally tends to be polite, inhibited, and not inclined to shouting -- slowly comes to the fore. And once they've gone a few games not singing, it just gets harder and harder to get them (I actually count myself) going. mix it up a bit amd maybe things would be more lively.

All seater stadia and perpetual seat renewals are killing the atmosphere in English football. If that doesn't reverse, one day it'll kill the game too.

Also, just to be clear, I'm no great fan of the HF. many many t***s among them. but I do like a great atmosphere. sp has also played an absolute stinker.

What on Earth are you going on about, you're talking nonsense.
The perpetual seat renewers are the life blood of the game.
It is they who go and watch their club whatever league or division they are in,they don't just turn up because their team is in the Premier League.
And if all seater stadiums are killing the game how come most Premier League games sell out ?

 

Leecpfc Flag Praying for love in a lapdance... 20 Oct 18 8.18am

Originally posted by Goal Machine

People convieniently forget that the HF were formed in 2005 whilst we were in the Championship. Contrary to what many believe on here, they didn’t just appear when we got to the Premiership. They have been at least equally loyal as other season ticket holders over this 13 year period (in my opinion they do far more than other season ticket holders to back the team, so deserve all the preferential treatment they receive).

They of course haven’t been around since the stand opened, but you can’t blame them for that as most of them probably weren’t even born then. For all we know they could all be season ticket holders since a very young age but did not join the HF until they stopped going with their dads.

To suggest the HF might not be in regular attendance if we got relegated seems extremely unfair.


Edited by Midlands Eagle (20 Oct 2018 7.19am)

We were playing Premier League football in 2005.... (well the first half of it)

 


Raised on a diet of broken biscuits

Jamesey Flag Wandsworth 20 Oct 18 9.08am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig


what else does it equate with, for you?


atmosphere | &#712;atm&#601;sf&#618;&#601; |
noun [usually in singular]
1 the envelope of gases surrounding the earth or another planet: part of the sun's energy is absorbed by the earth's atmosphere.
• the air in any particular place: these beetles breed best in a damp atmosphere.
• (abbreviation atm) Physics a unit of pressure equal to mean atmospheric pressure at sea level, 101,325 pascals.
2 the pervading tone or mood of a place, situation, or creative work: the hotel has won commendations for its friendly, welcoming atmosphere.
• [mass noun] a pleasurable and interesting mood: a superb restaurant, full of atmosphere.
ORIGIN
mid 17th century: from modern Latin atmosphaera, from Greek atmos ‘vapour’ + sphaira ‘ball, globe’.

The English dictionary doesn't even mention noise in its definition.
Definitely my last word on this thread.


Edited by Jamesey (20 Oct 2018 9.14am)

 


Nothing is fool-proof - fools are too ingenious

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 20 Oct 18 9.20am

Originally posted by Goal Machine

People convieniently forget that the HF were formed in 2005 whilst we were in the Championship. Contrary to what many believe on here, they didn’t just appear when we got to the Premiership. They have been at least equally loyal as other season ticket holders over this 13 year period (in my opinion they do far more than other season ticket holders to back the team, so deserve all the preferential treatment they receive).

They of course haven’t been around since the stand opened, but you can’t blame them for that as most of them probably weren’t even born then. For all we know they could all be season ticket holders since a very young age but did not join the HF until they stopped going with their dads.

To suggest the HF might not be in regular attendance if we got relegated seems extremely unfair.


Edited by Midlands Eagle (20 Oct 2018 7.19am)

Unfair as in moving a load of fans from their long term seats because you don’t fancy the ones you’ve got any more ?

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 20 Oct 18 9.38am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

interested to hear what those in the stand think of a no-numbered-seats policy. I'm sure it'd be initially difficult, and fractious, but would soon settle.

With the proposed singing section, there's nothing to say it wouldn't dilute over time. (if it ever gets going). Then what...

...what's needed is constant evolution and dynamism. people trying to congregate in little groups to get things going.

what's not needed --atmosphere wise at least-- is the same old faces sitting for decades in the same old seats.

How has this harmed the atmosphere in recent years? Not at all in my view and even if it did, doesn't mean old faces should be moved to accommodate another fan. The whole thing has been appallingly handled and the fix is ill thought out and obvious consequences not anticipated.

 

Glazed Over Flag Sevenoaks 20 Oct 18 9.58am

Don't kid yourself this is about 'atmosphere'. Because isn't that what the HF say they were doing in Block B?

So why not continue to do this in Block B? They've made plenty of noise, got plenty of TV time and have managed to organise displays from there.

This is about a piss poor effort in marketing the Club and is obviously 100% supported by Parish - to the detriment of loyal long standing supporters who have been given an ultimatum, with no real recourse other than being thrown a few crumbs.

Absolutely disgraceful behaviour, ill thought out and very short termism - this could have all been resolved when the new stand opens.

Just wait until those around those 400 in Block E get their views of the game ruined by persistent standing, flares going off and the general flag waving and tom foolery committed by this group. There will be trouble without a doubt.

Has any thought about the disabled fans in the LH been considered?

 

Jamesey Flag Wandsworth 20 Oct 18 10.29am

[Link]

For those who wish to stop the current plans to evict existing Block E season ticket holders, there is a change.org petition rapidly gathering momentum.


Edited by Jamesey (20 Oct 2018 10.37am)

 


Nothing is fool-proof - fools are too ingenious

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Oct 18 10.44am

Originally posted by Jamesey

[Link]

For those who wish to stop the current plans to evict existing Block E season ticket holders, there is a change.org petition rapidly gathering momentum.


Edited by Jamesey (20 Oct 2018 10.37am)

Good luck with that one !

I get the impression that the club will stick to their current position akin to chewing gum on a high heel, patently refusing to yield one solid imperial inch to those who criticise their decision.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 20 Oct 18 10.58am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Unfair as in moving a load of fans from their long term seats because you don’t fancy the ones you’ve got any more ?

I think you’ve missed my point, which is that HF are also loyal and are not Premier League glory hunters (as many think they are). Think 2010 protests outside Barclays to help save the club.

No one disputes that it’s unfair on the people in block E. The popular opinion appears to be that the decision to create the singing section for the greater good. Also, everybody hopes they are well compensated for their inconvenience.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 20 Oct 18 11.06am

Originally posted by Goal Machine

I think you’ve missed my point, which is that HF are also loyal and are not Premier League glory hunters (as many think they are). Think 2010 protests outside Barclays to help save the club.

No one disputes that it’s unfair on the people in block E. The popular opinion appears to be that the decision to create the singing section for the greater good. Also, everybody hopes they are well compensated for their inconvenience.

All hf had to do was put in place plans with parish to take the spot they wanted once stadium had been increased in two years time- parish could’ve offered existing central seating fans a main stand sweetener perhaps. But no, they ran before they walked. We love them here and they create electric atmosphere but this is at the end of the day, out of order in the way they dealt with this.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 20 Oct 18 11.13am

Originally posted by Goal Machine

I think you’ve missed my point, which is that HF are also loyal and are not Premier League glory hunters (as many think they are). Think 2010 protests outside Barclays to help save the club.

No one disputes that it’s unfair on the people in block E. The popular opinion appears to be that the decision to create the singing section for the greater good. Also, everybody hopes they are well compensated for their inconvenience.

What greater good????????????

Our reputation as a FAMILY club is now shot to pieces and we are becoming just a joke to opposition fans. We are going to become just another marketing tool for overseas viewers and sod the loyal fans.

One poster extols the virtue of American sports and all that jazz. If that is what you want for Palace then good luck but don't forget that in the USA you can wake up one morning and find your favourite sports team has suddenly been moved to another location often thousands of miles away. Ask any old fan of the famous New York Dodgers baseball team.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Jamesey Flag Wandsworth 20 Oct 18 1.17pm

Originally posted by Willo

Good luck with that one !

I get the impression that the club will stick to their current position akin to chewing gum on a high heel, patently refusing to yield one solid imperial inch to those who criticise their decision.

You are very probably right but anything is worth a try and it doesn't take that much effort to sign a petition.

At worst it might well surprise Mr Parish at the bitterness and serious opposition his clumsy and ill-thought-out decision has created.

 


Nothing is fool-proof - fools are too ingenious

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 20 Oct 18 3.23pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

I think you’ve missed my point, which is that HF are also loyal and are not Premier League glory hunters (as many think they are). Think 2010 protests outside Barclays to help save the club.

No one disputes that it’s unfair on the people in block E. The popular opinion appears to be that the decision to create the singing section for the greater good. Also, everybody hopes they are well compensated for their inconvenience.


What popular opinion? Where? HF or CPFC PR? BBC? Sky? BBS? i could go on. Have you asked anyone who is going to lose out from Block E? There are posts on here to explain the rubbish they've been offered.


Btw, there were far more honest, loyal, long standing fans outside Lloyds & on the march than the 'so-called' HF.

Edited by eagleman13 (21 Oct 2018 10.40am)

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

chris123 Flag hove actually 20 Oct 18 5.35pm

Originally posted by eagleman13


What popular opinion? Where? HF or CPFC PR? BBC? Sky? BBS? i could go on. Have you asked anyone who is going to lose out from Block E? There are posts on here to explain the rubbish they've been offered.


Btw, there were far more honest, loyal, long standing fans outside Barclays & on the march than the 'so-called' HF.

What was I doing outside Lloyds?

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Oct 18 12.39am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

because when the same old faces sit in the same old seats for decades, their human nature -- which generally tends to be polite, inhibited, and not inclined to shouting -- slowly comes to the fore. And once they've gone a few games not singing, it just gets harder and harder to get them (I actually count myself) going. mix it up a bit amd maybe things would be more lively.

All seater stadia and perpetual seat renewals are killing the atmosphere in English football. If that doesn't reverse, one day it'll kill the game too.

Also, just to be clear, I'm no great fan of the HF. many many t***s among them. but I do like a great atmosphere. sp has also played an absolute stinker.

Despite my frustration I agree. Standing still will result in ossification and being overtaken. Watford FFS.

But moving on should include all, and not be designed around a small bunch of young white males. Many of us are up for change so invite us into the fold, don’t alienate us.

For example, give us even a tiny hint how we can join the singing section. And how seats will be allocated for it. Surely not too much to ask.

If it really is the HF making such decisions help them set up proper communication with the rest of the fan base.

Edited by Mapletree (21 Oct 2018 12.44am)

 

Grey Greez Flag 21 Oct 18 10.06am

COUP For Today,a draw would be fine,a Win Would Be Awesome PTID!

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 21 Oct 18 10.39am

Originally posted by chris123

What was I doing outside Lloyds?

My bad, had been talking to them

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 21 Oct 18 9.33pm

Originally posted by eagleman13


What popular opinion? Where? HF or CPFC PR? BBC? Sky? BBS? i could go on. Have you asked anyone who is going to lose out from Block E? There are posts on here to explain the rubbish they've been offered.


Btw, there were far more honest, loyal, long standing fans outside Lloyds & on the march than the 'so-called' HF.

Edited by eagleman13 (21 Oct 2018 10.40am)[/small

Simply reading this thread and the other long thread on the subject, it’s quite clear the majority want the singing section to go ahead (probably 80/20 in favour) There was always going to be upheaval to get there sadly.

I’d say the messages on this website gives a fair representation of how Palace fans feel about the matter.

 

Page 14 of 71 < 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic