This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Kant
“Football is dead. Cricket is my number 1 now.” Cricket has had its equivalent of VAR for years and works well because the laws are sensible. 90% of the criticism directed at VAR is actually misdirected. VAR upholds the laws, and it’s the laws that most people don’t like. The laws say you are offside if your arm is off. The laws say it’s handball if the ball hits your arm unintentionally. Change the laws, not VAR. You Kant be serious.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Kant
“Football is dead. Cricket is my number 1 now.” Cricket has had its equivalent of VAR for years and works well because the laws are sensible. 90% of the criticism directed at VAR is actually misdirected. VAR upholds the laws, and it’s the laws that most people don’t like. The laws say you are offside if your arm is off. The laws say it’s handball if the ball hits your arm unintentionally. Change the laws, not VAR.
Right now, whether they are right or wrong the referees in football are not allowed to explain why they made a decision, and VAR is not consistently being used, or the rules applied. The FA needs to change the rules to adapt to the times.
If you come to a fork in the road, take it. |
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by NickinOX
Right now, whether they are right or wrong the referees in football are not allowed to explain why they made a decision, and VAR is not consistently being used, or the rules applied. The FA needs to change the rules to adapt to the times.
It’s taken a very long time to get it right in rugby. Mark Cueto’s try that the French TMO’s took 4 minutes to disallow is still a travesty. There was loads of controversy about how many phases refs should go back through to. There were lots of complaints about how many and how long refs took to review decisions. Decisions are now very clinical with not much room for intention or interpretation. Much as the offside rulings and handballs have been harsh this season, they are consistent. One of the problems is that the authorities haven’t persisted with rules for long enough for the public to come to terms with them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NickinOX
Right now, whether they are right or wrong the referees in football are not allowed to explain why they made a decision, and VAR is not consistently being used, or the rules applied. The FA needs to change the rules to adapt to the times.
It is not the FA but IFAB who establish the Laws of the game.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CT Charlie
On the U.S. broadcast, they said that Eze's corner was his first of the season. Is that true? Was it his first free kick also? If both are true, one wonders if a player has ever chalked up an assist and a goal on his first two set-piece opportunities. Maybe first free kick but definitely not first corner Edited by Spiderman (08 Nov 2020 8.05am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Casual
I did wonder where was Dann for the goal? Not blaming him but we seemed a bit at 6s and 7swhich is unusual
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Really impressed by the strength of the Palace bench. Some very good personnel not even making it. Agreed
|
|
|
Originally posted by Casual
Great result. Ayew definitely more suited to us than Batshui . Eze was great. Good overall performance, think that Clyne bottled it for their goal, should have gone through the ball , think he was worried about giving a penalty away, poor decision. 4-1, that’s a hiding. good spot. he was the covering man and should have blocked it
|
|
|
Have the rules changed? It used to be you couldn’t be offside by a part of the body that couldn’t score, thus his shoulder (or upper arm now) had to be offside. Originally posted by EddieMac
His arm was offside because he was pointing. The rules were followed to a tee.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Daddyorc
Have the rules changed? It used to be you couldn’t be offside by a part of the body that couldn’t score, thus his shoulder (or upper arm now) had to be offside. You can now sore with the t-shirt section of your arm i.e upper arm/ shoulder. Sakho would have scored against Villa last season
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
You can now sore with the t-shirt section of your arm i.e upper arm/ shoulder. Sakho would have scored against Villa last season Indeed but that one should’ve stood last season, it came off his shoulder/back not his upper arm, another shocking VAR decision.
|
|
|
I know we won and I am delighted to have sealed a 4-1 victory and three points but I cannot help feeling that Leeds were robbed of a perfectly good goal and the injustices of VAR have to be highlighted for the benefit of all EPL teams in the long run. Shockley Park allegedly have finer lines than the ones we are shown on the TV (Why aren’t we shown those?!) but yesterday, on the visual from the VAR team, the line drawn on Nathaniel Clyne was clearly about 5-6 inches wrong, having been drawn from the inside of the sleeve and not the outside of the sleeve, which was also away from his body. This would have confirmed that Bamford was onside. There is also the position of Kouyate (partially obscured by Bamford) and even his furthest forward foot is goal side of Bamford, a line drawn from his left boot or the edge of his left hip would likely have also played Bamford on side. Edited by Phil’s Barber (08 Nov 2020 10.42am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Phil’s Barber
Indeed but that one should’ve stood last season, it came off his shoulder/back not his upper arm, another shocking VAR decision. Yes it was shocking and worse watching it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Phil’s Barber
I know we won and I am delighted to have sealed a 4-1 victory and three points but I cannot help feeling that Leeds were robbed of a perfectly good goal and the injustices of VAR have to be highlighted for the benefit of all EPL teams in the long run. Shockley Park allegedly have finer lines than the ones we are shown on the TV (Why aren’t we shown those?!) but yesterday, on the visual from the VAR team, the line drawn on Nathaniel Clyne was clearly about 5-6 inches wrong, having been drawn from the inside of the sleeve and not the outside of the sleeve, which was also away from his body. This would have confirmed that Bamford was onside. There is also the position of Kouyate (partially obscured by Bamford) and even his furthest forward foot is goal side of Bamford, a line drawn from his left boot or the edge of his left hip would likely have also played Bamford on side. Edited by Phil’s Barber (08 Nov 2020 10.42am) The game needs goals and it needs to encourage goals VAR should give the benefit of doubt to the attacking team also it should only be the object nearest the ground to help with drawing the line along the ground and that happens to be the foot, it is so bleeding obvious it hurts, using feet in pic you can see all three are in line so the attacking player gets it in my book. Edited by Tickled pink (08 Nov 2020 10.58am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by PA
You’re right but it won’t happen. Apparently you have to decide whether to be a ref or an assistant ref and you don’t ever then move to other role. So no Assistant Refs will ever be actual refs (in the Premier League that is) Edited by PA (07 Nov 2020 9.21pm) Sorry PA, you are very wide of the mark. The match official & the 4th official are of the same level, the 2 assistants are from reffing in lower leagues working their way up the ladder, so if good enough they will officiate at a higher level due to promotion. Now, with the EPL, its different set up, being that the 30 refs are professional, ie, paid a wage, EFL refs only get a fee. There are 10 Epl matches, on average, per w/e, therefore you will have 10 elite refs in the middle, 10 elite refs as 4th official & the other 10 either at Stockley Park with VAR or in the lower leagues reffing. IF, assistants want to become an elite ref, they have to 1: get promoted & 2: give up their work to enable them to join the elite refs.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
VAR aside, Leeds were so open defensively we could feasibly have had another two or three, as could Leicester on Monday. Roy clearly looked at that game and we exploited their obvious frailties. Leeds looked tired by the end and that Ayew goal was ridiculous how much space and time he had. It's all well and good getting 5 or 6 players in the opposing box but if you can't get back to defend you're going to get whipped. We were braver on the ball yesterday and it paid dividends. Correct and I feel this is possibly where we have been in order to not be whipped when up against decent organised sides, credit must always be allowed for managers who think and plan, Mr Hodgson is a thinking man ...hence we are safe and sound and a really good proposition for any new manager when the time comes.
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
VAR aside, Leeds were so open defensively we could feasibly have had another two or three, as could Leicester on Monday. Roy clearly looked at that game and we exploited their obvious frailties. Leeds looked tired by the end and that Ayew goal was ridiculous how much space and time he had. It's all well and good getting 5 or 6 players in the opposing box but if you can't get back to defend you're going to get whipped. We were braver on the ball yesterday and it paid dividends. At the start of the break before Ayew's goal, you see one of the Leeds players in the middle of the pitch head just drop as he throws a strop like a stroppy teenager. Then take a look at Townsend calling for the pass in front of him before Ayew's goal. Draws both defenders attention away from Ayew. Still, that shouldnt detract from Palace players being deadly on the break.
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
VAR aside, Leeds were so open defensively we could feasibly have had another two or three, as could Leicester on Monday. Roy clearly looked at that game and we exploited their obvious frailties. Leeds looked tired by the end and that Ayew goal was ridiculous how much space and time he had. It's all well and good getting 5 or 6 players in the opposing box but if you can't get back to defend you're going to get whipped. We were braver on the ball yesterday and it paid dividends. Leeds are missing the defensive 'Shield' provided by Kalvin Phillips.He was missing against Leicester last week and again yesterday and Leeds conceded 8 goals in those two matches.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.