This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Willo
The incidents were identical with Benteke's right arm making contact with the player. Having produced a 'Yellow' for the first incident one can understand why the referee brandished a 'Yellow' for the second, which of course had to be followed by a 'Red'. In the interests of NOT turning this into a Willo thread I shall make no further comment on the decisions taken by Mr Coote. Edited by Willo (17 Dec 2020 11.22am) But the first was never a yellow, fact!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
The incidents were identical with Benteke's right arm making contact with the player. Having produced a 'Yellow' for the first incident one can understand why the referee brandished a 'Yellow' for the second, which of course had to be followed by a 'Red'. In the interests of NOT turning this into a Willo thread I shall make no further comment on the decisions taken by Mr Coote. Edited by Willo (17 Dec 2020 11.22am) If you watch Kane play, then on the basis of how that ref interpreted the law, he would be sent off every single match. Now I’m not sure the powers at the FA would like that very much. Surely you can’t defend consistently poor decisions.
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
Results suggest otherwise. Apart from the Burnley goal, Kouyate has been solid as the back. No idea why you say '' alleged '' midfielder but Kouyate plays CB at international level. And what this has to do with allowing crosses into the box, I don't know. I said alleged because his touch lets him down as a midfielder time after time. He does play CB at international level which leaves questions as to why he has been played in midfield consistently by your hero Roy. Fact is, that he's not really a specialist in either position. His been largely a poor to average signing. He's not done anything of note in his time here and plays in two positions where we have plenty of back up. He is an argument of why Hodgson shouldn't be trusted in the transfer market, as no matter what we need, we'll try and sign another defensive midfielder. You love taking things out of context or being willfully ignorance. If you read the posts you'll see I said I think Kouyate was ball watching and should have cut out the cross. It wasn't a great cross and drifting away from the goal. Haller had time to turn and react. All Kouyate had to do was take a couple of steps forward, but he just stood rooted to the spot. Tompkins hasn't got on the pitch yet this season... so I'm how you draw a comparison between results with and without Tompkins... I don't know.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
But the first was never a yellow, fact! Exactly my read on the second yellow - Benteke had positioned himself below the ball and jumped for it. The opposing player was arriving late and jumped into the challenge and got caught as a result. How on earth that merits a second yellow is ridiculous as the West Ham player was out of control and got a small knock as a result of poor positioning. Then again he was probably looking to get Benteke sent off as per team orders at HT as Moyes recognised the referee was a card happy mug.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
I said alleged because his touch lets him down as a midfielder time after time. He does play CB at international level which leaves questions as to why he has been played in midfield consistently by your hero Roy. Fact is, that he's not really a specialist in either position. His been largely a poor to average signing. He's not done anything of note in his time here and plays in two positions where we have plenty of back up. He is an argument of why Hodgson shouldn't be trusted in the transfer market, as no matter what we need, we'll try and sign another defensive midfielder. You love taking things out of context or being willfully ignorance. If you read the posts you'll see I said I think Kouyate was ball watching and should have cut out the cross. It wasn't a great cross and drifting away from the goal. Haller had time to turn and react. All Kouyate had to do was take a couple of steps forward, but he just stood rooted to the spot. Tompkins hasn't got on the pitch yet this season... so I'm how you draw a comparison between results with and without Tompkins... I don't know. The reason I consistently call you out is because of your anti Hodgson agenda. The majority of your posts have that undercurrent running through them. And, as with your latest effort, don't stand up to scrutiny. It may have escaped your attention ( or could it be wilful ignorance ) that we signed Eze - not a defensive midfielder, but a young, exciting player with enormous potential. No doubt you will conjure up a response which will include some anti Hodgson sentiment. Yes, I saw your claim that Kouyate and the cross, but I think you are using that for your own agenda as you patently don't rate the player, and if it's your opinion, fine, although I disagree. And you managed to criticise him in a response to Tickled Pink's comment about how Palace allow too many crosses into the box. Pathetic. My results comment you clearly struggled with...I was not drawing any comparisons, just stating that we have just gone 3 games unbeaten with Kouyate in the team.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
Tompkins isn't getting a look in whilst we consistently play an (alleged) midfielder as a centre back. It started out OK when he needed to stand in, has run his course. Kouyate is an international centre back and captains his country from that position. He also has pace, which none of the othe CBS do.
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
The reason I consistently call you out is because of your anti Hodgson agenda. The majority of your posts have that undercurrent running through them. And, as with your latest effort, don't stand up to scrutiny. It may have escaped your attention ( or could it be wilful ignorance ) that we signed Eze - not a defensive midfielder, but a young, exciting player with enormous potential. No doubt you will conjure up a response which will include some anti Hodgson sentiment. Yes, I saw your claim that Kouyate and the cross, but I think you are using that for your own agenda as you patently don't rate the player, and if it's your opinion, fine, although I disagree. And you managed to criticise him in a response to Tickled Pink's comment about how Palace allow too many crosses into the box. Pathetic. My results comment you clearly struggled with...I was not drawing any comparisons, just stating that we have just gone 3 games unbeaten with Kouyate in the team. I like your signature.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
I like your signature. Is that what your debating skills have been reduced to?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
But the first was never a yellow, fact! Without meaning to be paranoid it feels as though if Benteke had scored the overhead kick he’d have been booked and sent off for dangerous play.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
The incidents were identical with Benteke's right arm making contact with the player. Having produced a 'Yellow' for the first incident one can understand why the referee brandished a 'Yellow' for the second, which of course had to be followed by a 'Red'. In the interests of NOT turning this into a Willo thread I shall make no further comment on the decisions taken by Mr Coote. Edited by Willo (17 Dec 2020 11.22am)
Edited by the silurian (17 Dec 2020 1.35pm)
|
|
|
I still think that the ref should be made [ like managers ] to face the cameras and explain why they gave any decision they made .
|
|
|
Originally posted by Fatherken
I still think that the ref should be made [ like managers ] to face the cameras and explain why they gave any decision they made .
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
Most of Eze's passes were short one's that he under hit. He's still a work in progress but he has huge potential and we look a different team with him in it.
Edited by Phil’s Barber (17 Dec 2020 2.04pm)
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Kouyate is an international centre back and captains his country from that position. He also has pace, which none of the othe CBS do. This is a fair and reasoned argument for his place in the team. If the manager feels that his comparative technical ability is offset by technical ability then that's fine. In fairness, it was only a small laps in concentration and that happens from time to time. I was just trying to point out that often when "worldies" are scored, its normally down to their being no pressure on the attacking player. If it was Sakho, he may be getting ripped apart by some. Normally, people justify Roy's position because he is from Croydon, old, untalented, and white (talent being the only relevant point in a persons failings - but people seek comfort in using the other two as an excuse). They never put forward any argument to support his decisions, such as his repeated refusal to change formation last season. He's finally done it, and its paying dividends.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Phil’s Barber
To be fair their goal was absolutely class and whilst rather extraordinary it was certainly not a fluke. I think the overhead kick was class but the build up could have been stopped if firstly Maca had tackled the ball/guy that went past him to easily and then there was no one to to cut out the free cross that came in as we had a left back (PVA) and Eze out of position. Think we were our own downfall in that goal which was superbly taken?
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace chick
I think the overhead kick was class but the build up could have been stopped if firstly Maca had tackled the ball/guy that went past him to easily and then there was no one to to cut out the free cross that came in as we had a left back (PVA) and Eze out of position. Think we were our own downfall in that goal which was superbly taken? Spot on, if we were to really scrutinise it there were plenty of opportunities in the build up to pick apart.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Spot on, if we were to really scrutinise it there were plenty of opportunities in the build up to pick apart. Agree, the build up was what should have been stopped. It's hard to criticize the defenders, you're taught to keep yourself between the attacker and the goal, the ball was behind Heller, probably accidentally and he timed his shot perfectly. These things just happen sometimes (like the Giroud and Carroll goals a few years ago).
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
But the first was never a yellow, fact! Spot on. Also both defenders jumped with their arms up just like Benteke but he just got there quicker and jump higher. It is a big change when us fans are gutted Benteke is going to miss a game. All credit to him for turning things around.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.