You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace v Sheffield United Match thread
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Crystal Palace v Sheffield United Match thread


Page 14 of 18 < 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >
Aray Flag South London 31 Jan 24 11.37am

Originally posted by mtp1958

After 25secs we lost the game no we won when i last looked at the score line, and was on top they had very little chances after that , wood work has saved teams we have played but god forbid them hitting our wood work , all i hear was we was lucky not us unlucky when we done it ,
If you go to the game thinking we are going to lose your view of the game will be negative no matter what ,
After 50+ years of supporting this club i have never gone to a game thinking we will lose and never will , i done 3 seasons not missing a game when we was in the 3rd division and 2nd division , thats home and away and cups , so enjoy the wins dont look for reason why we did ,
we have hopefully 2 attack minded players signed and maybe a loan coming , see what happens when we go all out attack so you feel happy with us getting trashed because we dont have anyone back defending , look for the positives not negative's or you end up like you

Have you forgotten what we were actually debating? When did I say I started the game thinking we were going to lose?

I am saying that a poor team like Sheffield shouldn’t be allowed to dominate us at home. Of course we won - but normally I feel great after a win - but I didn’t. If you did - good for you!
We continue to play badly - despite Olise and Eze - and now our defence isn’t strong either.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 31 Jan 24 11.38am

Originally posted by Painter

The poor defensive displays coincide with Doucoure being injured and not playing. It’s no coincidence that without his defensive shield we get exposed, Lerma just as good.

Roy can only play, who he has available, without key players we struggle, as most teams below 8th do.

Quite right Painter. Mind you, we were caught with our pants down from KO last night, I reckon opponents know we are vulnerable starters and go for the jugular.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

taylors lovechild Flag 31 Jan 24 11.50am

What I liked about last night was that everyone else seemed to raise their game with Olise and Eze on the pitch. Passes weren't going astray as often and despite going behind twice I still thought we controlled the game. However, it also wasn't that dissimilar to our game against Everton but in that instance we lost 3-2. It's a hard balance. With two players capable of producing something out of nothing on a regular basis we really shouldn't be anywhere near the relegation places if they stay fit. Obviously that is a big if though.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 31 Jan 24 11.51am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Tellingly, the medical team didn't say he's not ready, don't select him.

They said it might be too much for him.

Olise then did what was agreed - when he felt he he couldn't carry on, he flagged it.

Agree NEILLO. I'm happy to go with my own view, from a position of complete ignorance, that both our starlets were fine and did what had been agreed beforehand. They indicated to the bench their time was up.

Interestingly, the commentator on the stream I was watching thought Roy's body language said as much and went on to suggest he should put Olise in a big ball of fluffy cotton wool until the next game.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

XKudu Flag The Midlands, England 31 Jan 24 12.08pm

I like Mateta but I’m never sure if his long legs are a help or hinderance. Of course, I can’t think of a solution other than longer socks perhaps which may confuse defenders.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 31 Jan 24 12.10pm

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

Agree NEILLO. I'm happy to go with my own view, from a position of complete ignorance, that both our starlets were fine and did what had been agreed beforehand. They indicated to the bench their time was up.

Interestingly, the commentator on the stream I was watching thought Roy's body language said as much and went on to suggest he should put Olise in a big ball of fluffy cotton wool until the next game.

So is either Olise or Eze injured and therefore probably unavailable in the short term? I feel I'm missing something. Didn't Eze spend a long time being attended to on the pitch before coming off? I'm in the dark.

 

i_8_clowns Flag Dorset 31 Jan 24 12.15pm

Originally posted by JRW2

So is either Olise or Eze injured and therefore probably unavailable in the short term? I feel I'm missing something. Didn't Eze spend a long time being attended to on the pitch before coming off? I'm in the dark.

Both looked fine - Olise certainly did.

To me, it looked like Eze was biding his time while Ozoh was getting ready.

 

The Dolphin Flag 31 Jan 24 12.27pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Well, anyone pushing for Richards to be our permanent right back must have been given food for thought in the opening seconds last night.

In terms of the defence as a unit, I'm starting to think that having a nervy Henderson behind them as opposed to the calmer and more imposing Johnstone is having an effect.

It's entirely plausible to think that if Olise and Eze had played together more often this season we would have another few more points in the bag which would take us to our spiritual home of mid table.

We still badly miss last seasons version of Doucoure in midfield. I'm looking forward to seeing what Wharton will do to improve that situation.

Over the 90 minutes we caused more of our own problems than Sheffield created. If we had scored the opening goal I think that could have been a two or three goal margin win.

Respect the win. Together with the two new signings, yesterday was a good day and we can go into this weekends game with a lot more positivity than of late.

I pushed for him ahead of Ward but probably not ahead of Clyne who has been okay of late.
Richards has been a utility player this season and moving positions can be annoying.
He was at fault for their first goal but our full backs never stay wide - it must be a (bad) tactic!
I prefer Johnstone and I also suspect that the defence misses Doucoure badly.

 

The Dolphin Flag 31 Jan 24 12.36pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I reckon it’s between us, Luton, Everton and Forest for the third relegation spot. We should have enough to stay up, but we must start defending better. Luton have made their home ground a bit of a fortress but they are useless away. Everton may still be deducted more points. Forest are very average. We are by no means out of trouble.

A fair post.
Forest may also get deducted - in fact I would suggest that they will lose 6 points and that Everton - while they may get a few points back this week - will get another 6 as well.
We may be reliant on point deductions to save us.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 31 Jan 24 1.06pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

The seat next to me declared 'we should win this about 6-1 now' after we got back to 1-1. I agreed and thought that was a very reasonable stance to take at the time. .

This sums up my concern with so many posts on here.

How on earth is it ever remotely reasonable to expect a 6-1 win in any game of professional football?!

I mean, how often do they actually happen, ever, in any game, even for Real Madrid, or Man City, or Bayern Munich?!

Yet Palace 'should' manage it!

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 31 Jan 24 1.10pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Well, anyone pushing for Richards to be our permanent right back must have been given food for thought in the opening seconds last night.

Which has been a great many people on here, very often.

Not that I expect anyone to contemplate whether they were wrong and Roy was right. Instead, it is Roys fault we conceded early.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 31 Jan 24 1.28pm

Originally posted by Painter

The poor defensive displays coincide with Doucoure being injured and not playing. It’s no coincidence that without his defensive shield we get exposed, Lerma just as good.

Roy can only play, who he has available, without key players we struggle, as most teams below 8th do.

Well, that’s a fair enough comment on Doucoure, but what about the two £40m/£50m central defenders that we’ve got and the young full back who a season or so ago was picked for England and being courted by some of the top teams. You would have thought they would have been capable of shoring up our defence, as they are our defence!

I also understand about struggling to top six teams but not sure why one defensive midfielder out should make us do poor defensively. That is effectively saying that Hughes, Ozoh, Riedewald Richards and Lerma aren’t up to the job. If that’s what you think then fair enough but I think our defenders are playing poorly and look like they have no confidence. That may stem from tactics or the goalkeeper behind them.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 31 Jan 24 1.30pm

Originally posted by Gribbo

And Edouard, who has no pace and does nothing on his own up front.


Did well when he came on.

Still our top scorer of the season.

Some people in here like to make out Doucoure is some wonder player he is not.

Last night was another example of Roy being the issue not the players.

Players out of position and changes to go even more defensive.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 31 Jan 24 1.30pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

This sums up my concern with so many posts on here.

How on earth is it ever remotely reasonable to expect a 6-1 win in any game of professional football?!

I mean, how often do they actually happen, ever, in any game, even for Real Madrid, or Man City, or Bayern Munich?!

Yet Palace 'should' manage it!

You must surely realise that was a figure of speech to indicate how much we were in control going forward?

It’s when we started trying to defend it all went pear shaped.

Edited by Eaglecoops (31 Jan 2024 1.31pm)

 

PatrickA Flag London 31 Jan 24 1.31pm

....well to an extent it was Roy's fault as he selected Richards at right back when Clyne has been in reasonable form and had done nothing to warrant being left out.
Similarly, he's played Richards in central midfield where he's like a fish out of water.
He's played Schlupp on the right or left wing where he looks uncomfortable.
He's played Hughes in advanced midfield where his lack of pace and ability to break forward is exposed.
It's not that complicated - play players in their correct positions.

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Which has been a great many people on here, very often.

Not that I expect anyone to contemplate whether they were wrong and Roy was right. Instead, it is Roys fault we conceded early.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 31 Jan 24 1.32pm

Originally posted by i_8_clowns

Both looked fine - Olise certainly did.

To me, it looked like Eze was biding his time while Ozoh was getting ready.

BBC reports says:

[Roy] was able to name Olise and Eze in his team for just the seventh time this season due to injury and their quality shone through.

However, both Olise and Eze had to go off after receiving treatment, but the latter said both players were fine.

"I'm OK, it was just a precaution, it should be fine," Eze said. "[Michael Olise] is also fine. He's good."

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 31 Jan 24 1.34pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

This sums up my concern with so many posts on here.

How on earth is it ever remotely reasonable to expect a 6-1 win in any game of professional football?!

I mean, how often do they actually happen, ever, in any game, even for Real Madrid, or Man City, or Bayern Munich?!

Yet Palace 'should' manage it!

I don't think it was a literal statement or prediction of the score, it was very tongue in cheek to represent the fact they looked very poor and we surprisingly looked as though we could produce a goal every time we got forward and should have been comfortable in seeing out a win.

It sums up my concern with so many posts on here that anyone would read into that so literally and write such a lengthy post off the back of it.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

TheBigToePunt Flag 31 Jan 24 1.39pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

....well to an extent it was Roy's fault as he selected Richards at right back when Clyne has been in reasonable form and had done nothing to warrant being left out.
Similarly, he's played Richards in central midfield where he's like a fish out of water.
He's played Schlupp on the right or left wing where he looks uncomfortable.
He's played Hughes in advanced midfield where his lack of pace and ability to break forward is exposed.
It's not that complicated - play players in their correct positions.


But yet so many on here wanted Richards at right-back ahead of Clyne and Ward, so if Roy was wrong to pick Richards there last night, how many of them will now say they were wrong to complain previously? Not many.

And who would you have picked in the centre of midfield ahead of Richards, given the injury to Docoure?

Schlupp is a winger. That is his preferred position. He can play in the middle or at left back, but he is a winger. If Olise, or even Rak-Sakhi had been fit, perhaps Sch;lupp would have played less, but that's not how it was.

He played Hughes there when Eze was injured. We don't have anyone else able to play there. If Roy had played a system with three defensive midfielders instead, everyone would be moaning about that.

You're right, it's not complicated. We just need to look at the circumstances as they are in real life.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 31 Jan 24 1.42pm

Something someone mentioned last night about the KO .I dont think anyone replied as they were too busy typing FFS and the like .

So seeing as we were kicking toward the Holmesdale first half it was observed that we must have lost the toss as that is our favoured second half direction of attack .

Why then did Sheffield take the KO ?

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 31 Jan 24 1.43pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I don't think it was a literal statement or prediction of the score, it was very tongue in cheek to represent the fact they looked very poor and we surprisingly looked as though we could produce a goal every time we got forward and should have been comfortable in seeing out a win.

It sums up my concern with so many posts on here that anyone would read into that so literally and write such a lengthy post off the back of it.

I promise I won't do that awful 'If you read what I actually said, and what you actually said' thing, but even if you were talking in general terms, the idea that Palace 'should' establish dominant control in a premier league game against a team fighting for their lives remains, to me, symptomatic of misplaced entitlement.

I'm amazed by how many posts on here are of the 'Sheffield Utd are s***, so the win means less' tone.

Christ, they played well, came back from behind twice (including one terribly unlucky deflection) to win and all some people can talk about is that Palace 'should' be winning.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (31 Jan 2024 1.45pm)

 

Page 14 of 18 < 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace v Sheffield United Match thread