You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Brighton vs. Crystal Palace match thread
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Brighton vs. Crystal Palace match thread


Page 14 of 17 < 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >
taylors lovechild Flag 03 Feb 24 6.03pm

What is Roy bringing to the table anymore? We didn't lose today because of the starting line-up, we lost because Roy can no longer manage at this level. He needed Eze and Olise to stay fit to cover that up.

The most painful bit was when we scored and Brighton had 6 men outside their 18-yard box and no Palace player with 15-20 yards. That's not the players, that's having a manager who doesn't trust his players.

Personally I hope Roy resigns and admits he's not up to it anymore.

On the positives Munoz and Wharton look like once they get used to the PL they'll give us an upgrade. Both were a bit slow on the ball at times, but every player experiences that, it was the same with Doucoure in his first season. Wharton in particular looks class, just a bit naive, which he should be able to shake off. JPM again one of the only players to contribute much, but was chasing lost causes all game.

 

radicalsteve Flag ottawa 03 Feb 24 6.07pm

It is all so depressing .... The squad may not be deep, but there is more talent in there than teams below us have.

Clearly keeping Roy is a bigger risk that bringing in a proven manager. It is incredible that we ship goals so quickly, something not right in the coaching and tactical awareness.

The decision to bring on Olise was "criminal and totally non-sensical" and should be the final nail, unless SP is equally desperate as his manager. You don't need to be a level 5 coach to see that the team set up is a mess and the instructions to the players put them at a disadvantage from the moment the whistle blows.

It is a mess all around and the only option now is to replace the manager. SP should never have put Roy in the position in the first place and it is a bad outcome for all. SP's judgement and football sense does't look very good does it? Easy to coach from the couch, but some things are blindingly obvious, unless you are on a different planet from the rest of us.

 

pssguy Flag 03 Feb 24 6.12pm

Originally posted by CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE


We are easily the worst team in the premier league. And Roy says he won’t retire till his job is done, that is till he relegates the palace.

He probably put a few grand on us going down when were 20-1 earler in the season

 

Sansomite Flag Portsmouth 03 Feb 24 6.19pm

Hodgson's lost the plot, lost the players and lost the fans.
It seems that the board's strategy (if there is one!) is to build a squad full of young, hungry 'up and coming' players which is great. Trouble is that unless the club makes progress year on year we'll have no chance of retaining the promising young talent that we have and building something good.
We have young players that are more talented than the likes of Shlupp, Hughes, Richardson, Lerma, Edouard etc. that are wasting away on the bench.
I think Parish is an egomaniac who's sole focus is his legacy of leaving us with the new main stand and I get that we're not the most attractive club for players or managers but the lack of action is just bizzare!
If something's not done it'll be the Championship next season and I'm expecting/hoping for an announcement soon, failure to act now could undo all the good that's been done since 2010.
Rant over!!

 

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 03 Feb 24 6.36pm

Originally posted by pssguy

He probably put a few grand on us going down when were 20-1 earler in the season

&#128515;&#128515;&#128515;

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 03 Feb 24 6.38pm

Unless we can find a motivational manager I fear if we are relegated we face a long time in the Championship, or worse, and even do a Charlton.

It is so depressing that Hodgson is now past his prime and should fall on his sword before he completely loses the players. He has already lost the fans. He now looks like his unsuccessfull time at Watford, unable to motivate or save a sinking ship.

Time for Mr Parish to call time

 


Man and boy Palace since my first game in 1948 sitting on my dad's shoulders

mart.denman Flag In a cave 03 Feb 24 6.40pm

Hodgson post match interview
He really doesn't give a flying f*** about the fans
Total arrogance

 

The Dolphin Flag 03 Feb 24 6.45pm

I have been out and missed it all.
Loose injured when he should have stayed on the bench.
Guehi injured??
Seen the brief highlights - why is Henderson glued to his line for the first goal - get Johnston back.
Anderson appears not to be able to mark his pants currently which doesn't help.
Mateta scores so Roy takes him off?
The orchestrater though is Roy and I hope he is gone tonight.
This game did for Viera last season so let's hope that lightening strikes twice!

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 03 Feb 24 6.48pm

Apparently Hodgson’s training has always been to go over the same scenario, again and again until everyone knows where to go.

Can’t help but think the opposition are not doing what he expects them
Too.

Things have moved on and whilst he brings calm to chaos he starts causing his own. Look at his CV - generally it’s a

Come to a club in turmoil
Make defensively stronger
Unattractive but effective football
Begin playing players out of position
Players start to look demotivated
Leave in a worse state.


Pretty much every job he’s ever done.

That and putting on Olise decision wise was right up there with invading Russia in a war.

Roy would like to be remembered as a well respected and innovative manager (in his own words - as compatible to Sir Alex if you examine his CV). I suspect Gary Glitter would like to be remembered for his music and his CV is compatible to David Bowie.

He’s tarnishing that legacy, the world has moved on. RH hasn’t.

 

humber eagle Flag hull 03 Feb 24 6.49pm

Has he gone yet?

 


In my day, a Selfie was what you had when the wife didn't put out.

Uphill Flag Bedford 03 Feb 24 7.04pm

Originally posted by humber eagle

Has he gone yet?

I am hoping for an announcement tomorrow if Mr Parish has any common sense.

 

becky Flag over the moon 03 Feb 24 7.08pm

Originally posted by humber eagle

Has he gone yet?

Well, it looks like he's not going to jump, so it will need to be a push.....


[Link]

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Plaistow Eagle Flag 03 Feb 24 7.10pm

Originally posted by Sansomite

Hodgson's lost the plot, lost the players and lost the fans.
It seems that the board's strategy (if there is one!) is to build a squad full of young, hungry 'up and coming' players which is great. Trouble is that unless the club makes progress year on year we'll have no chance of retaining the promising young talent that we have and building something good.
We have young players that are more talented than the likes of Shlupp, Hughes, Richardson, Lerma, Edouard etc. that are wasting away on the bench.
I think Parish is an egomaniac who's sole focus is his legacy of leaving us with the new main stand and I get that we're not the most attractive club for players or managers but the lack of action is just bizzare!
If something's not done it'll be the Championship next season and I'm expecting/hoping for an announcement soon, failure to act now could undo all the good that's been done since 2010.
Rant over!!

Great rant - sums up my feelings entirely..!!

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 03 Feb 24 7.14pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

What on earth are you going on about - our season is not over we are in a fight for our Premiership survival - big time..!!

And thanks to Captain cock-up looks like we’ll have to do it without Olise for weeks..!!

As for offering Roy a new deal - surely you’re kidding - needs to go now/tonight..!!

Where is the like button when you need one .

 

pax3908 Flag 03 Feb 24 7.17pm

Originally posted by Sansomite

Hodgson's lost the plot, lost the players and lost the fans.
It seems that the board's strategy (if there is one!) is to build a squad full of young, hungry 'up and coming' players which is great. Trouble is that unless the club makes progress year on year we'll have no chance of retaining the promising young talent that we have and building something good.
We have young players that are more talented than the likes of Shlupp, Hughes, Richardson, Lerma, Edouard etc. that are wasting away on the bench.
I think Parish is an egomaniac who's sole focus is his legacy of leaving us with the new main stand and I get that we're not the most attractive club for players or managers but the lack of action is just bizzare!
If something's not done it'll be the Championship next season and I'm expecting/hoping for an announcement soon, failure to act now could undo all the good that's been done since 2010.
Rant over!!


Absolutely spot on,it's bloody desperate to see a team that promised so much be destroyed!!!

 

Texas Eagle Flag San Antonio, Texas (via Adelaide) 03 Feb 24 7.20pm

RH has turned this team into a bunch of bunnies. Bereft of anything resembling a PL team, his sole tactic is to crowd the middle of the pitch and frustrate the opposition for as long as possible. Our ineptitude at defending set pieces is down solely to him and his coaching staff and their incompetence. This is not rocket science folks....! 11 goals conceded in the last 3 games is testimony to a stubborn man insistent on 1990's tactics. The quality in this squad is far superior to the results endured this season (to date). Please, Mr. Parish, if you wish to maintain our PL status, install a manager who is able to think laterally when required and not stubbornly persist in a game plan destined for failure from the kickoff.

This club needs to learn quickly to stop rewarding loyalty and start rewarding TALENT!

 


"Billy Gilbert really is God"

eritheagle Flag Erith 03 Feb 24 7.21pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I have been out and missed it all.
Loose injured when he should have stayed on the bench.
Guehi injured??
Seen the brief highlights - why is Henderson glued to his line for the first goal - get Johnston back.
Anderson appears not to be able to mark his pants currently which doesn't help.
Mateta scores so Roy takes him off?
The orchestrater though is Roy and I hope he is gone tonight.
This game did for Viera last season so let's hope that lightening strikes twice!

Although i am disappointed in Henderson thus far and want Johnstone back in goal, he too was always glued to his line on corners etc. We have 2 keepers that aren't that keen on coming for crosses.

 

ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 03 Feb 24 7.23pm

Tuesday’s win over SU papered over the cracks, Roy’s decision to go defensive after going 3-2 up against the bottom side who are currently 5 nil down at home sums him up to a tee!!

 

Malcolm Al Flag Wallington 03 Feb 24 7.45pm

Just got home after the worst experience I've ever had following Palace. Team were clueless for most of the match as Brighton ran rings around us, and frankly I can't disagree with their fans when they sang "your support is f**king s**t" We just weren't up for it on or off the pitch today...

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 03 Feb 24 7.52pm

Originally posted by eritheagle

Although i am disappointed in Henderson thus far and want Johnstone back in goal, he too was always glued to his line on corners etc. We have 2 keepers that aren't that keen on coming for crosses.

And when you add to that 2 centre half’s who seem incapable of defending a corner it’s not a good recipe for success.

 

Page 14 of 17 < 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Brighton vs. Crystal Palace match thread