You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy
November 21 2026 11.59pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy


Page 144 of 174 < 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 >
Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 06 Jan 24 8.46pm

Originally posted by the silurian

yes I read it, just dont believe you! you want our elected 'representatives' , who you have admitted lie, to get us back into the EU, to change things? Didnt go too well before did it? Why would it be different now?

This is about how we take decisions. Not the decisions themselves.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 06 Jan 24 10.03pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

You say you put great store by representative government, our elected representatives proposing and enacting our laws and policies. Yet you want to rejoin the EU where our elected representatives would be unable to do any of those things.

That’s of course untrue today as it always was.

There was always a trade off between the obviously positive and supposedly negative aspects of EU membership but we participated in the decision making process for those things delegated to the EU. Things that are better managed collectively and which we continue to be impacted by but can no longer contribute to how they are regulated.

I want our elected representatives to decide to rejoin in some way, probably in some kind of associate capacity initially. I want them to make the fundamental decision to delegate because it’s in our best interests to do so. That decision is though theirs. Not the EU’s. Their's is whether they accept any application.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 06 Jan 24 10.28pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

That’s of course untrue today as it always was.

There was always a trade off between the obviously positive and supposedly negative aspects of EU membership but we participated in the decision making process for those things delegated to the EU. Things that are better managed collectively and which we continue to be impacted by but can no longer contribute to how they are regulated.

I want our elected representatives to decide to rejoin in some way, probably in some kind of associate capacity initially. I want them to make the fundamental decision to delegate because it’s in our best interests to do so. That decision is though theirs. Not the EU’s. Their's is whether they accept any application.

Of course it is true. The representatives that we would elect to the EU sham parliament would not be able to propose and enact EU laws and policies that would take precedence over UK laws.

Delegate! You mean give the power to make laws that govern us to unelected EU Commissioners.

Edited by georgenorman (06 Jan 2024 10.36pm)

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 06 Jan 24 11.11pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

Of course it is true. The representatives that we would elect to the EU sham parliament would not be able to propose and enact EU laws and policies that would take precedence over UK laws.

Delegate! You mean give the power to make laws that govern us to unelected EU Commissioners.

Edited by georgenorman (06 Jan 2024 10.36pm)

I don’t think it’s worthwhile trying to describe how democracy works within the EU. It’s been covered in these pages many times. Our representatives would still enact the laws in this country when they are required.

What really matters is what delivers the best outcomes. Not an outdated outlook based on prejudice. If something else delivers then what’s the problem? The last years seem pretty conclusive that we were much better in every way as members.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 07 Jan 24 7.37am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I don’t think it’s worthwhile trying to describe how democracy works within the EU. It’s been covered in these pages many times. Our representatives would still enact the laws in this country when they are required.

What really matters is what delivers the best outcomes. Not an outdated outlook based on prejudice. If something else delivers then what’s the problem? The last years seem pretty conclusive that we were much better in every way as members.

Of course you don't, as it is clear and obvious that our elected representatives (that you put such store by) are virtually powerless in the undemocratic EU.

Then suddenly you say what really matters is what delivers the best outcomes. "If something else delivers then what's the problem?" What like Germany, Italy and Russia in the 1930s?

You do make me laugh, one minute our elected representatives are the be all and end all, next minute they are pretty much an irrelevance.

Edited by georgenorman (07 Jan 2024 7.44am)

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 07 Jan 24 8.11am

Originally posted by georgenorman

Of course you don't, as it is clear and obvious that our elected representatives (that you put such store by) are virtually powerless in the undemocratic EU.

Then suddenly you say what really matters is what delivers the best outcomes. "If something else delivers then what's the problem?" What like Germany, Italy and Russia in the 1930s?

You do make me laugh, one minute our elected representatives are the be all and end all, next minute they are pretty much an irrelevance.

Edited by georgenorman (07 Jan 2024 7.44am)

That you seem to think that our national Parliament becomes irrelevant if we are members of the EU is what makes me laugh. They would continue, as they do now, to have the ultimate power that decides the future of our country. Remember that Brexit depended on them enabling Article 50 and not the referendum which had no legal implications of any sort.

Yes their responsibilities are modified but they continue to have full control over the important issues. Have you really noticed much difference since we left? We still have budgets and control over fiscal policy. It’s things which are more efficiently done together which are handled at EU level. Even Thatcher understood and accepted the role of subsidiarity.

That you compare the EU with fascist Germany and Italy and with Russia under Lenin is risible. They were authoritarian dictatorships. The EU is a partnership of willing states working together for their mutual benefit.

The diversion onto another argument about the merits of the EU is what is irrelevant. My point was that the way we take decisions, whatever they are, is done by our representatives and not by referendum. We directly vote for those who represent us. They then must be left to do their job. Throwing the future of our country into the winds of chance implicit in any referendum is a stupid thing to even contemplate.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 07 Jan 24 9.15am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

That you seem to think that our national Parliament becomes irrelevant if we are members of the EU is what makes me laugh. They would continue, as they do now, to have the ultimate power that decides the future of our country. Remember that Brexit depended on them enabling Article 50 and not the referendum which had no legal implications of any sort.

Yes their responsibilities are modified but they continue to have full control over the important issues. Have you really noticed much difference since we left? We still have budgets and control over fiscal policy. It’s things which are more efficiently done together which are handled at EU level. Even Thatcher understood and accepted the role of subsidiarity.

That you compare the EU with fascist Germany and Italy and with Russia under Lenin is risible. They were authoritarian dictatorships. The EU is a partnership of willing states working together for their mutual benefit.

The diversion onto another argument about the merits of the EU is what is irrelevant. My point was that the way we take decisions, whatever they are, is done by our representatives and not by referendum. We directly vote for those who represent us. They then must be left to do their job. Throwing the future of our country into the winds of chance implicit in any referendum is a stupid thing to even contemplate.

The UK parliament did not have full control over our laws as EU law took precedence over UK law.
You stated “What really matters is what delivers the best outcomes. Not an outdated outlook based on prejudice. If something else delivers then what’s the problem?” I merely pointed out that Germany, Italy and Russia adopted “something else” and delivered all sorts of things. By the way, Russia in the 1930s was led by Stalin, not Lenin who booked his place in hell when he died in 1924.
As for “We directly vote for those who represent us. They then must be left to do their job.” The MEPs that we elected were virtually powerless and had no means of implementing any policies they might have had. “Left to do their job” – a job that is largely raking in massive incomes for doing very little.
You say, “Throwing the future of our country into the winds of chance implicit in any referendum is a stupid thing to even contemplate”, yet you want to throw the future of our country into the winds of chance implicit in having our laws and policies proposed and framed by unelected EU Commissioners.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 07 Jan 24 7.36pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Why the reluctance to blame them for anything? When they get it wrong it's still our fault for choosing them.
How many politicians are actually honest, capable and acting in the country's best interests rather than semi-competent, self serving chancers. Most of them couldn't run a bath let alone a country.

I am not as cynical as you. My own experience of MPs has been entirely positive. My present one is helping me with a problem and showing great empathy. I was impressed by Steve Barclay when I met him before I moved here, and with Michael Heseltine who I also met several years ago. I think most are honest and hard working and are motivated by a desire to serve. It’s the exceptions who aren’t. It’s the system we use which tends to compromise the ability of people to remain entirely true to their integrity.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 07 Jan 24 7.57pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

The UK parliament did not have full control over our laws as EU law took precedence over UK law.
You stated “What really matters is what delivers the best outcomes. Not an outdated outlook based on prejudice. If something else delivers then what’s the problem?” I merely pointed out that Germany, Italy and Russia adopted “something else” and delivered all sorts of things. By the way, Russia in the 1930s was led by Stalin, not Lenin who booked his place in hell when he died in 1924.
As for “We directly vote for those who represent us. They then must be left to do their job.” The MEPs that we elected were virtually powerless and had no means of implementing any policies they might have had. “Left to do their job” – a job that is largely raking in massive incomes for doing very little.
You say, “Throwing the future of our country into the winds of chance implicit in any referendum is a stupid thing to even contemplate”, yet you want to throw the future of our country into the winds of chance implicit in having our laws and policies proposed and framed by unelected EU Commissioners.

As I said it’s pointless trying to have another discussion about the way democracy within the EU is achieved with anyone so determinedly prejudiced against it. I have done it at length here several times without achieving any comprehension in response.

The UK always had full control. What do you think Article 50 was there for? We delegated certain processes to the EU. Ones where a common approach and common standards made sense. In my own area of food and beverages it was much easier to deal with one set of regulations than a multitude of them. It meant recipes and packaging could be standardised. Something we haven’t tried to change since we left but now have no voice in if new regulations are contemplated. That’s really where the winds of chance will blow.

There’s a million mile gulf between that and the regimes in Germany, Italy and Russia in the 1930s.

It’s only those things that are better regulated collectively that are delegated to the EU. Things like monetary policy, foreign policy and security remained with Westminster. No Commissioner has a role there.

Overall it’s a better arrangement for the future of our country in an ever faster changing world. One in which we need to be realistic about both our place and our prospects and stop dreaming of the long lost days of Empire.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 07 Jan 24 8.30pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

As I said it’s pointless trying to have another discussion about the way democracy within the EU is achieved with anyone so determinedly prejudiced against it. I have done it at length here several times without achieving any comprehension in response.

The UK always had full control. What do you think Article 50 was there for? We delegated certain processes to the EU. Ones where a common approach and common standards made sense. In my own area of food and beverages it was much easier to deal with one set of regulations than a multitude of them. It meant recipes and packaging could be standardised. Something we haven’t tried to change since we left but now have no voice in if new regulations are contemplated. That’s really where the winds of chance will blow.

There’s a million mile gulf between that and the regimes in Germany, Italy and Russia in the 1930s.

It’s only those things that are better regulated collectively that are delegated to the EU. Things like monetary policy, foreign policy and security remained with Westminster. No Commissioner has a role there.

Overall it’s a better arrangement for the future of our country in an ever faster changing world. One in which we need to be realistic about both our place and our prospects and stop dreaming of the long lost days of Empire.

Elected representatives to the EU have virtually no power, those elected to the North Korean Peoples Assembly have about as much power. MEPs can't even vote on the Commissioners budgetary and foreign policy measures.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 07 Jan 24 11.11pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

Elected representatives to the EU have virtually no power, those elected to the North Korean Peoples Assembly have about as much power. MEPs can't even vote on the Commissioners budgetary and foreign policy measures.

The EU Parliament has a different function to our or any other national Parliament. It has no interest in anything decided at national level but it can propose, scrutinise and pass legislation in the areas it does. It can also dismiss the Commission after a vote of censure. So it has power, but has not yet had to use it.

Try doing any of that in NK and you would be shot.

Edited by Wisbech Eagle (07 Jan 2024 11.12pm)

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 08 Jan 24 7.48am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

The EU Parliament has a different function to our or any other national Parliament. It has no interest in anything decided at national level but it can propose, scrutinise and pass legislation in the areas it does. It can also dismiss the Commission after a vote of censure. So it has power, but has not yet had to use it.

Try doing any of that in NK and you would be shot.

Edited by Wisbech Eagle (07 Jan 2024 11.12pm)

Different function indeed! It cannot propose or frame legislation, only the unelected EU Commissioners can do that. It can vote against some legislation, but in the case of budgetary or foreign policy law, it can't even do that.

You have stated several times that our elected representatives should make our laws and decide things for us. Our elected representative to the EU would be powerless to do that.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 08 Jan 24 8.53am

Originally posted by georgenorman

Different function indeed! It cannot propose or frame legislation, only the unelected EU Commissioners can do that. It can vote against some legislation, but in the case of budgetary or foreign policy law, it can't even do that.

You have stated several times that our elected representatives should make our laws and decide things for us. Our elected representative to the EU would be powerless to do that.

It isn’t a national Parliament so it inevitably works differently. Only if there was a complete abandonment of individual national sovereignty could what you appear to want be any different. Even a federal system would not achieve it.

[Link]

My remarks on what I want our elected representatives to do are addressed solely to those we elected to Westminster. Not to other bodies, like the EU or indeed local authorities. Those have different functions.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 08 Jan 24 9.50am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

It isn’t a national Parliament so it inevitably works differently. Only if there was a complete abandonment of individual national sovereignty could what you appear to want be any different. Even a federal system would not achieve it.

[Link]

My remarks on what I want our elected representatives to do are addressed solely to those we elected to Westminster. Not to other bodies, like the EU or indeed local authorities. Those have different functions.

Your link confirms exactly what I said - thanks for that.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 08 Jan 24 5.44pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

Your link confirms exactly what I said - thanks for that.

No it doesn’t. It explains the role of the parliament within the limits of the EU structure and its specific responsibilities. You want to compare it with a national parliament. It’s no more relevant than trying to compare chalk with cheese.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 08 Jan 24 5.50pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

No it doesn’t. It explains the role of the parliament within the limits of the EU structure and its specific responsibilities. You want to compare it with a national parliament. It’s no more relevant than trying to compare chalk with cheese.

The key phrase in your link is "a proposal for a ‘legislative text’ presented by the European Commission, the only institution empowered to initiate legislation."

I want to compare it to the democratic principle that peoples' elected representatives should make the laws that govern them.

Edited by georgenorman (08 Jan 2024 5.51pm)

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 08 Jan 24 10.04pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

The key phrase in your link is "a proposal for a ‘legislative text’ presented by the European Commission, the only institution empowered to initiate legislation."

I want to compare it to the democratic principle that peoples' elected representatives should make the laws that govern them.

Edited by georgenorman (08 Jan 2024 5.51pm)

They do, but not via the EU Parliament. That’s not its role. They have delegated and then the various institutions, including the Council of Ministers, carry out their tasks.

You want to mould everything to fit the UK model. It doesn’t work like that. Something that the Brexiteers were never able to comprehend. If Farage failed to, as he did, then what hope have you got? knew it was never going to be worthwhile trying to reason this out with you.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 08 Jan 24 10.30pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

They do, but not via the EU Parliament. That’s not its role. They have delegated and then the various institutions, including the Council of Ministers, carry out their tasks.

You want to mould everything to fit the UK model. It doesn’t work like that. Something that the Brexiteers were never able to comprehend. If Farage failed to, as he did, then what hope have you got? knew it was never going to be worthwhile trying to reason this out with you.

You repeating an obvious falsehood does not make it true. "It's doesn't work like that"! You can say that again! Most Leave voters comprehended only too well the undemocratic nature of the EU. Farage did not fail, he was a major factor in the country making the right decision.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 09 Jan 24 9.16am

Originally posted by georgenorman

You repeating an obvious falsehood does not make it true. "It's doesn't work like that"! You can say that again! Most Leave voters comprehended only too well the undemocratic nature of the EU. Farage did not fail, he was a major factor in the country making the right decision.

I was talking about Farage failing to understand the purpose of the EU Parliament. He was repeatedly bleating about a lack of direct control in much the same way you are now.

If having full control over every aspect of your life is what matters most to you, then go buy an island and become a self reliant hermit. You would live without the benefits of civilisation, suffer disease and be at the mercy of chance in everything. You would probably die young. But you would be in control.

As soon as people realised that some things are more efficiently done together society was born. Society demands that each member delegates certain decisions. It requires management. Originally the strongest managed but when they were overthrown by collective power democracy was born.

Every democratic system removes individual power and delegates it. That cannot be disputed. It’s only a question of how much power and to whom.

The important thing in deciding that question is not high and mighty principles based on history but a visionary view of what will deliver the best outcomes.

We delegate many aspects of the way we do things in a modern world to other authorities because if we do, so do others and together we do things efficiently. We delegate part of our defence to NATO for instance. The EU is no different.

So long as we retain the ultimate control in the representatives we ourselves elect to Westminster it remains a democratic system.

We have left the EU but we still delegate aspects of our lives to others. Do you want us to leave NATO, the UN etc etc? Do you want us to become hermits?

Brexit has not, will not and cannot deliver a better outcome for this country than us remaining as a member. Taking back control and finding the only way we can steer the ship is onto the rocks is a pretty empty benefit.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 09 Jan 24 10.11am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I was talking about Farage failing to understand the purpose of the EU Parliament. He was repeatedly bleating about a lack of direct control in much the same way you are now.

If having full control over every aspect of your life is what matters most to you, then go buy an island and become a self reliant hermit. You would live without the benefits of civilisation, suffer disease and be at the mercy of chance in everything. You would probably die young. But you would be in control.

As soon as people realised that some things are more efficiently done together society was born. Society demands that each member delegates certain decisions. It requires management. Originally the strongest managed but when they were overthrown by collective power democracy was born.

Every democratic system removes individual power and delegates it. That cannot be disputed. It’s only a question of how much power and to whom.

The important thing in deciding that question is not high and mighty principles based on history but a visionary view of what will deliver the best outcomes.

We delegate many aspects of the way we do things in a modern world to other authorities because if we do, so do others and together we do things efficiently. We delegate part of our defence to NATO for instance. The EU is no different.

So long as we retain the ultimate control in the representatives we ourselves elect to Westminster it remains a democratic system.

We have left the EU but we still delegate aspects of our lives to others. Do you want us to leave NATO, the UN etc etc? Do you want us to become hermits?

Brexit has not, will not and cannot deliver a better outcome for this country than us remaining as a member. Taking back control and finding the only way we can steer the ship is onto the rocks is a pretty empty benefit.

I'm just of the view that the EU is not democratic. I merely want to be able to participate in the election of the people that make the laws that govern me.
NATO and the UN do not make the laws that govern me. I could if I chose, vote for those who might advocate leaving NATO or the UN.
Your usual squid-ink cloud of irrelevant diversions demonstrates that you have no real defence.

Edited by georgenorman (09 Jan 2024 12.07pm)

 

Page 144 of 174 < 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy