You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy
November 21 2026 11.59pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy


Page 145 of 174 < 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 >
Stirlingsays Flag 09 Jan 24 10.17am

'Democracy' = people I agree with being in charge.

'Threat to Democracy' = people I don't agree with being in charge.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 09 Jan 24 4.20pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

I'm just of the view that the EU is not democratic. I merely want to be able to participate in the election of the people that make the laws that govern me.
NATO and the UN do not make the laws that govern me. I could if I chose, vote for those who might advocate leaving NATO or the UN.
Your usual squid-ink cloud of irrelevant diversions demonstrates that you have no real defence.

Edited by georgenorman (09 Jan 2024 12.07pm)

You do participate in the election of the laws that govern you! You presumably voted in the Parliament that decided to trigger Article 50 which meant we left the EU. If we re-enter you will vote in the Parliament that decides how we do. Such Parliaments also decide on our membership of both NATO and the UN, so your participation in that is no different. Our Parliament is sovereign. You help to choose it. What you seem to want is a direct democracy in which the people directly decide on everything, which is completely impractical in a country like ours.

You just don’t like the EU model. Which is fair enough. I think it can be improved so that the Parliament has a bigger role and people feel more connected to it. However on balance I believe it delivers more by us being a member than it takes away and that reform is better achieved inside than out.

I am convinced we will rejoin, probably in stages via a better “deal” initially followed by some kind of associate membership possibly as the EU divides into an inner and outer group.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 09 Jan 24 4.26pm

Democracy has nothing whatsoever to do with whether any individual happens to agree with what is done.

It is government of the people, by the people. Which can be defined in various ways.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Stirlingsays Flag 09 Jan 24 4.44pm

Matt Le Tissier on what happened to him around the covid madness.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 09 Jan 24 4.57pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

You do participate in the election of the laws that govern you! You presumably voted in the Parliament that decided to trigger Article 50 which meant we left the EU. If we re-enter you will vote in the Parliament that decides how we do. Such Parliaments also decide on our membership of both NATO and the UN, so your participation in that is no different. Our Parliament is sovereign. You help to choose it. What you seem to want is a direct democracy in which the people directly decide on everything, which is completely impractical in a country like ours.

You just don’t like the EU model. Which is fair enough. I think it can be improved so that the Parliament has a bigger role and people feel more connected to it. However on balance I believe it delivers more by us being a member than it takes away and that reform is better achieved inside than out.

I am convinced we will rejoin, probably in stages via a better “deal” initially followed by some kind of associate membership possibly as the EU divides into an inner and outer group.

While in the EU I could not participate in the election of those who make EU law and EU law had precedence over UK law. NATO and the UN do not make laws that govern me. If you mean by direct democracy the ability to elect those that make the laws that govern me, then yes, I do want that.
I respect your view that you think the racketeering, protectionist, undemocratic, third world damaging EU would be good for us, you should respect my view that I think it would not. Associate membership, inner, outer groups – all nonsense, you end up like Norway.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 09 Jan 24 5.21pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

While in the EU I could not participate in the election of those who make EU law and EU law had precedence over UK law. NATO and the UN do not make laws that govern me. If you mean by direct democracy the ability to elect those that make the laws that govern me, then yes, I do want that.
I respect your view that you think the racketeering, protectionist, undemocratic, third world damaging EU would be good for us, you should respect my view that I think it would not. Associate membership, inner, outer groups – all nonsense, you end up like Norway.

You did though particate. You voted in our elections which produced Parliaments which could, if they wished, have decided to trigger Article 50 at any time. They chose who became Ministers. Those Ministers attended the Council of Ministers meetings in which new laws were discussed and either approved or rejected. The Prime Minister also attended the European Council where general policy and direction are discussed so that the Commission can be directed.

In fact we voters had more input into the decision making process of the EU than either the UN or NATO.

I do not share your cynical dismissal of the EU. In my opinion it’s a force for good and a much safer place for us than either being alone or hanging onto the coat-tails of the USA. You are as entitled to your opinion as I am to mine. We both have to accept that it’s only the collective decision of us all that decides who governs us. I certainly do, and I want them to do it and never again ask the people directly via a referendum. That for me has always been my priority.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 09 Jan 24 5.32pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

You did though particate. You voted in our elections which produced Parliaments which could, if they wished, have decided to trigger Article 50 at any time. They chose who became Ministers. Those Ministers attended the Council of Ministers meetings in which new laws were discussed and either approved or rejected. The Prime Minister also attended the European Council where general policy and direction are discussed so that the Commission can be directed.

In fact we voters had more input into the decision making process of the EU than either the UN or NATO.

I do not share your cynical dismissal of the EU. In my opinion it’s a force for good and a much safer place for us than either being alone or hanging onto the coat-tails of the USA. You are as entitled to your opinion as I am to mine. We both have to accept that it’s only the collective decision of us all that decides who governs us. I certainly do, and I want them to do it and never again ask the people directly via a referendum. That for me has always been my priority.

Which EU laws did my elected representatives propose, frame and promulgate?

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 09 Jan 24 7.21pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

Which EU laws did my elected representatives propose, frame and promulgate?

None because as I have patiently explained it doesn’t work like that in the EU. That’s the job of the Commission who work to the priorities given to them by the Council and then examined, improvements proposed and eventually verified by the Parliament and Council of Ministers. It’s at those levels that our representatives are involved. Not in the early leg work of trying to find a draft that can work in 27 different locations. They have the experts able to do that. The Parliamentarians then examine the results from their specific perspectives. I doubt it could actually work any other way.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 09 Jan 24 8.44pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

None because as I have patiently explained it doesn’t work like that in the EU. That’s the job of the Commission who work to the priorities given to them by the Council and then examined, improvements proposed and eventually verified by the Parliament and Council of Ministers. It’s at those levels that our representatives are involved. Not in the early leg work of trying to find a draft that can work in 27 different locations. They have the experts able to do that. The Parliamentarians then examine the results from their specific perspectives. I doubt it could actually work any other way.

The Commission is not told what to do by anybody. From the EU's own website: "The European Commission is the EU’s politically independent executive arm. It is alone responsible for drawing up proposals for new European legislation … The European Commission is responsible for planning, preparing and proposing new European laws. It has the right to do this on its own initiative … The European Commission is the sole EU body capable of proposing new legislation."

Attached is that far right nationalist, Tony Benn on the EU and its Council of Ministers.
[Link]

Edited by georgenorman (09 Jan 2024 9.21pm)

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 09 Jan 24 9.48pm

quote=georgenorman;3847574]

The Commission is not told what to do by anybody. From the EU's own website: "The European Commission is the EU’s politically independent executive arm. It is alone responsible for drawing up proposals for new European legislation … The European Commission is responsible for planning, preparing and proposing new European laws. It has the right to do this on its own initiative … The European Commission is the sole EU body capable of proposing new legislation."

Attached is that far right nationalist, Tony Benn on the EU and its Council of Ministers.
[Link]

Edited by georgenorman (09 Jan 2024 9.21pm)

That is simply untrue.

The Commission is bound by the Treaties on which areas it can address and which it cannot. Treaties that have been agreed by our elected representatives and its priorities are defined by the Council during their quarterly meetings.

As a non political institution how it operates needs to be seen in its context. It needs to emphasise its independence from the politicians hence the particular phraseology. All new legislation is indeed initiated by the Commission. That’s one of its key functions. It doesn’t though enact any proposals. That’s done by the politicians. Anything that’s outside the EU’s remit, or not considered a priority, would be rejected so the Commission would be foolish to attempt it.

It works differently because it needs to work differently. The EU is not a federation with any kind of central control. It is an association of the willing. Countries prepared to work together to harmonise regulations in their mutual interests. The benefits flowing from that are very clear. The downside wholly imaginary and based on outdated ideas that don’t serve today and even less serve the future of our children.

[Link]

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 09 Jan 24 10.05pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

quote=georgenorman;3847574]

The Commission is not told what to do by anybody. From the EU's own website: "The European Commission is the EU’s politically independent executive arm. It is alone responsible for drawing up proposals for new European legislation … The European Commission is responsible for planning, preparing and proposing new European laws. It has the right to do this on its own initiative … The European Commission is the sole EU body capable of proposing new legislation."

Attached is that far right nationalist, Tony Benn on the EU and its Council of Ministers.
[Link]

Edited by georgenorman (09 Jan 2024 9.21pm)

That is simply untrue.

The Commission is bound by the Treaties on which areas it can address and which it cannot. Treaties that have been agreed by our elected representatives and its priorities are defined by the Council during their quarterly meetings.

As a non political institution how it operates needs to be seen in its context. It needs to emphasise its independence from the politicians hence the particular phraseology. All new legislation is indeed initiated by the Commission. That’s one of its key functions. It doesn’t though enact any proposals. That’s done by the politicians. Anything that’s outside the EU’s remit, or not considered a priority, would be rejected so the Commission would be foolish to attempt it.

It works differently because it needs to work differently. The EU is not a federation with any kind of central control. It is an association of the willing. Countries prepared to work together to harmonise regulations in their mutual interests. The benefits flowing from that are very clear. The downside wholly imaginary and based on outdated ideas that don’t serve today and even less serve the future of our children.

[Link]


______________________________________________________________

Their own website says "The European Commission is responsible for planning, preparing and proposing new European laws. It has the right to do this on its own initiative."!!
Have you listened to Benn's experience of being a minister there? He says he couldn't even submit a document or attend their meetings! You think you know better than a politician who was actually on the Council of Ministers.

Here is part of what he said: I was on the Council of Ministers, and it was the most shattering experience of my life, because I was the representative of Britain, and for six months I was the President of the Council of Energy Ministries. I wasn’t allowed to submit a document! Only the Commission, who are bureaucrats could submit a document. I could say yes or no, sort of a constitutional monarch if you like, they controlled it. It met in secret. It made laws for Britain, and everywhere else. It met in secret. And when I suggested that we met in public, oh they nearly strangled me, because all their dirty little deals would have come out. And so… the more I thought about this, and this is what it is about now – it is about democracy.

Edited by georgenorman (09 Jan 2024 10.16pm)

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 10 Jan 24 8.36am

Originally posted by georgenorman


______________________________________________________________

Their own website says "The European Commission is responsible for planning, preparing and proposing new European laws. It has the right to do this on its own initiative."!!
Have you listened to Benn's experience of being a minister there? He says he couldn't even submit a document or attend their meetings! You think you know better than a politician who was actually on the Council of Ministers.

Here is part of what he said: I was on the Council of Ministers, and it was the most shattering experience of my life, because I was the representative of Britain, and for six months I was the President of the Council of Energy Ministries. I wasn’t allowed to submit a document! Only the Commission, who are bureaucrats could submit a document. I could say yes or no, sort of a constitutional monarch if you like, they controlled it. It met in secret. It made laws for Britain, and everywhere else. It met in secret. And when I suggested that we met in public, oh they nearly strangled me, because all their dirty little deals would have come out. And so… the more I thought about this, and this is what it is about now – it is about democracy.

Edited by georgenorman (09 Jan 2024 10.16pm)

That’s very simply because that’s not the way it works. The Commission, being totally non political, keeps all politicians at arms length to ensure that their role is maintained as completely independent in approach. That way they avoid even the appearance of political interference. The involvement of the politicians comes separately, via their own institutions, the Council and the Parliament, when they define priorities and then scrutinise and approve, or disapprove the results before enacting any actual laws.

Benn, as a politician, may well have been frustrated and tried to involve himself. He had a perfect right to do so and argue for change but the way it is currently set up that’s not what happens and I can see why. There are some tasks that are better done independently and without having to worry about having any politician riding their favourite hobby horse through the process. Their opportunities come later when the whole package is ready and other politicians can also chime in.

You may not like this style of democracy. I sense you are the type who believes we should have the right to take decisions, by binding referendums, on all kinds of issues. I imagine you would want the people to directly decide on capital punishment for instance, or whether we refuse all asylum seekers or to ban the recognition of transgenders. I don’t. I want our representatives to decide after they have received the advice of, and seen the results of the work from, the professional experts we employ to help them.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 10 Jan 24 10.22am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

That’s very simply because that’s not the way it works. The Commission, being totally non political, keeps all politicians at arms length to ensure that their role is maintained as completely independent in approach. That way they avoid even the appearance of political interference. The involvement of the politicians comes separately, via their own institutions, the Council and the Parliament, when they define priorities and then scrutinise and approve, or disapprove the results before enacting any actual laws.

Benn, as a politician, may well have been frustrated and tried to involve himself. He had a perfect right to do so and argue for change but the way it is currently set up that’s not what happens and I can see why. There are some tasks that are better done independently and without having to worry about having any politician riding their favourite hobby horse through the process. Their opportunities come later when the whole package is ready and other politicians can also chime in.

You may not like this style of democracy. I sense you are the type who believes we should have the right to take decisions, by binding referendums, on all kinds of issues. I imagine you would want the people to directly decide on capital punishment for instance, or whether we refuse all asylum seekers or to ban the recognition of transgenders. I don’t. I want our representatives to decide after they have received the advice of, and seen the results of the work from, the professional experts we employ to help them.

Yes, the Commission keeps the politicians at arms length, the politicians that the people have elected. Yes, the Commission is completely independent, it does whatever it wants despite the policies of the elected representatives. All that you have said just illustrates the fact that the EU is not democratic in any real sense.

I don’t particularly want referendums on any issue. If the government holds one, as they did in 2016, then they should honour the result.

Certainly I think the death penalty should be available as a sentence, not in all case, up to the judge. I would not want to refuse genuine asylum seekers, whose numbers would be so much smaller than the number of bogus ones. What do you mean by ‘recognition of transgenders’, I think I would recognise a man with a beard in a dress as some sort of degenerate.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 10 Jan 24 11.46am

The EU is nothing short of a near authoritarian power grab for the elite neo/social liberal political class.

Its defenders just play with soft focus words like democracy.....which they can define is ways that would have most people scratching their head.

It's like the 'abuse', 'assaults'' or 'hate' term. They play on the fact that most people still think of the old fashioned and honest usage of these terms to convince people that....say a push on your arm is 'assault', when most sensible people know the difference between that an a punch in the face.

If the real right wing held control of the EU commission and all the EU institutions and systems. People who defend the current EU would be screaming their hearts out that they were living in a dictatorship.

It isn't about principles or democracy or any such waffle. It's purely down to whether the people they prefer are in charge or not.

That's what it always comes down to.....Who your leaders are and how much choice the majority get over them.

They hold the one way megaphone and they filter your choices.

Democracy my arse.

Edited by Stirlingsays (10 Jan 2024 11.53am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 10 Jan 24 4.27pm

'We thought you would like a new disposable face-covering'.

From: - Amazon Shopping.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 10 Jan 24 8.27pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

Yes, the Commission keeps the politicians at arms length, the politicians that the people have elected. Yes, the Commission is completely independent, it does whatever it wants despite the policies of the elected representatives. All that you have said just illustrates the fact that the EU is not democratic in any real sense.

I don’t particularly want referendums on any issue. If the government holds one, as they did in 2016, then they should honour the result.

Certainly I think the death penalty should be available as a sentence, not in all case, up to the judge. I would not want to refuse genuine asylum seekers, whose numbers would be so much smaller than the number of bogus ones. What do you mean by ‘recognition of transgenders’, I think I would recognise a man with a beard in a dress as some sort of degenerate.

I despair!

The Commission is not totally independent. That is a fallacy widely believed by the anti -EU fanatics. It is bound by the treaties and can only act in ways that implement them. Its priorities are determined by the Council. The heads of state of the members collectively deciding what is most important. Their independence comes from being free of political influence during the time they initiate the detailed legislation which cannot pass into law until it has been scrutinised and approved by the politicians.

It’s a different system to ours because the situation in the EU is different to ours.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 10 Jan 24 8.43pm

What it comes down is not, has never been and cannot be “who your leaders are and how much choice the majority get over them.”

That’s the pathetic reasoning of the arch Brexiteers who freely admitted they were prepared to accept a steep decline in our prosperity from which we wouldn’t recover for 30:years in return for “getting back control”! What an empty deal. Putting their pride above the future of our children.

What it comes down is what delivers the best outcomes. Nothing more or less. Ensuring we retain the ultimate power to both delegate responsibility and withdraw it is an essential outcome but after that comes what makes us safe, strong, healthy and prosperous.

Being in control of a sinking ship is not a good outcome.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 10 Jan 24 9.21pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I despair!

The Commission is not totally independent. That is a fallacy widely believed by the anti -EU fanatics. It is bound by the treaties and can only act in ways that implement them. Its priorities are determined by the Council. The heads of state of the members collectively deciding what is most important. Their independence comes from being free of political influence during the time they initiate the detailed legislation which cannot pass into law until it has been scrutinised and approved by the politicians.

It’s a different system to ours because the situation in the EU is different to ours.

What Tony Benn said contradicts most of what you say. Benn was actually a member of the Council of Ministers and saw how things were run at first hand. Benn and many others on the left and right could see that the EU was fundamentally undemocratic, as did those who voted to leave.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 11 Jan 24 8.34am

Originally posted by georgenorman

What Tony Benn said contradicts most of what you say. Benn was actually a member of the Council of Ministers and saw how things were run at first hand. Benn and many others on the left and right could see that the EU was fundamentally undemocratic, as did those who voted to leave.

Benn was, like Corbyn, as the Marxists they both were, fundamentally opposed to the EU. So it’s hardly any surprise that he didn’t find the way the Council of Ministers worked to his taste. Farage was a MEP and spent most of his time in the Chamber moaning about it too.

That you agree with Benn and Corbyn ought perhaps give you pause for thought.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 11 Jan 24 8.36am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Benn was, like Corbyn, as the Marxists they both were, fundamentally opposed to the EU. So it’s hardly any surprise that he didn’t find the way the Council of Ministers worked to his taste. Farage was a MEP and spent most of his time in the Chamber moaning about it too.

That you agree with Benn and Corbyn ought perhaps give you pause for thought.

Enoch Powell's view on this was exactly the same as Benn's. Presumably you think Powell was a Marxist too?

 

Page 145 of 174 < 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy