You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy
November 21 2026 11.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy


Page 146 of 174 < 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 >
Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 11 Jan 24 9.15am

Originally posted by georgenorman

Enoch Powell's view on this was exactly the same as Benn's. Presumably you think Powell was a Marxist too?

I am old enough to have witnessed Powell in office and to have heard him. He was a complicated man. Obviously sincere, intelligent and an orator. He would have made a good, possibly even great, war time leader. What he lacked was any sense of compassion for the common man, for the poor and disadvantaged. He was an early example of the type of attitude found today in the likes of Farage and Rees-Mogg. People who value independence far more than prosperity. Presumably because their own prosperity would remain intact and quite possibly be enhanced.

So not a Marxist but equally distasteful.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 11 Jan 24 9.57am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I am old enough to have witnessed Powell in office and to have heard him. He was a complicated man. Obviously sincere, intelligent and an orator. He would have made a good, possibly even great, war time leader. What he lacked was any sense of compassion for the common man, for the poor and disadvantaged. He was an early example of the type of attitude found today in the likes of Farage and Rees-Mogg. People who value independence far more than prosperity. Presumably because their own prosperity would remain intact and quite possibly be enhanced.

So not a Marxist but equally distasteful.

I am merely pointing out that the recognition of the undemocratic nature of the EU was and is recognised by people of both the left and right of politics.

There is nothing in Powell's life to suggest that he lacked compassion for the common man, the poor and the disadvantaged. He did a great deal in opposing policies that would adversely affect the ordinary man - as does Farage.

Also, Powell was not particularly 'rich'.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 11 Jan 24 11.15am

Enoch Powell was the last politician this country produced who cared more for the native people of these islands than his own career.

He was raised in a time where the elite were still somewhat connected to their people and worth a damn.....It should not be forgotten that when Powell was growing up the vast majority of the wealth class still had loyalty to their country.....not egalitarian and globalist fantasy concepts.

They were still part of the fabric that once made this union of countries great amongst the nations.

Powell was a stellar academic in the classics, one of the highest achieving of his era and any....which is something in comparison to today considering how far academic standards have fallen.

Not many people know but Powell had written love letters to fellow academics as a young man. We don't know if this ever went beyond that. However, as an adult he settled down as a stable family man who had children - two daughters. He was never an advocate for what we see today.

In war service he passed out top from his officer training was promoted and transferred to the intelligence corps as a captain. He was involved in planning at El Alamein and was awarded the MBE and was made a lieutenant-colonel before Mountbatten made him Secretary to the Joint Intelligence Committee for India to assist with planning offensives in Burma. By the end of the war he was a brigadier......he was one of only two men in the entire war to rise from private to brigadier

Powell never experienced combat and felt guilty for having survived.

I'll cut this short because he's life was so full this could be a very long post. Anyway most people don't know that he started out in the Labour party and was quickly recognised as a leading light but for various reasons moved to the Conservatives.

Quickly promoted, ironically he ended up being the health minister who went to the Caribbean to recruit doctors and nurses. His opinion changed radically once he realised that they weren't going back and that the will to make them wasn't there.

Unlike the traitorous Tories in his party he was willing to throw away his stellar career and high reputation to speak the truth about what the elites were doing to their own people.

Pretty much all his predictions came true....not surprisingly as he was just brighter than those in charge.

He is a hero.....that rare elite bird who was worth a damn.

Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Jan 2024 11.40am)

somecared.JPG Attachment: somecared.JPG (110.08Kb)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 11 Jan 24 1.42pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

I am merely pointing out that the recognition of the undemocratic nature of the EU was and is recognised by people of both the left and right of politics.

There is nothing in Powell's life to suggest that he lacked compassion for the common man, the poor and the disadvantaged. He did a great deal in opposing policies that would adversely affect the ordinary man - as does Farage.

Also, Powell was not particularly 'rich'.

No you aren’t. You are merely pointing out that those who cling to out dated ideas have always existed. It’s this, and only this, that binds this disparate group together.

That they, and you apparently, believe their policies were ultimately to the benefit of the common man is just what every right wing politician argues as they contemplate the performance of their investments.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 11 Jan 24 2.03pm

The sycophantic description of Enoch Powell caused my buttocks to clench. That is no doubt he was a brilliant academic who also had a distinguished military career.

If only it had only stopped then he could have been regarded as a hero, but unfortunately it didn’t. As well as being brilliant he was also a deeply flawed man, not least for the “Rivers of Blood” speech for which he is best known. That speech remains probably the most harmful and divisive political speech of my lifetime. His predictions in it, and elsewhere, have not come true but the hatred it created has endured and can easily be detected today, even in these pages with the constant references to “white” people. His legacy is not accurate predictions but the degree of hatred they created.

Powell was the first UK populist that I can recall. He appealed to the worst instincts of the general population and would be quite at home alongside Farage today.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 11 Jan 24 2.22pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I despair!

The Commission is not totally independent. That is a fallacy widely believed by the anti -EU fanatics. It is bound by the treaties and can only act in ways that implement them. Its priorities are determined by the Council. The heads of state of the members collectively deciding what is most important. Their independence comes from being free of political influence during the time they initiate the detailed legislation which cannot pass into law until it has been scrutinised and approved by the politicians.

It’s a different system to ours because the situation in the EU is different to ours.

Germany was bound by a treaty at the end of WW1.........

As far as I can see WE (and I've no desire to argue as you are never wrong) but your logic is based on.

We should elect officials to make decisions on our behalf. They should vote with their knowledge and conscience

but

If we elect the wrong person (Trump) then good sense should prevail and they should be excluded.


Personally I think Trump is a monkey in a suit, who is wholly unfit for Government, but the fact he exists should tell us something. Not every person who voted out is anti immigration and Anti EU. People vote based on personal circumstances, your one is is that life has worked in a way that has allowed you to benefit from a lot of advantages - and fair play to you for taking advantage of that and ending up in a lovely part of the world.

But your perspective is based on your experiences. You've made comment about how Wisbech is these days - I've seen Wisbech too and I can well understand why it had the highest "vote out" percentage in the East, because most people can't "pull themselves up" like you have.

I'm 42 years old and in the pandemic I saw all three sides - I ran a business, I advised other businesses and I lost a parent to Covid. The latter I knew would be in trouble if he caught it, but that the hangover from excessive lockdowns would be extensive and the public sector has very little idea of how the private sector works. Every side thinks they are right, whereas the reality is that it is hindsight.

I respect you have conviction in your beliefs, but my God you are one patronizing arse, who I suspect thinks himself this educated individual who should be listened to more than others. Remind you of someone who is thinking of running of President? I don't think Trump should be anywhere near President, but to dismiss anyone thinking of voting for him as a moron is dictatorial and highlights the whole reason he exists. It's one of the large reasons people voted out, that the Remain side didn't do enough to convince and understand why anyone would vote out, besides being a racist Little Englander.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 11 Jan 24 2.34pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

No you aren’t. You are merely pointing out that those who cling to out dated ideas have always existed. It’s this, and only this, that binds this disparate group together.

That they, and you apparently, believe their policies were ultimately to the benefit of the common man is just what every right wing politician argues as they contemplate the performance of their investments.

I think you are plumbing new depths with this - even for you. Totally devoid of any coherent argument.

How about David Owen, do you lump him in with Benn and Powell?

Edited by georgenorman (11 Jan 2024 2.57pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 11 Jan 24 2.48pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

The sycophantic description of Enoch Powell caused my buttocks to clench. That is no doubt he was a brilliant academic who also had a distinguished military career.

If only it had only stopped then he could have been regarded as a hero, but unfortunately it didn’t. As well as being brilliant he was also a deeply flawed man, not least for the “Rivers of Blood” speech for which he is best known. That speech remains probably the most harmful and divisive political speech of my lifetime. His predictions in it, and elsewhere, have not come true but the hatred it created has endured and can easily be detected today, even in these pages with the constant references to “white” people. His legacy is not accurate predictions but the degree of hatred they created.

Powell was the first UK populist that I can recall. He appealed to the worst instincts of the general population and would be quite at home alongside Farage today.

You mean apart from the many race riots over the years, terrorist attacks, mass rape of children, rampant knife, gun and drug crime.
Along with the massive industry of race relations trying to keep the lid on things and letting teachers having to go into hiding for fear of their lives.
Oh, and not to mention modern slavery, genital mutilation and honour killings. The strains on services, housing etc by massive increases in population numbers is probably too obvious to mention, as is the obvious real lack of integration and adoption of British culture.

Edited by georgenorman (11 Jan 2024 2.49pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 11 Jan 24 3.24pm

So the practices and ideas that made this country first among nations are 'outdated', but the ideas that have left this country a debt ridden and toothless middle of the road was-been are better.

There speaks subversion.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 11 Jan 24 6.28pm

6-ft’ social distancing ‘sort of just appeared,’ likely lacked scientific basis, Fauci admits.

Fauci is another who is going to be very nervous if the GOP take over.....In fact if Trump wins perhaps several prominent Democratic figures will leave the country.

[Link]

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 11 Jan 24 8.20pm

Originally posted by robdave2k

Germany was bound by a treaty at the end of WW1.........

As far as I can see WE (and I've no desire to argue as you are never wrong) but your logic is based on.

We should elect officials to make decisions on our behalf. They should vote with their knowledge and conscience

but

If we elect the wrong person (Trump) then good sense should prevail and they should be excluded.


Personally I think Trump is a monkey in a suit, who is wholly unfit for Government, but the fact he exists should tell us something. Not every person who voted out is anti immigration and Anti EU. People vote based on personal circumstances, your one is is that life has worked in a way that has allowed you to benefit from a lot of advantages - and fair play to you for taking advantage of that and ending up in a lovely part of the world.

But your perspective is based on your experiences. You've made comment about how Wisbech is these days - I've seen Wisbech too and I can well understand why it had the highest "vote out" percentage in the East, because most people can't "pull themselves up" like you have.

I'm 42 years old and in the pandemic I saw all three sides - I ran a business, I advised other businesses and I lost a parent to Covid. The latter I knew would be in trouble if he caught it, but that the hangover from excessive lockdowns would be extensive and the public sector has very little idea of how the private sector works. Every side thinks they are right, whereas the reality is that it is hindsight.

I respect you have conviction in your beliefs, but my God you are one patronizing arse, who I suspect thinks himself this educated individual who should be listened to more than others. Remind you of someone who is thinking of running of President? I don't think Trump should be anywhere near President, but to dismiss anyone thinking of voting for him as a moron is dictatorial and highlights the whole reason he exists. It's one of the large reasons people voted out, that the Remain side didn't do enough to convince and understand why anyone would vote out, besides being a racist Little Englander.

Germany broke its treaty. The members of the EU, with the probable exception of Hungary, haven’t.

I have never argued that Trump wasn’t elected legally and as a consequence had the right to be whatever kind of President he chose to be. I completely accept that many who voted for him did so in good faith and for valid reasons. Nor is everyone who voted out anti immigration or anti EU. Some were truly convinced that we would benefit from not having to pay our contributions, though I doubt whether those convictions remain now.

I too think Trump is unfit for office and that his behaviour ought either to make that legally enforced or rejected by the people. That so many in the USA disagree is what puzzles me and not Trump himself. Trump is a parody. He isn’t real. I don’t believe those who will vote for him are all morons, although some are. That others do raises many questions for me about the state of politics in the USA, and also about their education system and where and how they now get their information.

I am sorry about your personal experiences in the pandemic. Unfortunately they weren’t so unusual though that is no comfort. My primary objection to those who complain about the lockdowns is not that they aren’t entitled to their views but that those views aren’t based on all the information that was needed to reach a judgement. We employ experts to do that and for them to advise government, who take the decisions. Now we have an enquiry to see what lessons are available to guide us should we face anything similar in future. Rather than know alls with fixed prejudices pontificating on what went wrong and how their approach would have been better I think it’s more sensible to wait for the enquiry to report, but the know alls are already dismissing it as a whitewash.

I am not especially educated. I left school at 16 with 5 O levels, but did OK, working my way up on merit to become the MD of a substantial company before owning two businesses myself and employing a fair number of people. So, at nearly 80, I have some experience. I don’t intend to be patronising and apologise if that’s how it seems to you. I just find some of the ideas and comments posted here to be both very wide of the truth and often pretty unpleasant. So they get scorn.

The reason Remain just lost is easily explained. It’s the same reason why if we reran a referendum now they would win. It’s always easier to sell change than to sell the status quo. You can paint the picture of a golden new era without difficulty when offering change but when defending the status quo you have to deal with reality.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 11 Jan 24 8.44pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

You mean apart from the many race riots over the years, terrorist attacks, mass rape of children, rampant knife, gun and drug crime.
Along with the massive industry of race relations trying to keep the lid on things and letting teachers having to go into hiding for fear of their lives.
Oh, and not to mention modern slavery, genital mutilation and honour killings. The strains on services, housing etc by massive increases in population numbers is probably too obvious to mention, as is the obvious real lack of integration and adoption of British culture.

Edited by georgenorman (11 Jan 2024 2.49pm)

No, I mean there haven’t been any rivers of blood.

Exactly where have there been any race riots?

Some of the worst terrorist attacks we witnessed came from the IRA.

Yes, we have seen appalling behaviour from some new arrivals that reflect badly on them but also on us for failing to do enough to ensure they both accepted our standards and removed them if they did not. We have also seen many wonderful, hard working new arrivals playing important, often essential, roles in our society.

Things like knife and drug crime are not limited to immigrants. Stamping out such things as modern slavery, genital mutilation and honour killings is essential and is again as much our failure as anything else. We need to have zero tolerance of such things and no one should be in any doubt about that from day 1.

We need people to maintain and develop the economy. Whether they come by us increasing our birth rate or via immigration doesn’t change the fact that our infrastructure must expand to serve them. If it hasn’t that’s our failure. Not their’s.

That we ought to do more to get the feckless off benefits and back to work is certainly also true. That we don’t is another failure. I want to see everyone on benefits who is in any way capable of work, working. Even if all they can do is use a phone or a keyboard they should be required to do something, or lose something.

Edited by Wisbech Eagle (11 Jan 2024 8.55pm)

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 11 Jan 24 8.51pm

Deciding to create clear space around us was a common sense empirical decision taken originally I recall by the WHO. Fixing it at a notional 6 feet was merely a guide.

No science existed at the time for the completely new novel virus that was Covid 19. It could not have been anything more than theoretical.

Arguing otherwise and trying to put Fauci in the spotlight is just more shameless. political posturing

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 11 Jan 24 9.01pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

No, I mean there haven’t been any rivers of blood.

Exactly where have there been any race riots?

Some of the worst terrorist attacks we witnessed came from the IRA.

Yes, we have seen appalling behaviour from some new arrivals that reflect badly on them but also on us for failing to do enough to ensure they both accepted our standards and removed them if they did not. We have also seen many wonderful, hard working new arrivals playing important, often essential, roles in our society.

Things like knife and drug crime are not limited to immigrants. Stamping out such things as modern slavery, genital mutilation and honour killings is essential and is again as much our failure as anything else. We need to have zero tolerance of such things and no one should be in any doubt about that from day 1.

We need people to maintain and develop the economy. Whether they come by us increasing our birth rate or via immigration doesn’t change the fact that our infrastructure must expand to serve them. If it hasn’t that’s our failure. Not their’s.

That we ought to do more to get the feckless off benefits and back to work is certainly also true. That we don’t is another failure. I want to see everyone on benefits who is in any way capable of work, working. Even if all they can do is use a phone or a keyboard they should be required to do something, or lose something.

Edited by Wisbech Eagle (11 Jan 2024 8.55pm)

Powell never used the words “rivers of blood” in his speech.

Have you not followed the news over the last 60 odd years? A few race riots to be going on with:
1980 St Pauls riot, 1981 Chapeltown riots, 1981 Moss Side riot, 1981 Toxteth riots, 1985 Handsworth riots, 1989 Dewsbury riot, 2001 Oldham riots, 2005 Birmingham riots, 2001 Bradford riots, 1985 Brixton riot, 1985 Broadwater Farm riot, 1975 Chapeltown riot, 2001 Harehills riot, 1958 Notting Hill race riots, 1958 St Ann's riots.

Some of the worst terrorist attacks we have witnessed came from Islamic immigrant and/or their children.

Those with Caribbean heritage are over represented for gun, knife and drug crime.

Modern slavery, genital mutilation and honour killings are almost entirely largely the preserve of some immigrant groups – although I accept that some ‘traveller’ ‘communities’ are not adverse to modern slavery.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 11 Jan 24 9.07pm

The circumstances that made the British Empire the world’s dominant economy 150 years ago no longer exists.

Yet some here seem to think that what served us then could do so again, if only we dumped our pluralism.

That’s what living in the past means.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 11 Jan 24 9.40pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

The circumstances that made the British Empire the world’s dominant economy 150 years ago no longer exists.

Yet some here seem to think that what served us then could do so again, if only we dumped our pluralism.

That’s what living in the past means.

Straws and grasping spring to mind.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 12 Jan 24 9.06am

Originally posted by georgenorman

I think you are plumbing new depths with this - even for you. Totally devoid of any coherent argument.

How about David Owen, do you lump him in with Benn and Powell?

Edited by georgenorman (11 Jan 2024 2.57pm)

No. David Owen is completely different. He is pro-Europe to his core and a committed believer in the EU. He though did not like specific developments, like the move to federalism, the idea of a European army and the treatment of Greece. His support for Leave was, I believe, intended to focus attention on these things and force a better offer from the EU prior to the vote. He didn’t really want to leave. He wanted us to either move the EU back to its original purpose or negotiate a different kind of membership for us. I don’t think he really thought Leave would win, was shocked that it did and then campaigned for a very soft deal.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 12 Jan 24 9.45am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

No. David Owen is completely different. He is pro-Europe to his core and a committed believer in the EU. He though did not like specific developments, like the move to federalism, the idea of a European army and the treatment of Greece. His support for Leave was, I believe, intended to focus attention on these things and force a better offer from the EU prior to the vote. He didn’t really want to leave. He wanted us to either move the EU back to its original purpose or negotiate a different kind of membership for us. I don’t think he really thought Leave would win, was shocked that it did and then campaigned for a very soft deal.

Owen was originally pro-EEC. Like many Leave supporters he came to see the reality of the EU and became anything but "a committed believer in the EU". He campaigned for Leave in the Referendum, and has made no move to support rejoining. It is nonsense to say "he didn't really want to leave", he actively campaigned to leave. He rejoiced when we did vote to leave and did not campaign for "a very soft deal" (whatever that is).

Edited by georgenorman (12 Jan 2024 9.45am)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Jan 24 10.44am

No putting Fauci or the WHO in the spotlight isn't just more shameless. political posturing.

If companies ignored their guidelines they were open to lawsuits, so what they stated was incredibly important and was defacto policy.
We saw this in how companies and corporations just adopted everything coming out of their mouths like gospel.

What we are seeing post hoc is a throwing off of responsibility when they knew exactly the power they had. They were putting guidelines out there that were not based upon science yet companies and corporations were liable to be sued if they didn't follow it.....It was madness.

No, this isn't good enough.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Teddy Eagle Flag 12 Jan 24 1.08pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

No putting Fauci or the WHO in the spotlight isn't just more shameless. political posturing.

If companies ignored their guidelines they were open to lawsuits, so what they stated was incredibly important and was defacto policy.
We saw this in how companies and corporations just adopted everything coming out of their mouths like gospel.

What we are seeing post hoc is a throwing off of responsibility when they knew exactly the power they had. They were putting guidelines out there that were not based upon science yet companies and corporations were liable to be sued if they didn't follow it.....It was madness.

No, this isn't good enough.

Like the fact you were safe from infection sitting in a restaurant but not standing up in one.

 

Page 146 of 174 < 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy