This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
I agree with some of this Fraud definitely happens in every election. But in this case we can and will be able to say fraud on the scale suggested did or didn’t happen. Otherwise what are you saying - nothing is ever resolvable? Probability is useless? Lack of evidence is as strong as Evidence? Purgatory Agree investigating is the right, proper and fair thing to do What do you mean ‘why they aren’t’ - pretty sure they are in all 40+ court cases, so... or, as I assume you do mean, you think they should be making more of a song and dance in the ‘MSM’ about it? Or to you directly? Not sure of that logic, just because they’re not making as much noise as the trumpians, which in fairness for most is an impossible level to reach, doesn’t mean that is evidence of wrongdoing. Not sure I follow there - if I were them I’d be doing the same thing. Fight back in the courts, be dignified, and let the empty vessels make the most noise (until proven otherwise). It’s called the normal play, not the toys out of the pram play. Your cherry picking bits of what I wrote.
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Legitimately answered directly to you? So unless trump says it didn’t happen then you can’t square that it didn’t? Doesn’t that work both ways though? At some point you have to place some trust in some elements of the judicial system here. Have you read all of the legal documents, arguments, cases and so on? Have you followed up every claim, accusation and item of evidence to decide whether in your opinion it’s a genuine one or it’s a case of someone being paid ,000 to be a ‘witness’? No. That’s the job of the prosecution and the courts. I'll read the Supreme court judgement when it comes to that....which I think it should as I don't really trust the political neutrality of these state courts. So if the Supreme court accept the process with no issues yes, I think for myself I'd accept Biden's legitimacy....for all that matters. Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Maybe I’m being too logical here but at some point you just have to be rational and accept that if nothing comes of all this, then there was never any case to answer in the first place. Again, this is not some two bit claim here - if this was going on in a WIDESPREAD fashion to the tune of tens of thousands of votes, even just a few thousands of votes, it would be a sensation. Such a legitimate case would not be able to be rejected by any court. Or hidden for that matter - to orchestrate that level of deceit on such a large scale would be a) very hard to do and b) very hard to keep quiet - too many moving parts The same could be said for your idea that people are being paid to be 'witnesses'. I agree with you that in general conspiracies rarely work based upon human nature...as the Benjamin Franklin saying goes - probably adapted from Shakespeare (Three may keep a secret, if two of them are dead). Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Part of me hopes one of these somehow gets to the Supreme Court so it can be ruled on by the 6-2 republican majority, which it will, if there’s enough actual evidence... if it gets thrown out there, then will you accept it? As I said, I would...depending upon what the Supreme court actually say. If a republican majority court say this election has no major issue then cool. Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Obviously if more comes out later next year, great - but for now, a line has to be drawn at some point surely. A rational mind would agree with that. Otherwise it’s just a belief rather than an evidence based assumption, and that’s Jesus territory right there. I’m not saying slavishly believe everything you’re told, but sometimes, you’ve just got to make a call. I think we can all agree that fraud happens in every election to some degree, past present and future. I don’t think anyone can realistically say ‘there was no fraud in this election’ or any election, ever. I think what the republicans are saying does cover more than minor stuff. Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
People like Matthau will never accept any outcome other than the one Q has convinced them will happen - once you’re in the black hole of religion and a belief system, it’s harder and harder to be objective, and even harder still to occasionally admit you were wrong, or change your opinion. Why? Because it’s a religious system - and if you live your life by it, the longer it goes on the harder it is to break away from it and effectively admit you were duped, it’s embarrassing. But yeah, tip top tippy-top shape and all that jazz Can you truly blame the republicans for having their own conspiracy theory after the last four years? Surely there's a double standard if we are going to pour scorn on one while the other basically filled up Trump's presidency with half arsed claims based upon their own machinations. Believe me, if I genuinely believed that Democrats were an above board party that didn't use underhand tactics I'd be far more towards you and Badger's position. But I don't trust them at all.....I don't trust either party as they are both prepared to say the sea is purple if they gain from it. I've been saying on here that the polarisation is far too strong for the pieces to be put back together and so I'm not one who regards that unifying stories are important anymore.....if the Democrats want to believe that Trump's a Nazi and the Republicans want to believe Biden's a peado, then I regard that as just the growing pains of inevitable separation. There is no longer a unifying thread.....The words may be the same but they don't want or accept each other's language....if you know what I mean.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
I dont think any one can say fraud did or didnt happen. It's highly likely,to a degree it happens in all votes when mass population is involved. Oh I am sure that somewhere there could be one or two incidences of fraudulent behaviour to be found, but they will be equally shared between the parties. The parties themselves not being responsible but individuals. It will always be so when humans are involved. That though is NOT the accusation is it? The suggestion is of mass fraud conducted by one party to "steal" an election and that these are not wild allegations when no evidence has actually been presented. Who is actually trying to steal an election? It seems obvious to me that is Trump! The Dems don't need to defend themselves against something that hasn't happened. If there was evidence then it's the accusers task to reveal it and that of the election officials to rebut it. The Dems need to prepare for government and not get dragged down to Trump's level. To do would legitimise his strategy. Which looks to me as building a slush fund of donations from his base ready to be used to defend him and his family against the tide of indictments which will sweep over them next year and to continue to have political influence via his probable new TV channel.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Oh I am sure that somewhere there could be one or two incidences of fraudulent behaviour to be found, but they will be equally shared between the parties. The parties themselves not being responsible but individuals. It will always be so when humans are involved. That though is NOT the accusation is it? The suggestion is of mass fraud conducted by one party to "steal" an election and that these are not wild allegations when no evidence has actually been presented. Who is actually trying to steal an election? It seems obvious to me that is Trump! The Dems don't need to defend themselves against something that hasn't happened. If there was evidence then it's the accusers task to reveal it and that of the election officials to rebut it. The Dems need to prepare for government and not get dragged down to Trump's level. To do would legitimise his strategy. Which looks to me as building a slush fund of donations from his base ready to be used to defend him and his family against the tide of indictments which will sweep over them next year and to continue to have political influence via his probable new TV channel. Biden has already said that he will not pursue Trump which I think is the smart move. Others may have a go in different courts and jurisdictions but federal action is unlikely. Biden can't go around saying the country needs to heal whilst trying to put Trump in jail. If he wants he can let others do the deed whilst remaining above the fray.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Can you truly blame the republicans for having their own conspiracy theory after the last four years? Surely there's a double standard if we are going to pour scorn on one while the other basically filled up Trump's presidency with half arsed claims based upon their own machinations. Believe me, if I genuinely believed that Democrats were an above board party that didn't use underhand tactics I'd be far more towards you and Badger's position. But I don't trust them at all.....I don't trust either party as they are both prepared to say the sea is purple if they gain from it. I've been saying on here that the polarisation is far too strong for the pieces to be put back together and so I'm not one who regards that unifying stories are important anymore.....if the Democrats want to believe that Trump's a Nazi and the Republicans want to believe Biden's a peado, then I regard that as just the growing pains of inevitable separation. There is no longer a unifying thread.....The words may be the same but they don't want or accept each other's language....if you know what I mean.
I have wondered before if what is needed is a "Truth and Reconciliation Commission" of the kind established in post-apartheid SA. It would be a sad admission of the degree of division that exists and I have my doubts whether those in the Trump camp have the capacity to even understand it's purpose and would immediately accuse it of being "communist". Traditional Republicans might though, as I am sure would most Democrats. If it was established by Biden and given to the Supreme Court to supervise could this work? Edited by Wisbech Eagle (28 Nov 2020 3.03pm)
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I have wondered before if what is needed is a "Truth and Reconciliation Commission" of the kind established in post-apartheid SA. It would be a sad admission of the degree of division that exists and I have my doubts whether those in the Trump camp have the capacity to even understand it's purpose and would immediately accuse it of being "communist". Traditional Republicans might though, as I am sure would most Democrats. If it was established by Biden and given to the Supreme Court to supervise could this work?
I have no idea, however it would be madness for genuine conservatives who believe in their constitution as it is to remain in a US with its changing demographics and weird combination of corporate and socialist future. All the current red states are on a time limit and the republicans wouldn't exist as they are now. The elites of whatever side will always look to keep the states together in some form because their gravy train depends upon it. However, the republicans have seen what's happened in Europe to conservatism and won't find that edifying. If Trump goes there is going to be a significant internal battle within the republicans on their direction.....just as the Democrats turned more left, I see the republicans ultimately turning more right. I could be wrong but I doubt it, as republicans are going to be increasingly angry as the Democrats basically reverse all of Trump's policies....push for ever more censorship and indoctrination along their ideas, force businesses to close down much more than Trump ever did over Covid.....force stuff like critical race theory down on their kids...plus trans crap. Yep, it's going to be spicy.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Interesting development in Pennsylvania.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
These are the latest comedic developments:
A federal appeals court has shot down the Trump campaign’s attempt to overturn the election result in Pennsylvania—with a judge appointed by the president writing the scathing decision. “Free, fair elections are the lifeblood of our democracy. Charges of unfairness are serious. But calling an election unfair does not make it so. Charges require specific allegations and then proof. We have neither here,” 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals Justice Stephanos Bibas wrote in a 21-page opinion issued Friday - [Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Seeing as you have such faith in courts perhaps we should wait until we see how the highest court regards their claims before using such ridicule. It happened with Gore so it should happen here.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Interesting indeed. I have tried to look at news reports on the web about this to see how serious this is. I still can't get a sense of how senior the judge is e.g. is it the equivalent of a magistrate who will be over turned. Still this seems the first chink of light for Trump no doubt this will be appealed by both sides to the SC. The Pennsylvania development is even more unfortunate really, as it has nothing to do with fraud, and instead attempts to conjure up a technicality to right off votes. It's likely to be thrown out at State level Supreme Court, as rationally speaking it would be far more noteworthy or unconstitutional to throw out millions of votes. If it reached the Supreme Court, I can't image them giving credence to this. Some are just far more concerned with outcome than democracy. It's more of an opinion anyway as the case is at a higher court, plus Pennsylvania already certified the presidential election on the 24th [Link] There would be endless legal issues around decertifying an election result And if that did happen ironically they couldn't bring in new electors anyway on account that if the state election isn't certified they can't get seated to make such a decision in the first place. Chicken and egg. The state legislature adjourns on November 30th until next year. Trump has posted countless videos and posts with regard to fraud that are provably baseless with a 5 second search, and yet people are so invested in him and caught in their ideologically bubble that they just don't factor in that a compulsive liar might not be telling them the truth. Some sneer at journalism and mainstream media, but there's nothing particularly intelligent, real or complete in getting news from one tone twitter accounts or Q-Drops either. Right now, the conspiracies are failing in the courts. Edited by BlueJay (28 Nov 2020 5.22pm)
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Seeing as you have such faith in courts perhaps we should wait until we see how the highest court regards their claims before using such ridicule. By all means, if there is anything to merit any of these cases reaching the Supreme Court in the first place.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Your cherry picking bits of what I wrote. Yep. ‘I agree with some of this’ Hence the cherries Er - the onus is on the accuser here to have enough evidence to prove there is a case to answer. Why bother wasting time and money on something that (in most cases so far) didn’t happen as you know it’s going to get thrown out before even getting to that stage. Makes sense to me. Also you have to remember these are pre court... if a court decides to proceed with a case then they’ll defend themselves. Not before, it’s just not how it works. But obviously you’ll look for anything to maintain your beliefs Also - ‘show ballots’ What? Only in dem win states? All states? States where trump won? Where he came from behind to win? Is every republicans vote kosher? Every single ballot? To whom are these ballots being shown? Someone you approve of otherwise you won’t accept the outcome? The madness literally never ends
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Biden has already said that he will not pursue Trump which I think is the smart move. Others may have a go in different courts and jurisdictions but federal action is unlikely. Biden can't go around saying the country needs to heal whilst trying to put Trump in jail. If he wants he can let others do the deed whilst remaining above the fray. Has Biden actually said that? I wouldn't have thought it possible as a President cannot direct the D o J or AG. He might pardon him later, but that's different. Of course Trump doesn't believe in that, but he doesn't actually believe in very much.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Has Biden actually said that? I wouldn't have thought it possible as a President cannot direct the D o J or AG. He might pardon him later, but that's different. Of course Trump doesn't believe in that, but he doesn't actually believe in very much. Yes he has, I tried to tell you weeks ago that it doesn't make sense to go after Trump. It does give me cause to scratch my chin when you talk of persecuting Trump and then talk about the need to 'heal'.....as if the tens of millions of Trump voters are going to somehow accept that. They aren't regardless of what happens to Trump anyway....but Biden would be a fool to worsen the already crimson mood of Trump voters come January.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Has Biden actually said that? I wouldn't have thought it possible as a President cannot direct the D o J or AG. He might pardon him later, but that's different. Of course Trump doesn't believe in that, but he doesn't actually believe in very much. Like I said Biden will not go after Trump that doesn't stop others but he has enough sense to see that it's bad politics for him to be seen doing it. The Democrats wanted to defeat Trump they done that so do the smart thing and declare victory like George Bush senior did in Iraq and then get the hell out. The alternative is a tar pit, who knows what might float to the surface. There are many republicans who still believe Nixon was innocent and should not have resigned, you are not going to change minds about Trump. Even if the Democrats produce a video of Trump taking a bribe from Putin whilst snorting cocaine and doing the do with a hooker many people would simply not believe it. All you do is keep the hate alive. Trump like Corbyn is yesterday's man, Biden knows his energies are better spent elsewhere. As they often say in the movies "Don't do it Joe he's not worth it." Edited by Badger11 (28 Nov 2020 6.48pm)
One more point |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Trump moves to strip job protections from White House budget analysts as he races to transform civil service - [Link]
The move to pull off an executive order the president issued less than two weeks before Election Day — affecting tens of thousands of people in policy roles — is accelerating at the agency closest to the White House, the Office of Management and Budget. The budget office sent a list this week of roles identified by its politically appointed leaders to the federal personnel agency for final sign-off. The list comprises 88 percent of its workforce — 425 analysts and other experts who would shift into a new job classification called Schedule F. The employees would then be vulnerable to dismissal before Trump leaves office if they are considered poor performers or have resisted executing the president’s priorities, effectively turning them into political appointees that come and go with each administration. The Office of Personnel Management is also rushing to shuffle many of its own roughly 3,500 employees into the new category, a senior administration official said. Other agencies are pulling together lists of policy roles, too — but the budget and personnel offices volunteered to be test cases for the controversial policy, this official said, speaking on the condition of anonymity to discuss internal administration deliberations. By fast-tracking a process that gave agencies until Jan. 19 to identify affected jobs, the administration appears to be signaling its intent to leave as big an imprint as possible on a workforce it has long mistrusted. Democrats on Capitol Hill are trying to block the effort."
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Like I said Biden will not go after Trump that doesn't stop others but he has enough sense to see that it's bad politics for him to be seen doing it. I agree with this really. Realistically he should, but it would be counter to how he wishes to portray himself and wouldn't really gain him or the Democrats anything. Better to let Trump get dealt with at the State level due to the financial and criminal cases he will no longer be protected from post presidency. It's worth remembering though, that Trump has and continues to do nothing to pass on the presidential baton in a dignified banner, to the point where he denies and tries to circumvent the result of the election itself (and in fact informed us prior that he'd only accept the result if he won). You get what you give. Though as I say, that is best demonstrated here by the States, to allow for a less tabloid Presidency for a change.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I have no idea, however it would be madness for genuine conservatives who believe in their constitution as it is to remain in a US with its changing demographics and weird combination of corporate and socialist future. All the current red states are on a time limit and the republicans wouldn't exist as they are now. The elites of whatever side will always look to keep the states together in some form because their gravy train depends upon it. However, the republicans have seen what's happened in Europe to conservatism and won't find that edifying. If Trump goes there is going to be a significant internal battle within the republicans on their direction.....just as the Democrats turned more left, I see the republicans ultimately turning more right. I could be wrong but I doubt it, as republicans are going to be increasingly angry as the Democrats basically reverse all of Trump's policies....push for ever more censorship and indoctrination along their ideas, force businesses to close down much more than Trump ever did over Covid.....force stuff like critical race theory down on their kids...plus trans crap. Yep, it's going to be spicy. What is a "genuine conservative"? Who gets to define it? For me the genuine conservative is someone who believes in the principals espoused by our own "one nation conservatives", in the tradition of Disraeli and followed by most Tory pms ever since. There is no doubt that most Republicans are further to the right than that but Trump isn't any kind of a conservative. He is a populist and the disappearance of populism, and it's complete lack of an underlying principle, cannot happen soon enough, in my opinion. I don't believe most genuine Republicans are bad people, or have anything too much in common with Trump. He has been a vehicle to allow some of the things they care about, Evangelical Christianity, abortion and gun ownership, for instance, to be protected. Biden will tread slowly and carefully on all of these and in so doing hopefully will loosen their ties to Trump. The idea that there are groups of "elites" conspiring to maintain the status quo I find especially difficult to reconcile with reality. For me that is just another populist misrepresentation designed to set up a mythical enemy. A bit like the "deep state" when these are simply people trying to do their jobs. Trump's base are going to be angry come what may and how Biden deals with that anger is going to be challenging. What he won't be doing though are any of the things you suggest. There won't be any censorship. There might be more requirements put on social media companies to oversee content and remove blatant lies that seek to misinform. Social change won't be forced or hurried, it will be a slow and natural evolution. So I agree that there is going to be a battle for the heart of the Republicans but it's one that the traditionalists must win and one that I see the Democrats helping them to, in the ultimate interests of democracy. Hopefully, the bulk of the US will have had enough of the Trump style to last a lifetime. Huge rallies, lies, scant regard for democratic norms, belittling of the media and attacks on opponents and minorities were a feature of European politics 90 years ago. Let's hope it's at least that long before it is seen again.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.