You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread
November 20 2026 11.20am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Benteke thread


Page 148 of 166 < 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 >
HeathMan Flag Purley 03 Feb 20 9.03am

players are often talked about as being put in the shop window. Is it the case with CB that Roy has put him in the window, not for other clubs to be attracted, but for CPFC supporters to see that he needs to go?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 03 Feb 20 9.11am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Tosun was injured and Wickham gone but we did have another centre forward in Ayew who was played out of position and would probably have done better than Benteke if he played in his position instead

Maybe if Townsend was fully match fit he would have started right and Ayew centre.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 03 Feb 20 9.57am

Originally posted by BelfastEagle


The only way he will be gone in the summer is on a season long loan, nobody will be prepared to pay a fee for him.

Inclined to agree, just shows how massively we overpaid.

 

MikeCrete Flag Crete 03 Feb 20 1.05pm

Saturday is the last time he should be in the starting squad. Ayew would have been in the right place a couple of times & probably scored. Benteke will never score & if Roy persists in starting him we will be relegated this season.
Bite the bullet & get rid, I would have straight away after the Bournemouth debacle.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 03 Feb 20 3.11pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I read an article by an ex-footballer recently, I cannot remember who it was, but cannot shake this picture of Benteke now.

He mentioned in the article that Benteke was one of those players who just does not have a 'love for football' and this for me was a real light bulb moment.

Sure he can win headers, has a touch and he can shoot of course, but he has no enthusiasm or desire. Our team do not create many chances and a player who is not bothered and happy to do the bare minimum each game is not going to get goals for us, hence his return. I would have thought given the state of play he would be almost goal-hanging desperate to score, most strikers would, but he still refuses to get in the box.

He can be fit as ever, with his natural talent and play every minute but he does not have the right mentality for this team. We should have sold him a while ago, I had been one to stand up for him in the hope he would come back, but this has passed now.

Some of us have been hoping against hope that he'd put one of his chances away. I was so disappointed to see Ayew stuck out wide on Saturday - wasted out there especially with Andros back and raring to go.

 

Ian-VI Flag Vicenza 03 Feb 20 3.17pm

Originally posted by doombear
with Andros back and raring to go.

He might be raring to go but if someone doesn't play for 2 months I guess the level of fitness is not the one required for a full match.
Or at least it never happened to me that a player out injured for 2 months have been played straight away in all my sport years...

 


The best footie management game: [Link]

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 03 Feb 20 3.30pm

Originally posted by Ian-VI

He might be raring to go but if someone doesn't play for 2 months I guess the level of fitness is not the one required for a full match.
Or at least it never happened to me that a player out injured for 2 months have been played straight away in all my sport years...

I take your point but had hoped he'd be given more minutes that he was. Basically once Vicente had gifted them the goal, we needed Andros on the pitch.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 03 Feb 20 4.01pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I read an article by an ex-footballer recently, I cannot remember who it was, but cannot shake this picture of Benteke now.

He mentioned in the article that Benteke was one of those players who just does not have a 'love for football' and this for me was a real light bulb moment.

Sure he can win headers, has a touch and he can shoot of course, but he has no enthusiasm or desire. Our team do not create many chances and a player who is not bothered and happy to do the bare minimum each game is not going to get goals for us, hence his return. I would have thought given the state of play he would be almost goal-hanging desperate to score, most strikers would, but he still refuses to get in the box.

He can be fit as ever, with his natural talent and play every minute but he does not have the right mentality for this team. We should have sold him a while ago, I had been one to stand up for him in the hope he would come back, but this has passed now.

I'm pretty sure that was Stan Collymore talking about why Villa shouldn't take him back. He basically said that he plays football but he has no passion for the game. I have to say I didn't have much passion for my job, but I would have enjoyed it a lot more getting paid what he earns.

 

Ghostship Flag Norfolk 03 Feb 20 4.35pm

With a bit of luck Roy will drop him against Everton with Ayew taking his place and Andros coming back to start which should give us a better balance

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 10 Feb 20 9.27am

The best we can hope for is staying up by the skin of our teeth. and Big Ben scoring a few on the run in so someone is will to take a punt on him in the summer. I thought his luck had changed on Saturday after Pickford's howler, but if that was the case the one off his chest would have gone in and not hit the post, and he would have buried that header.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 10 Feb 20 9.36am

5 league goals in 2 and a half seasons, scintillating form that will have buyers queueing up all the length of Holmesdale Road. No wonder he's given a place in the starting line up, marvellous value for 130k a week.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 10 Feb 20 10.00am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

5 league goals in 2 and a half seasons, scintillating form that will have buyers queueing up all the length of Holmesdale Road. No wonder he's given a place in the starting line up, marvellous value for 130k a week.

I agree 100%. What I hope is he can knick a few goals that someone may think he has turned the corner and we can recoup some of our original "investment" and get rid of his wages.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Feb 20 10.08am

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

I agree 100%. What I hope is he can knick a few goals that someone may think he has turned the corner and we can recoup some of our original "investment" and get rid of his wages.

Perhaps his goal will be the catalyst for further goals this season which are instrumental in preserving our place in the PL and supporters will do a 'Volta face' and hope he is retained for next season amidst chants of "Benteke is back" !


 

taylors lovechild Flag 10 Feb 20 10.40am

He is looking very lean and seems to have recovered his pace, but I'm still no more convinced he has recovered any sort of composure in front of goal. Yes he scored, but to be honest if Pickford had saved it we would probably have complained it was a poor finish. I don't really buy into Collymore's comments as however bad Bentenke has been he always seems to be keen to get back into the starting line-up. Personally I think the problem is that his style even when was in form was fairly laid back, and fans will accept that when you're scoring, but when you're not then you become a big target for abuse. I do think he has worked harder than in the past when given his chance but I'd rather he just started scoring

 

jeeagles Flag 10 Feb 20 2.40pm

From the stats posted on other threads.

We have the lowest amount of crosses out of any team in the league. His strength is his ability to get on the end of crosses.

We also have the lowest number of chances created... which can't help strikers.

 

EddieMac Flag 10 Feb 20 2.51pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

He is looking very lean and seems to have recovered his pace, but I'm still no more convinced he has recovered any sort of composure in front of goal. Yes he scored, but to be honest if Pickford had saved it we would probably have complained it was a poor finish. I don't really buy into Collymore's comments as however bad Bentenke has been he always seems to be keen to get back into the starting line-up. Personally I think the problem is that his style even when was in form was fairly laid back, and fans will accept that when you're scoring, but when you're not then you become a big target for abuse. I do think he has worked harder than in the past when given his chance but I'd rather he just started scoring

I agree with you. I have seen a massive improvement in him in his last 2 games but it is that laid back attitude that does him no favours. That silly celebration he does boils my blood. If I had gone so many games without a goal and then got one at Everton I would have celebrated like a mad man. It will be interesting to see if he keeps his place.

 

Johng Flag 12 Feb 20 11.21pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Benteke (my theory) ' by bexleydave

Right, here it is:

Benteke doesn't have a problem with his head/mind. It's his body. When you look at the way he runs and his general physicality, it is very different to when he was banging in goals for Villa. When you see him run these days, it seems as if he's running on his tiptoes, he doesn't look balanced. He's clearly not as flexible in the hamstring or achilles department as he was. Just look at how it used to be (Villa). I reckon the Palace physio dept. Have been remiss in spotting this and have taken their eye off the ball (so to speak). If they focus on sorting this flexibility/balance issue out, then I reckon he could be the man he was.

I now await the backlash.

 

Ian-VI Flag Vicenza 12 Feb 20 11.32pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Benteke (my theory) ' by bexleydave

I don't know if it's his head or body, but I noticed too what you described here.
I've been looking closely him lately, and really I don't understand what happened to him.
It reminds me when coaching young children that still don't have the right coordination, so they do a lot of quick half steps to find the right distance from the foot and the ball. He did it once last match too, and finally did a very bad shot.
It makes me laugh when I read on here that he's not played to his strength, like he was always scoring headers... look at his Villa goals, and you will see it doesn't even look the same man.

 


The best footie management game: [Link]

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 12 Feb 20 11.45pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Benteke (my theory) ' by bexleydave

My theory ...

He has Genital Herpes.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 12 Feb 20 11.53pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Benteke (my theory) ' by bexleydave

Yeah, I'm fairly certain that an injury has basically destroyed his ability to play football. Heard lots of comments that when you watch him in the pre-game warm-ups, he simply doesn't run or strike the ball properly.

 

Page 148 of 166 < 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread